Batman Eternal: 10 Best Moments So Far
Can Gotham be saved again?
DC ComicsAnnounced to coincide with the 75th Anniversary of Batman, the weekly ongoing series Batman Eternal has been going strong now for nearly four months. Featuring an all-star lineup of writers (including Scott Snyder, James Tynion IV, Ray Fawkes, Kyle Higgins and Tim Seeley) and a revolving door of artists as well, Eternal is one of the most ambitious DC projects in recent memory. The plot so far has been driven by the framing of Commissioner James Gordon following a horrific accident in the Gotham City subway. Police corruption reaches an all-time high in Gordon's absence, and various forces vie for control of the Gotham underworld. Meanwhile, supernatural stirrings at Arkham Asylum threaten to add another element of evil to the problems on Batman's plate. Despite a strong opening, there's still a lot of Eternal left to go - this article will cover the best moments from the first 14 issues, and so a spoiler warning for those issues is hereby in effect. If you haven't begun a new Batman book in a while or are looking for a fresh, ongoing series, the action-packed Eternal just might do the trick. Honorable Mention: The Return Of Deacon Blackfire
DC ComicsDeacon Blackfire is the primary antagonist of the well-respected Batman miniseries The Cult, written by Jim Starlin and published in 1998. Without spoiling the ending of that particular arc, suffice it to say that Blackfire has been absent since his debut in the pages of The Cult. Early on in Eternal (#2), Blackfire has seemingly returned, and his appearance is decidedly different. This New 52 continuity may possibly honor the original history of the insane Deacon, and time will tell how much of a player Blackfire will be in the Eternal storyline.
10. Bat-Armor
DC ComicsIt's no secret that Bruce Wayne has a surplus of gadgets, suits, weapons, vehicles, and accessories to allow him escape from nearly any situation. Bat-copters, bat-databases, shark-repellent bat-spray - you name it, the Dark Knights probably got it. Bruce has sported body armor in his rotation of suits on more than one occasion, but his entrance in Eternal #1 wearing a formidable weaponized getup showed the experience of this particular Batman. The timeline of Eternal has always been in contention, as it takes place in the New 52 continuity and yet exists outside of the regular Batman and Detective Comics lines, but this is clearly a Batman who has been operating for some time. The newbie, purple-glove wearing Batman of Scott Snyder's other current arc Zero Year - a new origin story for the Caped Crusader, and an excellent one - is replaced by a Batman with enough crimefighting know-how to keep a spare bat-armour lying around. Bruce's entrance heralded a miniseries in which Batman knows what he's doing - a fact which makes the impending challenges all the more threatening.
9. Julia Pennyworth
DC ComicsThe introduction of Julia Pennyworth - estranged daughter of Bruce Wayne's trusted butler Alfred - marked the first appearance of the character since she was retconned out of existence by the DC event series Crisis on Infinite Earths. Her debut in the New 52 continuity is hopefully more than a cameo, as her real role in Eternal is yet to play out. So far, Julia has been working for SRR in Hong Kong, attempting to take out a mob boss associated with Carmine Falcone. Batman interferes, as Batman is wont to do, and Julia ends up injured. Thankfully, her father has more than a fair share of experience treating battle wounds, and he nearly divulges as much to Julia back at Wayne Manor. Will Julia discover Bruce's secret identity? Her view of her father is less than flattering, and she shows visible disappointment that her father follows and dotes on a spoiled playboy. There's still a lot of Eternal left to play out, so you can bet that Julia will discover her father's true, honorable nature among the filth of Gotham as a warrior for the Good Side.
