10 Worst Things Superman Has Ever Done

Those times when comics' greatest hero wasn't all that great.

The Adventures of Superman Annual #3 Maxima
DC Comics

Since making his bow in 1938's Action Comics #1, Superman has forever been positioned as the bright, shining light of comics.

Across over 70 years, the Last Son of Krypton has become a bona fide pop culture icon and is famed for always finding a way to do the right thing in his quests to save the day. While other heroes like to menacingly brood or take an aggressive approach with their methods, Superman has so often been the moral compass as the granny-hugging, baby-kissing good guy. Oh, and he also had an utterly marvellous mullet for a spell in the '90s after returning to action following his purported 'death'.

Still, not even Superman is completely flawless, and the Big Blue Boy Scout has carried out his fair share of boneheaded, illogical, tasteless or outright evil actions over the decades. Here, that's precisely what the spotlight is on, as we take a look at the more questionable decisions of Kal-El's time in the sun.

With that in mind, then, here are ten of the most underhand, brutal or outright villainous things that Superman has done in his extensive history.

10. Paralysing A Football Player - Superman, Gridiron Hero

Superman Tommy Burke Action Comics #4
DC Comics

Imagine that you're a young football hopeful looking to make yourself stand out in order to make a better future for you and your family. With the biggest game of your burgeoning career on the horizon, things suddenly take a term for the disturbing when you are purposely paralysed and replaced by a doppelganger.

For Tommy Burke, that's the precise situation he found himself in way back in 1938's Action Comics #4.

A story somewhat questionably titled Superman, Gridiron Hero, this tale had Tommy left paralysed after the Boy Scout infected him with a unique substance. Why would the ever-heroic Last Son of Krypton do such a thing? Well, that was so that he could alter his appearance to look like Tommy and then take his place in the football team.

There was a paper-thin plot in here about a corrupt coach that Superman was trying to bring down, but the bigger take-home point of Gridiron Hero is that Big Blue purposely paralysed an innocent young fella.

If there was some semblance of a silver lining for Tommy Burke, it's that the bunch of touchdowns scored by the disguised Superman during this time led to Burke's ex-girlfriend getting back with him. Although in hindsight, she does sound awfully fickle the more you think about it...


9. Eviscerating Doctor Light - Trinity War

Superman Doctor Light Justice League Trinity War
DC Comics

The New 52 was a strange time for DC Comics. Deciding on a complete rebrand for its characters and titles, this relaunch left an immediate bad taste in the mouth of many long-time comic book fans for how it presented certain heroes and villains, and also for the utterly miniscule amount of female voices involved creatively. And right at the front of such backlash, there was Superman.

Amongst some of the major criticisms delivered in the direction of this iteration of the Man of Steel, he was a brash, selfish ass whose 'one true' was Wonder Woman rather than Lois Lane. For sure, this was a bold new direction for Superman, but it was a new direction that many took umbrage with.

In terms of particular New 52 moments that pissed off the masses, look no further than Supes' actions against Doctor Light in 2013's Trinity War.

While someone taking a shot at your beau is never a cool thing, Regular Superman wouldn't go as far as murdering that someone. Not in the case of New 52 Superman, though, for he uses his heat vision to literally melt the head of Doctor Light after Light accidentally fired an energy blast at Wonder Woman.


8. The Abuse Of Jimmy Olsen - The Son Of Superman

Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen #30 The Son of Superman
DC Comics

For nearly as long as there's been a Superman, there's been a Jimmy Olsen.

Debuting in Action Comics #6 back in 1938 - just five issues after the Man of Steel's own debut - Jimmy is the long-time close friend of the Boy Scout, in addition to working with Clark at the Daily Planet.

While getting one's own title is always a great moment for a supporting character, things didn't work out all that well for Olsen when 1954's had him headline his own Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen book. Bizarrely, this title found Jimmy being abused by Kal-El on a scarily frequent basis.

The most messed up part of this came in Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen #30, in a story labelled The Son of Superman. In what could clearly be seen as a positive, the Last Son of Krypton adopts Jimmy here in much the same way that Bruce Wayne has adopted the likes of Dick Grayson and Tim Drake over the years.

Unfortunately, this all proved to be a disaster for young Olsen.

Rather than an idyllic life with his personal hero as a father figure, Jimmy was constantly bullied by Superman. What started as name-calling soon escalated to working the boy like a dog, and eventually got to the disturbing point where Supes set fire to the Father's Day present Jimbo used his savings to buy for his new pops.

