8 Smartest Decisions In DC Villain History
How do you take down Superman when you're just a man?
Supervillains may be, as Batman always says, a 'cowardly and superstitious lot', but they know how to bring their A-game when the occasion calls for it. Naturally, given the DC universe is home to some of the most skilled and powerful heroes in the superhero genre, their antagonists have often had to rely on outwitting their opponent rather than engaging them head to head.
Most fail, but a select few manage to succeed - at least for a given time. The fact it's the exception and not the rule makes the whole thing so much more gratifying to see play out, and even though readers never actively will their heroes to fail, there's something brilliant about seeing a villain go to town and come this close to besting them.
It's rare they get to keep their victories after all, but still, it's not difficult to pause and appreciate the methodology behind their schemes, especially if it yields results.
Much as it is satisfying to see Batman take on a New God and win, watching Deathstroke match wits with Superman, or Amanda Waller with the Justice League, makes for a uniquely rewarding reading experience. You don't have to like either, but you can appreciate the lengths they've gone to in order to achieve their goals - particularly when it leads to such devastating consequences...
8. The Al Ghuls Get Their Heir - Batman & Son
Ever since the al Ghuls were first introduced back during the Bronze Age of comics, their one goal has been to recruit the Dark Knight as an heir to the League of Assassins, and to marry Talia to continue the lineage. They've been vexed in their efforts for decades thanks to Batman's refusal to kill people, and y'know, engage with eco-terrorism, even while Bruce harbours feelings for Ra's' daughter.
So, concocting the ultimate plan, Talia decides to spend the night with Bruce (who doesn't take his mask off, FYI), and uses his DNA to create a baby in an artificial womb. The League would then raise this child, waiting for the right moment to send it to the Caped Crusader to disrupt his crimefighting efforts.
As most will probably have gathered by now, this child was Damian Wayne. Grant Morrison and Andy Kubert's Batman & Son details the plot, and even shows Bruce's biological progeny actively disrupting the Bat-family at the age of ten. He's young, brattish and also a living weapon; quite the quandary, even for the World's Greatest Detective.
As far as plots go, it's actually pretty ingenious. If you can't get the heir you want, have a child, send him to disrupt the old heir (who's incidentally also the biggest threat to your own schemes), while also learning from him, and you're left - in theory - with the ideal candidate.
Of course, Damian sees through his mother's machinations in the end. He's now a Robin, and Talia? Well, she's seen better days.
7. Faking Kryptonite Bullets - Deathstroke
Deathstroke is one of the most intelligent, resourceful and downright ruthless villains the DC universe has to offer (though he may take umbrage with the 'v' word if you were to call him that). Plus, with an alias like 'The Terminator', you know he's got to be the real deal.
In his storied career, Deathstroke has taken on the likes of Batman, Green Arrow, the Teen Titans and more private armies than you could possibly imagine. So, just think about what would happen if you outfitted this mercenary - a super soldier with an unrivalled move-set and tactical nous - with one of the most advanced super-suits in DC's library. You get Christopher Priest's Deathstroke.
Priest's stint on the character alongside artist Carlo Pagulayan has proven to be a surprising highlight of DC Rebirth, with one of its best moments involving a confrontation between Slade and the Man of Steel himself, Superman.
Staring down the barrel of a big Kryptonian demi-god, Slade uses all the tools in his arsenal to buy himself some time. He uses the Ikon suit to repel Supes' attacks back at him, and - on the way to accomplishing his mission - chooses to douse his own bullets in neon green to emulate the look of Kryptonite. Meanwhile, Slade causes enough destruction to keep the Man of Steel occupied, and would've likely succeeded had the big blue boy scout not recruited Wilson's son, Jericho, to decommission the Ikon suit.
Either way, Slade's battle with Supes was a prime example of how intelligent the character is. Sure, he has some help, but the fake bullets are the cherry on top of a brilliant battle.
