Death Of Wolverine: 10 Far Better Ways He Should've Died

There had to be a better way to go than looking like a knock-off Han Solo in carbonite.

Wolverine is not just a mutant and member of the X-Men. He is arguably the most identifiable mutant and X-man in existence, at first slowly growing in popularity after his debut brawl with Hulk and and then exploding into a fan favorite when Chris Claremont took him on during his epic run on the X-Men some decades ago. Sure, the character has had his missteps in comics or other forms of media (the less we talk about Wolverine: Origins, the better), but throughout his fictional life Wolverine has captured the imagination of countless fans intrigued by his mysterious history (that eventually was revealed in the shocking Origin mini-series), tough-guy attitude, and healing-factor that is as cool as it is admittedly kind of gross. Considering how much love Wolverine gets, when not too long ago Marvel finally confirmed the rumors that everyone's favorite cigar-chomping badass was going to die in an epic comic event, it raised some eyebrows and got a lot of people excited. Then they made him mortal and had him frozen into a statue via liquid-hot adamantium. Yeah. Considering just how amazing and popular a character Wolverine was (or is, as do our heroes ever truly die?) here are 10 far better ways Marvel could have given him the sendoff he deserved.


10. Drowning, Of Course

It's so obvious that it has to be listed first. Wolverine has a skeleton made out of a heavy metal known as adamantium, and those of you with a passing knowledge of science are aware that heavy things don't float well in water. Therefore, should you want to kill Wolverine, it really could be as simple as tripping him face down into a kiddie-pool and not letting him up until his brain runs out of oxygen, dies, and his body goes with it. Perhaps the fact this is such a clearly easy way to kill Wolverine is why Marvel had often teased it in the past as a way Wolverine's enemies would try to off him, but not what Marvel actually did. Still, the fact it would be so unsurprising for Marvel to kill Wolverine this way...would have actually made it a tad surprising if they had just gone and drowned him.

9. Blowing Him Up

Wolverine of course has a healing factor which has served the purpose of making him essentially invincible. The thing is, depending on whom has been writing the character, his healing abilities can vary from being able to regenerate from basically a few flakes of skin as if he were a less funny version of DC's Lobo, to the idea of him getting shot up, putting him out of commission for a number of hours. It really is up to interpretation, and that fact makes it quite possible that if someone were to truly go and blow Wolverine up, make sure to utterly destroy his adamantium skeleton (during the times in continuity he has had it), and keep all his DNA in millions of little pieces, maybe, just maybe, good ol' Logan would stay dead. That said, some writer could come and claim a new Wolverine could grow from an old fingernail clipping, so this probably isn't the best idea.

8. Time Travel!

We all talk about those "what if" scenarios where we could travel through time and stop something we dislike from happening--like talking Kim Kardashian out of making a sex tape and hopefully keeping her from ever becoming famous. With that in mind, wouldn't it make perfect sense for a villain of Wolverine to hop in a time-machine, keep James Howlett (his actual birth name) from ever being born, and not ever have to worry about getting stabbed by the angry Canuck? Sure, it is kind of a cop-out, and Marvel actually had a whole event that ended with reality being broken due to all the characters always meddling with time-travel (the Age of Ultron comic), but I'm sure time could handle just one more little alteration without being utterly destroyed, right? After all, Kang the Conqueror does basically nothing but travel through time and mess with continuity as Marvel sees fit (so the Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver aren't mutants now, thanks to him).

7. Lose Him In Outer Space

Drowning was mentioned earlier, but suffocation in space is a bit different. What if Wolverine were to be literally lost in space, forever floating about, not-quite dead but without enough oxygen to be alive in any sense? It would be an actually kind of quiet way for Wolverine to die, just forever slowly moving through the vacuum of space. Considering how often Marvel has epic space-fights, it wouldn't be too much of a surprise to think of Logan saving the day in a spaceship and then dying a heroic death as it blows up and hurls him light-years away. Plus, should Marvel ever want to bring him back it would be as easy as some aliens finding his body in orbit and giving it life again with some crazy sci-fi powers.

6. Starvation

While we may not often see super-heroes taking a break from the latest world-ending event to grab a snack, many are somewhat human in that they get a bit hungry. It would be simple: you just need to lock him away and not let him have anything to eat for a few weeks (or days if you can keep him from getting any water too). Now, in the comics Wolverine has made mention of times he was faced with starvation and went as far as cutting off his own skin and eating it to stay sated--cutting off a chunk every time a new one heals in its place. Putting aside the question of if you're committing cannibalism if you eat yourself, one could theorize Wolverine would eventually burn out his body much in the same way people lost at sea can only drink their urine for so long before it is devoid of anything useful (sorry for the gross image, but it gets the fact across). Still, this seems like a lot of effort when other methods could get the job done much more easily.

