Alternative Oscars: The Nominees & Winners For Every Category

No more Oscar bait.

Amy Adams Arrival Oscar
Paramount & AMPAS

The 89th Academy Awards is very nearly upon us, and as usual, there are plenty of reasons to complain about the line-up of nominees: awesome movies were ridiculously snubbed, not-so-great movies got way too many nominations (looking at you, Lion), and films were disqualified from certain categories altogether for boring bureaucratic reasons that don't concern your average viewer.

The Alternative Oscars seeks to cut down on the Oscar bait, champion some lesser-known, under-appreciated fare and basically present the slate that, in an ideal world, would match up with the actual Oscars themselves.

20. Best Supporting Actor

Hell Or High Water Ben Foster
Lionsgate

WINNER: Ben Foster (Hell or High Water)

Easily one of the most egregiously snubbed performances of 2016, Ben Foster brought a ton of uniquely manic energy to David Mackenzie's fantastic neo-western as one half of a fraternal bank robber duo.

Foster has a litany of unhinged performances in his cachet, but not one is as hilarious, demented and downright entertaining as his superb work here.

It's a tough category, but Foster marked out his territory early over the summer and never found a superior opponent despite a few game attempts.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Mahershala Ali (Moonlight)

3. Jeff Bridges (Hell or High Water)

4. Michael Shannon (Nocturnal Animals)

5. Liam Neeson (Silence)


19. Best Visual Effects

Jungle Book Baloo.jpg
Disney

WINNER: The Jungle Book

Nothing came even remotely close to challenging The Jungle Book all year as the undisputed winner of this category, and it'll probably go on to win the actual Oscar as well.

Creating convincingly lifelike talking animals is no easy feat, and integrating a human being into the mix only makes it a ton more complicated, yet Jon Favreau and his team of effects wizards made the results look beautifully seamless.

Plus, whoever decided that King Louie needed to have Christopher Walken's actual eyes is a genuine genius. Terrifying.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Doctor Strange

3. Deepwater Horizon

4. Captain America: Civil War

5. Arrival


18. Best Supporting Actress

I Daniel Blake Hayley Squires
eOne Films

WINNER: Hayley Squires (I, Daniel Blake)

No 2016 film has been as Oscar-snubbed as Ken Loach's magnificent drama about Britain's unfair benefits system, and though BAFTA feted it with an Outstanding British Film win, they sure as Hell weren't doing so out of misplaced patriotism.

Squires' heartbreaking performance as a young mother living below the breadline and struggling to feed her kids is devastatingly true-to-life, and the fact Squires hasn't received more recognition for her fantastic work is an absolute travesty. She'll take the Alternative Oscar instead.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Michelle Williams (Manchester by the Sea)

3. Naomie Harris (Moonlight)

4. Angourie Rice (The Nice Guys)

5. Greta Gerwig (20th Century Women)


17. Best Cinematography

Moonlight Film
A24

WINNER: Moonlight

This was a tough category to judge because it's full of beautiful looking films, and though La La Land will likely take the easy win at the actual Oscars, Moonlight's James Laxton did a far more memorable job with the actual look of his film.

Moonlight makes excellent use of light both natural and not to create a warm glow that permeates through most of the movie and gives it a very unique look while also keeping it grounded as a drama.

It's important to remember that La La Land's direction and editing are more responsible for its impressive visuals than the sheer quality of the cinematography itself (which is undeniably great), so it doesn't win out here.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Hell or High Water

3. La La Land

4. Arrival

5. Jackie


16. Best Documentary

13th Documentary
Netflix

WINNER: 13th

Ava DuVernay's (Selma) shocking documentary about America's inherently racist penal system is a brutal expose of a regime in desperate need of change, detailing how the deck is stacked against blacks from the outset by powerful politicians both Democratic and Republican, and how slavery in essence is still lingering around.

It is by far the most important documentary film released this year, but it's also the most informative, surprising and powerful, and to give DuVernay her moment up on the Oscar podium would only hammer the film's crucial message home further.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Tower

3. Weiner

4. Tickled

5. Zero Days


15. Best Original Screenplay

Hell Or High Water Ben Foster Chris Pine
Lionsgate

WINNER: Hell or High Water

Sicario writer Taylor Sheridan delivered another singular masterwork with this magnificently well-calibrated script, crafting a unique crime thriller with a social conscience, well-drawn characters and a welcome dash of dark humour.

Full of memorable dialogue and a hilarious scene with the world's most cantankerous old waitress that's basically unforgettable, Sheridan continues to prove himself to be one of the most distinctive voices working today, a master of tone who for his part helped create one of the best westerns of the last decade.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Manchester by the Sea

3. Zootopia

4. I, Daniel Blake

5. The Nice Guys


14. Best Foreign Film

The Handmaiden
CJ Entertainment

WINNER: The Handmaiden

Director Chan-wook Park's (Oldboy) erotic period crime caper wasn't even submitted by South Korea for Oscar eligibility, despite being a sumptuous, beautifully mounted film with more than a few clever stings in its tail.

