10 Great Comic Book Movie Castings Fans Couldn't Handle
In a different universe maybe, just maybe...
Well, well, well, this is an exceptionally rare occurrence! It isn't often that we can already feel the scorching, seething hatred of the internet before we've even published an article... or before we've even written it. But here we are.
Before we even began this article we knew how you lot would react, so in preparation/preemptive retaliation we really did our research on this one. We did so much research in fact that every single entry you'll find here isn't even a matter of opinion at this point, it's objective fact. And yes, we know how much angrier that statement makes you.
A few rules we self-imposed are as follows: 1) Every entry has to make complete sense in terms of the actor - not in terms of their back catalogue but also their personality, 2) no one who's actively expressed no interest in being a part of a comic book franchise - that means no Daniel Radcliffe as Daredevil, sorry guys, and 3) at least a few who are now considered the "definitive" version of that character - we like a challenge.
Oh, you might notice that there aren't a ton of DC characters on this list and that's because, well, as far as recasting is concerned they already have that market pretty solidly cornered, eh?
So, in another universe perhaps, these might happen. So join as we ask What If...?
10. Bob Odenkirk - J. Jonah Jameson
Can we be honest with you? This one kind of scared us the most...well, let's call it a tie. We thought we'd lose you with this one because, let's face it, the role of J. Jonah Jameson essentially belongs to J. K. Simmons at this point, and rightfully so too, he's been knocking it out of the park all these years. So much so, in fact, that Marvel even seemed to agree after integrating him into the MCU.
But hear us out, what we're proposing isn't that Bob Odenkirk try and do some pale imitation of Simmons' Jameson - because that's all it would inevitably be - but instead a re-imagining of the character altogether.
Let's face it, what is it that we associate Odenkirk with first and foremost? That's right everyone - other than you comedy nerds who said Mr. Show - it's Saul Goodman, the criminal criminal lawyer. Saul Goodman - at least in his Breaking Bad iteration - is the definition of sleaze and smarm. A purely despicable character that for some reason you can't help but love.
So with that in mind, why couldn't we have a J. Jonah Jameson within the MCU who - instead of the brash, shouty, over the top version we know and love - is instead the kind of grotesque, smarmy news anchors we've become far too acquainted with in reality? That's all good, man.
9. Aaron Paul - Ant Man
Kevin Feige claimed that the reason for Paul Rudd being cast in Ant-Man was because he was precisely the kind of person you could see doing somewhat questionable or unsavoury things and yet still find yourself somehow rooting for. Hmmmm, now who have we spent around about six years of our collective lives rooting for as he did, arguably, some pretty shady-ass stuff. That's right, Aaron goddamn Paul.
Jesse Pinkman stands as one of the most sympathetic yet also most corrupt characters in history; one of the most tragic, and yet, at times, one of the most hilarious. Paul could easily fill the pretty large...or rather the small...actually sometimes quite large shoes of Scott Lang.
It's not just Paul's acting chops throughout Breaking Bad but also BoJack Horseman that stand as testament to his ability to fill this role. Todd Chavez provided some of the best goofball lines in recent comedy history and fully embodied the "is he kind of smart or just incredibly stupid/lucky" vibe that Scott Lang has throughout the Ant-Man films. Combine that with Paul's real life charisma and boundless humour and goddamn do you have a winning formula. Yeah, bitch!
8. Kumail Nanjiani - Wolverine
Yes, yes, we know. This isn't ever going to happen anymore thanks to Nanjiani already being a part of the MCU thanks to his casting in The Eternals, but, as we said, this is a What If...? situation we have on the go here. So, in another universe, let's just imagine.
We all know that one of Wolverine's key characteristics is that, well...he's kind of a douchebag sometimes. A douchebag with a heart of gold deep down, but a misanthropic douchebag nonetheless. Nanjiani has proven he can play that role pretty spot on thanks to his time playing Dinesh on Silicon Valley - who was every bit as sarcastic and sardonic as Logan...although Dinesh was certainly far more pathetic.