6. Making The Justice League Question Their Own Existence - JLU's Cadmus Arc
Dwayne McDuffie did some of the best superhero-related things ever while involved with the DC Animated Universe, with Justice League Unlimited's Cadmus arc arguably his finest contribution to the animated medium.
JLU was no stranger to straddling complex themes and narratives, but Cadmus was particularly ambitious. It asked startling questions surrounding the presence of the League, the admittedly terrifying implications of harbouring an army of human weapons in an orbital satellite, and whether or not Batman is really as intimidating as he seems. (Major spoilers ahead, by the way.)
So, what is Cadmus? They're a government organisation headed up by Amanda Waller designed to counteract superhero influence. At first they just seem like another shadowy black ops force out to get the League, but they're not all that bad. In fact it's Waller who gives Batman a dressing down in her bathrobe when the Dark Knight tries to intimidate her into revealing Cadmus' secrets, forcing him and other figures in the League to reappraise their own value, and whether they may actually be doing more harm than good.
Loyalties are strained, and the League nearly falls apart. But the real kicker is that it's Lex Luthor who's been pulling the strings all along, running as President to effectively put Superman off balance and sow division between the public, Cadmus and the League. It's revealed he's been sharing a body with Braniac all along, and was merely buying time to upload his and the Kryptonian AI's consciousness into an Amazo android, thus gaining immortality.
It was a damn fine scheme. Just a shame The Flash had to go and ruin it all by discovering the speed force.
5. Executing The Plan BEFORE Explaining It To The Heroes - Watchmen
It would be easy to kick off this entry by qualifying Watchmen as the amazing deconstruction of superhero comics that it is, but given you've heard it all before there's pretty much no point. Instead, let's take a look at Ozymandias, and how the climax where his scheme is revealed specifically exemplifies the genius of the comic.
Everyone who's read a comic or consumed any old piece of superhero media will be familiar with the tired and tested cliche of the villain revealing their master plan to the heroes, only for said heroes to use that information against the villain and thereby save the day. None ever seem to ponder the thought that their scheme could be foiled by their tenacious rivals, instead choosing to savour the moment by revelling in their own genius for just a second too long.
Ozymandias makes no such error. When Nite-Owl and Rorschach go to confront him for the murder of the Comedian, he reveals his grand design to his old teammates, with the presumption being he's yet to go through with his plan.
And then he just goes ahead and says he did it thirty-five minutes ago. Doing so eliminates the risk he could be foiled, and he proves successful when Doctor Manhattan ties up the loose-end that is Rorschach. It's left open ended as to whether or not Rorschach's journal exposes Ozymandias (at least when you ignore Doomsday Clock), but you'd struggle to find a more fool-proof plan.
4. Dismantling Bruce Wayne's Legacy - Heart Of Hush
Thomas Elliot arguably didn't become the great Batman villain he's known as today until much later into his career as a comic book character. Sure, he enjoyed a fine introduction in Batman: Hush, but he seemed unremarkable; another villain tied to Bruce Wayne's past who'd disappear, never to be seen again.
Six years after the publication of Hush, Paul Dini, Dustin Nguyen and Derek Fridolfs would prove everyone wrong by orchestrating Heart of Hush, a tie-in to Batman R.I.P. that saw the bandaged supervillain strike at Batman in a whole new way - by stealing Catwoman's heart.
Not in a figurative sense, by the way. No, Hush literally takes Selina Kyle's heart and forces Batman into a wild chase in an attempt to get it back. Usually that'd be that; Hush hates Bruce Wayne and would do anything to make him hurt. However, Elliot takes it all one step further by revealing he's reconstructed his entire face to look like Bruce Wayne. The end goal? To impersonate his rival and tarnish his family's name.
Villains have tried time and again to get underneath Batman's skin, but none had the... inspiration, shall we say, to think this far ahead. The Bat-Family are able to curtail Elliot's schemes to a degree during Streets of Gotham, but in presenting a new quandary for them to deal with - all while the real Bruce was missing following Final Crisis - Hush's scheme will go down as one of DC's smartest.