Unsurprisingly, Park's usual f***ed up tendencies show up in abundance, which may be offputting to some, but for those who have stomached his previous films, they'll have no problem soaking in this deliriously entertaining romp that ended up on a high number of critical top 10 lists.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Aquarius

3. Toni Erdmann

4. Neruda

5. Elle


13. Best Adapted Screenplay

Arrival Amy Adams
Paramount Pictures

WINNER: Arrival

Adapting Ted Chiang's mind-melting sci-fi story into a movie script must've been an enormous challenge, but Eric Heisserer did a marvelous job translating his abstract ideas to the cinematic medium.

Refreshingly refusing to talk down to its audience while exploring the complexities of language and the way the brain behaves in relation to it, all while loading up an Earth-shattering, devastating plot twist for the third act, Arrival's script is the perfect blueprint for director Denis Villeneuve and his fantastic cast to deliver an undeniable classic.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Silence

3. Moonlight

4. Fences

5. Hidden Figures


12. Best Costume Design

Jackie Natalie Portman
Fox Searchlight

WINNER: Jackie

This category almost always favours period fare, and this year is no exception. Jackie came out of the gate with a massive advantage because, of course, many of the outfits Natalie Portman's Jackie Kennedy wears are both lavish and extremely iconic.

There were a lot of fine contenders in this field, but considering what the movie does with the character in her various costumes and what this means in the wake of her husband's assassination, the clothing has an uncommon, striking impact.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. La La Land

3. Florence Foster Jenkins

4. Silence

5. Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them


11. Best Animated Film

Zootopia Sloth
Disney

WINNER: Zootopia

Disney just might be in the middle of a new Golden Age if their recent output is anything to go by, and this is one award that the Academy's sure to get right.

Zootopia may have been marketed as a fairly shallow Madagascar-esque romp, but thanks to a screenplay that melded the crime caper hijinks of Shane Black with enormous social relevance, it ended up being both the funniest and most intelligent animation of the year.

Pixar usually has this award locked up, but Disney has been on a roll lately, and are sure to take the big gold guy home this time.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Moana

3. Kubo & The Two Strings

4. Sausage Party

5. Finding Dory


10. Best Production Design

La La Land Traffic
Summit Entertainment

WINNER: La La Land

This was a tough one to call, but the elaborate nature of La La Land's various set-ups (especially that mind-boggling opening freeway dance sequence) makes it the winner here, combining gorgeous sets with larger-than-life locations to magical effect.

It's clear that the production design melded perfectly with director Damien Chazelle's own vision to make the film one of the year's most eye-pleasing experiences, evoking a classically old-school feel while still serving as a potent love letter to modern sun-kissed Los Angeles.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Jackie

3. Passengers

4. Silence

5. Hail, Caesar!


9. Best Film Editing

La La Land Ryan Gosling Emma Stone
Summit Entertainment

WINNER: La La Land

This is another fiercely-contested category, but La La Land's pulsing energy is so indebted to Tom Cross's rhythmic editing, which shouldn't be too surprising considering Cross took home the Best Editing Oscar two years ago for his sublime work on Chazelle's Whiplash.

Cross' punchy work helps the various set-pieces become infectiously enjoyable almost immediately, but he also does a fantastic job with the slower, more deliberate dramatic exchanges between Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone's protagonists.

Expect Cross to be a frequent winner in this category over the next few years, especially if he keeps teaming with Chazelle.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Arrival

3. Hacksaw Ridge

4. Moonlight

5. Hell or High Water


8. Best Actor

Manchester By The Sea Casey Affleck
Amazon Studios

WINNER: Casey Affleck (Manchester by the Sea)

Casey Affleck has been rightly dominating the awards circuit with his jaw-dropping yet restrained performance as a man returning to his hometown to pick up the pieces following his brother's untimely death.

It's soul-stirring work that's an incredibly difficult ask of any actor, and Affleck's rendition of a shattered man being faced with unbearable responsibility sticks with viewers long after the credits roll.

Personal controversies aside, he's got this sewn up both here and at the actual Oscars.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Dave Johns (I, Daniel Blake)

3. Denzel Washington (Fences)

4. Chris Pine (Hell or High Water)

5. Ryan Gosling (La La Land)


7. Best Original Song

Before The Flood Leonardo DiCaprio
National Geographic

WINNER: Before the Flood ("A Minute to Breathe" - Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross)

Though Leonardo DiCaprio's climate change documentary sadly didn't have much of an impact on the U.S. Presidential election, the film was nevertheless a passionate call to action, bolstered by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross' haunting tune written for the movie.

A Minute to Breathe cements the urgency of the climate change issue, and how future generations will judge society by what it does today. It's nowhere near as popular or catchy as what will eventually win (La La Land's "City of Stars"), but on sheer merit a much meatier and more important song.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Moana ("How Far I'll Go")

3. La La Land ("City of Stars")

4. Sing Street ("Drive It Like You Stole It")

5. Sausage Party ("The Great Beyond")


6. Best Makeup & Hairstyling

Star Trek Beyond Jaylah On Bridge
Paramount

WINNER: Star Trek Beyond

Star Trek Beyond's make-up is a big reason the movie is so much fun and two of its most distinct characters are as effective as they are.