But we have to address that whole 'heart of gold' thing too, don't we? Well, Nanjiani has that down on lock too thanks to his turn in The Big Sick that saw the traditionally off the wall, oddball comedy actor plumb new - and up until that point unseen - emotional depths. And, honestly, so many scenes from that movie were absolutely heartbreaking, and that's precisely the kind of emotional range needed to play someone as complicated as Wolverine.
Also...the dude is super jacked, man.
7. Toby Kebbel - Tony Stark/Ironman
Alright, you guys, this list isn't just about wish fulfilment. We're also dealing with second chances here. We're dealing with people who had their shot once before and got screwed by powers that were entirely outwith their control. This entry, friends, is nothing less than a tale of redemption...alright, fine, that's a bit much.
However, Toby Kebbel deserved far better than the hot trash he got handed in the form of 2015's Fantastic Four, and to this day he's a woefully underappreciated actor in every regard. To most he'll be best known for his turn in Black Mirror's season one classic episode The Entire History Of You, which showed an incredible emotional range from Kebbel - and which, oddly enough, was optioned by Robert Downey Jr. Hmmmm.
Beyond that though Kebbel has starred in numerous movies over the years that have shown off his acting chops. One in particular that comes to mind is Rock'N'Rolla which, while an average movie at best, showed Kebbel at his most cocksure, playing a character that seemed almost infallible in his intellect - and not to mention arrogance. And can you really say that that face doesn't just scream Tony Stark?
Plus, Chris Evans got another chance after the atrocity exhibition that was the first Fantastic Four, so this seems only fair, right?
6. David Lynch - Uatu/The Watcher
Okay, so traditionally Uatu is something of an observer of all the goings on on Earth and in the solar system. His entire race are dedicated to watching what's kickin' throughout the multiverse. Generally he's our narrator for all the What If...? scenarios over the course of Marvel history, but Uatu hasn't done a ton else otherwise. Well...he helped out the Fantastic Four a few times...and some other stuff...but let's just leave that out.
Look, it isn't really the plot details that are important with this entry it's the fact that, if we're honest, Uatu is probably a kind of strange dude who will seem kind of/really not of this world/universe. Can you name a single goddamn person who matches that description better than David Lynch? No, we didn't think you could. If you need convincing then we suggest you go and check out What Did Jack Do? on Netflix wherein he interrogates a monkey who might have killed someone. Or perhaps check out his recipe for quinoa on YouTube...yes, seriously.
Watch literally anything with David Lynch in it and tell us that he isn't actually an all knowing alien trying his best, and sort of failing, to seem human. And then try telling us he shouldn't be our Uatu!
5. Jodie Comer - Hela
We imagine that titles such as Queen of Asgard's underworld and The Goddess of Death probably aren't exactly earned particularly easily. We also assume that whomever did the work to earn such titles also isn't really someone you'd want to meet down a dark alley. We've got to say that whomever fills the exceptionally large cloak of Hela has one Hela-va job ahead of them...we're sorry, please keep reading.
Now, who in recent memory, seemingly overnight, became one of the most terrifying and intimidating characters to ever grace our television screens? Not to mention one of the most goddamn stylish too? That's right, Killing Eve's Jodie Comer as Villanelle. The thing with Villanelle is that she isn't just a scary character, something about the way that Comer plays her is almost as though she's from another planet, almost as though she is godlike.
Villanelle is a little more used to using guns and knives to mow down her countless victims, but we're willing to bet that she'd be down with the ability to obliterate anyone with a single touch. Plus, given Comer and Villanelle's shared sartorial history, we bet that she'd be more than happy to don the cloak and crown of Hela.
4. David Tennant - Norman Osborn/The Green Goblin
We spoke earlier about people getting their second chance at the MCU and, in a way, this is one of those cases. The only difference being that David Tennant isn't getting another shot because of how abysmal his previous effort was, but instead because of how goddamn good he was the first time around.
Tennant was arguably the highlight of Netflix's Jessica Jones. He was creepy, terrifying and almost utterly inhuman...whilst still possessing precisely the level of charm you'd expect from a complete and utter sociopath such as Kilgrave. And, we should be clear, that creepy, manipulative charm is something Tennant has a fair talent for. Hell, it's his bread and butter at this point. Another key bit of recent work that highlights this perfectly is Deadwater Fell. Seriously, guys, check it out, it is absolutely killer.
