8 Things DC Want You To Forget About Harley Quinn

They did WHAT for a competition?!

Harley Quinn
DC Comics

Harley Quinn is one DC's most popular characters, but - more often than not - that popularity has also courted controversy.

Said controversies have mostly occurred within the past five or so years, where appearances in both the Arkham games and various other animated features precipitated the character's cinematic debut in 2016's Suicide Squad - itself criticised for its depiction of Dr. Quinn. Harley also led the charge during DC's divisive New 52 relaunch - it, too, the subject of much criticism.

Point being, Harleen has had it rough these last few years. And while yes, her original misadventures undoubtedly had their problematic elements, few writers/artists have given the bisexual abuse survivor the respect she truly deserves, with DC now being able to boast a catalogue of errors in regards to their treatment of the Paul Dini creation in mediums animated and otherwise.

That stinks, and it's more true now more than ever that the company aren't doing enough to combat perceptions that cast the character's relationship with the Joker as romantic and one to be coveted. The production of a rom-com Joker/Harley movie confirms as much.

While DC's abject ignorance in regards to her treatment would imply an apathy in regards to what they do - and don't - want you to forget about the character, it's clear that the fanbase cares. For good reason too...


8. How They Keep Romanticising Her Abusive Relationship

Warner Bros.

Recently - in the comics at least - a real effort has been made to disassociate Harley Quinn from the Joker. Harley's got a girlfriend in Poison Ivy, hates the Joker with a burning passion, and is very much over the purple-clad clown in every sense of the word. The part of her life where she was with Mister J isn't looked upon fondly - it's remembered for being the abusive relationship that it was.

That hasn't stopped fans and studios alike from misreading the relationship entirely, however. Suicide Squad presented an utterly painful dynamic where Harley and Joker were very much in love with each other, and it's one that will, ostensibly, be further mined when the team that brought you the Hangover make a rom-com revolving around the pair. Blurgh.

It's just wrong. It's tacky, and it's wrong. And despite the aforementioned efforts to distance the character from her synonymy with the Clown Prince, it's an element DC keep returning to. Harley is and has been more than her relationship for many years now. Why is that so difficult to translate off the page?


7. Her First Live-Action Appearance Came In Birds Of Prey

The WB

Although Suicide Squad was never something to write home about, Margot Robbie's performance as Harley Quinn was one of the film's few redeeming aspects. She had the voice, the look and the presence to make it work in live action, but other Harleens haven't been as fortunate.

For those not in the know, the Birds of Prey was a short-lived TV show centred around the eponymous team from the comics, led by Oracle, Huntress and Black Canary. Among the few villains the series was able to boast was Harley Quinn, who was played by Mia Sara during its initial 13 episode run. There, she's cast as a psychiatrist who - unbeknownst to the wider team - was the original Quinn when Joker was still around.

This Harley is as interesting as any other, but considering that Birds of Prey only has one home release to speak of, it would seem as though DC would prefer this series - more than others - to go unnoticed.


6. Break Into Comics With Harley Quinn!

Harley Quinn Amanda Conner New 52
DC Comics

Back in 2013, to celebrate the launch of Harley's solo series for the New 52, DC launched a competition for aspiring artists to draw Harley with the promise that they could, potentially, get fast-tracked into the industry. Doesn't sound all that bad, right? For an industry as competitive as the comics one, it seemed - at the time at least - like a positive move.

How wrong we were.

You see, the images that artists were requested to draw were inflammatory in every sense of the word, all involving Harley attempting to kill herself shortly before suicide prevention week began. It took a massive response online for DC to realise that maybe - just maybe - making a rib on an abuse survivor attempting to kill herself wasn't in good taste, particularly in as literal a way as the script demanded (it involved Harley chucking electrical appliances into a bath-tub).

To Jimmy Palmiotti and Amanda Conner's credit, the initial description that went out for the scene lacked the context added dialogue would've undoubtedly afforded it. There's no denying the move was poorly-timed, however, and - as far as DC controversies go - this one is right up there with the company's most recent errors.


5. Everything To Do With Suicide Squad

Harley Quinn Suicide Squad New 52
DC Comics

God, the New 52 really was pants, wasn't it?

Without getting into the myriad of reasons of why, exactly, it was doomed to fail, one of the most egregious errors the reboot made involved Harley Quinn, with DC having attempted to synergise the character's looks with the edgier, less iconic redesign that had appeared in Rocksteady's Arkham series. This entailed a new origin (which we'll get to in a moment), but also some bizarre alterations that came in 2011's Suicide Squad comic.

