10 Comic Book Movies That Got MULTIPLE Characters Wrong

So who is to blame? The actor, the director, or the studio that's trying to sell toys?

Batman & Robin Villains
Warner Bros.

Comic books are simultaneously the easiest and hardest stories to adapt to the big screen. On the one hand, they have intricate storylines, deep characters, are already laid out in storyboard format and come with a dedicated, built-in audience. On the other hand, that same audience can make or break the box office if their favorite characters are mishandled.

Producers and directors have to walk a fine line when drawing from this source material. What works on the page doesn't always translate to the screen. Being faithful to a comic doesn't guarantee success. David Harbour's Hellboy is a bit more comic-accurate, but Ron Perlman's Hellboy was more enjoyable. Zack Snyder's Watchmen has sequences directly lifted from the page, but still can't quite capture the feeling and tone of the comic.

Us comic book movie fans are lucky to live in an age where our inked heroes are jumping off the page. Avengers: Endgame is the highest grossing movie ever, Christopher Nolan gave us a definitive Batman trilogy, and there are so many exciting projects still to come. And, this is all without including some great work taking place on the small screen.

BUT... what about those movies that missed the mark? Had amazing characters to work with and still dropped the ball...? We're not talking about screwing up one character like Judge Dredd or Catwoman, but messing with everyone in the script...

10. Fantastic 4: Rise Of The Silver Surfer

Rise Of The Silver Surfer Poster
20th Century Fox

Perhaps no set of comic book characters has suffered quite as much as the Fantastic Four. From the ultra-low budget 1994 movie (made only to retain the rights) to the 2015 Fant-4-stic failure, through four(!) movies no one has yet been able to nail down the characters.

Though each movie has varying degrees of success/failure with the four team members themselves, the villains and side characters have never been done correctly. This was never more apparent than in the 2007 sequel.

In Fantastic 4: Rise of the Silver Surfer we have our returning heroes: a pre-Captain America Chris Evans as a fun Human Torch, Michael Chiklis doing the only real acting as The Thing, Jessica Alba as unconvincing as ever as Sue Storm, another forgettable turn from Ioan Gruffodd's Mr. Fantastic, and Julian McMahon returns as a terrible version of Dr. Doom. Though in hindsight, he comes off slightly better than Toby Kebbell's crash-test dummy.

The newcomers Silver Surfer and Galactus are handled the worst. The Surfer looks like slightly upgraded T-1000 and somehow comes with less personality. And as hard as it may be to translate the world-eater Galactus as an impossibly huge giant in purple armor, that still leaves no excuse for the way they handled the character and turned him into a cloud, worthy of a Sharknado sequel.


9. Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad Poster
Warner Bros

Create a list for best soundtracks to terrible movies and 2016's Suicide Squad will be near the top. It began with a wonderful trailer that made it seem like they were actually going to pull off making a movie about Batman's villains, without establishing them in a Batman movie first. It ended with a rushed storyline, an uneven tone, and a world-ending plot that was impossible to take seriously.

So what worked? Well, obviously Margo Robbie knocked it out of the amusement park with her Harley Quinn, Viola Davis is perfect for Amanda Waller, Joel Kinnaman is fine as Rick Flag, and Jai Courtney is surprisingly not the worst. Oh, and Will Smith was great as Will Smith, I just thought that Deadshot was going to be in the film.

Katana is a wasted character, reduced to "body guard" who doesn't speak English and her sword makes her sad. Killer Croc is forgettable, hardly menacing, and about to drop a hot 16 bars. El Diablo's backstory was altered along with his motivations. Slipknot is forgotten about quicker than he is introduced. Enchantress not only shouldn't have been the main antagonist, she also deserved a better actress than Cara Delevigne.

And finally, the Joker, played far too over-hyped by Jerod Leto. Leto is one of the top actors working today, however did himself no favors with the stories coming out before the release with his over-the-top "method" acting. Finding out he had barely more screen time than Slipknot and a couple more lines than Scott Eastwood, audiences were disappointed in the lack of Joker. This version of the clown prince of crime kind of works for the DCEU...however, we've slowly come to realize the DCEU doesn't work.


8. Iron Man 3

Iron Man 3 Slattery
Paramount Pictures

Two words: Trevor Slattery. With that one name, the MCU dropped the ball on one of Iron Man's most fearsome villains. We're not treading any new ground here by dragging Ben Kinglsey's character through more mud, so lets move on...

Can we talk about the Iron Man suit as a character? Because "Mark 42" has to be the worst thing Tony Stark has ever created. It hardly works, falls apart with a light breeze, attacks Pepper (although yes it saves her too), and the P.O.S. can’t seem to stay charged (why does it need to be charged if he's got the arc reactor??). Just because you keep saying it's a “prototype” does not mean that Tony would ever invent something that unreliable.

Guy Piece plays Aldrich Killian, but really he's a mashup of multiple characters and barely resembles the lowly scientist who kills himself because of guilt. There's a lot of weird choices made for Pepper, Happy, and Rhodey that their characters never would have done under Favreau. Shane Black comes with a lot of writing credibility from Lethal Weapon, The Nice Guys, and Last Action Hero, but should never touch another comic book property again.

