20 Things You Somehow Missed In Shutter Island
Unpacking all the hidden details in Scorsese's chilling thriller.
Martin Scorsese's Shutter Island might be one of the most criminally underappreciated films of the last 15 years - an expertly crafted mystery-thriller where even the most fleeting moment is executed with real intention by the master filmmaker.
Even though many have superficially dismissed Scorsese's movie as predictable, that of course ignores the darker implications of its tragically bleak ending, and also the treasure trove of incredible details hidden throughout the story.
It is a textbook example of a movie that benefits from many repeat viewings, because once you know the particulars of the narrative, you can focus on all the sneaky hints and Easter eggs scattered along the way.
Scorsese has clearly thought long and hard about every aspect of his production, sprinkling sly visual hints to the truth of Teddy Daniels' (Leonardo DiCaprio) trip to Shutter Island in almost every single scene.
As a result, this is truly one of those movies that uncovers something new on every subsequent viewing, and having pored extensively over it, these are the 20 details and facts you've probably not yet noticed. But if you caught any of them yourself, well done...
20. Chuck's Inexperience With Weapons
There's a tell incredibly early on that Teddy Daniels' new "partner" Chuck Aule (Mark Ruffalo) isn't the U.S. Marshal that he is presented to us as.
When the pair first arrive at Ashecliffe Hospital on Shutter Island, Deputy Warden McPherson (John Carroll Lynch) asks them to surrender their weapons, at which point Aule awkwardly fumbles with his gun holster, before handing over both his gun and the holster to an exasperated McPherson.
It's tough to picture a veteran cop ever handling a gun so clumsily, so it's a major upfront clue that Chuck isn't who he says he is. And of course, it's revealed later in the story that he's actually Teddy's doctor, Dr. Lester Sheehan.
19. The Edgy Guards
The disposition of Shutter Island's guards throughout the movie also tips viewers off that something isn't quite right.
When Teddy gets into a vehicle with McPherson and another guard, he notices all the guards in the surrounding area studying him intently and mentions to McPherson how on-edge they seem. McPherson then aptly replies, "Right now, Marshall, we all are."
On an initial viewing we understandably assume McPherson to be referring to the fact that a patient, Rachel Solando (Patricia Clarkson), has gone missing, when in reality the guards are actually intensely anxious at taking part in a role-play intended to cure Teddy (real name Andrew) of his delusions.
After all, letting an inmate wander around the island with minimal supervision as part of a radical, elaborate curative exercise is surely far from a usual day at work, and one that presents major risks. Basically, their concern is very legitimate.
18. "Shutter Island" Is An Anagram Of "Truth And Lies"
Because, again, nothing in this movie happens by accident, even its title is a tricky sleight of hand.
The name "Shutter Island" is actually an anagram of both the phrases "truth and lies" and "truth/denials," which is fitting given the story's focus on the elusiveness of truth and denial/self-deception.
It gets even better when you consider that anagrams are a wider part of the movie themselves, given that Andrew Laeddis is an anagram of Edward Daniels, and Rachel Solando is an anagram of Teddy's dead wife Dolores Chanal (Michelle Williams).
From the ground-up, Shutter Island is a riddle of a movie that seems like it's never finished unfurling.
17. Teddy Doesn't Strike Matches In The Movie's First Half
Keep an eye on Teddy's smoking habits throughout the movie, and you might notice something curious.
In the first half of the film, Teddy never once strikes a match, instead relying on Chuck to do the honours or, in one nightmarish sequence, the man he believes to be arsonist Andrew Laeddis (Elias Koteas).
On one hand, you can argue that this is simply a safety precaution on the part of Dr. Sheehan, to not give a mentally ill person a pack of matches, but it more likely relates to Teddy's traumatic association with fire after his wife was allegedly killed in a fire set by Laeddis.
Yet at almost exactly the film's mid-way point, as the treatment begins to take hold and Teddy slowly becomes Andrew again, he starts striking matches while skulking around Shutter Island, free of quite the same horrifying relationship with fire.
16. There's Way More CGI Than You Think
Though it might seem like the bulk of Shutter Island was shot on location and in elaborate sets, Martin Scorsese spent a major chunk of his $80 million budget on expertly integrated VFX elements.
For one, green screen compositing was used to create the vast exteriors of the island itself, combining CGI with practical location elements and miniatures.
But most impressively, even the interior sets of Ward C required a ton of post-production tinkering. Due to the logistical and technical complexity of building and lighting such huge sets, Scorsese filmed most of these scenes on partial sets employing a ton of green screen.
The sets were then completed and extended in post, the results of which are staggeringly seamless throughout.
15. The Patient Flirting With Chuck
Early in the movie, Teddy and Chuck speak with one of Ashecliffe Hospital's patients, Bridget Kearns (Robin Bartlett), who killed her husband with an axe.
