Pixar: Ranking Their Films From Best To Worst

Mike_Monsters_University_still_1 Pixar deservedly have a grand reputation that has them at the forefront of animation: they have stretched the medium technically and created some of the most innovative and loved tales over the last 18 years. From the earliest days with Toy Story, Pixar went on an unprecedented run, delivering masterpiece after masterpiece, and you can justifiably make the claim that Pixar have only made one truly bad movie. They have constantly pushed the boundaries of animation since their inception and despite Dreamworks' best efforts, they just cannot match Pixar for quality and innovation. The likes of Woody, Buzz, Sully, Nemo and Wall-E have permanently entered the pop culture pantheon and are some of the most popular characters in movie history. Pixar's main competitor does not come from the US, but from Japan in the form of Studio Ghibli and Hayao Miyazaki as they too create masterpiece after masterpiece as if it's nothing. Pixar films typically appeal to adults as well as children and have a sort of nostalgia about them that makes us wish we were kids again. Pixar films are just so easy to access and indulge in, as they are narratively simple and have eternally likeable characters. Philosophically, Pixar movies tend to be optimistic, bordering on the idealist, which normally wouldn't go over with hard boiled cynics but Pixar just have a way of melting you each time. With 14 films now under their belt with the recent release of Monsters University, Pixar have more than established themselves as the frontrunner in animation, as their films will always leave a lasting impression with the audience. Pixar always treats it audience with complete respect, and is currently the finest the animation world has to offer.

14. Cars 2

Cars 2 Cars 2 is the only Pixar movie you could call a complete failure. There really was no need for a sequel in the first place, the first movie was okay but didn't reach the heights of their best work and box office returns were tepid in comparison. But it's the Cars merchandise sales that rule all. Cars 2 is a movie motivated entirely by commerce and selling the maximum amount of toy cars possible, and watching the movie, it's clear to see Pixar were more interested in getting the toys right rather than forming any substantial plot. Away from the cynical motivations for the making of the movie, there's just not a lot there. The movie has an interesting premise, and it could have been an interesting spoof of the spy genre, but the whole thing stinks of laziness. The 'mistaken identity' plot device has been used hundreds of times before and from Pixar, it is reasonable to expect substantially better. The animation, as it always is with Pixar, is dazzling and locations such as Japan and London look superb, but Cars 2, on the whole, is a shallow, vapid affair, and the weakest link in Pixar's filmography.

13. Cars

Cars Pixar making a car movie was inevitable, Pixar CCO John Lasseter is a noted car fanatic and bringing cars to life seemed like a logical step for the animation giants, but the two Cars movies are by far the least loved in their catalogue. A reason for this is their lack of attachment to the human world, as unlike things such as Toy Story which is fantasy set in the real universe, Cars is in a world of its own, and the lack of human heart leaves the audience cold. The film isn't without merit of course, some parts are witty and charming, and supporting character, Mater is the only real highlight, as central character, Lightning McQueen is unlikeable and boring. Cars suffers from the incredibly high standard Pixar have set themselves, but the fact that children would much rather re-watch their old copy of Monsters Inc than sit through this again says it all. Cars, ultimately, is a wasted opportunity, suffering from a lack of warmth and human connection, with its predictable plot and it bores the adults quicker than any other Pixar movie.

12. Brave

brave The first Pixar movie to feature a female protagonist (voiced by Kelly MacDonald), Brave is pretty standard fare despite their attempt to change the traditional dynamic between mother and daughter in Disney movies. The obligatory witch is in there and despite the character depth, the plot is riddled with girl power cliches rather than important feminist statements. Brave is very much an earnest movie, but it's instantly forgettable and its suspect moral message has none of the power like the good Pixar movies. It took until 2012 for Pixar to make a female centred movie, and it's impossible to think of it as anything other than a disappointment. The film, despite its heroine, is a movie aimed at a male audience, Merida is very boyish and doesn't really give young girls a character they can relate to. Pixar have a reputation for breaking new ground and much like Cars, there's nothing overtly wrong with it, there's just nothing special about it either. Watch Tangled instead, it's much more fun.