First and foremost, there's Sofia Boutella's Jaylah, who is lent so much more character by her fantastically otherworldly alien facepaint, and of course, Idris Elba's villainous Krall, who basically looks like a total bada** and is completely unrecognisable from Elba.

It wasn't exactly a banner year for makeup at the movies, but Star Trek's evocative work deserves to be recognised.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Suicide Squad

3. Jackie


5. Best Actress

Arrival Amy Adams
Paramount Pictures

WINNER: Amy Adams (Arrival)

Amy Adams was curiously snubbed by the Academy for her arguably career-best work in Denis Villeneuve's magnificent sci-fi film, a performance all the more impressive considering how much of the film rests on its shoulders and the initial ambiguity of what Adams' character is experiencing.

It's also extremely rewarding to watch the movie a second time and interpret an entirely different dimension to Adams' performance with the knowledge of what she's seeing.

While perhaps not as flashy as sure-to-be-winner Emma Stone's work in La La Land (which just barely missed the cut here), Adams' subtle, challenging turn leaves a far greater lasting impact.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Natalie Portman (Jackie)

3. Viola Davis (Fences) - despite what the Academy might tell you, it's not a supporting performance.

4. Annette Bening (20th Century Women)

5. Isabelle Huppert (Elle)


4. Best Original Score

Moonlight Chiron
A24

WINNER: Moonlight

Even if it didn't have any musical score to speak of, Moonlight would be a masterful drama, but award-winning composer and pianist Nicholas Britell helps take it to the next level with his deeply affecting, violin-driven compositions.

The signature track, Middle of the World, is a work of awe-inspiring beauty, and anchors a musical score that perfectly cements and compliments the movie's sumptuous themes and gorgeous visual style.

Arrival was a very close second here, but as its signature song actually isn't an original composition, it gets the silver (while the Academy in fact disqualified it completely on these grounds).

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Arrival

3. La La Land

4. Jackie

5. Hell or High Water


3. Best Director

La La Land
Summit Entertainment

WINNER: Damien Chazelle (La La Land)

Any of these five nominees would've been more than worthy winners, but Damien Chazelle's mastery of cinematic space and ambitious step-up from his debut Whiplash makes him the decisive victor here.

He exhibits such smooth control over such an elaborate production, tying all aspects neatly together into a sonically and visually intoxicating experience that's infectiously charming and technically astounding.

At just 32 years of age, it's nothing short of mind-boggling how skilled this on-the-rise artist is.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Denis Villeneuve (Arrival)

3. Martin Scorsese (Silence)

4. Kenneth Lonergan (Manchester by the Sea)

5. Barry Jenkins (Moonlight)


2. Best Sound Mixing

La La Land Ryan Gosling Emma Stone
Summit Entertainment

WINNER: La La Land

Musicals always have a leg-up here and La La Land is no exception, perfectly incorporating its music and dialogue into a gorgeously symphonic mix.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Hacksaw Ridge

3. Deepwater Horizon

4. The Jungle Book

5. 13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi

Best Sound Editing

Hacksaw Ridge Andrew Garrfield
Summit Entertainment

WINNER: Hacksaw Ridge

In terms of sound creation, the action genre is always a big hit here, and Mel Gibson's brutally violent war film certainly didn't shy away from the ear-ringing terror of battle.

Yes, it's hard not to show favoritism towards the movie's sound editor, Kevin O'Connell, who has been nominated 21 times without a win, making him "Oscar's biggest loser". That streak needs to end (but it won't at the actual Oscars, sadly).

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Deepwater Horizon

3. The Jungle Book

4. Captain America: Civil War

5. La La Land


1. Best Picture

Arrival Amy Adams Jeremy Renner
Paramount Pictures

WINNER: Arrival

Arrival is a challenging, whip-smart, visually stunning, emotionally devastating, beautifully acted and thought provoking sci-fi film with a message of enormous relevance for the modern world (especially in light of recent political events).

It manages to ground an inherently heightened scenario and present with audience with a fascinating series of questions while entertaining as it also prods and informs.

It's a difficult juggling act but director Denis Villeneuve continues to prove himself one of the best directors working today, and the cast is consistently fantastic.

RUNNERS-UP:

2. Silence

3. Hell or High Water

4. Manchester by the Sea

5. Moonlight

6. The Jungle Book

7. Captain America: Civil War

8. 13th

9. Hacksaw Ridge

10. Jackie

Most Wins

In conclusion, the big winners are:

La La Land - 4 wins

Arrival - 3 wins

Hell or High Water & Moonlight - 2 wins

What do you make of these alternative Oscar picks? Agree? Disagree? Got your own to share? Shout them out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.