9 Cool Batman: Knightquest Moments Everyone Forgets About

What happened when a man with a broken moral compass took on the mantle of the Bat!

Jean-Paul Valley Azrael Batman
DC Comics

When most people think of the Knightfall saga, it's in terms of the bookends of this run.

First, the Knightfall story itself; Bane's destruction of Bruce Wayne and Batman's resurrection in the guise of the assassin-turned-vigilante Azrael, aka Jean-Paul Valley. The other bookend is the Knightend arc which features Wayne's eventual return to reclaim the mantle of the Bat from his psychopathic understudy.

Often forgotten, however, is the long period where "Az-Bats" - as fans came to affectionately know him as - was the star of the various monthly Batman books.

While Bruce Wayne searched the world for the McGuffin that would enable him to walk again, Valley had his own adventures. None of the stories are Eisner Award winners by any stretch of the imagination, but many of them were interesting, fun and gave us a look at a Batman not tempered by Bruce Wayne's moral compass.

9. A Very Different Batman

Azrael Batman Tim Drake
DC Comics

For the first 54 years of his crime-fighting career, the man beneath Batman's cape and cowl was millionaire playboy Bruce Wayne. Then in 1993, the impossible happened, and a criminal called Bane broke Wayne's back, forcing Bruce to entrust Gotham City and the legacy of Batman to another.

Instead of picking the obvious choice and going with the former Robin, Dick Grayson, he would pass the mantle onto the reformed religious zealot and assassin known as Azrael.

DC Comics introduced a very different Batman to the readers and citizens of Gotham City. Instead of Wayne's sleek athletic build, keen intellect and incorruptible sense of justice, there was an armoured nightmare more in line with the '90s comics zeitgeist; one not forged by a desire to save the innocent, but one who had achieved human perfection through psychological manipulation - a warrior built and programmed rather than shaped from pain and sacrifice.

And that was ultimately what Jean-Paul Valley was. Not a hero pursuing justice, but a vicious avenger punishing the guilty through fire and steel.


8. The Man Behind The Bat

Bruce Wayne Alfred Batman Knightquest
DC Comics

While Azrael's "Crusade" took place in Gotham City, the now broken Bruce Wayne would undertake a mission of his own and search for Jack Drake and Shondra Kinsolving.

From an editorial standpoint, the entire Knightquest: The Search arc was an excuse to remove Wayne from Gotham City without killing him off. It would also allow writers to deal with his broken back without infringing on the sense of gritty realism they were trying to portray in the other Batman titles.

The Search storyline is a ground-up reconstruction of Bruce Wayne, looking at all the elements that made him such a formidable character. Here was a hero who had become defined by his allies, his gadgets and his peerless physical prowess, reduced to a lone man in a wheelchair, travelling the globe attempting to solve a kidnapping with nothing but his intellect and faithful butler.

While it may have pretty quickly strayed from its original premise (Including a crossover with the Justice League Task Force), it is one of those rare occasions where readers are given time with the man behind the mask and a look at what makes Bruce Wayne so unique.


7. New Villians

Trigger Twins Batman Knightquest
DC Comic

Batman has the best rogues gallery in comics. However, when you have such a pantheon of degenerates, psychopaths and crimes bosses to choose from, stagnation and repetition can soon set in.

Whenever a new writer takes over on one of the Batman books, it's only a matter of time before they want to tell their Riddler story or show us their take on Ra's al Ghul.

Knightquest offered DC an opportunity to introduce a whole slew of new criminals to Gotham City, ones who the writers would tailor for a new kind of Batman.

During this time, Benedict Asp, the Trigger Twins and Mekros, to name a few, would appear. While most of the new additions were not what you would call first round picks, it allowed the writers to do more than rehash the same old stories.

While an encounter with Malevolent Maniaxe might not be the stuff of legend, it is still refreshing to see creators create and not just drag the same old toys out of the box.


6. The Joker And Batman Relationship During This Time

Joker Batman Knightquest
DC Comics

His relationship with his villains defines Batman, which is never more true than in the case of the Joker.

The Clown Prince of Crime is Batman's dark reflection; a horrible mirror image of how life could have been had Bruce Wayne made a different choice after what happened that night in Crime Alley.

These two are locked in a constant struggle, with Joker developing an all-consuming obsession with the Dark Knight Detective. His crimes became less about material gains or spreading chaos, and more about getting the attention of the object of his twisted affections.

When "Az-Bats" saves a missing teenage girl, dressed as Robin, from plummeting to her death, he happens upon the Joker making a movie about the destruction of Batman. Seeing Azrael in action, it takes only a few moments for the Jester of Genocide to discover that the man behind the mask is an imposter.

Then, readers are treated to a moment of absurdist humour where the Joker walks away; refusing to indulge the pretender in his delusions and sulking about how much time he had wasted on a faux-Batman.

Unlike his ill-advised ponytail, Joker's "Bat-Lite" antagonism would become a recurring theme with Jean-Paul Valley in all his future guises.


5. The Batman/Punisher Crossover

Batman Punisher
DC/Marvel

On paper, Batman and the Punisher share strikingly similar origins. Each watched their loved ones murdered before their eyes and swore to do everything in their power to make sure that it never happened again. However, that is where the similarities end.

