7 Reasons You Should Give Up Superhero Comics In 2017

There's more to comics than capes and tights.

gwen stacy spiderman
Marvel Comics

Depending on whom you ask, the superhero comics industry is either thriving like never before or a sinking ship that should be abandoned. Though superhero movies and TV shows are more popular than ever, comic book sales remain decent at best. The current zeitgeist of constant relaunches and renumbering, believed to draw in new readers who would be scared away by a high issue count, seemingly succeed only in driving longtime fans away.

DC’s Rebirth has been very successful, but it’s unclear if that’s due to an increase in quality or the focus on nostalgia. Marvel has resorted to giving away extra copies of books with low orders to inflate their sales numbers after driving away their die hard supporters.

While DC is steering the ship out of the storm, Marvel is right in the middle. Their last two major events have suffered huge delays and had their endings spoiled by the post-event books released before they could finish. All of their iconic, most popular heroes are currently either dead, mind-controlled Nazis, title-less bums, or acting so out of character as to be unrecognizable. New readers aren’t taking the bait of diverse heroes and old readers are fed up with all of the changes - expect a “Rebirth” from them soon.

It’s hard to be a superhero comic fan and it’s hard to be a creator. The genre depends on stagnation but also thrives on change. Too much change and you can risk breaking the formula altogether - not enough change and the book feels boring. At this point, most of the characters we love are over fifty years old, some over seventy. In a lot of ways, all of the possible stories have been told. A good writer can always come up with a fresh idea, but the accumulation of history makes that harder and harder. Most fictional characters don’t need to continue their stories every month, indefinitely. Nobody had to write sixty years of Zorro stories.

It just might be that superheroes were never really meant to endure like this. When they were created, nobody thought they’d last this long. But comic books are so much bigger than superheroes. Ever since the beginning, there have been adventure comics, sci-fi comics, horror comics, romance comics…

They might not ever have achieved the popularity of superhero comics, but the everyday exploits of Archie and the Riverdale Gang have endured since the 1940s. If you’re someone who has limited your reading to books coming from the Big Two, you may be sick of comics, but you can have your passion reignited by migrating toward other publishers with less gimmicky stories. If you’re on the fence, this might be the push you need.

7. Continuity Doesn’t Matter Anymore

Captain Marvel
Marvel Comics

A lot of writers hate continuity because it makes their jobs harder. These guys read comics when they were younger and then fell off as they grew up and started their careers. This is why so many of them, as their first order of business, retcon to make everything more similar to how they remember.

It’s also why rebooting is so popular. When the New 52 relaunched, Geoff Johns had Batman and Superman fight each other for the first time - again - in the second issue of Justice League. Having them battle in the pre-Flashpoint stories would’ve been boring; it would’ve been the millionth time we’ve seen that, but because it was a brand new continuity, that meant it would be “fresh” again!

During the Silver and Bronze Age, continuity was a lot tighter. If the Avengers were in space for that month’s issue and the X-Men visited Avengers Mansion in their own book, they’d find it empty; an editorial box would explain the Avengers’ whereabouts. Something like “They’re in space! Find out why in Avengers #128 - on sale now!”

These days, Captain Marvel can have adventures in the multiverse in The Ultimates, her own adventures in her solo title, and involvement in major events like Civil War II all at the same time. People say Batman has no superpowers, but he can clearly transcend space and time with all the different books he manages to appear in at once. For obvious reasons, maintaining that level of order over so many titles is a lot of hard work, so it’s easy to see why current editors have adopted a “who cares?” approach.

And it’s not just keeping track of past events that’s problematic. Some of these characters have died and come back multiple times at this point. When you truncate over fifty years of stories into a timeline of about ten years, you end up with a biography so packed with plots it stretches plausibility.

How can watching Batman fight the Joker for the eightieth time really be that exciting? Sure, if they’re made out of Legos, but on the comic page? At a certain point, the “Why doesn’t Batman kill the Joker already?” question becomes too loud to ignore. You’ve thrown the Joker in Arkham Asylum like five hundred times, Batman - I think the system is broken.


6. Event Fatigue

civil war 2
Marvel Comics

In superhero comics, it feels like there’s always a prelude or an aftermath. Marvel published Civil War in the summer of 2006 and ever since then have tried to repeat that success with a new event basically every summer. DC is just as bad, even the much acclaimed Rebirth is ramping up to a big line-wide event featuring characters from Watchmen. Limited series that take over ongoing books are part of the problem, but another huge part is the events the individual titles thrust upon themselves. Green Lantern has been going from event to event without any chance to catch a breath since 2005. The X-Men are constantly in the middle of some new “things will never be the same” gamechanger.

