The Hunger Games: Catching Fire - 5 Reasons It's Better Than The First One
When Gary Ross' film adaptation of Suzanne Collins dystopic novel The Hunger Games was released in spring of 2012, most fans could concede that the odds were mostly in their favor. In an era when most young adult novels hit the screen with a big wet flop or meet vapid, starved cheers, The Hunger Games was largely faithful to the novel, cared about all the same big ideas its author cared about, and gave us a pitch-perfect take on its central heroine, Katniss Everdeen. Sure, there were things that didn't work, or could have worked better. Ross isn't an action director, and the helter-skelter camera movementdesigned to pull a PG-13 out of a really gruesome scenarioharmed the momentum and emotion in the action sequences. Everything felt rushed, and the thematic heft that came from seeing this world through Katniss' eyes was traded up for a theme-park tour ride; the Tributes zooming train became the distorted alter-ego of Disney's Small World attraction, zipping us through a totalitarian dictatorship with a stunning variety of oppression. At the end of the day though, The Hunger Games was a solid endeavor and a fine entertainment that respected and honored its source material, and more importantly, made a bonafide star of the much deserving Ms. Lawrence. Ross delivered two things the franchise dearly needed to begin well; structural integrity and exactly the right cast. It was a good beginning, but the nature of Collins series suggested that the next go-round wouldn't be nearly as easy. Now that Catching Fire is here, all can breathe a big sigh of relief. Francis Lawrence, a competent director that never dared to be great until now, grabs the reigns of the saga and instead of simply maintaining Ross' straight-forward trajectory, pushes it towards a bolder, bigger destination. This isn't just one of the best action/adventure films of the year, it's a substantial and heartfelt improvement over the picture that came before it. Instead of belaboring or rehashing the general plot-pointsyou've either read the books or deserve to go in to this and experience it yourselfwe will take a look at the ways in which Catching Fire has gathered a sturdy start and turned it into genuine triumph. Note: I've done by best to mitigate any spoilers or major plot info regarding Catching Fire, but there will be some discussion about the events of the original Hunger Games. So, without further prep, let's dive right into the wilderness of Panem...
5. Plutarch Heavensbee Blows Seneca Crane Out Of The Water As Games Master
It might seem like a relatively small change when you are talking about quality between two films, but the replacement of Wes Bentley's arrogant, preening games master with the affable-yet- sinister Hunger Games maestro Plutarch Heavensbee massively improves the suspense and competitive nature of the game sequences themselves. This was by design even in Collins' novel, where Crane was merely a delusional tool of the government machine, while Plutarch functioned as a mysterious free agent, who advises Snow and threatens Katniss but never once seems like someone's puppet. In a dystopian novel of this type, the real villain is the social hierarchy and its leaders, which can often feel shadowy, vague and insubstantial as a primary antagonist. The first film had President Snow as the ruthless face of the Capitol and its regime, but his scenes were minimal, even when greatly expanded from the book. In order to feel the tension of the game event and perceive Katniss and Peeta as having a real adversary---outside the other scared but dangerous kids fighting for their livesRoss and his scriptwriters did an interesting and welcome thing; they went behind the scenes of the game-planning. We watched Seneca Crane as he and his Truman Show-esque team manipulated the terrain, delivered aid or set traps. It was just what a more literal vision of the story needed. The problem was really down to Wes and an insubstantial Crane. He never felt particularly sinister or imposing, and so these scenes added interest but not suspense or gravity. Not so this time around. Snow and the Capitol are sufficiently fleshed out and menacing, but they take a backseat eventually to Hoffman's spin on Heavensbee, which is so terrifically understated that it vibrantly stands out from the rest of this universe. If you're from the districts, you're covered in mud or coal dust, and if you're from the Capitol you look like you raided the wardrobes of Brazil or The Fifth Element. Not Hoffman's Plutarch, who could have just wandered right off the set of The Master, wearing the same exact suit. When this guy digs in to work he's like a stockbroker or a composer; there's no emotional attachment registered as he goes about government-sanctioned murder as entertainment. Hoffman gives him texture without playing his hand, which makes him more threatening, not less.
