10 Worst Marvel Movie Decisions

Yes Wong, we did want more. What about those heroes fighting in Hell's Kitchen?

Galactus Cloud
Fox/Marvel

Today, the comic book movie is one of the most popular and most lucrative genres in cinema. In 2019 alone there were 16 movies released based on comic books, and while these came from a number of different companies, Marvel is unquestionably leading the way right now, and has been for some time.

The Marvel Cinematic Universe is one of the biggest movie franchises in history (the single biggest looking at just box office numbers alone), and has inspired the shared universe trend throughout Hollywood. Even before the MCU and the Disney takeover, Marvel had success with Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy, and while the X-Men Universe limped over the finish line with Dark Phoenix and the question of if and when New Mutants will be released, it was excellent at its best.

Of course the path to this kind of success wasn't easy, and there have been a lot of mistakes along the way. From uninspired casting decisions, to staffing issues behind the scenes, and the complete lack of understanding of certain characters on the part of the studio, Marvel have often had to learn the hard way that the path to cinematic success is one fraught with peril.

10. Letting Go Of Edgar Wright

Ant-Man Peyton Reed Edgar Wright
Marvel Studios

The process of making a movie is long and incredibly costly, and there will always be obstacles to get around. Some projects encounter more than others, while some seemingly suffer setbacks at every possible stage. Even the mighty MCU isn't immune to this, as Ant-Man spent years in developmental hell before making its way to theatres in 2015.

As far back as 2006, nine years before the movie was eventually released, Marvel hired Edgar Wright to write and direct the movie. Suffering delay after delay, rewrites due to the way the MCU had changed since the project began, and more than enough release date changes, the Hot Fuzz director left the project.

Marvel eventually hired Peyton Reed and while the Ant-Man movies are fun, when considering the franchise against the others within the MCU, it certainly falls near the bottom of the list.

While the likes of James Gunn, Taika Waititi, and the Russo brothers have all worked to make Guardians of the Galaxy, Thor, and the Avengers some of the most popular franchises in the world, Marvel fans are left thinking what could have been had Wright stayed on. With the passion he clearly has for the comics and the character, the director could have made the film something really special.


9. Cancelling The Inhumans Movie

Inhumans Logo
Marvel Studios

Who knows just how far in advance Marvel Studios has the MCU planned? While there is a master plan, with movies and shows being announced years in advance, there will always be tweaks and changes. When Phase Three was first announced, the was no Spider-Man, no Ant Man and the Wasp, and an Inhumans movie scheduled for November 2018.

As one of four new properties being released as part of the phase, along with Doctor Strange, Black Panther, and Captain Marvel, there was a lot of excitement and intrigue surrounding Black Bolt and the Inhumans, and how the MCU would be furthering its reach into the cosmic corners of the Marvel mythos.

Though not the royal family the movie would be based on, the alien race soon after made their debut in Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D, and Vin Diesel was reportedly attached to star as Black Bolt himself.

After being pushed back several times however, the movie was eventually cancelled altogether. What we had to make do with was possibly the MCU's worst ever outing, the Inhumans show on ABC, cancelled after just one season.

Instead of an incredible movie delving into the depths of the Inhuman lore and beyond, potentially bringing more powerful beings into the fight against Thanos, Marvel gave the world a show worth just 11% on the Tomatometer (and possibly the worst CGI hair in the history of television).


8. The Galactus Cloud

Fantastic Four Rise of the Silver Surfer Galactus
Fox

Reed, Sue, Johnny and Ben make up Marvel's first family, and one of the most popular properties the comic book giants have to offer. But only on the page, however. When adapted to the big screen, the Fantastic Four have simply not done justice to their comic book counterparts.

With two underwhelming efforts in 2005 and 2007, and a reboot attempt that we'll get to later, there are many reasons why the movies simply didn't work. Tim Story's Rise of the Silver Surfer however, committed a crime against comics that is simply unforgivable.

After a shockingly poor iteration of Doctor Doom in 2005, the Silver Surfer came as the herald of Galactus - one of the greatest villains Marvel have ever put to paper. The hulking, planet eating, skyscraper sized alien would have been something amazing to see on the big screen, but instead, we got a... villainous... cloud.

Fundamentally, this got everything great about the character wrong. Galactus could have been a terrifying, awe-inspiring monster, with the hidden complexity that there is no malice in the destroying of worlds, but simply survival. It's much harder to put this across with a cloud. You'd have thought this would go without saying but apparently not.


