Star Trek Beyond: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best
Uhura...who?
The verdict is in! Star Trek Beyond is finally out, and while certainly not reaching the heights of the 2009 reboot, it's a rock solid entry into the franchise that remedies a lot of the issues people had with the previous film, Star Trek Into Darkness.
Arguably the best thing about the movie, which was co-written by Simon Pegg himself, is how much time it devotes to characterisation, resulting in some of the best dialogue-based interactions in the entire new Star Trek trilogy.
Sure, not everyone is as well-served as they could have been and there are some glaring omissions, but for the most part, Star Trek Beyond puts the human element first while flying closer to the tone of the original series.
From the heroes, to the villains, to the crucial supporting characters, here is every significant Star Trek Beyond character ranked from worst to best...
12. Commodore Paris (Shohreh Aghdashloo)
There was a lot of intrigue when it was revealed a few months ago that legendary, Oscar-nominated veteran actress Shohreh Aghdashloo had been added to the film in late re-shoots.
Many assumed this implied a substantial re-shaping of the end product and Aghdashloo would be involved in a major subplot, but sadly, this isn't the case at all.
She appears for just a few short scenes as Captain Kirk's superior and does very little of significance or worth remembering. Her screen time totals maybe three minutes, and feels like a gigantic waste of Aghdashloo's talents.
Seriously: why hire someone so terrific for such a throwaway part?
11. Keenser (Deep Roy)
Keenser may not be a significant part of these movies, but he's been a consistently entertaining presence as Scott's engineering comrade ever since the 2009 reboot, and continues that tradition here.
Yes, his screen time is incredibly minimal and he naturally doesn't say a word, but his physical comedy, usually propelled by body language, gives him a few hysterical moments opposite Scotty.
You still may not remember his name even after three movies, but the second he re-appears on-screen in Beyond, you'll be reminded of his hilarious antics with Scotty prior, which are ably recalled here and provide welcome comic relief.
10. Nyota Uhura (Zoe Saldana)
One of the biggest disappointments about Beyond is that the only female of the core Trek crew ends up feeling cruelly under-served.
Her place in the film is pretty much this: she's got relationship woes with Spock, she briefly helps out, faces off against the bad guy, finds out a revelation, and restores her personal status quo by the time the film ends.
It does nothing interesting or really especially memorable with the character, which is a huge shame given the enormous potential. She could very easily have been written out of the movie given how little she actually contributes to it, which is pretty damn sad to say in a time where people are rightly asking for more prominent, strong female characters.
9. Kalara (Lydia Wilson)
A semi-prominent character in the movie who was almost completely left out of Beyond's marketing, Kalara is pivotal in propelling the plot forward earlier on and introducing the Enterprise crew to the villainous Krall, after she lures Kirk and co. to her position only for it to be a trap.
Easily Kalara's most memorable moment in the film, however, is her spectacularly, hilariously over-the-top demise, as she ends up flattened by the Enterprise once Kirk and Chekov are able to activate the ship's thrusters. It's a suitably savage, brutal death for a villainous character, and made her appearance that much more memorable.
8. Hikaru Sulu (John Cho)
Controversy be damned, John Cho gives another terrific, restrained performance as Sulu that doesn't merely recall George Takei's riff on the character but very much makes it his own.
The fact that Simon Pegg has written Sulu to be gay in Beyond received much press online, specifically that Takei himself disapproved of it, but honestly, it takes up maybe 20 seconds of the movie and passes without much of a second thought.
As for the core narrative, Sulu has some of the weaker material when paired with Uhura, often as a prisoner or in a passive role, but when he's in his chair, he's totally kick-a**.
7. Pavel Chekov (Anton Yelchin)
It's practically impossible not to watch Star Trek Beyond without a twinge of sadness whenever Anton Yelchin's Chekov appears on-screen, given the actor's shocking and untimely death last month.
Still, a slight comfort comes in the sense that Chekov gets easily the most screen time he's had in any of the three new films to date, and Yelchin again does a stand-up job bringing heart and humour to the character.