3. Using Batman's Paranoia Against The JLA - Tower of Babel
Truth be told, there's not much Ra's al Ghul really has to do in Tower of Babel. In fact it's really just Batman's own hubris that proves to be the most decisive asset to his old enemy in this Mark Waid-helmed Justice League tale, but no villain had ever thought to use it before.
Tower of Babel is famous for all the wrong reasons in that it tends to get used by Bat-fans as an excuse to wheel out the ol' 'Batman can beat anyone with prep-time' spiel, but it's still an interesting tale. Dig deeper, and it's actually one of the smartest JL books of the last two decades, as it sees the Dark Knight's own distrust for the Justice League exploited in the worst possible manner.
Although the Dark Knight has never really been a team player (he says, fully aware of the fact he's led multiple teams and has his own family - but whatever, I'm beholden to the cliche in this particular instance), none suspected he'd actively analysed and prepared countermeasures to incapacitate his comrades in the event they ever went rogue.
Through some trickery, and as a means of keeping the League occupied while he executes his latest scheme to 'defend' the earth, Ra's steals Batman's League countermeasures and deploys them against his teammates, leading to all sorts of gruesome scenarios. The League of course prevail in the end, but their trust in Batman is completely shattered, forcing the Caped Crusader to abandon them by the arc's close.
2. Having A Double Agent On The Team - Judas Contract
The Judas Contract is a seminal comics storyline that put the Teen Titans - and Deathstroke - on the map. It was well executed in terms of just how devastating at was, and its centre lied the conceit that the Titans newest member, Terra, was actually a double-agent working for Deathstroke, their arch nemesis.
If any comic were to cement Slade as a relentless operator, then it would be Marv Wolfman and George Perez's. Terra was introduced as a new member for the team but the intention was always to have her revealed as a villain, and for her to die shortly thereafter, but it wasn't her scheme. In many ways, she was just like the rest of the Titans - a victim of Deathstroke's machinations.
Make no mistake, Deathstroke abused this girl to get what he wanted - and it nearly paid off. Using intel gathered by Terra, Slade struck at each of the Titans when they were most vulnerable, using their secret identities against them to gain the upper-hand. One by one, he catches all of them, bringing them to H.I.V.E., the Terminator's employers.
Introducing a double agent into the equation isn't exactly the most inventive idea, but it was deployed to great effect in the Titans' seminal outing. Deathstroke only fails due to the intervention of his wife and son, while Terra suffers a full-blown breakdown and kills herself with her own powers.
1. Overwhelming The Dark Knight - Knightfall
Batman is a creature of habit. Even though he has a family and a dependable network of allies, you can almost always guarantee that he's going to do things the hard way, on his own, and that it'll have a detrimental effect at some point. Were someone to realise that, it's safe to say they could cause a whole lot of damage.
The first villain to truly understand the Dark Knight's frailties was Bane, and he didn't waste time in capitalising on him. Using all his resources, the venom-enhanced supervillain overwhelms Gotham by causing a mass breakout at Arkham Asylum, thus unleashing all of Batman's most dangerous enemies at once, and causing an immense panic across the city. While trying to put everything back together the Caped Crusader suffers a complete burnout, struggling to deal with the escalating violence caused by Bane's prison-break.
At this point in time, Bane also made the incredibly smart decision to look at the Dark Knight's jaw for more than a second, and realises that it belongs to none other than Bruce Wayne. With that knowledge in hand, and with Batman weakened by an unending crisis engulfing the city, Bane makes his way to Wayne Manor and beats the Dark Knight senseless, completing his plan by breaking him in two in one of the most iconic Batman moments of all time.
It's a simple plan, but sometimes the most genius ones are. Batman could never hope to quell an entire city ravaged by his worst enemies by himself, and only in understanding that is Bane able to exact his revenge, and cement himself as one of DC's most formidable antagonists.
Watch Next
DC Quiz: Can You Name These Obscure Batman Villains?