When Teddy asks her about Dr. Sheehan, she becomes visibly nervous and trips over her words, before saying that he's nice and "Easy on the eyes, as my mother would say."
Scorsese then cuts directly to Chuck, who awkwardly looks away before sheepishly letting out a sly smile.
On an initial viewing most will surely pawn this off as Chuck simply being mildly exasperated with Kearns deviating to discuss a mundane detail, when in fact he's getting a little bashful because, of course, she's talking about him being a handsome devil.
14. The "Invisible" Water Cup
Literally seconds after this, Kearns asks Chuck to get her a cup of water while she writes a note to Teddy.
Chuck returns and passes Kearns the cup of water, yet as she drinks it, eagle-eyed viewers might notice that her hand is actually empty, before the cup is visible again in the next shot as she puts it down - albeit with the other hand.
Though some were silly enough to pawn this all off as some sort of technical or editing error, it was clearly an intentional flourish on the part of Scorsese and his legendary long-time editor Thelma Schoonmaker.
The entire film is packed with visual oddities intended to throw the audience off and keep them constantly feeling like something subtly isn't right, and this is surely one of the very best.
13. The Guard Behind Teddy
And one final detail from this scene - keep an eye on how Scorsese frames Teddy, Chuck, and Kearns. During their individual shots, we always see a guard standing behind Kearns and Teddy, but not Chuck.
While we would expect to see a guard in close proximity of inmate Kearns, having one also stood close to Teddy provides yet another subtle hint that he's also a patient.
Even when we cut to the wide shot of Teddy and Chuck, the guard is on the right-hand side of the screen by Teddy, and therefore able to quickly restrain Teddy if he ends up violently acting out.
12. It Has No Original Music
Shutter Island is such an absurdly atmospheric movie despite the fact that it doesn't feature any original music at all.
Rather, Scorsese opted to hire his regular collaborator Robbie Robertson as a music supervisor, to select existing music for inclusion in the film.
And so, Shutter Island's soundtrack consists of nothing more than classical music (both centuries-old and recent), including the likes of Gustav Mahler, Krzysztof Penderecki, György Ligeti, John Cage, Ingram Marshall, and Max Richter.
As much as the film was praised for its cannily picked soundtrack, this immediately disqualified Shutter Island from being nominated for the Best Original Score Oscar, due to its total reliance on existing music.
11. Teddy's Jacket Is Too Big
Here's something that basically leaps out at even fairly unobservant viewers from the outset: doesn't it seem like Teddy's jacket is a bit too big for him?
While on an initial viewing some might simply dismiss it as a mistake of the movie's costume department or an indication of Teddy's own sloppiness, it's actually an incredibly straight-forward hint that Teddy isn't really who he's presented as.
Teddy looks like somebody playing dress-up because that's precisely who he is - evidently the Ashecliffe staff couldn't be bothered to size him up and buy a new jacket, so just used whatever clothing they had lying around for the experiment.
10. The True Meaning Of "Rat In A Maze"
Jackie Earle Haley appears briefly in the movie as deranged inmate George Noyce, who tells Teddy that the doctors are experimenting on their patients, and that he's being deceived as part of a "game."
Noyce memorably tells Teddy that he's a "rat in a maze," which at first appears to be a fairly throwaway comment from an unreliable figure, until the end of the movie reveals that, indeed, Noyce's comment is more literal-minded than anyone expected.
Indeed, Teddy is a test subject in a bold psychological experiment from which escape is either unlikely or impossible.
Noyce's line was featured extensively in the film's trailers, yet few could've anticipated its actual context in the final movie, or that the unhinged Noyce was actually totally on the money.
9. The Guards Aren't Actually Looking For Rachel
Teddy and Chuck visit Shutter Island on the pretense of investigating the disappearance of Rachel Solando, who of course turns out to not exist, having been created in Teddy's mind.
But there's a major clue hinting at this when we see the island's guards apparently searching for Rachel - or as the case may be, not.
The guards are largely seen to be less-than-enthusiastic about finding Rachel, with Scorsese showing them sitting down, laughing, and otherwise not giving a damn about an escaped patient.
While we're led to believe this is simply a case of the guards being callously unsympathetic, it's of course because they know Rachel doesn't exist and are simply playing along with Teddy's delusion in thoroughly half-baked fashion.
8. The Symbolism Of The Band-Aid
From the film's very first scene, Teddy wears a distinctive band-aid above his left eye, though if you pay close attention, you might notice that the band-aid disappears at a specific point in the movie.
At the start of the third act, Dr. John Cawley (Ben Kingsley) informs Teddy that he came to the island alone and without a partner, after which Teddy takes a shower.