5. We Never Learn How

What if Marvel killed Wolverine, but kept it a mystery how he died? It sounds odd, but for many years the character's own history was completely unknown, so wouldn't it be clever if Wolverine died, and all his friends talk about how he is dead, but readers never actually find out how? Yes, it would infuriate many, but as this list makes apparent, there are numerous ways Wolverine could die, and every person undoubtedly has their own favorite way. Were Marvel to kill Logan off and have the gall to not tell comic-fans how it happened, that would be ballsy, and pretty awesome. It is easy to do also, they just show him leaving for some sort of mission and then cut to the funeral, then every fan could imagine their own perfect way he died. Honestly though, Marvel would probably not be able to keep it a mystery for long at all and would have a big reveal to sate fans' curiosity. The fact Marvel probably wouldn't commit to this makes it less cool than it seems at first.

4. Unique Illness

Imagine if there were some kind of targeted super-flu that manages to infect Wolverine due to his healing factor and begins killing him (only him, however, we're not talking the infamous Legacy virus that afflicted all mutants). He is running out of time, has to do everything he ever planned to do now that he's on a timetable, and Marvel could have the comics engage in something clever like having each issue of the comic represent a day in his shortly-concluding life. It would be dramatic, tragic, and make for a nail-biting read. Plus, if Marvel made it so that this imaginary disease only could hurt characters with a healingfactor, they could throw Deadpool into the mix for the story and have some of the comic focus on him managing to survive, but with it being too late for Wolverine. That would be a touching way to end this imaginary event, considering how Deadpool and Wolverine have had a love-hate relationship at various points. Plus, Marvel milks Deadpool for all he's worth so putting him and Wolverine together in a comic is generally a license to print money. Everybody wins!

3. Decapitation

It was mentioned earlier that depending on who is writing Wolverine, it can be easier or harder to kill him. Interestingly enough, there seems to have often been an agreement among most stories about Wolvie that should his head be chopped off--especially with special weapons such as the Muramasa blade--he has to either get it reattached soon, or he'll be DOA. Considering the Muramasa blade was what Logan used to kill Sabertooth some years ago (before Marvel promptly brought him back not too much later) the concept isn't without precedent. It isn't extremely flashy, but it definitely is dramatic and would make for a shocking image--and if there is one thing comic companies love, it's a nice, shocking image.

2. Fighting The Hulk

Wolverine's first appearance actually had him fighting the Hulk. All the way back in 1974, he and the Hulk went at it in The Incredible Hulk #181 and few would have predicted back then just how popular both characters would become thanks to their respective movie-history and comic events. Both Wolverine and the Hulk have led fascinating lives, so bringing it all back to square one and having a fight to the death between Logan and Bruce Banner (when hulked out, of course) just feels extremely fitting. Comic companies and fans both love to bring up continuity so it would be exciting for it all to come full circle. Plus, if Marvel really wants to drive readers wild, it could have both characters end up dying. That would be a twist!

1. After Taking On The Entire Justice League, And Almost Winning!

This is basically impossible considering the last time Marvel and DC crossed over was in the early 2000s, and that was before they became especially bitter rivals towards each other and Disney bought Marvel. Still, in a perfect world, Wolverine would fight the entire League and through the power of his will, strength, and maybe some help from his friends in the form of useful tools (he'd need Kryptonite, obviously), almost wins. It would be a fan's wet dream for Wolverine to fight the entire Justice League, and maybe even somehow appear to beat them all before something even more insane happens--like Batman breaks his rule against killing in order to end the fight and through his immense knowledge and skill manages to finish off Wolverine. It sounds crazy, but considering how a yarn such as this would basically have to be out of continuity, both companies would win, because Batman wouldn't have "really" killed Wolverine and Marvel could carry on like Wolverine wasn't "really" dead. It just makes for an awesome story each company could promote the beejeezus out of. The sheer fun-value of this potential comic alone makes it the #1 choice. Should you disagree with any choices, or have any methods of your own that you feel would have been better ways for Wolverine to die, do please share them with us! Heck, you can say if you think Marvel is going to bring him back via "Secret Wars" and what method you think they'll use if you want!

In this post: 
Wolverine
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

David Bitterbaum is a big fan of all the things that entertain us. He is the creator of The Newest Rant (www.thenewestrant.com) and has opinions, so, so many opinions.