Star Trek 4: 8 Villains We Might See
It's time for all-out Klingon war, surely?
Whilst the rebooted Star Trek films have all been well-received delights, a common criticism of the three films is that its villains have been rather lacklustre. Sadly, this summer's instalment in the franchise could be accused of the same flaw, despite having a brilliant actor like Idris Elba taking on villainous duties.
The reboot's villains, apart from Benedict Cumberbatch's Khan, have not really stood out or been a powerful presence. And even goodwill towards the rebooted Khan dissipated because of the whole "John Harrison" controversy.
There's all sorts of solutions to fixing this villain problem in the next film, and it starts with mining the Star Trek franchise's rich rogue's gallery for a villainous species, or a despicable individual, that is either memorable enough to reinvent, or obscure and ridiculed enough to show in a completely new light.
The Kelvin Timeline's Enterprise crew need an antagonist that is just as formidable a force as them, and there have been quite a few aliens over the last 50 years who could emerge from the shadows to threaten Kirk and his team like never before...
8. An Original Villain
On the one hand, the new iteration of the Enterprise crew should be facing new threats rather than rehashing what came before. But on the other hand, Nero and Krall were original villains that never quite worked.
Nero had a strong connection to Kirk and Spock in both the original timeline, and the current altered one. But Eric Bana mostly sat in a chair and raised his voice. But Krall had even more potential as an unknown threat, but got lost up in the fact Star Trek Beyond was an ensemble piece- everyone was having too much fun to see him as a significant threat. But Benedict Cumberbatch's Khan was a lot more formidable, pushing the crew to their limits.
A new villain can be someone that arrives out of nowhere simply because the Enterprise crew gets in their way. An emotionally manipulative villain, who can spoil the team's family dynamic and turn them against each other, is far more interesting than a bad guy with a grudge against Kirk or the Federation.
The opportunity to create a villain we've never seen before is tempting, and some new writers plus a shrewd casting director could bring us an antagonist unlike anything we've seen in the Star Trek franchise. Hopefully they will learn from what hasn't quite worked previously.
7. Gul Dukat and The Cardassians
Many people talk of Khan as the greatest Star Trek villain, but militant Cardassian Gul Dukat is a serious contender for that title. The Cardassians are a refreshing alternative to the Klingons, and proved to be brilliant antagonists in The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine. There is no iconic lead Kilngon villain, but Dukat is a powerful villain with a powerful supporting army.
In fact, the Cardassians are so badass they're enemies of the Klingons- if ever there was a force to cause an uneasy alliance between the Klingon empire and the Federation, it's the Cardassians. They are more extreme in every way to the Klingons, a totally ruthless and xenophobic race who don't have diplomacy or unity on their minds. they even fight amongst themselves.
With Kirk and his team now older and wiser, they would have to maintain their composure, use their brains and their brawn to face off against such a violent yet highly intellectual race, headed by Gul Dukat who eventually loses his mind. Chris Pine's Kirk needs an iconic enemy in the same way Shatner's Kirk had Khan, and later captains had the Borg. Gul Dukat could be the perfect foil for him.
6. The Changeling
The Changeling are not necessarily evil, but their pursuit of corporeal form could provide a different type of body horror to the Borg, providing a paranoid, Cronenberg-style fourth film that makes us question what it means to be human.
The Changeling's motivations are not necessarily evil, and by the end of the film the crew's potential defeat of the Changeling could make them look like the villains.
Their physiology has real cinematic potential. They cannot retain one physical form for too long, or they begin to deteriorate, which could mean their personalities or attitudes change at a vital moment when the Enterprise crew have managed to reach a compromise with them. They are unpredictable, because it is in their nature - it is a survival technique. It's almost impossible for Kirk to reach an agreement with them.
They can mimic fire, clouds, electronic devices... they can be anything, anywhere, at any time. The crew would turn on each other and the film would be reminiscent of Invasion of the Body Snatchers.
Star Trek Beyond was a step in the right direction- a lot more intimate, personal and contained than the previous two films. A fourth film where the crew face the Changeling would really let us get to know Kirk, Spock et al at their worst and really see their flaws when faced with such a challenging force.
5. The Ferengi
A well-established race for many years now, the occupations of the Ferengi is ripe for a movie that satirizes trade and the current economic situation. Sort of like The Big Short or The Wolf of Wall Street in space. The Star Trek series hasn't done a blatant comedy since the fourth film, The Voyage Home. The Ferengi present an opportunity for a change of tone, so that the series doesn't just become a series of action movies.
Earning profit is the primary objective of the Ferengi- how does the team we know and love fight against that, when they can't use logic or lasers? They have to be manipulative and single-minded to beat the Ferengi, and that may put them in direct conflict with the Federation they report to.
