It Chapter 2: Every Character Ranked Worst To Best
Two Losers Clubs, one clown and a whole world of fear...
As with any large ensemble cast, the important thing in It Chapter 2 is balance. That goes particularly to this film because of its admirable attempt to mesh two separate timelines and two different "realities" in each together to create one cohesive, coherent narrative.
It should probably go without saying that there are some compromises in that balance - with some characters being left behind almost entirely in fact - but with a cast this good and performances in the first film so good, it was still always going to be an entertaining experience. What counts now, though, is working out who walked away as the best characters. Remarkably, it wasn't Pennywise.
For this, let's go with characters who influence the plot in some way. There are obviously characters created solely as projections by It, like Eddie's mom and Georgie (credited as Dead Georgie, which is nice) and Mr Keene the pharmacist and his daughter Gretta (both the young and older version) but they're pretty minimal and don't really need to be in the ranking. That said there are other supporting figures who DO deserve their own mention...
SPOILERS FOLLOW
15. The Shopkeeper - Stephen King
The film is actually pretty nicely punctuated by references for Stephen King fans (and horror fans) - including the "Here's Johnny!" thrown in there - but the most on-the-nose is definitely the appearance by the great man himself.
He appears as an antiques dealer who Bill encounters in a case of the most meta reference ever (Bill is, after all, a thinly-veiled cipher for King too), criticises him for his lack of finesse in ending stories (insert Spider-man pointing at Spider-Man gif in your own head here) and then sells him his own bike.
It's just fan-bait and a little silly, even if it's nice to see him included, and there's an unfortunate feeling that King is so strange looking that he's going to end up being a monster. And then he's just sort of not.
14. Webby & The Homophobic Bullies
Strangely not subsequently proven to be a projection by It - though surely they SHOULD have been, given what they do to the young gay couple who partly end up being Pennywise's first victim - the gang of four bullies, lead by Jake Weary's Webby, terrorising the fairground are typical Stephen King characters.
They seek out the vulnerable or the easily targeted - in this case, an "outside" gay couple - and seek to destroy them. For them to have gotten so much of an active role in the opening is actually quite a surprise, but they're an important part of Derry. Not a welcome one, but an important one: because it's key - in King's logic - that Derry would hold a lot more horrors than It, because it's designed to be a place people always want to leave.
They're still no more than a narrative device with limbs and they SHOULD have been retrofitted as It's use of the couple's fear against them (because it makes so much sense), but you can't have everything.
13. The Kid (Dean) - Luke Roessler
What there is of Bill's arc mostly focuses on his accountability for Georgie's death. The film is very much invested in showing how trauma affects memory and it turns out that Bill lied about how ill he was, leaving George to play alone and Pennywise to take him as his first victim (when he intended to take ill). It's all very touching, even slightly mishandled.
And thrown into the pot is little Dean, a neighbourhood kid who lives in Bill's old house (and his a fan of Richie's stand-up comedy act apparently). He ends up being the film's stand-in for George, as Bill tries to stop him from becoming another victim of It and becomes the key to Bill wanting to stand up to him once again.
Again, he's mostly a narrative function personified and it's a little hard to care what happens to him, but you can at least tell Bill is invested in that.
12. The Gay Couple - Taylor Frey & Xavier Dolan
As already mentioned, the film makes a strange decision in opening with the persecution, assault and attempted murder of a gay couple - played by Taylor Frey and Xavier Dolan (director of Matthias & Maxime and Laurence Himself among others). Their involvement is clearly supposed to help sell the idea of Derry as a poisoned place, but the sequence comes off as a little unnecessary.
It also doesn't help build up the mythology of It, because it makes him a criminal of opportunity, as if he'd choose his first victim solely because it landed in his lap. And why he chooses to go after those two random adults when his rules for attacking adults should have been informed ONLY by the Losers Club thwarting him isn't established either.
Unfortunately, in an attempt to add in another message, their involvement becomes a little muddled and the performances barely matter.
11. Stanley Uris - Andy Bean/Wyatt Oleff
Sometimes, narrative dictates character hierarchy, which is precisely what happens with Stanley Uris. While Wyatt Oleff continues his good work from the first film, he's mostly pushed to the side because the film is obviously about the remaining Losers exploring their own suppressed memories and using them to take on Pennywise again.
Because he's not there, he's not in it very much at all, which is a shame, but a necessary one.
His older version - played by Andy Bean (who was recently in DC Universe's Swamp Thing) - is mostly only notable for the startling way he leaves the film and the fact that he genuinely does look like Wyatt Oleff could have grown up to be him. Other than that, there's no a great deal to say about him, because he boils down to a presence rather than a real character.