Paired up with Kirk when the Enterprise crew are separated early on, Chekov gets a lot to do while the script also deepens his character further with some fun nods to his Russian heritage and his apparent status as a ladies' man.
As the mid-credits tribute makes clear, for Anton, indeed.
6. Montgomery Scott (Simon Pegg)
Simon Pegg may have co-written Beyond, but he generously gives a lot of the prime rib material to his co-stars, even if he does admittedly benefit from being paired with new alien comrade Jaylah for most of the movie.
Their banter is extremely sweet and entertaining, and Pegg continues to nail the comedic exasperation of the character without turning him into a caricature or merely an impression of James Doohan.
Though it remains to be seen how far the next movie will take a potential romantic pairing between Scotty and Jaylah, they worked terrifically well together and so it wouldn't seem especially forced.
5. Krall (Idris Elba)
Most of the reason that Krall works as a villain isn't the script, but rather Idris Elba's terrifyingly imposing performance and some jaw-droppingly good make-up work.
As a character, Krall is a fairly standard Trek baddie, and even when the full extent of his origins are made clear, it seems fairly by-the-numbers. That said, Elba makes him immensely menacing with his stature and his voice, while a number of physical changes to the character over the course of the movie do add up to make him more interesting than he initially seems.
Sure, he can't help but pale compared to Benedict Cumberbatch's Khan, but as a nod to the TV series' more conventional alien foes, Krall undeniably works.
4. James T. Kirk (Chris Pine)
Kirk gets some excellent character development in Beyond, specifically as he considers leaving the Enterprise to become Vice Admiral and is now a year older than his father ever lived to be.
This isn't a mopey Kirk by any means, though: he gets a ton of the movie's most memorable moments, teaming up with Chekov and riding a vintage motorcycle in order to distract the enemy at a pivotal moment.
Of course, Kirk stays with his crew by movie's end, but the character work felt genuine, and though many were initially hesitant about him playing the part, Chris Pine again proves how superbly well-cast he is for the role.
We're still waiting for him to meet up with William Shatner's future version of Kirk, though...
3. Spock (Zachary Quinto)
Much like Kirk, Spock has many moments of introspection throughout the film, specifically once he learns of Spock Prime's death, and meditates on what this means for himself.
It's a good deal more interesting than Spock and Uhura breaking up, which is pure soap opera and thankfully not lingered on long. Pegg also smartly pairs Spock with Bones, their differing personalities resulting in some of the movie's most hilarious and entertaining moments (and if you ever wanted to hear Spock say "horse s***", well, you got your wish).
And finally, be honest: you got a lump in your throat when Spock pulled out the picture of the classic TOS crew at the end of the film, right? Once again, Quinto knocks it out of the park.
2. Leonard McCoy (Karl Urban)
Possibly the most pleasant surprise in the entire movie is how much screen time Bones gets, a major step-up from his role in the previous films. Not only is his aforementioned pairing with Spock superbly written and acted, but Urban on the whole gets a number of the film's funniest moments regardless of who he's interacting with.
Many have said that Urban "channels" DeForest Kelley in these movies, and while he does deliver a thoroughly faithful rendition of the character, he also brings plenty of himself to it as well to make it at least partly his own take.
Try not to laugh as Bones' iconic "I'm a doctor, not a..." line is cut-off by the transporter mid-sentence.
1. Jaylah (Sofia Boutella)
Even with all of these iconic personalities and excellent actors, the show was uniformly stolen by Sofia Boutella's Jaylah, an alien scavenger who saves Scotty from certain death and basically becomes his pal from there on out.
She's kick-a**, she's got an awesome look, and Boutella's performance makes her almost immediately likable. She's a tough, resourceful female character, which considering how much Uhura is sidelined in this movie, was desperately needed.
Her motivation for helping take Krall down is simple but effective, her banter with Scotty is terrific and, best of all, it seems like she'll be returning for the next movie, considering that she joins Starfleet at the end.
What could easily have been a disposable "one and done" character will hopefully have a similarly prominent part in Star Trek 4, because she was insanely awesome here.
What did you make of the character work in Star Trek Beyond? Shout it out in the comments!