Most of the time, stories get interrupted because of involvement in events. The New 52 Catwoman book could never really find its footing because it was constantly being forced into the plot of some Bat-title. More recently, Power Man and Iron Fist slammed the brakes on its intended story to work in the events of Civil War II (some say to its benefit). But hey, that book is getting cancelled soon anyway, so it barely matters. And if the events themselves don’t end up messing with the plot of books directly, they often do so indirectly because of massive delays. We end up seeing the fallout of the event before the event is actually done, which ruins the enjoyment of both. And then it’s right on to the next. Marvel seems to have learned nothing from the delays on Secret Wars and CW2 because they’re already headfirst into the next event: Monsters Unleashed.

The events are tiresome for their uniformity. Usually seven to nine issues, stagnation and stalling until around issue five, then a hasty resolution that doesn’t quite make sense crammed into the back half of the last issue. But on top of that, they keep characters from becoming grounded. How can we care about how the characters respond to the debate in CW2 when we barely have a sense of how they really feel in the post-Secret Wars Marvel Universe? How can we become invested in a story when it keeps getting interrupted?


5. They Refuse To Take Real Risks

Death Of Spider Man
Marvel

Since superhero comics are built on franchises and properties, writers have to find a way to please fans with new material, but also keep the corporate owners happy by not changing things so much they’ll no longer be profitable. That means Spider-Man can never really die - and if he does, there’d better be an easy way to bring him back at a moment’s notice. That makes every death of a main character extremely underwhelming. Any shock factor is completely gone because the cynical fanboy within knows they’ll be back eventually. The only surprising thing about Wolverine’s death is that it’s taken so long for him to return (but it’s accepted by all that he will).

It’s not like Brian Michael Bendis suddenly felt he had a new story to tell about Jessica Jones, so they launched a new solo title for her; the Netflix show did well and Marvel wants to capitalize on that success, so a new title is ordered. And the moment it’s no longer profitable, it will be unceremoniously canceled and replaced. Taking a chance on a labor of love so it can have time to find its audience? That’s for independent comics.

Even the most recent diversity push from Marvel has a safety net. The changes to Thor, Captain America, Iron Man, etc. can all be easily fixed within an issue or two, if so required, plus, there’s usually an alternative available if you’ve been alienated by a diversity change. Yes, there’s a woman as Wolverine right now, but there’s also Old Man Logan for your male oriented needs. The black Captain America can hand the shield back to his white counterpart in a single panel. If you want to watch characters grow and change and experience a loss that isn’t a dead girlfriend, superheroes just aren’t for you.


4. Chasing New Readers

ricky and morty comics
ricky and morty

Back before the 1980s, comics were mostly available on newsstands. They were like just like magazines. The cover of an issue might catch your eye and, even though you don’t usually read it, you buy a copy. Comics had to appeal to average people as well as dedicated fans and part of that was done by chasing trends. Wonder Woman lost her powers and learned Judo to make her seem more feminist (even though that makes no sense) and characters like Spider-Woman and Ms. Marvel (the white one) were also riding the wave of female empowerment. Luke Cage was created because of the popularity of Blaxploitation films. Vibe was a breakdancer because that was hot on the streets.

But since then, comics have become a specialty item, ordered through particular methods. There’s practically no advertising aimed toward people who aren’t already into comics or some tangential geek media. Many react with shock that comic books are even still being published and some are surprised to find out, for instance, that Superman is actually alive - they thought he died in 1992.

Do the legions of fans demanding season three of Rick and Morty know there’s a comic based on the show? How would they even find out? Yet, the Big Two constantly use gimmicks to gain these new readers that end up alienating the people who actually buy comics and invariably fail. They seem to think that the problems are due to representation; so the teenage girls who squee over the Avengers movies but don’t read comics are only avoiding the medium because there aren’t enough “girly” books. Forget that the supposedly male oriented Avengers movies have tickled the fancy of young women; forget the direct market stores that are often uninviting to newcomers; forget that these girls have no way to become immersed in these comic universes other than “read a bunch of wiki articles;” the real way to get them into stores is a woman Thor and a bunch of series with webcomic art.

These half-assed attempts to gain new readers just flat out don’t work. Any increase in sales is almost definitely from people who were already reading comics and just expanded their diet. Why bother doing them at all? To impress your friends from art school? To pay lip service to those who totally absolutely definitely would buy your comics if you jump through the hoops they demand?


3. They Won’t Move Forward

batman dc comics
DC Comics

There is a difference between a reboot and a relaunch, though they often achieve the same goals. A reboot, as traditionally used, usually means a complete alteration to the plot, characters, and spirit of a property. A good example is John Byrne’s Man of Steel reboot from the mid 1980s that retold his origin, eliminated key aspects from the Silver Age and provided a fresh Superman to tell new stories with. A relaunch doesn’t necessarily make any drastic changes to the core elements, but it does shake up the status quo. The New 52 was a reboot; Rebirth is a relaunch.

If you look at the stories from the Silver and Bronze ages, change was a constant. Peter Parker graduated high school a mere four years after his debut (he spent over a decade in college, though); Reed Richards and Sue Storm got married, pregnant, and became parents all within the sixties. But as time went on, these types of things became fewer and further between. Characters began aging much more slowly; changes were superficial, not milestones. The focus became “the illusion of change” rather than actual growth. And if too much growth has occurred, be prepared to reboot or relaunch. Either one will result in an unearned feeling of change that is ultimately false.