4. We Finally Get To See The Broader Reality Of Panem In All Of Its Horror And Glory
Let's give Gary Ross some credit from the outset. It isn't easy trying to build a fantasy world while also remaining faithful to a myriad of characters, concepts and icons that fans are hungrily looking for. He paved the way beautifully, and his overcast, gritty take on the Districts as collapsed industrial cities or mining townsthink Detroit or Appalachia-- grounded the movie in a realistic pall of despair. Likewise, the Capitol of Panem sufficiently resembled its round-about namesake, the Roman Empire. What was missing was the nooks and crannies of a plausible, lived-in universe. Like that ominous train shooting along the tracks, the plot itself hardly slowed long enough for us to see much of the world outside of District 12 or the arena where the first Hunger Games was held. In Collins novel we more directly registered the iron grip of the Capitol and its barbarism. There were a few minor, undefined shots of riots in some of the other Districts but the focus was lacking. In Catching Fire, it's not just that we are treated to more of Panem in general---the Victory tour ensures we see exactly what's going on in some of the other Districtswe are invited to share in what life is like for these people, down to the littlest details regarding how the power crunch trickles down and impacts their lives. The Capitol too, is more pronounced in its debauchery. Why does any of this matter so much? The narrative gist of Catching Fire isn't about surviving the Hunger Games, but about the realities of revolution and dissonance. The Gestapo tactics of Snow's military force are necessary in etching the stakes, but just as valuable is the more relatable and timely depiction of a media-saturated social opiate that feeds citizens processed, tranquilizing entertainment so they might remain oppressed and impoverished. Everything regarding the newfound celebrity that Katniss finds herself thrust into rings with nuggets of pointed truth. We believe this world more deeply than before, and as such, we can sympathize more with our protagonist's desire to escape it.
3. Francis Lawrence Delivers Coherent, Rousing Action Scenes
You are likely to hear this trotted out more often than not, but it's true nonetheless. In particular, it's one of the few areas where the improvement comes directly from a changing of the guard on the film's end, and not just a natural result of Collins story being different from what came before. The action in the first Hunger Games was initially frustrating and later, desensitizing. Death had no excruciating stingeven one of the book's younger, beloved tributes met her end with a surprising lack of emotional resonanceand eventually, the challenges faced were similarly bereft of danger. Director Lawrence has come off of several adaptationsConstantine, I Am Legend, Water for Elephantsthat called for big set pieces and showy moments, and in fits-and-starts he delivered some of the necessary spectacle without making memorable movies. Here, with the confidence of the story itself, and plenty of time to ramp-up to the confrontations, he comes into his own directing the action and makes this 75th Quarter-Quell games far more devastating and grueling than similar skirmishes in R-rated action flicks. The tropical jungle setting for the games helps, as does a more fluid sense of structure once the combatants are dropped into their surroundings. Best of all, there's a texture and geography to these moments that was entirely lacking last time round. When Tributes must band together to assess the jungle, it's dangers, and those trying to kill them, we are delivered directly into their perspective. Some of the violent ends are still obscured, but not the kinetic movement leading up to the death blows. The last third of the film feels like an epic graphic-novel, and the primal scream that punctuated something like Lord of the Flies is finally present onscreen. Without giving too much away, it also helps that Heavensbee's traps and obstacles are very cinema-friendly, both scary and colorful in equal measure. An attack by a certain animal species, as well as Collins haunting jabber-jays, are particular highlights.