7. Wade Wilson In X-Men: Origins

X Men Origins Wolverine Deadpool
Fox

It is widely agreed upon that the first iteration of Deadpool in X-Men Origins is one of the worst adaptations of a character in the Marvel Universe. The film's introduction of Wade Wilson seemed promising, with his wisecracking, crude and quippy personality all present and correct. However, it went swiftly downhill from there.

First of all, they didn’t use Deadpool's iconic costume. A suit crafted to cover his brutal physical appearance, inflicted upon him through the experimentation. By removing his mouth in his final form in the film, he went from the 'Merc with a mouth' to just a merc with no personality. And while this is a callback to previous scenes in the film with Logan commenting they 'finally figured out how to shut you up, huh?' it does take away possibly the most integral part of the character.

In comparison, they gave him a load of random powers which were completely disassociated with the character so much that by the end, he barely resembled Deadpool and may has well have been a fresh new character created just for the film.

While it is noted that directors like to put a different take on characters to make it their own, this felt like a step too far from the source material. Even though Deadpool 2 rectified this in a mid credits scene by shooting this abomination, it still leaves a bad taste in the mouths of comic book fans everywhere.


6. Casting Mads Mikkelsen As Kaecilius

Doctor Strange Kaecilius
Marvel Studios

For the most part, Marvel have a strong track record when it comes to casting decisions. There are great choices like the Chris trio of the MCU, and there are straight up perfect choices like Robert Downey Jr. as Iron Man, Ryan Reynolds as Deadpool, and the Professor X/Magneto quartet of Stewart, McAvoy, McKellen, and Fassbender.

However, there are some casting decisions that were not so inspired. Topher Grace, Edward Norton, and Terrance Howard to name just a few. These all failed for different reasons, but possibly the most unique casting faux pas on the account of Marvel is that of Mads Mikkelsen.

The Hannibal actor portrayed the villainous Kaecilius in Doctor Strange, and while the character didn't exactly stand out, Mikkelsen did what he could with the material at his disposal. The problem here is not that he was bad, but that he was wasted.

Mads Mikkelsen is an incredibly talented actor, but was used in such a small way. Just think, after the Disney/Fox merger, who in the world would have been better to bring Doctor Doom to life in the MCU? Nobody, that's who. And for someone like Doom, a potential candidate for the next big bad after Thanos, the casting would have to be perfect.

Though there is precedent for an actor to play two separate characters in the MCU, this wouldn't work with a villain who would have as big of an impact on the franchise as Doom.


5. Iron Man Never Met The Mandarin

Iron Man 3 Mandarin
Marvel Studios

Though some super heroes have literally pages and pages of villains in their rogues gallery, there is always one that stands above the rest. Captain America has the Red Skull, Spider-Man has the Green Goblin, and the Fantastic Four have Doctor Doom. In keeping with this theme, Iron Man's arch nemesis from the comics is the Mandarin.

During the build up to Iron Man 3, excitement was through the roof to see Tony Stark come to blows with Ben Kingsley's villain, but that's not what we got. Instead, Kingsley played booze-fuelled actor, Trevor Slattery.

This in itself isn't the worst thing in the world, as it was something different and genuinely surprising. It was just a shame that it wasn't the showdown everyone wanted to see. Just one year later in the Marvel one shot, All Hail The King, it was revealed that the Mandarin and the Ten Rings existed in the MCU, and there was still hope of the long awaited meeting.

Sadly however, Tony Stark snapped his fingers and passed away before having a chance to come face to face with his greatest enemy. Imagine if Cap had never faced Red Skull! While it is great that the villain will be explored in Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings in 2021, it is a shame Tony Stark won't be the one to face him.


4. Ignoring The Defenders

Defenders Netflix EW
Netflix/EW

While the main bulk of the MCU is the 23 movies that make up the Infinity Saga, there is of course the TV aspect of it. Shows like Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D, Agent Carter, Runaways, Cloak and Dagger, Inhumans, the upcoming Disney+ slate, and the Netflix corner of the MCU.

Though there were often references in the shows to the movies, this was not reciprocated, and any crossovers were minimal. Despite Marvel working hard on building a shared Netflix universe with Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, The Punisher, and The Defenders, all shows were cancelled without any crossover with the movies.

