The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug - 5 Elements It Nailed (And 1 That Failed)
Aside from one issue, Peter Jackson's latest is also arguably his finest Middle Earth movie...

5. The Improved-Upon 48FPS And Outstanding Use Of 3D

4. The Increased Amount Of Action
An Unexpected Journey took its time introducing to us the vast amount of characters and setting up its narrative, and of the running time of 169 minutes, more time was spent with dialogue and getting to the action itself. But when the action showed up, boy was it captivating: thanks in part to the 3D the action stood out, and even in a 2D format the action is still a joy. The Desolation Of Smaug plays a different card, increasing the action scenes tenfold and introducing inventive ways to use the 3D at the same time. Each bit of action in this film easily upscales all of the action scenes from An Unexpected Journey, in some cases even in the original three LOTR films. The hotly anticipated barrel sequence is one of the most engaging action scenarios of 2013, bar none: even in 2D I could watch that scene all day long, extended or not. And then of course there are the Mirkwood spider sequence, and the climactic sequence where the pace hits its apex at Erebor when Smaug appears and steals his scenes entirely. Even the criticised decision to bring back Legolas added more action elements, and channelled the higher-octane spirit and pace of the original trilogy. It's al part and parcel of setting up a trilogy: the original trilogy had the same experience, with The Fellowship Of The Ring pursuing a more sophisticated method in introducing characters and pushing action to the back burner, then The Two Towers looked to introduce the beginning stages of the action before The Return Of The King went full-blood with epic action sequences. In this case, An Unexpected Journey was the build-up, The Desolation Of Smaug started the action, and There And Back Again will hopefully reach that same fever pitch as The Return Of The King.
3. Putting Thorin In The Limelight

2. Smaug

1. Ending On A Monumental Cliffhanger
Despite being likely to attract both controversy and praise, the ending to The Desolation Of Smaug is, by all accounts, the most rewarding aspect to the film and perhaps one the greatest decisions Peter Jackson has ever made. What makes this ending so rewarding is how it ends: just as it seems Thorin, Bilbo, and company have dispatched Smaug in a flood of molten gold, the nearly invincible wyrm breaks loose of both his golden prison and Erebor and makes for Esgaroth, living up to his promises towards Bilbo that he looks to make the citizens of Laketown suffer, declaring "I am fire....I am death." As Smaug flies into the distance to unleash hell, Bilbo is seen scurrying to the ruins of the Erebor's entrance, asking to himself, "What have we done?". Cut to credits and a black screen made all the blacker by the shock and awe of the spectacle we just witnessed. What better way to end a middle chapter than at that point? Peter Jackson and his production crew have usually run into trouble finding a stopping point for each film, even back when production on the Lord Of The Rings began. How do they divide three whole books into three whole films? How do you split key events up? Such is the case with The Hobbit, but with only one book that is barely over 315 pages being divided into three more films, the task of creating a gripping narrative that is both fresh and familiar was even more daunting, but both films so far have ended in exactly the right place. In this case, the ending gives Smaug more screen time in the third film, even if it is limited to the opening sequence. It also leaves us pondering a number of issues: what of Gandalf being trapped at Dol Guldur and the Orc armies heading for the Lonely Mountain? What of Legolas chasing after Bolg? What of Kili and Tauriel, even if it is a bit of a forced romance? Does Bilbo really possess the Arkenstone? There are so many plot points left unanswered, but that is exactly as it should be to build excitement for the final film. And now on to the one major issue that ruined The Desolation Of Smaug's perfect score...The Major Problem: The Addition Of An Unneeded Romance