2. The Direction Is More Accomplished And Character-Driven
Both Hunger Games films were praise-worthy on their aesthetic values, and again Ross set the template for what was to come. That the new crew doesn't throw out his work or try to re-imagine it is to the series' ultimate benefit. This isn't Alfonso Cuaron giving the world of Harry Potter a completely different vision from Chris Columbus' candy-coated storybook approach. Instead, Lawrence adds a sense of opulence and patient observation, extending the overall timing of shots to include space for meditationnot much mind you, but these kids don't live in a world where there's much time at all for such pleasantries. His team also expands the scope and emphasis of the visual elements, using them to impart more subtle aspects of Collins story that would often be lost in translation. From beautiful sequences of Katniss standing solitary and alone in the forests of her District, or watching the grief-stricken faces of Rue's family during the Victory tour, cinematographer Jo Willems funnels the fantastical visions of this rotted Oz directly through the eyes of its beleaguered protagonist. The effect is two-fold; we aren't visiting Panem on an escapist jaunt, but as one of its victims, and the enhanced emphasis on Katniss' headspace (turns out PSTD is a side effect of the games) ably replaces the first-person narration of the novel. All of the characters are given more to do, but they also shine in their scenes, and are better linked to the burgeoning storyline. Gale, Katniss' would-be love, and mentor Haymitch are both more interesting here than last time, as is Elizabeth Bank's Effie Trinket. She was all hair and Lady Gaga posturing, now she's the Capitol's example of a little lost sheep trying to pretend everything is ok. Visually, these improvements are achieved through the absolutely fantastic costuming work of Trish Summerville, the sets by Larry Dias, and the production design of Philip Messina, all coming together to inform and inspire the characters instead of crowd them out. Lawrence also gets extra credit for inserting homage into Catching Fire without the need for cheeky reference or wholesale steal. In addition to some carefully placed visual cues that ignite memories of Children of Men, Logan's Run and Soylent Green, there are also odd callbacks to the Fire Swamp of The Princess Bride, and a pivotal moment of rebellion manifests itself as the antithesis of the dark transformation in Darren Aronofsky's The Black Swan. This is a great looking film, but each of its pieces serves the story being told and that makes all the difference.
1. It Has The Best Acting Ensemble Of Any Recent Blockbuster
I suppose I could have typed Jennifer Lawrence for every single entry here and not actually stepped wrong. I could spend the next few paragraphs doing the same thing, but it would only belabor something clearly evident every second she's onscreen; Jennifer Lawrence is Katniss Everdeen, and if I'm being so honest as to anger fans of the book, she's a better Katniss than Collins initially envisioned. Lawrence brings both her vulnerability and lively spark to the role, as well as her recent experience as over-night media darling who's learning to addle the spin machine (recall early in her career when she sarcastically convinced a Rolling Stone writer to craft an interview seriously suggesting incest?) She makes Katniss undeniably, quantifiably human and fallible, but also strong and empathetic. There's great acting, but there's an added essence of being. She was good originally, but she's grown enough to know when to carry a scene or to simply support someone else while they do. Lawrence is far from alone in the enhanced acting chops department. Josh Hutcherson has also experienced a transformation in the role, and I'd argue that his work as Peeta is even more impressive because he comes a father distance with slightly less to work with. He doesn't just embody Peeta's internal humility and honor, but also plays the character as Katniss herself sees him. Liam Hemsworth isn't one of the star players, but he's good as Galen, and the likes of Donald Sutherland, Harrelson, and Stanley Tucci take established characters and make them iconic. The passion and intensity of the stars is no small thing for the franchise, and there's heat here that is honest and palpable. What better way to enhance and fan that flame, than with a second-act supporting cast that includes Jeffrey Wright and Amanda Plummer as mad scientist types, Sam Claflin as a swaggering Adonis who's more than he seems, and Jena Malone's murderous, sultry ax-wielder, Johanna Mason. Malone and Claflin are particularly strong, demonstrating energy I'd not seen from either before. At the end of the day, it's refreshing to have a big-budget saga that doesn't skimp on the delicious frosting but can still deliver substance through good old-fashioned storytelling, character development and fine acting. Hunger Games franchise, may the odds stay ever in your favor!