What Happened Every Time The Thing Fought The Hulk?
The Fantastic Four's strongman has taken on Marvel's Hulk countless times, but who's won most?
Comic readers love to watch their favorite heroes go head to head to see who would win. It's by far the one thing about BEING a comic book fan that's remained unchanged since comic books had dedicated fanbases at all.
Even before they were making superhero books full time, Marvel understood this, having their first two superheroes, the Human Torch and Namor, going at it when they first met.
But by far one of the most famous superhero rivalries to come out of the house of ideas has been that between the ever loving blue eyed Thing, and the jade giant himself, the Incredible Hulk.
The two are practically built to dislike each other, the two being similar in all the wrong ways. While the two definitely respect each other, if they spend too long in the same room together, that room is inevitably going to be destroyed.
The Thing and the Hulk have fought a LOT, so to keep this concise, we'll be keeping it to the most important fights between The Thing and the various different versions of Bruce Banner's temperamental other half.
9. Fantastic Four #25-26
What better place to start than at the beginning?
The initial run of Fantastic Four by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby is nothing short of legendary, due to how much groundwork it laid that Marvel writers are still building on today. So, of course, this is where Ben Grimm's rivalry with the Hulk had its explosive beginning.
Granted, they technically first met back in Fantastic Four #12, but that fight was cut short by shenanigans leaving a winner undecided. When fans complained, Lee and Kirby made it up to them with an explosive two-parter where the Hulk and the Thing square off for a proper round two, tearing down half of Manhattan in the process with an efficiency that would make Robert Moses feel incredibly anxious.
The fight ends with Ben coming out on top thanks to his more level headed and stubborn nature giving him an edge against the animalistic Hulk.
If Lee and Kirby had left their interactions in that previous story, these two most likely would not be the bitter rivals they are today. But this two-parter showed Marvel's readership that them coming to blows was the coolest damn thing ever, and the rest is history.
8. The Incredible Hulk #122
As much as I'd like to keep this to one-on-one brawls, there actually aren't that many between the Thing and the Hulk. The fact is, if you're picking a fight with Ben Grimm, you're picking a fight with the entire FF, so it's no surprise that a lot of fights on this list have Ben's teammates pitching in to put the jade giant down.
In this issue of The Incredible Hulk, Hulk takes on the entire Fantastic Four, with Ben just barely managing to hold him off by punching him through several buildings.
After holding him off for long enough, though, Reed ends the fight by using a machine he had built specifically for this occasion to knock out the Hulk, giving the FF the win for this round.
Reed planned on curing the Hulk for good now that he had him sedated and harmless, but of course things didn't work out for him on that front. But in terms of fighting The Thing, Hulk is at 0-2.
7. Fantastic Four #112
It tells you a lot about how much readers loved seeing these two go at it that at this point they knew they just had to have them charging at each other on the cover, and it would sell. Didn't even bother with a background - after all, it's not like WHERE they fight is ever important.
This issue was where the Hulk got his third round revenge against his bitter rival, in a blowout fight that lasts from front to back of the entire comic. And this comic makes you truly understand the difference in strength between Ben and Bruce.
While the Thing's adaptability, level headedness, and being roommates with a woman who can explode your head with a thought have helped him eke out wins in the past, this time it's just him vs Hulk, and no matter what he throws at the jade giant, nothing so much as slows him down.
It seems Ben is about to win when he gets out of the Hulk's chokehold and goes in hard, but the debris caused by their fight almost hits Ben's eternal love interest Alicia Masters, distracting him just long enough for the Hulk to secure his victory with a near fatal hook to the face.
6. Fantastic Four #166-167
While #166 is another instance of the entire FF getting in on the action when the Hulk goes on ANOTHER rampage, this time throughout St. Louis, it leads into a true one on one in issue #167.
The first half of this two-parter is a very well done fight between the Fantastic Four and the Hulk, with the four utilizing their powers in creative combinations to incapacitate the monster. The fight ends with Johnny burning away the air around the Hulk, Sue putting up a force field around his head to keep him from replenishing his air supply, and Reed wrapping himself tight around the Hulk to give the Thing an opening to knock Hulk flat.
Then we move on into the second part, where the Thing busts the Hulk out of prison when the military decides they wanna turn Bruce into a lab rat for the rest of his life.
However, this alliance is almost hilariously short lived, as the two are soon back at it all over again atop the St. Louis Gateway Arch. While the Thing puts up a valiant fight, it ends bad for him when he suddenly starts turning back into Ben Grimm. Which is, of course, very bad when fighting someone like the Hulk, who slugs him off the bridge.
5. Fantastic Four #320
It just wouldn't be an article about the Hulk if it didn't at least touch on the many different personalities vying for control of the tightly wound ball of crazy that is Bruce Banner's brain.