Possibly the most disappointing thing is that there were more than enough opportunities over the years. For one thing, the movies are based in New York. Doctor Strange and Spider-Man both spent a lot of their MCU debuts in the Big Apple, and even Thor spent some time there in Ragnarok. Would it have been that hard to at least reference the Defenders of Hell's Kitchen?

The biggest opportunity would have absolutely been in Civil War. Tony found his newest team member running around New York as a vigilante, and as much as it was the perfect MCU introduction for Peter Parker, he could have at least looked at Daredevil or the bullet proof Luke Cage for help from an already established character.

When Doctor Strange assembled the entire MCU heroes in Endgame, it felt like the Defenders really should have been there.


3. Everything About Fant4stic

Fantastic Four Ending
20th Century Studios

Reboots can be a tricky idea to navigate, and pulling one off can be incredibly difficult. These can either be reacted to very well, like with Tom Holland's Spider-Man coming into the MCU, or they can be absolutely hated, like David Harbour's Hellboy.

With critics and audiences scoring it just 9% and 18% respectively on Rotten Tomatoes, a global box office gross of just 167 million dollars against a reported 200 million dollar budget, and even the director himself slating the movie, it's fair to say that Fant4stic falls into the latter of these two categories.

With Miles Teller, Kate Mara, Michael B. Jordan, and Jamie Bell involved, the casting wasn't a problem, it was just everything else. The movie was bland, dark and dreary, and honestly down right boring. Josh Trank has claimed that he would have had more success had he been allowed by the studio to make the Fantastic Four movie he actually wanted to make, which achieved nothing but highlighting the problems behinds the scenes of production.

However, since the pre-planned sequel was quickly scrapped, and with the rights going to Marvel Studios, as far away from Trank and Fox as possible, we'll never know. There aren't many people who look back at this film and not wish it hadn't happened.


2. Firing James Gunn

James Gunn Fired
Disney

Previously known to only the most die hard comic book fans, the Guardians of the Galaxy has become one of the most popular properties in all of the superhero movie genre since 2014, and in no small part thanks to James Gunn.

The director of both 2014 and 2017 Guardians outings brought to the franchise a unique style that has since been emulated by Thor: Ragnarok, and even the marketing for Wonder Woman 1984 to some degree. Not only was Gunn instrumental in the creation of one of the most popular franchises within the MCU, he was also an executive producer on both Infinity War and Endgame.

Needless to say, when he was fired by Disney in 2018, panic set in. A number of ill-advised tweets dug up from the director's past led to the termination of his contract, sending fans into a frenzy. Not only did his cast defend him, Dave Bautista threatened to leave any potential Guardians sequel altogether unless Gunn was rehired.

The question soon became not who would replace James Gunn, but what would replace Guardians of the Galaxy? DC wasted little time getting the director on the phone and literally offering him a job on any property he wanted.

Fortunately, Disney and Marvel soon saw the error of their ways, and whether it was realising the Guardians and the MCU would never be the same without him, or suffering from FOMO after DC picked him up, Gunn was re-hired. Thankfully, Guardians 3 will now definitely be happening, even if we have to wait until after The Suicide Squad to see it.


1. Letting Their Properties Go In The First Place

Captain America Civil War Spider Man
Marvel Studios

Remember when the Civil War trailer broke the internet? That little 'hey, everyone' confirmed that Spider-Man was finally coming to the MCU and the world went mad. How about the news of the Disney/Fox merger, after all these years bringing the X-Men and Fantastic Four under the Marvel Studios umbrella?

There were celebrations when each of these properties came back to Marvel from Sony and Fox, but just imagine if they never left in the first place.

Throughout the 1990s, Marvel was struggling to stay afloat and resorted to selling the film rights to a number of key characters and properties in order to make some quick cash. In fairness, this obviously helped see the company through a rough patch and make it to the other side of the 20th century intact.

At the time Marvel had no idea just how big the MCU would become, and just how much the fact that there were movies in separate universes would mean to their fans. If Marvel could have just held on to these rights all those years ago, Hulk could have fought Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, there would be no need for two different Quicksilvers, and we could have had something incredible like Avengers Vs X-Men instead of Age of Ultron.


MCU Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Phase 1?

Iron Man 2 Tony Stark Opening
Marvel Studios

1. What Rock Classic Does Iron Man 2 Use To Reintroduce Tony Stark?

Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.