11 Famous Musicians Who Made Much Better Actors

Does Fred Durst's sex tape count?

Plenty of great musicians have also turned out impressive performances in films. There's David Bowie, Debbie Harry, Ice Cube, Björk, Elvis Presley, and... um... Snoop Dogg. On the flip side though, the graveyard of musicians producing woeful cinematic performances is heavily swollen, with the likes of Bon Jovi, Bob Dylan, Madonna and Mariah Carey and... um... Snoop Dogg chucking out some genuinely appalling excuses for "acting". This article is about neither of those sets of artists. Instead, this is a focus on musicians whose performances in films outshone their patchy musical careers. Perhaps they were renowned for churning out trashy pop hit after trashy pop hit, or created the most clichéd or overrated rock tracks around. Maybe they were just the least essential members of their respective bands. Regardless of the reasons for their less-than-glittering musical careers, these guys have still managed to show some impressive acting chops - whether just the once, or on a more regular basis. Sadly, Fred Durst's sex tape doesn't quite make the list. Sure, his performance in the video easily outstrips any of his work with Limp Bizkit, but the most impressive fakery in the clip actually comes from the poor woman forced to pretend she's enjoying copulating with his miserable features.

11. Toyah Willcox

A few of the actors included here actually had/have fairly distinguished music careers, and Toyah Willcox stands out more than most as one who, particularly in her early musical career, put out some genuinely good music. But her performances in Derek Jarman's early films are just so, so impressive that it's impossible not to wonder what she could have achieved if she'd stuck with it more. Check out Jubilee. She pretty much steals the show. Jarman was an expert at bringing the best out of raw, erotic actors, and Toyah is one of the best examples of that. She easily outshines the other punk icons in the film (Jordan, Adam Ant, etc.) and her heavily made-up image is one of the most iconic in Jarman's oeuvre. A very good musician, yes - but an even better actor.

10. Jack White

Jack White has successfully turned himself into some sort of guardian of contemporary blues music, despite the fact that he has in effect been churning out nostalgic 60s/70s-style garage rock for the better part of 15 years now. A favourite of indie fans and classic rock fans alike, he's actually contributed more than most to arguments about how retrospective and backwards-facing music is. This overrated rock star needs to do music a favour and try to further his acting career for a while. He hasn't done much (a few cameos here and there, a small performance as Elvis Presley in Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story) but his turn as Georgia in the critically-acclaimed Cold Mountain was genuinely excellent and truly emotional. He's not in it all that much, but he captivates in the few scenes that he spends onscreen. This is in a film alongside titans such as Donald Sutherland, Natalie Portman and Philip Seymour Hoffman. If White can hold his own in such esteemed company, then surely he has the ability to make a full career out of acting?

9. Courtney Love

Hole aren't actually very good. Admit it. Of all the awesome grunge bands to emerge in the 1990s, Hole were actually remarkably plain. Courtney Love's chaotic lifestyle and celebrity marriage to Kurt Cobain granted the band far more recognition that it ever merited, and the fact that they continue to tour today is pretty ridiculous. However, Love can act. In fact, she can absolutely blow away pretty much every other performer that she works alongside. The People Vs. Larry Flint was adored by critics, yet it wasn't just the performances of highly visible and popular character actors Woody Harrelson and Edward Norton that grabbed the headlines. It was also Love's turn as stripper Althea Leasure that had jaws dropping in cinemas globally. She was nominated for pretty much every award going (except for the Academy Awards, sadly) and won all but two of them. For someone that had effectively been written off by the media as a drug-addled rock star, she had proven herself to be an unbelievably gifted actor. Maybe she should finally start acting full-time and let the rest of her band crawl back into whatever Hole they came from.