They’re not doing it because they love telling bad stories; it’s a consequence of working on corporately owned characters. Even though Dick Grayson’s entire character arc is training to someday replace Batman and it made perfect sense that he would take up the mantle and mentor Batman’s son (orphan redux), Grant Morrison’s work on Batman and Robin had to be undone and downplayed because Bruce Wayne is Batman in the eyes of the general populace and must remain so to be profitable. Superheroes, despite all of these attempts to seem progressive, are completely opposed to progress. They’re constantly repainting, but the structure stays the same.


2. Indie Titles By Mainstream Creators

Sex Criminals
Image Comics

A lot of comic writers and artists work on popular titles in order to generate a fanbase and then publish original creations through independent publishers like Image Comics, which has no formal editorial structure whatsoever and offers full creative freedom. It’s where your favorite creators can spread their wings a little. So if you loved Jonathan Hickman’s work on Fantastic Four and Avengers, you can check out Manhattan Projects and East of West; if you’re a fan of Greg Rucka’s current Wonder Woman book, pick up Black Magick and Lazarus; if you like Jason Aaron read Southern Bastards. Jeff Lemire’s Descender. Rick Remender’s Black Science. Matt Fraction’s Sex Criminals. The list goes on. Practically every popular writer for Marvel and DC has a book with Image or somewhere else.

These are books with vision. The writers are not beholden to profit margins or toy sales. Independent books can avoid all of those problems. There will never be an executive who insists that Hellboy start using a Hellmobile because it would make a great toy. Even if you’re not quite THAT tired of superheroes, just superheroes from the Big Two, there are titles like Robert Kirkman’s Invincible and Kurt Busiek’s Astro City. You can actually appreciate them more if you’re familiar with the tropes of the superhero genre.

That’s just the tip of the iceberg. Before you make it to reading translated European comics like Blacksad and Asterix, Image comics are a nice transition from mainstream to stuff like Zippy the Pinhead - if underground comics are your final destination. Here’s just a taste of the world outside of DC and Marvel: Dark Horse, Top Cow, Dynamite, IDW, Valiant, Top Shelf, Boom Studios. King Features has a crossover with The Phantom, Flash Gordon, Prince Valiant, Mandrake the Magician, and Jungle Jim - and if that doesn’t excite you at least a little then you’ve been limiting yourself too long. It’s like insisting your hamburgers come only from McDonald’s or Burger King.


1. They Treat You Like You’ll Never Leave

batman superman comics
DC Comics

DC and Marvel are like an abusive boyfriend. You remember how things once felt and you silently hope for a return of those good feelings even though he beats you up once a week. You’re not happy where you are and maybe your friends think you should leave, but it’s just too hard. He’s a part of your life and you can’t picture it without him. DC and Marvel know this. They make you feel like you’ll be losing a part of yourself if you give them up. Don’t you like being a part of this exclusive club? Don’t you just love tracking your favorite character’s appearances through multiple titles you don’t actually like? Don’t you love being blamed by creators for the failures of their books?

Frankly, DC and Marvel take you for granted. They know you’ll continue to gobble up whatever they release; they’re counting on it, in fact. There are fanboys who continue to purchase books, bag and board them, but never actually read them. They’re hooked. They can’t cope with the idea of not having every single issue of Thor that comes out. Some fanboys purchase multiple copies of a book: one to read, one to store, and one to sell for an inflated price on eBay. And then they buy the hardcover when it comes out! That’s why the Big Two have the attitude they do. They’re the abuser, sitting on the couch, knowing you’ll never move out because the last thing you want to do is start boxing up all your clothes and bubble-wrapping your dishes. That’s a major life change and change is scary! Here’s the latest issue of Rocket Raccoon.

Fans have been complaining about the practices of the Big Two for well over a decade, but the parade of gimmicks, events, and overall !*$% has only increased. DC really shot itself in the foot with the New 52, but they’ve gained a lot of goodwill trying to correct that. Marvel is due for something similar any day. But don’t expect these changes to be revolutionary; they’ll be just enough to keep you from heading out the door. The true power you have as a consumer to demand change doesn’t come from twitter updates or tumblr reblogs: it’s your wallet. The only way the powers that be will truly learn is if they start losing their foundation audience, their bread and butter. Not only will you spare yourself the grief of exploding with anger every time you read the solicits, but you’ll be exposing yourself to new work and possibly getting DC and Marvel to end the practices that drove you away in the first place. If you’re truly that disgusted with the direction they’re going, don’t stick around. Don’t make yourself angry for no reason. And don’t give up comics altogether. There’s a whole world out there.

Got any other suggestions for great indie books? Share them in the comments!


In this post: 
Superheroes
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Trevor Gentry-Birnbaum spends most of his time sitting around and thinking about things that don't matter.