8 Reasons Why Marvel Really Is Better Than DC
Bring your pitchforks - it's controversial opinion time.
Over a year after 9 Reasons Why DC Really is Better Than Marvel was brought kicking and screaming into our world, it's time to complete the circle, and argue the exact opposite; that it is, in fact, the Spider-Man wielding, Disney-merged franchise that is the superior of the two.
And while both DC and Marvel have their respective strengths, in the wake of Avengers: Endgame rising to the number one grossing film of all time worldwide, it's definitely worth exploring what makes Marvel more appealing - ostensibly - to a wider audience. Although many aspects of DC and Marvel are similar, the way in which they use the role of superheroes is wildly different, with the House of Ideas arguably creating some significantly more relatable and empathetic characters than its darker twin.
Despite being the comics underdog in many regards, Marvel has proven time and again that it can hold its own against the Distinguished Competion - and even outdo them, here and there.
While avid DC fans may disagree, Marvel is now the frontrunner in terms of recognisable comic franchises - so they have to be doing something right.
8. The Reboots Are WAY Less Confusing
Both DC and Marvel are guilty of rebooting their franchises more than is good for a cohesive timeline.
While Marvel has also received flack for this, DC's reboots tend to be more of an upheaval, as those like the New 52 and Rebirth not only totally change pretty much every existing DC title, but also require you to read around a series of other comics to get the full picture.
While this interconnectedness should work to create a sense of consistency - as these reboots are technically continuing a chronological timeline - it actually serves to confuse it further, as to gain an understanding of where the characters are today, you have to also learn all the convoluted events that rewrote the universe.
Meanwhile, Marvel's reboots - while undeniably likely also the source of much confusion - tend to exist in their own separate sphere, which those who dislike it can safely ignore (for the most part). Neither are perfect strategies, but in terms of making reboots that are easier to digest, Marvel has to take the win.
7. The Lighter Tone Works Better
While DC is not quite the pit of despair it is often made out to be, it also seldom mirrors the genuinely hilarious joke-fest that Marvel provides so consistently within its comics.
This isn't to say that Marvel is without it's darker moments either - with moments like Iron Man's descent into alcoholism, or Hank Pym beating his wife proving that pretty efficiently - but these moments tend to be more balanced out with significantly more light ones than its brethren.
While this naturally does vary from character to character - the Punisher is never going to have an exceedingly light series, for instance - the rule of thumb is that DC tends to hold a consistently darker tone.
This is hardly a crime, but it does mean that many of the darker moments lose some of their impact, as they're not meted out with comedy, which makes you actively anticipate grim events, instead of being taken off guard by them.
6. Setting The Marvel Universe In The Real World Works Better
While there are positives to placing the 'normal' parts of the DC universe under made up names - as names like Metropolis, Gotham, Bludhaven and Star City can all represent real places without having the political connotations of literally being them - there's still something to be said for using the actual names of real places.
Marvel using real locales makes their work feel all the more relatable and, by extension, all the easier to connect with as a result.
Seeing civilians casualties and destruction wrought out in real places makes fights seem all the more real and dangerous, because suddenly a battle is taking place somewhere that you had your summer holiday.
It's a small detail, for sure - but sometimes it's the small details that make all the difference.
5. Stan Lee
Even if you absolute despised Marvel comics with ever fibre of your being, it'd still be pretty hard to hate Stan Lee.
While the man is not without controversies - mainly surrounding Marvel creators Steve Ditko and Jack Kirby's allegations that Lee had taken credit for their work - for better of worse, he is largely regarded as a positive figure in the comics industry for actions such as his founding of the Stan Lee Foundation, which aimed to improve access to literary sources and the national literacy rate.
On a more practical note, Lee is also a helpful recognisable face in terms of linking the MCU to the greater Marvel world, as having such a prominent figure in the comics industry appear in films allows fans to feel as though they have some idea of the industry and its creators.
With Lee's tragic passing in 2018, his memorialisation in the thing he loved most - comics - serves to continue this positive influence, all the while showing respect to a bastion of the industry.
4. The Characters Are Just More Relatable
As much as DC's superheroes are awesome and interesting, many of them are as far from realistic as imaginable. Superman is borderline omnipotent, Batman is a billionaire smart enough to take down basically anyone, and Wonder Woman is literally the creation of the Greek God Zeus.
They're interesting, dynamic characters, but also characters who are inherently 'better than' being human.
Where DC hopes to make you connect with extravagant characters, Marvel shows you figures just like yourself - and then gives them cool powers and rad adventures.
Spider-Man is maybe the best example of this, as we often see him trying to do well in school, and get a job and pay his bills, all the while balancing it with his Spider-Manning responsibilities. It makes the whole thing feel so much more real, and the universe all the more convincing - albeit, the kind of vaguely depressing realistic one where you can imagine Doc Ock doing some taxes.
In the Marvel universe, it seems all the more common for regular people to become superheroes - and that's inspiring, in its own unique way.
3. The Marvel Cinematic Universe
Naturally, mentioning Marvel nowadays without thinking of the Marvel Cinematic Universe is simply impossible.
The absolutely monumental scope the film franchise now possesses is as surreal as it is completely awesome, with heroes like Iron Man and Captain America now being pop culture icons to just about anyone who has looked at a film screen.
While DC's films are definitely improving, they have yet to match both the fan hype and sheer scale of its Marvel nemesis. With the lukewarm reaction of DC's 2017 Justice League film, it's clear there are still steps to be taken before the franchise can begin to match up to the MCU.
With the amount of money a fully established DC film universe would provide, there's no doubt that the DCEU will be fighting fit in no time. But, until then, Marvel basically has a monopoly on the comic book movie market.
2. The Consequences Of Superpowers
While this may appear like a petty thing to comment on in terms of differing traits between DC and Marvel, it actually has a much bigger impact on overarching storylines than might initially be thought.
While the best example of this is undeniably the Hulk, the mutants that make up the X-Men also serve as a particularly good example.
For the Hulk, this is perhaps the most apparent - as his immense physical strength is undermined by the fact that Banner must transform into his green counterpart to use it, with his alternate form being often resistant to Banner's ideas, and also profoundly unnerving to those around him.
Similarly, the X-Men's powers are played almost painfully realistic in that people are intensely cruel and discriminate against them, due to the same combination of fear and a lack of understanding that provokes people to hating marginalised groups in the real world.
While it's not an always a pleasant representation of the world, Marvel's choice of showing superpowers as something that generally come at a great cost serves to make their heroes seem all the braver for embracing them.
1. Encouraging DC (Via Competition)
This may come as a surprise to those expecting an article that ruthlessly dunks on DC, but it's not without credence to say that one of the best things that Marvel do is to encourage DC to do bigger and better things - much like the same could be said in reverse for DC encouraging Marvel.
While fans are easily divided over which company is 'better', it tends to be forgotten that one of the main reasons both have evolved so dynamically and decisively is because of having to outstep the competition; and with DC and Marvel being the two main bastions of the comics industry, it stands that each has inadvertently improved their rival.
Without Marvel's prodding, there's a very real chance that DC would not have come leaps and bounds in making more compelling and clever stories, and as such, it does make sense to say that it can be considered one of the factors in DC's current status.
Adversity is a gift, we suppose - meaning comics fans on both sides of the aisle should be thankful for the Marvel/DC rivalry. Without it, it's possible the superhero genre wouldn't be what it is today.
The Ultimate Marvel Comics Quiz