Such a d*ck was Superman here, Jimmy took legal action to get this adoption scrapped.


7. The Excessive, Brutal Beating Of Metropolis' Criminals - Triple Threat

Superman Gangbuster
DC Comics

Introduced in 1987, Gangbuster was a brutal Metropolis vigilante who patrolled the city's Suicide Slum. Jose Delgado was the man under the mask, and Gangbuster disappeared when Delgado damaged his spine.

By the time of 1989's Triple Threat story - which culminated in Adventures of Superman #450 - a new Gangbuster was cracking skulls in an even more severe, ferocious way than his predecessor.

At that point, readers were introduced to a random new character called Matt. A blonde-haired fella regularly labelled a 'daredevil' by those he interacted with, the insinuation was that Matt was Gangbuster and that he was DC Comics' spin on Marvel's Matt Murdock, aka Daredevil.

With Guardian and Superman both separately trying to locate and stop Gangbuster and his vicious attacks, the big revelation is that Superman is Gangbuster. This revelation is made when a battle with Guardian sees Gangbuster's outfit tear open to reveal the famed S symbol.

So, why did the Man of Steel decide to don a new mantle and beat the absolute piss out of the criminal element during all of this? Well, the reason for this carnage-laced rampage from Supes, was down to him having blackouts due to the guilt of having killed some alternative dimension bad guys as part of a scheme from General Zod. Throw in some nefarious brain tinkering from Braniac for good measure, and Kal-El manifested a violent vigilante persona.


6. Sending Supergirl To An Orphanage - The Supergirl From Krypton

Action Comics #252 The Supergirl From Krypton Superman
DC Comics

Action Comics #252's The Supergirl From Krypton famously saw the full debut of Kara Zor-El, aka Supergirl. The cousin of the Man of Steel, Kara had a similar journey to Earth as Kal-El, with her being sent to the planet by her parents after disaster struck.

In the case of Kal, that disaster was the decimation of Krypton. Unbeknownst to Superman, a small part of Krypton managed to survive, and it was there that Kara was later born. Once that once-save haven came under threat from radiation, Kara's parents made the call to send her to Earth - where Superman was immediately on the scene once the Maid of Might's rocket crash-landed.

Once the pair realise they're cousins, the Boy Scout promises to look after Kara, says he'll always be there for her, and the whole scene is literally described as "perhaps the happiest moment in Superman's life".

Bafflingly, this panel of proclamations of family unity and love is followed by a panel where Clark tells Supergirl he's dumping her in an orphanage rather than let her stay with him. Nice one, cuz.


5. Allowing The Alien Abduction Of Pete Ross' Son - To Live In Peace - Nevermore!

DC Comics Presents #13 Superman Pete Ross
DC Comics

While certain heroes embarked on darker, more serious stories through the Bronze Age of Comics, the Superman tales of that time were often still remarkably cheesy or just outright made the Man of Steel look like a bit of a jackass.

One prime example of such jackass behaviour came during 1978's DC Comics Presents #13, with the Boy Scout taking centre-stage in a tale dubbed To Live in Peace - Nevermore! from Paul Levitz and Dick Dillin.

In this story, poor Pete Ross - as in Clark Kent's best pal, who was also a widow by this point - has his son Jon abducted by the Nyrvin alien race. If this wasn't traumatic enough for Pete, Superman actually had a chance to rescue the youngster but ultimately opted against doing so.

Upon locating Jon, Kal-El is informed by the Legion of Super-Heroes that the abduction of the kiddo is a pivotal part of ensuring peace in the future. Rather than doing what was right by his grieving high school pal - who is one of the few to know that Clark and Kal are one and the same - Supes decides to leave Jon with the Nyrvin.

It's no surprise that the fallout of this was the disintegration of Ross' relationship with Superman, and the loss of his only child resulted in Pete having a breakdown and being instituionalised.


4. Destroying People's Homes Because They're Poor - Superman In The Slums

Action Comics #8 Superman
DC Comics

Man, those heady days of the late-1930s threw up some stories with slightly questionable morals at their core.

In Action Comics #8, Superman in the Slums featured the Big Blue Boy Scout coming to the most ridiculous, callous of decisions when realising that a group of criminals originate from the poorest part of Metropolis.

