10 Ways Marvel Shafted Spider-Man; and How He Can Be Restored
Marvel has some explaining to do. Spider-Man/Peter Parker is one of the most beloved characters in the history of comic books; perhaps second only to DC's Superman. Since his origin in 1963, Spider-Man's many adventures based upon his mantra "With great power comes great responsibility" have thrilled us and inspired us. Sad to say, Spider-Man isn't really Spider-Man anymore. I mean that both literally and figuratively. In spite of his global popularity, the Wallcrawler has been treated as a stepchild by Marvel Comics by quite a while now. This mistreatment of the Amazing Spider-Man has angered his new fans; but has fostered true discontentment in his longtime fans (which I firmly consider myself). It is all well and good that Spider-Man is enjoying great success at the global box office, in his animated television shows, in the world of video games, and in the merchandising world of toys and clothes. But all of those things were made possible through his monthly comic books. And that's where Spider-Man most needs an infusion of love, strategic planning, and a back-to-basics approach. In my not-so-humble opinion, here are ten ways Marvel has shafted Spider-Man:
10. The Second Clone Saga
The first "Clone Saga" was published in 1975; and was an exciting, well-written story which ended in a groundbreaking twist virtually unseen in comic books at that time. I still own an original copy of those issues of "The Amazing Spider-Man". The second "Clone Saga", published 19 years later, remains one of the most controversial storylines in comic book history. The very concept that the person we all believed to be the real Peter Parker was actually a clone infuriated countless people. Famously, it was Marvel's intention to have that remain the case. The unprecedented backlash by Spider-fans forced the publisher to rewrite that plan. Think about that. For nearly 20 years, Spider-Man would have been an imposter. And the real deal Webcrawler? Now renamed Ben Reilly, he would have spent all that time traveling the world living a lie force-fed upon him. Sounds like the plotline of an awesome sci-fi movie.
9. One More Day
Long story short: In order to save the life of a comatose, mortally wounded Aunt May, Peter essentially made a deal with Mephisto (as close as it gets to the devil in the MCU) to trade his entire marriage to Mary Jane in a mystic exchange. That Peter held himself responsible for the assassin who shot Aunt May by order of the Kingpin is entirely beside the point. Peter Parker would never have sold MJ out to the devil under any circumstances not even to spare his beloved Aunt. Like many fans, I viewed this action as a complete betrayal of Peter's character and integrity.
8. Civil War - Spidey Unmasked To The World
In the pages of 2006's "Civil War #2", Spider-Man did the unthinkable. At the encouragement of his friend/mentor/employer Tony Stark, Peter Parker removed his mask and revealed his identity to the entire world at a televised news conference. Peter did this to comply with the Superhero Registration Act; of which Iron Man was the leader. I was genuinely shocked by Peter's decision. The problem wasn't that Marvel Comics made the move to have Peter unmask himself publicly; the problem was that this game-changing moment wasn't seized upon. In retrospect, I honestly think that Spidey's coming clean was permitted precisely because it was always going to be undone shortly thereafter. And that, my friends, is lazy storytelling. I loved the growing friendship between Spider-Man and Iron Man at the time. Many awesome stories could easily have been gleamed from this historical moment, but Marvel chose to undo this milestone mere months thereafter. Talk about missed opportunities. This is all the more frustrating when you stop to consider that years later, Spider-Man revealed his secret identity all over again to the New Avengers and to the Fantastic Four. Going from unmasked to remasked to once again unmasked makes our guy look more than just a little unstable.
7. The Other (Spidey's Death, Resurrection, New Powers, And Erasure)
So, some geniuses at Marvel decided it might be a great idea to have Morlun a mystical bad guy Spider-Man had already defeated come back, all but beat Spidey to death in public, and successful evade the Avengers in the process. In his final act, a now-savage Peter awakens on his deathbed just in time to save MJ from Morlun by killing him. Yes, our principled Spider-Man killing someone. Peter dies in MJ's arms. As the Avengers prepare to bury him, his body is found torn apart from the inside out. Peter leaves Avengers' Tower, places himself in a cocoon, and later reemerges with his previous superpowers plus a host of new, enhanced abilities. Stop me if you're heard this before: Spider-Man's embracing of his 'other' side was soon ret-conned out of existence. Bye, bye potentially new-and-improved Spidey.
6. Man-Spider
A villainess named the Spider Queen selected Peter as her mate. With a single kiss, she infected Spider-Man with a mutagenic enzyme which gradually transformed him into a real spider. Peter turned into a monstrosity with four eyes, eight limbs, and fangs. Spider-Man changed into a Man-Spider. I'd love to tell you I was joking, but that would be untrue. Man-Spider really happened.
5. Too Many Spider Costumes To Count
Iron Spider. Captain Universe/Cosmic Spider-Man. The back in black uni. Ends of the Earth Spidey. Future Foundation Spidey. Spider-Tron... errr, I meant the Spider Stealth suit. New Spider-Armor. There are, of course, other Spider costumes I didn't mention. And we cannot forget Otto Octavius's seemingly endless black and red variants of Spider-Man's classic red and blue suit. Sometimes, I wonder who has had a tougher time identifying who Spider-Man is his friends or his foes. The Webslinger has worn more costumes in the past 7 or 8 years than in the previous 40 plus years combined. That's a great statistic for University of Oregon football; but a bad one for Spider-Man fans. Stick to the original suit.
4. Spread Too Thin
Did you know that recently, Spider-Man was a member of the New Avengers and the Future Foundation simultaneously? How did that leave any time for his solo adventures, his team-up tendencies in Avenging Spider-Man, his exploits as a Secret Avenger, his full-time job at Horizon Labs, and any semblance of a personal life? No wonder poor Peter is so unlucky at love. He simply doesn't have the time to care. 3. Too Many Love Interests
Since ripping Peter and Mary Jane apart in egregious fashion, Peter has been romantically linked with Ms. Marvel, Black Cat (again), NYPD forensic specialist Carly Cooper, criminal defense lawyer Michele Gonzales, and fellow Empire State University student Debra Whitman. Really, Marvel? Eggheads don't have such a full dance card; not even superpowered ones. Clean this up, please.
2. Too Many Spider-Men
Marvel has inexplicably maneuvered itself into the exact same problem DC has with Superman: too many virtually identical characters. For many years, Spider-Man was unique in the Marvel universe. In recent years, we have seen Ultimate Spider-Man/Peter Parker, Miles Morales (successor to the recently deceased Ultimate Spider-Man/Peter Parker), the new Scarlet Spider (Kaine), Spider-Man 2099, the deceased Ezekial, and Ben Reilly (Spidey's deceased clone/friend/ally). In last year's "Spider-Island" event, half of the island of Manhattan's residents were granted spider-powers via the spread of a tailored virus. Even Mary Jane had superpowers similar to Spider-Man's. It's next to impossible to stand out when you're just one of many.
1. The Superior Spider-Man
Doctor Octopus building a device allowing him to trade bodies with Spider-Man? Bad. Peter's mind being trapped in the body of a Doc Ock on his deathbed? Worse. Doc Ock having full access to Peter's memories, hopes, dreams, and fears? The worst. And on top of that, having Doc Ock an unrepentant villain, killer, and evil genius assume the mantle of Spider-Man? That is an insult of the highest magnitude and a swift backhand to the face to anyone who ever cared about Peter Parker and Spider-Man. Click "next" below to read how Spider-Man can be redeemed;