While excuses are made for Tony suffering from PTSD throughout the film, this is literally the dumbest version of Tony we've seen. His decisions make no sense, from inviting an attack on his home and not having a defense ready, to creating and blowing up a bunch of barely HAMMER-quality mech-suits. Then to "fix" his heart in surgery that was never supposed to be possible and have him act like he's going to retire from being Iron Man when we all know there's more Avengers movies coming? Let's all just take a moment to appreciate the Russo brothers again.


7. Constantine

Constantine Keanu Reeves
Warner Bros.

Keanu Reeves post John Wick can do no wrong, pre-Wick and he's known as a wooden actor who should never attempt accents. His 2005 movie Constantine fell into the latter, however in hindsight, it's looked back at as a solid film though not a faithful adaptation. Let's get this out of the way first, who cares if John Constantine was blonde or not? Daniel Craig was an amazing brunette in James Bond right? Moving on...

Keanu's take on the popular Hellblazer character was much more noir and his setting was changed to LA from the UK (although, with what we know about his accents, its probably a good choice). Hair color aside, Constantine is supposed to have a bit more style and flair to go along with his bisexuality that was never expressed in the movie. Keanu also plays the character stoic with more bulldozing confidence than clever cockiness and wit. He also never should be carrying a "holy" shotgun.

Audiences were also unkind to Shia Labeouf as Chas Kramer. For one, what's with the name change from Chandler? Since Chas was not only supposed to be John's sidekick, he's also one of his oldest friends with the two meeting as teenagers, it's a little weird having the character be so much younger.

They switched up the angel Gabriel by casting the master of androgyny Tilda Swinton. But, don't you dare say a word against Peter Stomare as the best movie-version of the devil we've ever gotten.


6. Batman & Robin

Batman And Robin
Warner Bros.

Out of all the Burton-verse Batman movies, 1997's Batman & Robin is the fourth best. Joel Schumacher had returned Bruce Wayne to his campy ways with Batman Forever. But with Burton still on board as a producer, the film was mostly respectable and didn't get too out of hand. That all changed with Burton stepping away and Schumacher facing tons of studio pressure to make toys.

First, we have Arnold Schwarzenegger getting top billing as Mr. Freeze. With a paycheck reportedly around $25 million, he must have been getting paid per pun. His dialog is cringe worthy with such gems as "Let's kick some ice!" and "You're not sending me to the cooler!". Literally every line is somehow etched with an ice pick. They may have taken his "Heart of Ice" backstory, but the character is far removed from calculated genius shown in the comics.

From there, we get an over-the-top Poison Ivy in Uma Thurman's worst role and far less lethal than she should be. We get a damn near 30-year-old Robin who is far too spoiled, bratty, and egotistical. And since Commissioner Gordon was never really a fleshed out character, Alicia Silverstone's Batgirl is now Alfred's family instead of Barbara Gordon. Worst of all is poor Bane, who instead of being a cunning and tactical threat, is basically reduced to glorified henchmen.

The only saving grace of the film is Michael Gough's Alfred Pennyworth, a character he portrayed perfectly through the four films.


5. The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen

league of extraordinary gentlemen
20th Century Fox

Chalk this up as yet another Alan Moore adaptation failure. Like most all of his works turned into movies, 2003's League of Extraordinary Gentlemen fails to capture the essence of the story and character. His characters' darkest and most complicated edges are always toned down for fear of turning away a mainstream audience.

Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde is now literally just Bruce Banner & The Hulk, Captain Nemo was... , and they didn't even use the correct Invisible Man because of copyright issues. Plus, adding in Tom Sawyer was just a failed ploy to entice American audiences (he was never in Moore's comic).

The Mina Harker/Murray character has all of her subtext removed, Dracula's victim is no longer a woman ahead of her time and not conforming to the strict standards a "lady" should be in Victorian England. Instead they use her basically as muscle for the action set pieces, leaving her a vampire.

Sean Connery famously retired from acting after his experience with making this movie, however, it must also be stated that he should shoulder some of the blame for its failings. He was not only portraying the main character of Alan Quatermain, he also served as executive producer. Quatermain the character had none of the nuance and depth from the comic, no longer a frail opium addict and instead the sturdy leader-type. Sean Connery plays him as an aged version of his most famous character.


4. Venom (And Spider-Man 3)

Spider-Man 3 Venom
Sony Pictures Releasing

Consider this a 2-for-1 special, as both 2018's Venom and 2007's Spider-Man 3 both miss the mark on Eddie Brock and the Venom symbiote in different and spectacularly bad ways. Tom Hardy single-handedly makes Venom watchable as he simply can't give a bad on screen performance. However, the movie completely messes up Venom's origin by removing the relationship to Spiderman and removing Eddie's rivalry with Peter Parker. Without Spiderman, it doesn't even make sense as to the way the symbiotes design themselves into suits.