For all Bruce Wayne's violent actions, his modern incarnation has held fast to two unshakeable rules; no guns and he never kills. Fans cannot say the same for Frank Castle.

When Bruce encounters Punisher during the JLA/Avengers crossover, it's as a throwaway joke. Wayne swoops down between panels and cleans up a violent altercation between Castle and a group of armed thugs, quickly defining the difference between the two men.

In contrast, things were very different when Jean-Paul Valley was under the Bat-mask.

Ostensibly, this meeting followed the standard pattern of the two heroes coming together, falling foul of miscommunication and fighting to a draw before finally teaming up to defeat the real villains - in this case, Joker and Jigsaw.

However, what this offered DC was an opportunity to show just how different Azrael was from his predecessor and just how slim the gap between this Batman and the Punisher had become.


4. The Catwoman And Batman Relationship

Batman Knightquest Catwoman
DC Comics

Bruce Wayne as Batman has had many loves over the years, from Vicki Vale and Vesper Fairchild, to Talia al Ghul and Silver St. Cloud.

Still, no woman has had a more tumultuous relationship with him than Selina Kyle, the sometimes ally and sometimes enemy known as Catwoman. No matter which side of the law she is on, there is always an undeniable chemistry between Selina and Bruce.

Unlike other classic Batman characters who would encounter Jean-Paul Valley, for Selina Kyle there was never a moment of doubt or hesitation. From the moment she set eyes upon Batman's new armoured visage, she knew that he was not the man she had such strong emotions for.

It is Valley who comes out of this encounter changed the most. The almost puritanical religious fanatic is left to contend with new feelings of attraction towards his latest foe.

Selina exploits the entranced vigilante and uses it as an excuse to flee Gotham City with the McGuffin that had drawn her there in the first place. Like the Joker, when Catwoman encounters Valley in the future, she is aware of his time as Batman, and continually exploits his naivety and attraction towards her.


3. Almost Murdering Gunhawk

Gunhawk Batman: Knightquest
DC Comics

Azrael's last case as Batman would see him taking on the murderer known as Gunhawk and his sidekick Bunny. It was also the culmination of Jean-Paul Valley's slow descent into madness.

Throughout the entire Crusade story arc, Valley's psyche had been on a knife edge. On one side, his need to be "Batman" keeps Gotham City safe from the darkness that threatens to consume her. On the other, his programming from the Order of St. Dumas gives him his abilities and feeds his need for vengeance.

During a confrontation between Batman and Gunhawk, Bunny is injured, forcing Valley to retreat from combat and choose between justice and vengeance. Azrael concludes that he can have both and swears to becomes a Batman who will punish the guilty and save Gotham City from itself. After Azrael makes final alterations to his armour, he heads to the hospital, planning to deal with Gunhawk once and for all.

Valley, lost to bloodlust, traps his foe and rains down blows upon him. Only moments away from killing Gunhawk, Azrael is interrupted by a GCPD tactical squad, and the vigilante disappears into the shadows instead of confronting the armed police officers.


2. The Jim Gordon And Batman Relationship

Azrael Batman Knightquest Jim Gordon
DC Comics

While the likes of Robin and Batgirl may have all been "with" Batman for a long time, only Alfred Pennyworth's relationship with Bruce Wayne is as tenured as that of Jim Gordon.

These two men pulled Gotham City back from the brink after it almost drowned in a sea of corruption, organised crime and senseless violence. Although it has never been clear whether Gordon knew who the man under the mask was, the two share a bond of mutual trust and respect - one which breaks when Bruce leaves the "Mantle of the Bat" and protection of Gotham City to another.

Like Joker and Catwoman, Gordon knew almost instantly that this Batman wasn't "his" Batman, and this led to him questioning if he had been right to put so much faith in Bruce Wayne.

Azrael, for his part, tolerates Gordon as a means to an end, although he finds that he has more in common with the aggressive and antagonistic Harvey Bullock.

It would take many years for Bruce to regain Gordon's trust, although the fracture in their relationship would never truly heal.


1. Letting Abattoir Die

Batman Abattoir Knightquest
DC Comics

If ever fans had any doubt during the Knightfall event about Bruce Wayne's return, DC put them to rest during Jean-Paul Valley's encounter with the serial killer Abattoir. Batman has held one rule above all others; he does not kill. No matter the circumstances or how many lives he would ultimately spare by simply breaking the Joker's neck - all human life is sacred.

Arnold Etchison, a killer obsessed with murdering members of his own family, abducts his cousin and imprisons him inside a death trap. Batman tracks him down to a foundry, and in the ensuing battle Abattoir ends up hanging for his life over a vat of molten lava. He pleads with Azrael to save him, but instead, Batman watches as Etchison loses his grip and plummets to his death.

To compound matters, Azrael later learns from Jim Gordon that Etchison's cousin died while Batman was busy seeking vengeance.

Jean-Paul Valleys inaction resulting in the deaths of both the innocent and the guilty.


Contributor
Contributor

Kevin McHugh is a code-monkey by day and a purveyor of the unpleasant by night. Having had several comics published by Future Quake Press he is now moving into prose. An avid fan of punk rock, cheap horror movies and even cheaper fast-food Kevin can be found pontificating either on Twitter or over at WhatCulture Comics where he is a regular contributor. He lives in Edinburgh with his wife and two daughters.