Inspired by a newspaper headline detailing a tragic cyclone disaster in Florida, Supes realises that the best way to bring down the crime levels in Metropolis is to destroy the most struggling, desperate, low income areas of the city. And so, he literally takes his superpowers and a hammer to the houses of Metropolis' poverty-stricken residents.

While he does give some of the children of these areas mild warning of what he's going to do, the Man of Steel expects these families to take up their life possessions and simply find themselves a new place to live somewhere else.

In hindsight, this sort of disturbed, single-minded, extreme approach from Superman was an accidental indicator of what the Last Son of Krypton was capable of in future stories like the whole Injustice: Gods Among Us shenanigans.


3. Becoming A Government Lapdog - The Dark Knight Returns

The Dark Knight Returns Superman
DC Comics

Given his long-standing mantra of truth, justice and the American way, Superman has often been aligned with the US government in. In Frank Miller's seminal The Dark Knight Returns, though, this is taken to the extreme when the Man of Steel becomes the ultimate, brainless government lapdog.

With Bruce Wayne having hung up the cape 'n' cowl a decade prior, this four-issue 1986 offering saw Bruce suit up once more after the nefarious Mutants begin to terrorise Gotham City. Where Superman comes into this, he's tied at the hip to President Ronald Reagan.

Unhappy that Batman has resurfaced - with independently-minded heroes all viewed as loose cannon vigilantes by the authorities - Reagan debates what actions to take against the Caped Crusader. For Superman, he's tasked with warning (see: threatening) his on-off BFF that he may have to take him down should the World's Greatest Detective carry on suiting up.

Never one to shy away from a threat, Bruce implores Superman to do whatever he needs to do.

So blindly loyal to the US President is Big Blue here, he ends up eventually battling Batman in a fight that culminates in the Dark Knight's 'death'. Granted, this demise would be a fake-out planned ahead of time by Bats, but Superman didn't know that when he was beating his old ally to a pulp - all because the man in the Oval Office told him to.


2. Having Sex On Lois Lane's Grave - Beyond The Reach Of Time

Adventures Of Superman Annual 3
DC Comics

Sex on anyone's grave is a disgusting, disturbing, distasteful act to partake in. Making that infinitely worse, though, is having sex on the eternal resting site of your deceased wife; a resting site that is engraved with the words "Beloved wife of Clark Kent, Died while carrying their only child".

Yep, not just was Clark married to Lois Lane at this point in time, but Lois was also pregnant with the couple's first child.

In the Beyond the Reach of Time tale of The Adventures of Superman Annual #3, Lois dies just a handful of pages into the story, collapsing and dying alone at home due to a kick from her superpowered baby. Supes arrives on the scene just in time to hear his beau's final words - "I... love you" - and is left utterly distraught at this loss.

So much for "utterly distraught", mind, for Kal-El is flirting with the alien princess Maxima just six pages after we've seen the funeral of Lois Lane, and the pair would eventually hook up on Lois' gravesite.

Thankfully, this is all part of some 'what if?' future conjured up by Waverider as part of the larger Armageddon 2001 story.


1. EVERYTHING In Injustice - Injustice: Gods Among Us

Injustice: Gods Among Us Joker Death
DC Comics

In all honesty, this entire list could be made up of incidents taken solely from the world of Injustice.

This alt-world DC realm debuted in 2013, with a prequel comic book title launched alongside the Injustice: Gods Among Us video game. Here, the launching point for this whole skewed universe is that Superman was driven to insane villainy after the death of the pregnant Lois Lane.

Not just did Lois die, of course, for it was Kal-El who actually murdered his lover and unborn child after being duped into thinking he was facing Doomsday. The mastermind behind said duping? That'd be the Joker, who likewise attached a switch to Lois' heart that caused Metropolis to be nuked once Lane died.

Deciding that he was no longer going to play the nice guy, Superman punched a hole in the Clown Prince of Crime's chest and embarked on a change of character that saw him rule the world with an iron fist - which ultimately caused his fellow heroes to either align with the Man of Steel or to be the enemy of him.

In terms of the heinous acts carried out by the Boy Scout in this world, he killed Shazam by melting his face with heat vision, slaughtered Green Arrow, dumped Aquaman's home of Atlantis in the middle of the Sahara Desert, revealed Batman's secret identity to the world, instigated the death of Alfred Pennyworth... and that's just the tip of the tyrannical iceberg.


Watch Next


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.