It's precisely this kind of personality and behaviour that's necessary for someone to play a character such as Norman Osborn. Osborn starts off as an amoral, corrupt businessman with zero scruples, sure, but he still possesses an undeniable charm, but his descent into utter madness is so gradual that it's almost a trickle of insanity. That's a hell of a lot of balls to juggle at once, but Tennant is undeniably up to the task.
3. Joseph Gilgun - Gambit
Oh how long have we all been collectively crying out to see Gambit on the big screen? Or the small screen for that matter? Granted, Taylor Kitsch did an...okay job, we guess, in the abomination that was X-Men Origins: Wolverine, but that was hardly noteworthy. And then there was the proposed solo Gambit movie that got abandoned after years in development hell. A movie that was supposed to star Channing Tatum in the lead role. And can we just be the first to say...uh, no.
Who could possibly fill the shoes of the swaggering, arrogant, charismatic ne'er do well? We'd propose none other than Joseph Gilgun. Pretty much all of Gilgun's filmography is crammed full of nothing but charming, rakish scamps. His big break came in the form of Shane Meadows' This Is England where he played the kindhearted Woody, but we'd bet that most of you know him as Preacher's Cassidy.
Not only did the role of Cassidy showcase him as loudmouthed, silver tongued and effortlessly charming, but it also goes to show that Gilgun is no stranger to the odd action scene or...thirty. And if you needed anymore confirmation, just go and check him out in Brassic, showing he's got the whole 'tortured soul' business nailed down too. He's your man, trust us.
2. Jeffrey Wright - Dr. Otto Octavius/Doctor Octopus
Otto Octavius' early comic book days showed him being portrayed as your standard mad scientist type villain, but over the years Doc Ock has become a more nuanced character. A complicated character and arguably Spider-Man's foe with the most depth, and as such is pretty tough to cast, as well as pretty tough to play.
In his most recent portrayals on screen, be it Spider-Man 2 or Insomniac's Spider-Man, have shown him to have something akin to dissociative identity disorder - more specifically his tentacles seem to communicate with him to some degree. That means essentially playing two roles at once and that's a pretty tall order.
Jeffrey Wright's not only still a stupendously underrated actor who's only just getting his dues, but he's your man if you want a complicated, nuanced individual with flaws for days - he also plays tortured genius with aplomb too.
As Dr. Valentin Narcisse on Boardwalk Empire, Wright proved that he can play a silver tongued villain with charm for days, who's just a hairpin from snapping into a violent rage, and as Bernard on Westworld he proved he could play not only the aforementioned tortured genius but more recently that he can also pull of what amounts to dual roles too...uh, spoilers.
1. Steven Yeun - Joker
And now we've come to literally our only DC entry on this whole damn list. Over the years we've seen countless iterations of Batman's greatest foe. From the out and out wackiness of Cesar Romero in the 1960s TV series, Jack Nicholson's gangster take in 1989's Batman, the arguable gold standard that was Heath Ledger's turn in The Dark Knight, all the way to...Jared Leto's...thing, and Joaquin Phoenix's genre-bending interpretation. Gotham also had like...twelve versions? We want to say twelve. So who the hell could take up the mantle next?
The actor we'd like to see take up the iconic maniacal grin would be Steven Yeun. No doubt you're thinking "Glenn? Goddamn Glenn from The Walking Dead? Why?!" To which we say, keep reading we'll get to it. Sure, he's best known from his stint in The Walking Dead, but recently Yeun has been showing quite the aptitude for playing quietly creepy and unsettling psychopaths.
The first contender here is 2018's Burning, a quiet yet disturbing South Korean thriller starring Yeun as...well, a weirdo with a penchant for burning stuff. Aside from that, one of Yeun's most recent utilisations of that creepiness was in an episode of The Twilight Zone that had him playing an enigmatic stranger with an ability to unravel someone's psyche with a flick of his silver tongue.
It would be fascinating to watch Yeun take that oddly silent sociopathy and turn it on to the maniacal Clown Prince of Crime...perhaps across from Pattinson at some point? Get that Change petition going guys!