The first time the Thing properly fought Mr Fixit, the Grey Hulk, was in Fantastic Four #320, when Doctor Doom hired the devious mercenary Hulk to kill Ben Grimm for him. Fixit is, of course, all too willing to take up this job, however, he quickly runs into a problem.
See, the drawback for Grey Hulk getting to keep his intellect is that he isn't even half as strong as normal Hulk. Oh sure, he's tough, but the Thing can go toe to toe with the strongest Avenger there is, and as Fixit finds out in the comic, he chose a very bad time to take on the Thing.
Events in the larger story had mutated Ben's body even further, now making him look like a particularly angry pineapple in a pair of swim trunks. Absolutely ridiculous to look at, but it made one of the strongest heroes in Marvel even stronger still, and before Doctor Doom interrupts, Ben thoroughly trounces the grey bruiser.
4. The Incredible Hulk #350
Technically a continuation of the previous entry, it gets its own spot because it's in a different comic and is its own self contained fight.
After getting absolutely trounced by the Thing, and when Doctor Doom's Hulk robot doesn't fare much better, he manages to convince the Hulk to have another go at him through good old fashioned reverse psychology.
Fixit isn't keen on getting his butt kicked again at first, but then he realizes that he can use the brain he still has to his advantage, and leads the Thing into Central Park. Once there, he uses the dense woods of the park as well as the cover of darkness to lead him on a wild goose chase, occasionally leaping out to pop off hits at him, exhausting him with the chase while pissing him off enough with the sudden attacks to keep Ben from realizing what's going on before it's too late.
And sure enough, right as the Thing gets wise as to what the Hulk is playing at here, Hulk leaps out one more time and knocks him out with a well placed punch.
3. Fantastic Four #534-535
After Bruce fused his Hulk personalities into one during the nineties era of the character, obviously him and Ben didn't see reason to fight as much. So it was quite a few years before we got another proper showdown between these two famous bruisers.
However, when Bruce gets caught in another gamma explosion that turns him into an even more powerful, even more mindless new Hulk, the Thing has to intercept before he reduces L.A. to a parking lot. Ben leads him into the desert, with the plan being for him to hold him off while Reed tries to think of something.
Ben's only advantage in this fight is that the Hulk isn't really focusing on him like in the other fights on this list, instead just swinging wildly at anything like an animal. However, that does not improve his chances by much, since the Hulk is holding back even less than he usually does, eventually shattering the Thing's ribs underfoot and almost killing him.
Even though the fight is cut short by the visions driving Hulk into this mad rage being expelled from his mind, that doesn't change the fact that the Thing was about as thoroughly defeated as he would ever be by the Hulk short of being killed.
2. World War Hulk #2
The Thing can just barely hold his own against a Hulk that's pissed off at normal stuff, so it's no surprise that his fight against the Worldbreaker Hulk in the World War Hulk storyline doesn't last all that long.
When the Hulk returns after being exiled by the Illuminati to another planet, seeking revenge when the ship they sent him packing with explodes and kills his family, the Thing rolls up to take on the Worldbreaker in defense of his best buddy Reed.
Even though he admits that Reed is a bastard for doing what he did to Hulk, he's not too keen on his "raze New York to the goddamn ground" approach.
Their fight here is short but GLORIOUS, the two holding nothing back against each other. However, this isn't the mindless monster that the Thing could outsmart to eke out a win before, Worldbreaker Hulk is just as smart as Bruce, and just as strong as default Hulk.
So really, there was only one way it was going to end for poor Ben, as he's eventually overwhelmed by the righteously furious Hulk, who then moves on to capture Reed.
1. Fantastic Four #12-13
Before, when the Thing turned back human in the middle of fighting the Hulk, it ended...less than ideally for him. However, back then, he didn't have Alicia around to protect/impress, so it makes sense that he'd be a bit more motivated this time around.
When Ben and his new bride Alicia head off to finally take a much needed vacation, the Hulk - controlled by Alicia's father Puppetmaster, interrupts and attacks him.
The Thing, knowing there are too many innocent people around to safely fight, and also knowing he's about to turn back human for the next two weeks in just a few minutes, actually swallows his pride at first and acquiesces the title of strongest one there is to Hulk, which might have worked on a Hulk in his right mind. But the Puppetmaster makes him attack anyway.
The fight, due to the Thing being kept on his back foot because of the above mentioned handicaps, is brutal as hell, but right as the time limit runs out, the Thing manages to put an end to the fight with one last punch that shatters the rock on his arm with the force, knocking out the Hulk right as Ben transforms back to human.
Watch Next
Quiz: Which Incredible Hulk Said These Quotes?