10 Worst Things Captain America Has Done

Decapitation? Looking back at those times when Captain America wasn't quite as heroic as we thought.

Captain America Mystique
Marvel Comics

With an origin that goes all the way back to 1941, heroes don’t get any more heroic than Captain America.

Introduced as a propaganda tool during World War II, Cap instantly made an impression by punching Adolf Hitler square in the face during his very first appearance for Timely Comics. And with that, the tone was set for Steve Rogers to be a symbol of hope, strength, and of simply doing the right thing.

DC Comics may have Superman as their squeaky-clean poster boy, but Marvel Comics – which Timely would eventually become in 1961 – has long since had the Sentinel of Liberty as their golden goose of positivity and optimism.

At times, like so many others, Captain America has seen some lulls in popularity, but the whole Winter Soldier saga of 2005 saw the Cap comics given a giant shot in the arm; a shot in the arm that has only been further boosted by Chris Evans’ phenomenal portrayal of Steve Rogers in the big-screen MCU.

Throughout the decades, however, readers have at times been shocked by some of the chilling acts committed by Captain America; proving that even the most heroic of heroes may not always be what they seem.

10. Retiring After A Rejected Wedding Proposal – Tales Of Suspense #95

Captain America Agent 13
Marvel Comics

Nobody was brutally killed. Nobody was severely injured. Nobody was exposed as a sinister double-agent. No, this entry doesn’t involve any of those things; it just focusses on Captain America acting like a complete and utter stroppy teenager.

This was all back in 1967’s Tales of Suspense #95, with Steve Rogers deciding to ask Agent 13 on a date. Whether it was his 1920s thought process or his brain hadn’t quite thawed out yet, Cap got down on one knee and asked Agent 13 to marry him. On their very first date!

Like any sane person, Agent 13 would reject Rogers’ proposal. Well and truly throwing his toys out of the pram, Steve Rogers made the petulant decision to retire as Captain America as a result of Agent 13 refusing his over-eager advances.

This did nothing but make The Sentinel of Liberty look like a creepy old man, whilst simultaneously giving Agent 13 a bucket-load of guilt as she blamed herself for one of the world’s greatest heroes hanging up his shield. And remember, this was before Agent 13 revealed herself to be Sharon Carter, the niece of one Peggy Carter.


9. Stealing Hank Pym’s Wife – Ultimates #9

Captain America Janet van Dyne
Marvel Comics

The whole line of Ultimate comics was a great alternative to the standard 616 realm for a while there. Now, where some characters were given a new level of energy and intrigue, other famed heroes were made to be even more unlikable. Case in point: Hank Pym.

As part of The Ultimates – the Ultimate world’s take on The Avengers – Hank was even more of an erratic genius than usual. It seems that whatever version of Hank Pym and Janet van Dyne readers are given, the two are often incompatible for the most part; largely down to Ant-Man and his intense highs and lows.

In The Ultimates, the fragile relationship between Hank and Janet comes to an explosive head that sees Pym nearly kill his wife by setting thousands of ants on her shrunken form. While Wasp recovers from this, Cap decides to pay Hank a visit and proceeds to beat the ever living snot out of him.

Not content with this, Steve goes one step further and starts dating Janet.

Did Pym deserve his wife leaving him? Sure. But his good pal Steve Rogers instantly coming in to take his wife off his hands? Many saw that as overstepping the line.


8. Allows Bucky To Be Killed – Thunderbolts #12

Captain America Bucky Barnes
Marvel Comics

Mark this one down as another one for Hydra Cap.

With Helmut Zemo starting to question whether or not he can really trust Steve Rogers and his loyalty to Hydra, the rogue serves up a litmus test in the form of Bucky Barnes.

Remembering that Bucky killed Helmet’s father Heinrich – the original Baron Zemo – by strapping him to a rocket, the younger Zemo returns the favour and ties Barnes to a rocket designed to send him to his explosive death. Will Rogers save his BFF and show that he’s not really as dedicated to Hydra as he claims, or will he let Zemo’s plan play out and send Bucky to the afterlife?