8. Arthur Brown's Secret Life
DC ComicsThe first glimpse into the world of Eternal came during the Scott Snyder/Greg Capullo origin arc Zero Year, which is nearing an end in the Batman title (with a few ancillary crossovers into other DC titles like Detective Comics). As Zero Year progressed, Eternal suddenly replaced the current storyline for one issue (Batman #28), providing a suitably vague but doubtlessly intriguing flash-forward into the upcoming miniseries. One important player in that sneak-peek issue was Stephanie Brown, absent in the New 52 so far and sporting the guise of the vigilante Spoiler. When Eternal actually began, it became clear that Stephanie Brown's story was vital to the coming events. She happens upon her father in the costume of the villain Cluemaster, consorting with other Gotham baddies like Lock-Up and Signalman, and from then on Stephanie's life is a dangerous one. Slowly, the tales of both Stephanie and Arthur Brown are becoming intertwined with the larger arc of Eternal. Flashbacks to the creation of Cluemaster in the mind of Arthur Brown are revealed as Stephanie researches her father's hidden past, and it's clear that Batman and Co. will cross paths with the Browns sooner rather than later.
7. Spectre And Batwing Enter Arkham
DC ComicsIn an event series as large as Eternal, one risk is that too many characters get jammed into each issue just becausewell, just because they can. Fifty-two weekly issues is a lot of story to tell, and Snyder and the Eternal writers could have easily fallen prey to the urge of including DC characters that ultimately have little bearing on the actual story. It may be too early to tell, but although Eternal is indeed packed with characters old and new, the sense that all of them are connected and working towards the story (rather than against it) has been strong. Jim Corrigan's otherworldly alter-ego Spectre has popped up a few times, and his presence seems to indicate that the villains behind the current ills of Gotham could also be supernatural. And unlikely duos always make their way into miniseries like Eternal, this time in the form of Spectre and Batwing. Their first meeting is written predictably, but it's no less satisfying. Batwing is confounded by the magic of Spectre, Corrigan is somewhat irked at the inexperience of Batwing, but both are focused on the decidedly treacherous mission at hand.
6. James Gordon Jr.
DC ComicsAmong the many surprising character additions throughout the first collection of Eternal issues is that of James Gordon Jr., appearing at the tail end of Eternal #14. Scott Snyder has experience writing the quietly murderous Young James, mainly through his excellent Dick Grayson-as-Batman arc collected as The Black Mirror. Gordon Sr. being taken out of commission so early on was always a highly suspicious occurrence, and it will be interesting to see how James Jr. plays into that (if at all). There are already a lot of villains populating Eternal - including Blackfire, Professor Pyg, Carmine Falcone, The Penguin, etc. etc. - but James Jr. is just as likely to be a Big Bad in the world of Eternal. In many ways, James Jr. is the perfect foil for his father, a sentiment which is echoed in the subtle reflection in Gordon Sr.'s glasses in the illustration above. It will be interesting to see how both intelligent, devoted Gordons figure into the larger game afoot, and how Snyder and Co. provide a fresh take on a character that Snyder has already had success with.
5. War On Batman
DC ComicsThe Gotham City Police Department's official stance on Batman has been ever-shifting, even since the earliest incarnations of the Caped Crusader. The original Batman was essentially a private contractor for the police, albeit with motives of his own, and the GCPD respected Batman's vigilantism and never lifted a finger to stop him. By the time the Year One Era rolled around, the GCPD resented Batman and actively hunted him. James Gordon himself was a big part of the hunt for the Dark Knight, and his realization of the necessity of such a force in Gotham City is both the best part of Frank Miller's Year One and an important step in freshening the relationship between the two. Obviously, Eternal takes Gordon out of the picture, leaving room for a full-scale war on the Bat. This appears to be a much more concentrated effort than any we have seen before, to the extent that actual criminals are ignored in favor of hunting the black-caped vigilante. The war is an overarching plot point that will no doubt come to a head, but it has already yielded some more specific moments of significance...