11. Monsters University

Late Despite never getting anywhere near the heights of Monsters Inc, there is still enough fun to be had with Monsters University. Whilst it takes a while to get going, the teenage Mike and Sulley are funny enough to get us through without too many complaints. What the film mainly lacks is a heart, which is what made the first one so great and everlasting. There's no emotion to be invested in the film because it's one of Pixar's lighter efforts that focusses heavily on comedy and leaves out much of the drama that they've become famous for. What Monsters University really missed is Boo and all of her charm and sweetness, and the end result is a slightly above average college comedy. Pixar did have so much to live up to with this film that anything less than perfection would have been deemed a disappointment and whilst it's easy to walk away from the film feeling let down, there are some good jokes to be had and the camaraderie between Mike and Sulley is still delightful. Monsters University is perhaps proof that Pixar are their own worse enemy, they've set themselves such a high precedent with so many enduring classics that we expect every film they release to be in a similar vein. The very best Pixar movies have a great sense of humanity and love, but sadly, Monsters University isn't one of them.

10. Ratatouille

Ratatouille Ratatouille was always a risky project from the start - it has a title that's not easy to pronounce and is focussed on an animal which isn't exactly anybody's favourite. The concept was not one of Pixar's most appealing and was treated with the most scepticism prior to release, but that cynicism subsided after everybody saw the movie. Directed by the excellent Brad Bird, Ratatouille is a slightly strange (in a good way), earnest movie with an excellent imagination and subtle humour. The humour in the movie is old fashioned compared to what we're used to getting with Pixar, but it works tremendously because of the concept. If there is one criticism of the film, it's that it is not the most child friendly Pixar movie, and is more enjoyed by adults. Like all the great animated films, Ratatouille has exhilarating action sequences that dazzle the hearts of minds and it's easy to see why Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol was so scintillating after a re-watch of Ratatouille. Beneath all the charm of Ratatouille is a profound message that is eternally relatable - your dreams are possible no matter where you come from - that may be a simple idealism, but it's nice to lose your cynicism for two hours. It's perhaps a disservice to Ratatouille that it's ranked so low here, but it doesn't quite reach the same level of magic as some of Pixar's other work, despite the daring premise and glorious enjoyment it brings.

9. A Bug's Life

Bug's Life Because it's one of Disney's older efforts that isn't part of the Toy Story franchise, A Bug's Life can get overlooked when discussing Pixar's best movies, but the reality is, it's a timeless classic. A Bug's Life is full of vibrancy and colour and it solidified Pixar as a power to be reckoned with and that they weren't a one hit wonder after Toy Story. Its target audience is the youngest of all the Pixar movies, but the clever, excellently written story and some inspired casting (Kevin Spacey) makes it a pure delight. One of the best things A Bug's Life does is have these tiny characters exist in this huge world, and much like Toy Story and Finding Nemo, it integrates existentialism into proceedings and shows that's there's a difference between being small and acting small. A Bug's Life has an iconic and memorable set of characters, from the menacing Hopper to the hilarious Heimlich, with each having a definitive personality and sense of uniqueness. A Bug's Life is essentially Seven Samurai with insects (a very good thing), and unlike its rival Antz, it doesn't attempt to clumsily preach politics and is focused on entertaining its audience.

8. Wall-E

wALL-e EYES Wall-E was originally conceived way back in 1994 when Toy Story was nearing completion and Pixar heads were seeking ideas for follow-up projects. After numerous writing problems, work on Wall-E never substantially started until well into the 00's as there were numerous glitches arrived around the conceit and character. Wall-E ended up developing into Pixar's most adult and socially conscious venture yet as ecological concerns are a huge art of the plot which has led to the film being championed and criticised by members of both political wings. The politics in the film does not get in the way of the typical Pixar spirit, and it exists deftly in the subtext of the picture and it is handled gently enough so that kids take notice and adults don't get irritated. The fascinating picture is keenly influenced by silent movies, as much of the first half of the film features no dialogue and only music, which is both a good and a bad thing. Wall-E is a truly beautiful movie that explored the art of communication as for much of the movie characters only integrate through body language and the landscape. The movie also communicates with the audience in a unique way, as the dialogue contemporary audiences are used to is replaced with music and robotic noises. With a lack of dialogue, the movie has to set the right tone and atmosphere to work which Andrew Stanton does perfectly as you are enamoured by the intimacy of the piece. Wall-E explores loneliness and love in a sophisticated fashion and signalled the more mature movies Pixar would make over the next few years (Up and Toy Story 3). Whilst Wall-E may be a personal favourite, it failed to connect with children like their previous films and some found it boring and inaccessible, which makes it the animated Silent Running. Wall-E will get better with age, and thematically, it does lean towards an older audience, but it's just too good not to be universally accepted. And Terry Gilliam loves it, which must count for something.