Bucky chooses to die rather than say "Hail Hydra!", leading to an annoyed Kobik pulling him out of that time-frame and returning him to the present day with his knowledge of Cap's duplicity. But even then, Bucky again finds himself to strapped to a rocket in the current day as Steve bids farewell to his former "friend to the end".


7. Captain America, Mutant Slayer – Age Of X: Universe #2

Captain America Mystique
Marvel Comics

2011’s Age of X story arc takes place in an alternative reality where the relationship between mankind and mutants is explosive, to say the least.

In this world, Charles Xavier never formed The X-Men. As a result, humanity never truly became accepting or understanding of mutants and their unique abilities. And all of this wasn’t particularly helped by a young Jean Grey destroying Albany, New York and killing 600,000 people due to her having not had the guidance to control her powers.

A task force version of The Avengers is put together to hunt down and eradicate any and all mutant threats. With Captain America leading a group made up of Iron Man, Hulk, Sue Storm, Jessica Drew and Ghost Rider, one of the biggest shocks came when the team found Mystique. As the shape-shifter stood protecting a group of children, Captain America killed her.

The silver lining of all of this, however, was that Mystique’s death caused Cap to question what this war was all about. Well, until he was later killed himself by The Hulk.


6. Working With Villains – Captain America: Steve Rogers (Various Issues)

Captain America Hydra
Marvel Comics

Over the decades, plentiful heroes have helped to reform their villainous rivals; taking them under their wing and showing them the wrongs of their ways, as they set them on the straight and narrow. Alas, this is not what we mean when we talk about Steve Rogers working with villains.

Instead, Cap and his Hydra-championing ways saw the Sentinel of Liberty strike up a working relationship with several nefarious sorts. The agreement here is that Rogers will allow these criminals to go about their evil activities, on the proviso that he will then swoop in to save the day.

This means that the rogues in question get to enjoy themselves by causing chaos and carnage, while Captain America gets the plaudits and praise of the public for being a hero. Adding an extra layer of underhandedness to all of this, Rogers would save these charades to when the rest of Earth’s Mightiest Heroes were tied up with their own particular bad guys and issues.

As Supreme Leader of the Hydra High Council, this gives Cap extra sway with his Hydra pals while doubling-down on his public persona of the all-American hero.

Wait, did you say Supreme Leader of the Hydra High Council…?


5. Supreme Leader Of The Hydra High Council – Captain America: Steve Rogers #15

Captain America Hydra
Marvel Comics

Yes, all alluded to in our previous entry, Captain America – beacon of hope to the American people and a symbol of all that is right in the world – ended up becoming the head of the villainous organisation that he had spent literal decades fighting.

As part of the whole twist of Steve Rogers having secretly been working for Hydra for, well, ever, readers saw Captain America given the position of top dog of the shiny new Hydra High Council as reformed by Madame Hydra.

After Madame Hydra had filled out the key positions of this new collection of uber-bastards, she had saved the role of Supreme Leader for none other than Steve Rogers. The reason that Madame Hydra had held this position vacant for Rogers? Well, not only had he more than proven himself to be one of the toughest, most intelligent fellas on the planet, but she also happened to have a crush on dreamy ol’ Cap.


4. Killing The Red Skull – Captain America: Steve Rogers #15

Cap Kills Skull
oyster.ignimgs.com

Like so many heroes and villains, Captain America and Red Skull have done the usual dance for as long as anyone could remember; Skull coming up with an evil scheme, Cap thwarting him, the Nazi loyalist escaping and vowing to return with an even more devious plan.

The Red Skull has been presumed dead more than most throughout the years, but as part of Cap’s Hydra heel turn, the Sentinel of Liberty put a decisive, deathly stop to his longtime foe.