Topher Grace is an actor, but doesn't have the prowess of Hardy and is given arguably worse material to work with. Being wedged in with far too many characters, he is not given enough time to develop and establish himself as the truly dangerous threat Venom/Eddie should be. Similar to Dark Phoenix, the Venom storyline needs time to develop and cramming the origin into only one movie completely ruins what make the characters so compelling.

As far as the other characters go, the main protagonist in Venom, Riot is no longer an offspring of Venom but instead the sadistic leader of the symbiotes and basically is just Carnage with grey food coloring. And in Raimi's spider-verse, Kirsten Dunst has always been a bad Mary Jane. She's a fine actress, but she's far removed from the confident, natural red-headed supermodel and no one was happy with James Franco's Harry Osborne.


3. The Amazing Spider-Man 2

amazing spiderman 2 poster
Sony Pictures

Oh we're not done dissecting Spiderman movies, there's a reason they keep getting re-worked and rebooted. The first Amazing Spider-Man was a perfectly ok Spidey movie, though it was released far too soon with the Rami-verse still on people's minds. It's been generally accepted that Toby Maguire was a wonderful Peter Parker and an okay Spiderman with Andrew Garfield being the opposite.

The villains in 2014's Amazing Spider-Man 2 are some of the worst depictions we've seen. Main antagonist Electro looks more like Dr. Manhattan from Watchmen than his comic book counterpart. Admittedly, the green and yellow costume with giant face lighting is ridiculous, so it's understandable that the producers tried a different look. The whole gaining powers from electric eels thing is super weird too. Jamie Foxx is a great actor, but his character motivations were all off.

Rhino is absolutely bonkers, doesn't get enough screen time to actually develop, and the mech-suit is all wrong. Paul Giamatti, is completely wasted in the part, with no nuance...just shout in Russian!

They decided to just skip over one of Spiderman's best villains in Norman Osborn, jumping straight to his son as Green Goblin II. Now Dane DeHaan is playing Harry with a weird disease then a mutation, it's all awful. The only saving grace of AS2 is the amazing Emma Stone as Gwen Stacy. Sony, please keep working with Disney/Marvel.


2. X-Men: First Class

first class square poster
20th Century Fox

We're not making another entry about the failures of Dark Phoenix and Apocalypse. That's low hanging fruit at this point, Oscar Isaac couldn't pull off a good Ivan Ooze and Sansa Stark failed as Jean Grey- we get it. A sequel can only stand on the foundation built by the movies before them. 2011's X-Men: First Class was a reboot that was supposed to give the franchise a clean slate after the failure that was X-Men 3.

When told the title is "First Class", one would assume that the creators will draw from the original line-up of Cyclops, Jean Grey, Iceman, Angel, and Beast. Sure Beast is there with young Professor X. But instead of Cyclops, we're treated to his (now) older brother Alex who takes on most of Scott's traits. We get an Angel, only this one is Angel Salvadore who is a former stripper rather than an abused teen. No Marvel Girl or Bobby Drake.

We get Banshee introduced to the team far too early. And Darwin, who's power literally means he can not die, dies. From here it only gets worse with Jennifer Lawrence's version of Mystique. Rebecca Romijn did a fairly admirable job with the older version of the character. Even when Lawrence was still giving effort, her character was written all wrong as Charles' adopted sister and now she fights with the good guys when it's convenient?

While First Class is actually one of the better movies, it's no wonder the X-Men franchise kept getting worse. If only they had started off with the right characters...


1. X-Men

Wolverine X Men 2000
20th Century Fox

Let's first acknowledge that comic book movies would not be anywhere near the quality that they are today with out 2000's X-Men. That being said, the filmmakers took far too many liberties when adapting the superhero team. It's too easy to point out the missed opportunities of X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men: The Last Stand. We know Deadpool and Juggernaut were mishandled, but what led them to this point?

We're introduced to this world through Anna Paquin's Rogue, who is no longer the tough talking, flying, mighty, former villain with a strong southern accent. They rightfully give focus to her insecurities when it comes to love and physical touch, however Paquin is completely miscast. She's too young, looks nothing like Rogue from the comics, has no backstory with Mystique, and she's supposed to be with Gambit - NOT Iceman!

Speaking of Iceman, he's supposed to be one of the OG's, why is he a young student? The villains are mostly fine but Ray Park is too cool and underutilized as Toad. And while Tyler Mane looks the part as Sabertooth, a far better portrayal would come later from Liev Schrieber.

Famke Jansen and James Marsden are fine as Jean Grey and Cyclops (in this movie). Halle Berry gives none of the leadership and strong-willed qualities that Storm possesses. Hugh Jackman may not have been the first choice to play Wolverine, but the worst thing you can say is that he's too tall. At least Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen are perfect.

The powers-that-be wrote themselves into a corner with the very first movie in the franchise by not giving age appropriate starting lines to their characters. Hence the various ways the X-Men films have failed, been rebooted, and timelines altered. Phoenix never stood a chance.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

A humble vaudevillian veteran cast vicariously as both victim and villain by the vicissitudes of Fate