7. Toy Story 2

Toy Story 2 With the exception of The Godfather Part II, The Empire Strikes Back and a couple of others, sequels are never as good as the original, but Toy Story 2 isn't far off. Originally intended to go straight-to-DVD, Toy Story 2 has no right to be anywhere near as good as it is. The production had to be rushed for release, John Lasseter and his team re-wrote the story in a single weekend and the whole film had to be completed in a minuscule nine months, and the result was the second part in arguably the greatest trilogy ever made. Toy Story 2 is inspired work, born out of Pixar boss John Lasseter seeing a young boy with a Woody doll at an airport, and that kind of love and affection is what makes the Toy Story series so special. If Toy Story didn't, then Toy Story 2 would definitely remind you why you loved your toys so much when you were a kid, and the earnest magic of the picture can break down even the hardest and coldest of cynics. The addition of a central female character in Jessie is very much welcomed and she adds more greatness to the film, as it is endless innovative and in some people's eyes, better than the first one.

6. Finding Nemo

Finding Nemo The opening of Finding Nemo is a traumatising experience for even the hardest of souls as a mother and all her eggs except one are eaten, leaving the solitary egg and the father alone. From that opening scene, the movie has you hooked, and is the perfect device to explain why Marlin is so overprotective of Nemo. The grand ocean is the perfect environment for a lost child story as it exposes horror and wonder in equal measure. The voice work of Albert Brooks and Ellen DeGeneres is amongst the best in the whole Pixar cannon, as Brooks' Marlin is eternally sympathetic and witty and DeGeneres' Dory has become one of the most popular and quoted Pixar creations. For obvious reasons, Finding Nemo appears massively to the parents taking their children to see the picture, as the movie gently explains that overprotecting your children will inevitably alienate them and expose them to the dangers you were attempting to protect them from. Finding Nemo also features some of Pixar's very best animation as the ocean world looks fantastic and each of the fish are captured for their unique quality. Overall, Finding Nemo is completely engaging, impossible to dislike and warm-hearted, even if its central message is overly idealistic.

5. The Incredibles

The Incredibles The Incredibles features everything from a dysfunctional family to psychotic super villains to an homage to Alan Moore's Watchmen. Until Brave it was the only Pixar movie that was centred on human beings and not animals or inanimate objects, which unveils a whole new dynamic to the Pixar vehicle as it is the most naturally relatable Pixar movie. The father, Mr. Incredible has been confined to an office cubicle, the mother, Elastigirl, is a housewife, the son, Dash, is a promising sports star unable to compete because of his power, the daughter, Violet, is a hormonal teenage girl; which makes each member of the family aimed at a specific target audience, a deft move by Pixar which never feels cynical. The strength of The Incredibles is also its weakness as it loses its grand fantastical aura that came with the worlds completely foreign to us, but calling it a weakness is probably a gross exaggeration. It's a fantastically fun movie, willing to rip on spy and superhero movies with love and appreciation. It's bombastic and whilst it never heats the emotional highs of Pixar's very best work, it's thrilling and worth it for Samuel L Jackson's Frozone alone.

4. Monsters Inc

Monsters Inc From the second you hear the concept - an entire monster world is powered by scaring children - you know you're on to a winner. It takes the 'monsters in the closet' conceit and turns it on its head as the monsters are the ones really afraid of human contract, believing they'll become infected. Monsters Inc is one of the most purely funny movies made in recent years as Sully and Mike (voiced brilliantly by John Goodman and Billy Crystal respectively) are a a buddy duo for the ages as the jokes come so fast it's hard to keep up. The animation of Sully and his fur is rightly acclaimed, but the sheer scope of the universe Pixar have created here often goes overlooked. Every little detail is given the care it needs and the result is a pristine looking picture in one of Pixar's most technically challenging productions. The soon to be released sequel is hotly anticipated and much like with Toy Story it's impossible to think how they could top the original, but with Pixar you can never write anything off. Monsters Inc also possesses one of the most wonderful endings of the last decade, and if you don't cry, you're a harder man than me.