8. Alanis Morissette

Is Alanis Morissette actually a decent musician, or...? Regardless of your perspective (and it's probably worth setting the much-maligned Ironic aside for a moment), there can be no doubt that she should have been offered (or accepted, whichever is the issue) far more cinematic roles after her remarkably understated performance in all-star comedy Dogma. Casting Morissette was a seriously brave choice by those in charge of the film. Her only previous acting role had been in a Brazilian soap opera, and she was being asked to play God. Yes, that's right - a FEMALE God. Dogma may be a comedy, but anyone playing God - especially a non-male God - has to get it right. Amazingly, she nailed it. Her scenes are pretty captivating, and she matches up to the likes of Ben Affleck, Matt Damon and Alan Rickman quite well. Oddly, she's only made a few television cameos since. Her music career has continued to blossom though. Shame on both fronts, really.

7. Hannah Spearritt

S Club 7 effectively started out as "actors". They were one of the earliest examples of a record label using television's influence to create pop stars that could be sold to children. The various S Club 7 series and films didn't exactly feature Oscar worthy performances, though, and it was the group's catchy-but-irritating numbers that ultimately grabbed them brief but huge success in the UK. After their dissolution, the group tried various things. Rachel Stevens, seen as having the most obvious "star" potential, started a solo singing career. Hannah Spearritt, however, became a full-time actor. Her most prominent role came in ITV's Primeval and, lo and behold, she was actually pretty damn good. OK, ITV dramas are hardly the breeding ground for exceptional acting chops, but Spearritt certainly showed plenty of promise. Her character on there was a hell of a lot less irritating than the one she played in the S Club 7 movies, anyway. Hopefully there's more to come from Spearritt.

6. Billie Piper

Similarly to Hannah Spearritt, Billie Piper was another 1990s industry-created pop singer that threw out the most manufactured plastic pop imaginable in order to appeal to tweens. She had massive initial success, then effectively disappeared. Until, that is, she showed up as Rose Tyler in Doctor Who. Many questioned the decision to cast her before the show aired, but once she hit the screens the reasoning was obvious - she was impressive, and her onscreen chemistry with Christopher Eccleston was seriously good. When David Tennant took over the lead role, their relationship was even better. While Piper has hardly gone on to become a megastar since, she has offered some great performances in the likes of Mansfield Park, Secret Diary Of A Call Girl and Penny Dreadful which suggest that there could be plenty more to come from her.

5. Lil Bow Wow

Bow Wow was (and is) a pretty average rapper. His gimmick when he started out - as Lil Bow Wow - was that he was young. He was basically a child rapper, making hip-hop safe for "the kids". It's the exact kind of marketing nonsense that shows major record labels are petrified of genuinely aggressive and subcultural music styles, and do everything to make it less confrontational. As he's grown older and dropped the "Lil", Bow Wow's middling flow has become scrutinised increasingly. He would be better sticking to a film career that shows just how gifted an actor he actually is. Like Mike may have been a pretty predictable kids' film, but Bow Wow certainly stole the show with his likeable and energetic performance. He was good enough to be chosen for a recurring role in HBO's Entourage too. Given HBO's track record with both comedy and drama, that's no mean feat.

4. Meat Loaf

Bombastic, overblown, pretentious... Meat Loaf's big budget, high concept rock operas have garnered him an audience with prog nerds everywhere. Everyone has whistled along to Paradise By The Dashboard Light once or twice, but they've also all cringed whenever I'd Do Anything For Love has shown up on their local soft rock radio channel for the 47th time that day. Meat Loaf has made a killing as a singer, so he's unlikely to ever change his career, but that doesn't mean that he wouldn't have been better suited to acting. Appearances in Fight Club, House, Monk and, most famously, The Rocky Horror Picture Show were marked by some pretty enjoyable (if slightly campy) acting. His star turns in many of his music videos have also been fairly decent, even if they're effectively silent roles. Given that he already has the ridiculous theatricality to create hideously over-the-top operatic rock songs, it goes without saying that he could at least work a decent career in pantomime.