From this point on, the band-aid is absent for the rest of the movie, as Teddy's delusions start to melt away and he sees the truth for what it is.
It's both the literal and metaphorical pulling off of the band-aid, if you like.
7. The Shining Homage
If you're gonna borrow, you might as well borrow from the best, and that's certainly what Scorsese did at the start of his movie. If the music during the opening titles sounds familiar, that's because you've probably heard it before in another classic horror movie.
The titles are scored to an excerpt from György Ligeti's 1967 orchestral composition "Lontano," which was also used throughout Stanley Kubrick's iconic The Shining.
On one hand Scorsese was likely just nodding to one of his own favourite horror movies, but on the other, having the audience develop an unconscious association between this movie and one of the greatest horror films of all time is a pretty neat trick.
6. The Reverse Cigarette Smoke
Teddy's aforementioned nightmare sequence half-way through the movie shows him smoking a cigarette lit for him by "Andrew Laeddis," before coming across the blood-stained visage of Rachel Solando - or rather, a nurse in the guise of Rachel (Emily Mortimer).
After "Rachel" lets out a scream, Teddy turns and, if you take a close look at his cigarette, the smoke is actually disappearing back into it in reverse.
We see this effect deployed in two separate shots in the sequence, with the clear intent of visually conveying the un-reality of Teddy's nightmare.
It's a fairly basic VFX trick, but honestly, aren't the best tricks often fiendishly straight-forward?
5. The Law Of Four
The mystery of Rachel's "disappearance" is propelled into motion by a cryptic note she left behind, reading, "The law of 4. Who is 67?"
In reality of course the note is simply part of the role-play intended to lead Teddy to break his delusions and embrace his real identity as Andrew, something that's very sneakily hinted at mid-way through the story.
When Teddy attends an Ashecliffe staff meeting held by Dr. Cawley, he inquires with Cawley about the note left by Rachel, at which point Scorsese cuts to a staff member at the meeting who off-handedly tells a colleague, "The law of four. I love that."
It's such a quick moment spliced into the scene, and one that many might not even catch, yet once the twist is known, it's clearly further proof that everything we're seeing is part of a controlled fabrication which all the staff members are aware of.
4. Teddy Refuses To Look At Laeddis' Intake Form
At the end of the second act, Chuck tells Teddy that he took a detour to Ashecliffe's patient files area and found an intake form for Andrew Laeddis, which he then attempts to show Teddy.
Teddy says he'll look at it later, and when Chuck asks him what the matter is - given that Teddy's aloofness seems a tad out of character - he defensively reiterates that he'll look at the form later.
In retrospect, this is evidently a case of Teddy being unconsciously aware that the form will contain his true identity, and so choosing to avoid looking at it as it will shatter his present dissociative delusion.
3. Teddy's "Outstanding Defense Mechanisms"
Early on in the film, Teddy meets with Dr. Cawley and his assistant, Dr. Jeremiah Naehring (Max von Sydow).
After Teddy refuses an alcoholic drink, Naehring notes the incidence of alcoholism in the police force, to which Teddy retorts that psychiatry is a profession "overrun with boozers and drunks."
Naehring then laughs and retorts that Teddy has "outstanding defense mechanisms," a comment he repeats about a minute later as we catch a glimpse of Teddy's traumatic experiences in World War II.
There's of course a wider meaning to this, though, given that the entire point of the movie is that the doctors are attempting to break Teddy out of his delusion, which requires battling his substantial psychological defense mechanisms.
Naehring's comment was truer and more loaded with hidden meaning than anyone realised at the time.
2. Teddy's "Dead" Daughter Visibly Moves
At the very end of the movie, the truth is revealed to Teddy, who experiences a horrific vision of the aftermath of Dolores drowning their three children.
Teddy removes the kids from the lake and lays their bodies on the shore, yet if you look closely, you can actually see the actress portraying the daughter breathing and moving her eyes underneath her eyelids.
Granted, this sort of mistake is easier to accept in a surreal scene such as this where reality isn't on an even keel anyway, but even so, Scorsese evidently didn't catch the gaffe during shooting.
The lesson here? Playing dead is way harder than it looks, and that probably goes double if you're a kid.
1. The Sun Only Comes Out At The End
A major component of the film's atmosphere is the increasingly chaotic weather throughout Teddy's journey.
When he "arrives" on Shutter Island, the sky is dull and overcast, and over the course of the first half the weather becomes increasingly dire until a full-on storm breaks out.
Even once the storm passes, almost the entire remainder of the movie has a grim pallor to it, until once Teddy's delusion has finally been broken at the end, we eventually see that it's now a sunny day.
The visual metaphor speaks for itself, of sun breaking through the storm, even as the ending implies that Teddy feigns a relapse in order to be lobotomised and forget that he killed his wife after she drowned their children.