3. Toy Story

Toy Story Like Monsters Inc, Finding Nemo and Up, Toy Story has at the heart it a misfit buddy duo that immediately warms your heart. Woody and Buzz are the definitive Pixar characters and the iconic pairing upon which Pixar's success was built. The release of Toy Story saw cinema changed forever as it pioneered computer animation and set a new benchmark for animated movies. Toy Story was either going to be the hit it became or a disastrous flop as everybody involved was going for broke, with money and resources stretched to the limit and Disney being apprehensive about the project. What we got was one of the most innovative movies ever made that displayed the brilliance of the imagination for all to see. Without Toy Story, there would be no Monsters Inc, The Incredibles or Up. It's the film that kicked off Pixar's dominance of animated movies, as they were unstoppable for over a decade. John Lasseter and his team also capture the essence of toys and give each toy a special characterisation that is true to them, which creates a fantastical universe that is truly a wonder impossible to not get lost in. The film has many great moments, both awe-inspiring and poignant, emphasising its ability to appeal universally, but the thrilling escape sequence aside, the supreme moment in the film is when Buzz devastatingly realises he is just a toy - it's a powerful and often overlooked moment. For all the attention the animation and visuals received, Toy Story's magic is in its heart with the characters and the words they say.

2. Toy Story 3

Toy Story 3 Nobody thought it was possible, nobody thought Pixar could make a film on the same level as the previous two entries, yet alone surpass them, but that's exactly what they did. Pixar committed to the brave move of growing with its audience, as fans of the first two movies would now be in their teens and Pixar owes them a satisfying third part. Despite being the third film in the series, and tackling far more mature themes than before, the film is still accessible to those engaging with the Toy Story universe for the first time. The story is beautifully written and new characters such as the tragic villain Lots-O-Huggin Bear, the smooth talking Ken and wonderfully hilarious Mr. Pricklepants are brilliant additions to the already esteemed cast of characters. It's almost impossible to discuss the emotional highs of Toy Story 3 as it was just so perfect, and written words could never do the picture justice. It hits the bullseye every single time and despite the fact this is the third entry in the series, still brought great surprises that had you laughing out loud, such as Spanish Buzz. The film builds brilliantly, and the final act is essentially a prison breakout movie that is more tense than most live action movies. Toy Story 3 is mainly a film about the loss of childhood and growing up even if we don't want to, but it's also a celebration of the joys of childhood and the relationship all children have with their toys. The unforgettable scene in Toy Story 3, is of course, all of the toys holding hands in the face of horror and destruction, because it made the audience, including this writer sob uncontrollably. We fell in love with these toys way back in 1995, and over 15 years later, we're still as attached as ever.

1. Up

Up Up brought Pixar to an entirely new level. The montage in the opening minutes is simply one of cinema's finest scenes as it has the ability to make you laugh and cry with equal power. The montage shows Carl and Ellie's life together, from their meeting as children, to their first house, to their jobs as a balloon seller and zookeeper respectively, to their inability to have children, and finally, to Ellie's heart-breaking death that didn't leave a dry eye in the house. The sombre opening is the perfect example of Pixar respecting its audience and refusing to condescend its apparent primary fanbase of film fans not yet in their teens. Up is a grand adventure, as Carl wishes to realise his dream of reaching Paradise Falls, only he accidentally picks up a passenger in the loveable Russell, and the two form a tight bond as Carl literally drags his house to Paradise Falls for his late wife. Up is unbelievably touching, and is so genuine and touching and it never loses its sense of humour, despite the fact it tackles some hard stuff thematically. Up is like the finest poem, it's beautiful, sweet and stays with you long after its over. It became the second ever animated film to be nominated for Best Picture at the Academy Awards, and it should have won. Do you agree with our ranking? Share your own ranks of Pixar's stable of films below in the comments thread.

In this post: 
Pixar
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.