There, Harley began a romance with Deadshot, and exemplified pretty much every comic book cliché when it comes to the design and characterisation of women in the medium.

The series itself was a critical flop, and while other characters featured throughout the run fared no better, none emerged worse than Harley, who again, seemed to typify all that was wrong with the relaunch's attitude to women on and off the page.


4. Nightwing Did What?

Warner Bros.

Bruce Timm is one of the best and brightest minds to have lent his talents to the DC Universe these last few decades, having been instrumental in the success of Batman: The Animated Series, Justice League, and countless other animated features adapted from the DC library. Batman & Harley Quinn, however, does not speak well for that reputation.

Neither does 2016's adaptation of The Killing Joke, which, having already taken the trope of refrigerating women by default, managed to cool the temperature even more by introducing a bizarre and frankly creepy romance between Bruce Wayne and Barbara Gordon. At the time it felt like nothing more than inappropriate fan-service, especially since past Timm works had intimated a romantic interest between the pair previously.

Unfortunately, the same feeling pervaded last month's Batman & Harley Quinn - another Timm-led project that, while admittedly distant in tone to TKJ, was no less adamant with its bizarre ships. The ship this time was, of course, between Nightwing and Harley, and it's about as awkward and off-putting as you can imagine.

The two end up bumping uglies at one point (although the film is polite enough to cut away as things get going), and yeah, it's just there, isn't it?

It'd be nice to see Harley and Ivy together in a medium other than the comics themselves, but for now, fans will have to tolerate... whatever this was.


3. Bud And Lou

Harley Quinn Bud And Lou
Warner Bros.

Fans of Batman: The Animated Series will no doubt be aware of Bud and Lou, Harley's voracious pet Hyenas who, more often than not, got the chance to chow down on the Dark Knight on plenty of occasions.

Harley really does love her pets, even if they are more exotic than your average Alsatian, but that hasn't stopped DC and others from doing their best to harm the poor critters. Rocksteady famously killed the pair of them off in between Arkham Asylum and Arkham City, with Penguin having stuffed and placed them on display in his City museum.

Not the nicest Easter Eggs, then, for a character already dealing with the Joker's impending demise. Worse yet, however, was Bud and Lou's treatment in the Death of the Family - a seminal Bat series that, while undoubtedly impressive, really had it in for Harleen. In it, a galvanised and fully sadistic Joker turns the hyenas against their owner, and Harley - faced with no other option - is forced to kill them.

It's a sad moment, and while some fans might find the gimmick of two pet Hyenas jarring in certain respects, Harley really was fond of them.


2. 2008's Joker Graphic Novel

Harkey Quinn Joker Brian Azzarello
DC Comics

Although Brian Azzarello's 2008 Joker OGN bears many aesthetic similarities with Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy, they're unconnected. Probably for the better, mind you, considering the series' depiction of Harley Quinn.

In the book, Harley's role is further marginalised, with the character taking on the role of Joker's dialogue-less henchwoman and stripper. She doesn't have a single line to boast, and while Lee Bermejo's art is as wonderful as ever, Harley once again comes up short, taking on a role unbefitting of a character of her stature.

The book itself was controversial, with the Joker doing plenty of twisted things in it that even the mainstream clown would probably find repellant. And while itt might just be the one story, Harley doesn't really benefit from it at all.


1. Her New 52 Origin

Harley Quinn New 52 Origin
DC Comics

Until 2011 - when the aforementioned New 52 relaunched DC continuity for the worse - Harley's origin was set in stone, for the most part. It followed on from her roots in BTAS, with the story of a psychologist falling for Gotham's most notorious criminal and becoming his righthand woman proving to be the origin of choice.

While the Joker's deception in manipulating Quinzel to break him out of Arkham continues to be the best Harley origin going, the New 52 opted to spice things up, conjuring a very literal transformation for Harley instead of the more believable and better known one produced years before.

In this newer origin - imitated in last year's Suicide Squad film - the Joker launches Harley into the same chemical bath that, ostensibly, changed him. It's a very on the nose change, and takes away the agency the doctor had in her original origin story, further eroding the significance of the very real and very harmful aspects of her relationship with the Joker.

Here, she's more Joker, less Harley. It doesn't work.

-

What do you think of Harley's most recent changes? Are you a fan? Let us know in the comments below!


Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.