Initially working underneath Red Skull, the now-totally-evil Captain America saw a perfect opportunity to challenge Skull for the leadership of Hydra. Why was this the perfect opportunity, you ask? That would be because Johann Schmidt had just come out of surgery to have parts of Professor X’s mind removed from his noggin’.

Seeing Schmidt in this weakened state, Cap easily dispatched of Red Skull; killing him off by throwing Skull out of a window. And it was only mere minutes after this that Madame Hydra would turn up to instil Captain America as the Supreme Leader of her rejigged Hydra High Council.


3. Decapitating Baron Blood – Captain America #254

Captain America Baron Blood
Marvel Comics

The sight of a comic book hero killing somebody is always a little jarring and causes you to do a double-take. But Captain America – the insta-smiling, baby-kissing, whiter-than-white, flag-waving good guy – murdering somebody in cold blood? That could never happen. Only it did. And it was brutal.

Brought over to the UK by Union Jack and Spitfire to assist in their hunt to find a killer that was terrorising the country, Cap went one better and didn’t just find said killer; he well and truly put a stop to the rogue’s rampage.

It was Baron Blood who was on a murder spree here, and clearly he caught Steve Rogers on a bad day. Upon confronting Blood, Captain America used his trusty shield to decapitate the villain. Bar the obvious allusion that Cap had killed people during World War II, this was the first time that Marvel Comics had shown this beloved hero taking someone’s life.

Luckily for Baron Blood, he’s a comic book character. And we all know, death isn’t exactly a permanent arrangement when it comes to comics. As such, he’d be briefly resurrected in 1987 before several other appearances over the subsequent years.


2. Throwing Jack Flag To His Death – Captain America: Steve Rogers #1

Captain America Jack Flag
Marvel Comics

Like so many other heroes, Captain America has had plenty of protégés and sidekicks working alongside him. One of the more unfortunate of these protégés, was Jack Flag.

In the “wait, Cap is really working for Hydra?” twist from 2016, readers were shown a far darker, murkier side to the Sentinel of Liberty. And on the receiving end of this evil Steve Rogers was Jack Flag, who would be killed at the Captain’s hands.

Having recruited young Jack to work for S.H.I.E.L.D., Captain America takes the eager Flag with him on a mission to track down Baron Zemo. In a shocking moment, after Jack refuses Cap’s orders to stop following Zemo, Steve casually throws his new sidekick from their airplane before quipping “Hail Hydra”.

The spirited Jack would survive the fall thanks to his healing abilities, although he would be left in a coma. Attempting to finish the job, Captain America makes a beeline for the S.H.I.E.L.D. medical bay with the intention of poisoning Flag. It’s then that Rogers finds out that Jack’s parents have decided to take him off life support.

Even worse? Steve Rogers pretends to mourn his fallen protégé and even consoled Jack Flag’s parents at the funeral.


1. The Death Of The Hulk – Civil War II #3

Hulk Death
Marvel Comics

While Bruce Banner was killed in the third issue of Civil War II, that death had its roots in Captain America: Steve Rogers #5.

In terms of the one to inflict the fatal blow on Banner, that was a job that Hawkeye and his trusty arrows. The reasoning for killing Banner was that he was about to embark on some gamma therapy that was going to backfire and turn him into a completely uncontrollable, murderous version of The Hulk. But this wasn’t always the way the situation was meant to play.

Concerned that the future-predicting Ulysses was about to rumble Cap’s allegiance to Hydra, Rogers looked to switch Ulysses’ attention elsewhere. And so, Steve arranges for Bruce Banner to receive some new gamma research that will prompt the Jade Giant to start experimenting on himself.

All of sudden, Ulysses sees a new future in which all of this leads to The Hulk becoming crazed. Deeming this a nightmare scenario, the decision is made to kill Bruce Banner before this future can play out.

And so, when Carol Danvers asks Bruce to join her outside for a chat, Hawkeye is waiting to fire an arrow into the skull of poor Banner.


Watch Next


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.