And their single-mindedness may expose certain hypocrisies of the Enterprise crew and of the Federation. There has never been slavery or genocide in Ferengi history. What horrific sacrifices and compromises have the Federation made in the past to establish themselves?
The Ferengi would inadvertently cause a lot of soul-searching for the Enterprise crew, making them question if they really want to be a part of the federation.
4. The Gorn
The Gorn have long been thought of as a joke thanks to the famous wrestling scene with William Shatner:
There have been one or two attempts to reinvent them as serious threats, but none have really landed. For this reason, the Gorn are ripe for a bold reinvention, especially considering their aggressive hatred of other species, like a non-diplomatic, more primal version of the Klingons.
There are such gaps in what we know of the Gorn's culture and mythology, the creative team behind the next movie can do whatever they want. Having Kirk and the crew stranded and being hunted down by the Gorn would be a nice change from the relentless pace of the previous films- a tense survival thriller similar to Predator, The Thing or Jaws would see the team truly working together to face an unfamiliar threat.
Although they eventually become very sophisticated, meeting the Gorn as they are on the verge of evolving into a higher species would show us a species transitioning from their more savage form- some Gorn may want to better themselves, others wishing to keep things the way they are.
The Gorn's own worst enemy could be themselves, and the Enterprise crew could be the ones to save them.
3. The Borg
Perhaps the most popular enemies of the Federation besides the Klingons, the Borg offer the most potential of any classic villain, and if done correctly could create a truly unique fourth film.
It is hard to respond to the Borg hivemind with anything but violence. They are less of an antagonist, and more of a force of nature, driven only to assimilate. In some ways they are more terrifying than Doctor Who's Cybermen. When the Enterprise comes across the Borg Cube, their only option is fight to survive.
Going up against the Borg would raise the stakes for the team- hopefully it would lead to at least one meaningful death at the hands of the Borg. Not even Khan could kill Kirk- there's every chance, for example, Uhura or Sulu could be assimilated and lost forever. The Enterprise family torn apart by an enemy that can't be reasoned with, or negotiated with.
Jonathan Frakes did a fantastic job directing a distinctive and stylised Borg movie with 1996's First Contact. Bringing Frakes on board would not only give the next movie a bit of old-school magic, but Frakes' experience in directing the Borg would ensure an enemy with real presence.
2. Q
The last three films have focused on an individual as their villain, rather than an entire species, so if the creative team follow that pattern there's no one better than John de Lancie's mysterious Q. Bringing him back to the fold, and keeping de Lancie in the role, would mess with the rebooted timeline. Mind-bending blockbusters like Inception and Doctor Strange prove audiences have an appetite for getting their brains fried by a film.
Q presents an intellectual and philosophical threat to a team who are in need of being pushed to their limits, and we haven't had a Star Trek that tackles philosophy and theology since the awful fifth film, "The Final Frontier". Not that tackling such topics would be a boring change of pace- the filmmakers need only look to intelligent science fiction films like Interstellar or Arrival to see how films with bold ideas do well with critics and audiences alike.
Plus, Q is just a brilliant character. Irritating and mischievous, he could very easily bring out the humour in every situation, however perilous or emotional draining for the Enterprise crew. Having Q butt heads with Bones is to exciting an opportunity to miss! For a very different kind of Star Trek film, Q is the villain to pick!
If the filmmakers insist on recasting the role of Q, the best replacements would be James Woods, James Spader or even Toby Jones.
1. The Klingons
The Klingons are the most obvious choice for the next villain. They were only fleetingly viewed in the first two films of the reboot, but an all-out war film or political thriller in the vein of The Undiscovered Country would be a refreshing change of pace for the series.
It really is time for The Klingons to take centre stage- they are the equivalent of The Daleks or the Cylons and need a chance to face off against this generation's Star Trek team. They haven't really been the primary antagonists for over a decade, and this needs to be corrected. Listening to Michael Giacchino's incredible theme for them has you desperate to see more of the Klingons heading into battle to this music:
They can outwit Kirk, Spock and the rest of the crew, they can intimidate them, they can arguably mature the Enterprise crew into the team we loved for decades. This could be the opportunity for the reboot films to come full circle.
We would see the Federation at their strongest, and most ruthless, as the Klingons wage all-out war across the stars. To see a Star Trek movie turn into a full blown war film like Apocalypse Now or Saving Private Ryan is an incredibly exciting prospect, and who else but the Klingons could make it happen? This could be what all the other reboot films have been leading up to.
Which villains would you love to see show up in the next Star Trek film? Let us know in the comments below!