10. Ben Hanscom - Jay Ryan/Jeremy Ray Taylor
Ben is the first real disappointment of It Chapter 2 because he ends up being so inconsequential even as you get the sense that he should have been so much more. He has arguably the most interesting arc between the movies because he changed so much, but aside for an encounter with Pennywise that explores SOME of his mentality and why he changed after he was "rejected" by Beverly, we just don't get to see it.
Instead, Ben is rather unfortunately turned into eye candy, which Jay Ryan is very good at selling, because that's what he was cast for. Instead of being a genius who knew Derry's lore inside out as he was in the first film, his arc is defined more by his jealousy over Bev and Bill, which never develops into a proper point of friction.
In the end, he gets to where you want him to, but once you look back, it's a little hard to remember how or why he even really deserved it.
9. Alvin Marsh - Stephen Bogaert
While he's only in the film for a fairly short amount of time, Bev's abusive father Alvin (played by Stephen Bogaert) is a great part of It's armoury against her and a lot of that comes down to Bogaert's excellent performance. He's a broken man, twisted by trauma who takes it out on his daughter unforgivably and there's so much authenticity in how that plays out that his scenes are being retrospectively fitted with a trigger warning by some audience members.
Whether you agree with the necessity of that remains to be seen, since this is a horror movie, but it says something about how well it works.A
Alvin gets a chance to blossom into full-blown King monster by the end too and him borrowing Jack Nicholson's infamous The Shining line is an absolute high-point for the finale. You just get the feeling that he should probably have been in it more to explore Bev's arc better, given that it begins with her abusive husband and it looks like that's the way we're headed more overtly.
8. Mike Hanlon - Isaiah Mustafa/Chosen Jacobs
With Ben no longer in charge of passing on the history of Derry, that honour falls to Mike (played by former Old Spice commercial model Isaiah Mustafa - a fact I mention because it will keep popping into your head every few minutes in the movie). He never left Derry, so he's not subject to the same memory issues as the other Losers.
Sadly, Mike is where the film should have deviated from the book. He's not a direct retelling of the novel's version of Mike, but the Ritual Of Chud that forms the end of the 1958 sequence is reused so Mike becomes the one who takes charge of it. It didn't really need to be used at all, since it fails and since It isn't defeated the same way as in the book.
He's an okay character, but there's so much of the usual King nonsense in his character's arc - because he sought out the reason behind It - that he's asked to complete an almost impossible task. We get a lot of him talking about his quest to uncover the ritual and the need to do it, but there's not much development in there at all.
It's not wrong that he discovers the ritual, by any means, it's just that it ends up being a replacement for his personality somewhat. That goes for his younger self too, because he's mostly just left out other than as an ensemble player.
7. Henry Bowers - Teach Grant/Nicholas Hamilton
Henry Bowers deserved way more screentime in It Chapter 2. When he's broken out of his psychiatric hospital home thanks to It's influence, we get to see the beginnings of a great little dynamic on screen, between him and his dead buddy Patrick Hockstetter, who becomes his chauffeur. Now, putting aside how little sense that makes, it's a great moment and it sets up Bowers being a great secondary antagonist.
Unfortunately, even with so much run-time to play with, Bowers ends up being completely under-played. There's no explanation of his dynamic with It (which is odd, because some elements of the plot are PAINSTAKINGLY explained) and instead you get no real handle on whether he's really being guided by Hockstetter or if it's a murderer's delusion.
And because he's underused so much and ends up adding precisely nothing to the plot, you have to feel like he should have been left out.
6. Beverly Marsh - Jessica Chastain/Sophia Lillis
Despite how well Jessica Chastain is cast here and how wonderful Sophia Lillis was as Bev in the first movie, she's rather unfortunately under-nourished in the second film. We get to see more of her backstory than most of the others, because as well as just seeing what she does now (as if that offers an insight into what an adult is entirely), we see that she ended up in a relationship like the one she had with her abusive father.
From there though, aside for the excellent sequence that sees her terrorised by Mrs Kersch in her old apartment, we get too little of Bev that isn't tied into the perception of others of her. She's key to Ben's arc (what there is of it) and she's brought in as a component for Bill's identity crisis, but beyond that it's a little hollow.
She never gets a chance to really stand up for herself and cast off her abusive past - which you sit and wait for for a couple of hours - and instead, she ends up with her new romantic partner by the end because she finds out he wrote her a poem and now he's handsome. If that sounds reductive, it's because the script doesn't offer much else.