3. Chris Isaak

For a guy that has put out a lot of albums in his career, Chris Isaak has effectively remained a one-hit wonder in the eyes of most music fans. Wicked Game is a great song, and anyone that disagrees wants their ears syringed. David Lynch knew it - that's why he placed it prominently on the soundtrack of the Palme D'or-winning Wild At Heart. It's also why Lynch cast him as Special Agent Chester Desmond in Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me. There aren't many braver casting decisions than this. Lynch was creating a prequel (rather than an oft-requested sequel) to a TV series that many people had lost interest in (due to its meandering second season), with a plot and style that railed against those of the original show. Controversial enough, but the lead actor from the series, Kyle MacLachlan, had also confirmed that he would only have a minor role in FWWM. Lynch effectively "replaced" his parts with a new character, played by Chris Isaak. The film is an underrated masterpiece, even if it was panned at the time, and Isaak's performance is one of its hidden gems. He plays an arrogant, smarmy mirror of MacLachlan's loveable Agent Dale Cooper, and his chemistry with Kiefer Sutherland, David Lynch and Harry Dean Stanton is great to watch. Isaak actually hasn't acted much since (perhaps because of the backlash against FWWM), but he really should have. He's got the ability to do so.

2. Ringo Starr

Cue the flaming. Look, everyone knows The Beatles were one of the greatest bands of all time, but everyone also knows that their success had very little to do with Ringo Starr. He barely wrote any of their great songs, his singing was fairly poor, and - as has been well-documented - he wasn't even the best drummer in The Beatles. Not the best drummer, no. But undoubtedly the best actor. He effectively singlehandedly carries The Beatles' films, which are fairly schlocky pseudo-psychedelic messes. Lennon, McCartney and Harrison stumble their way through their lines, but Starr is assured and, at times, actually rather good. He's proven his abilities since, too. Candy and Blindman are cult classics. Zappa's 200 Motels is insane avant-garde brilliance. He was in the smash-hit That'll Be The Day, and even starred in his own Being John Malkovich/My Name Is Bruce-style fourth wall-busting fictional biopic Ringo over 20 years before Spike Jonze's film. Granted, it wasn't very good, but the idea was strong - and the performance wasn't bad, either. his voiceovers in the likes of Thomas The Tank Engine and The Point are fun too. Of course Ringo has appeared in some utter rubbish - Caveman, Son Of Dracula, Give My Regards To Broad Street - but so has pretty much every actor. The fact is, his acting abilities far outweigh his drumming performances.

1. Jared Leto

This was an obvious choice. Jared Leto, singer of 30 Seconds To Mars, has proven himself to be one of the most exceptional actors around. From his early performances in Fight Club and Requiem For A Dream, right up to his Oscar-winning tour-de-force turn in Dallas Buyers Club, Leto has revealed himself to be multi-faceted and seriously gifted as an actor. His work in Dallas Buyers Club is just stunning. A trans woman with HIV, Leto's sensitive and layered performance is one of the best LGBTQ portrayals in a high-profile Hollywood film to date. Its recognition has opened the door for more complex and nuanced explorations of sexual minority experiences. His abilities have also, of course, landed him the role of The Joker in DC's cinematic universe, with his debut set to occur in 2016's Suicide Squad. By being cast as The Joker, he's been entrusted with the task of filling a void left by the incredible Heath Ledger. On the flip-side, 30 Seconds To Mars is a pretty generic alt-emo band. Sure, they claim a progressive and space rock influence, but their sound is actually fairly standard and... Well... Dull, really. Leto's vocals are nothing special, and fall under the whiney style that is fairly typical of most mid-noughties alternative emo-rock bands. Thankfully he's found his true calling as an actor. Perhaps his hyper-emotionalised musical style was an influence on his ability to bring to life such sensual and complex characters onscreen - in which case, I suppose everyone has to be thankful for his band's existence... Albeit grudgingly.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.