4. Forbes Lets Pyg Loose
DC ComicsActing Commissioner Forbes is a cut above your typical corrupt Gotham cop. Again, with Gordon out of the picture, the police crackdown on Batman's vigilantism is able to reach new heights. Forbes is the guy to steer everything toward that goal, although he's doing so at the bidding of the more dastardly villains in the pages of Eternal. Still, Forbes is pretty nasty in his own right. Professor Pyg, the utterly ridiculous yet somehow terrifying hack surgeon bent on brainwashing Gothamites, has featured quite a bit in the first few issues of Eternal, only recently being caught by Batman and strung up for the police to handle. The police begin to do just that - until Forbes comes along and actually cuts him loose. That Forbes would take his hunt for Batman so seriously that he actively assists dangerous supervillains along the way suggests that Forbes certainly enjoys his current position of power as Commissioner. Even though he's really just a henchman for the more well-known bad guys, Forbes is managing to do more than his fair share of damage to Batman and his allies.
3. Bard Saves Batman
DC ComicsThe flip side of Forbes's shameful alliances is populated by the likes of Jason Bard, another lesser-known character that has nonetheless taken the spotlight in Eternal from the very first issue. Bard originally appeared in 1969 as a Gotham City cop with a war injury to his knee, and the character popped up every now and then during the 1970s and '80s. Bard's appearance in Eternal is his first in several decades, and he's certainly a different character than the war-torn Marine of the pre-Crisis comics. This Jason Bard is a young, idealistic cop from Detroit brought to Gotham by Jim Gordon himself, just before Gordon is incarcerated for the disastrous train incident. Bard sees the strength and honor in Gordon from their first meeting, and he seems loyal to him despite just having arrived in Gotham. While Forbes rigs a trap to catch Batman, Bard manages to allow the Dark Knight the smallest of windows for escape - which Batman takes - and in doing so jeopardises his standing with the Commissioner. This scenario sets Bard up to be a young Gordon of sorts, defying the "law" in favor of the "right", and it's exciting to imagine the possibilities of where Bard's character could go in the coming issues.
2. The Return Of Carmine Falcone
DC ComicsOne of the biggest reveals so far in Eternal also came quite early on, at the tail end of Eternal #2, and that was the presence of infamous mafia don Carmine Falcone. Falcone is a well-known villain despite his lack of theatrics or superpowers, largely due to integral roles in Jeph Loeb's seminal Batman mystery The Long Halloween and an appearance in Christopher Nolan's film Batman Begins. As is the case with characters like Deacon Blackfire and James Gordon Jr., it's unclear exactly which elements of the pre-New 52 Falcone remain intact. The scars on his face indicate that some events from The Long Halloween may be honored, and it is fairly obvious that this return to Gotham City comes after a long stint away. The "unfinished business" that Falcone and Selina Kyle keep alluding to is also a reference to The Long Halloween and the original depictions of the mob boss. On one hand, honouring that lineage is exciting; on the other, it hardly even matters. Eternal is forging a new path with a fresh vision of Gotham City, and Falcone is bringing the mafia element into the mix in a big way. So far, he's been a major player - we'll see if he's really the one pulling the strings, though, or if he's just another marionette for the real Eternal villain. Speaking of which...
1. The Beginning Of The End
DC ComicsThe opening page of Eternal #1 remains the most compelling series of panels thus far in the extensive story arc. While eerily reminiscent of Grant Morrison's run on Batman, the flash-forward to "The End" on the very first page does provide a lot of intrigue. We see Bruce Wayne tied to the Batsignal, a bleeding Batman logo carved onto his chest, and Gotham City burning around him. An unseen evil speaks to him: Your allies have been slaughtered. Your city is burning to the ground. I have taken everything from you, piece by piece. Watch, Brucewatch as you lose everything.This is the primary antagonist of Eternal, although it's not clear whether this true villain has popped up yet. Is it Falcone? Surely not. Blackfire? Who knows? Events have already begun to spin out of control, and we're told from the first page that things are going to get very, very bad before they get any better. What have been your favorite moments from Eternal so far? Are you looking forward to the continuation of the series? Let us know in the comments section below.