Lillis' return is more successful when she's shown in flashbacks - rather hauntingly when she's shown appeasing her abusive father - and when she becomes an instrument of It's fear, she's at her best.
5. Bill Denborough - James McAvoy/Jaeden Martell
In the first movie, Jaeden Martell's Bill is the lead, because the entire story blossoms out of the death of his brother. This film is a continuation of that arc, in that it follows Bill's accountability back a little further.
Bill here is mostly just a stand-in for Stephen King, though. He's the author's usual trick of writing himself into his stories, only he might as well have a "Hello, my name is Stephen" name-tag on, so unsubtle is the allusion. When the real King rejects him signing his book because it's not very good, you know it's gone too far.
There is a fair bit of good in there and McAvoy is strong with what he's got to do (aside for his stutter being a little less organic than Martell's), but he's not quite up to the performance of his younger co-star, who is great when he returns to confront Georgie again.
4. Mrs Kersch - Joan Gregson
It's character projections are a real mixed bag in Chapter 2. Some of them end up being way too cartoonish and somewhat hampered by poor effects, but Mrs Kersch is the best of them by some distance. Well, apart from the main eventer, anyway.
She stars in a sequence showing the kids going back to find their totem items (artefacts) to destroy in he Ritual of CHUD and terrorises Beverly in a scene that is part Get Out (when she stares vapidly), part Harry Potter (the Nagini sequence in The Deathly Hallows) and part creepy It masterclass. Seeing her move around unnaturally and naked is just horrifying and while she loses something when she goes full cartoon version, she's one of the most lasting hauntings of the whole film.
Why almost her entire part had to be shown in the bloody trailer is a mystery. Though, actually, it'll be because it was scary and Warner Bros wanted to sell the fact that they were still going for that in the sequel. As if anyone would have NOT seen this movie based on that dumb assumption.
3. Pennywise - Bill Skarsgard
It says a lot of how good Bill Skarsgard's performance as Pennywise is that he feels a little under-served in Chapter 2. He's not absent, exactly, but it definitely feels like he should have been in more rather than the catalogue of other monsters we see trotted out. Even if he was involved in those, it would have been better.
Skarsgard's performance is a truly transformative one, part disarming kids TV presenter part full-blown psychotic monster and the amount of impact he can conjure out of doing that roaming eye thing is just wonderful. The fact that he manages to make such a weird package genuinely creepy is impressive and it's just a shame he wasn't given more of an opportunity to do it.
And it's further testament to the character's brilliance that when he transforms into the giant horrific spider monster at the end, it's not the huge letdown that the ABC version was. That must have been the biggest pitfall of the entire film and it's dealt with wonderfully.
2. Eddie Kaspbrak - James Ransone/Jack Dylan Grazer
There's a very good chance that James Ransone will be the cast member to emerge out of Chapter 2 with the biggest boost in profile, because he's absolutely brilliant as the grown up Eddie Kaspbrak.
It definitely helps him that he's paired mostly with Bill Hader's Richie, but Ransone's brilliance comes in how well his stunted development is. He's still a child, acting out adulthood, still crippled by his mother's influence and his hypochondria, still dangerously susceptible to fear and still very, very immature. It all works together to build a wonderfully charming character who is great value for money.
He's also a really great extrapolation of the performance by Jack Dylan Grazer, who was so good in the first movie and who is great again here. It's just a shame that the deaging effects used to push him back the wrong way through puberty were so distractingly off for him for some reason.
1. Richie Tozier - Bill Hader/Finn Wolfhard
Bill Hader is very, very good. Not just in Chapter 2, but generally speaking. He's funny, charming and immensely likeable, even when he's playing somewhat provocatively unlikeable characters. In anyone else's hands, the grown-up Richie could have been a relentless douchebag, but Hader's subtle performative observations make his vulnerabilities and how much he's over-compensating brilliant.
He and Finn Wolfhard are absolutely perfectly cast together, just as Ransone and Grazer were, and they're both as good as each other. Had this been a movie only about them, it would have arguably been better.
There's a good subtext in here concerning his sexuality and it has to be said that one of the most impressive decisions was to not have Richie use the final victory as a platform to come out. It looks for a long time that he's going to do it, but the most important part of his arc is that he feels comfortable with the idea of his own sexuality, rather than being made to feel like he has to suppress it. That's far more important than him coming out to friends who would have accepted him anyway. It's a rare moment of welcome restraint in the script.
What did you think of It Chapter 2? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.