The Menu Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs
A deliciously thorny satire packed with surprises.
With the theatrical side of the film industry suffering from an increasing lack of unique, original movies, it's always a pleasant surprise when we can watch something totally new, with no rooting in an existing IP, on the big screen.
And that's exactly what The Menu is - an imperfect but consistently entertaining black comedy-horror which eschews easy categorisation and goes down some avenues you surely won't expect.
If you're craving some soulful nourishment alongside your horror, look no further, because between its spiky-if-unsubtle social commentary, excellent ensemble cast, and stellar production values, The Menu is quite the rich, sumptuous meal of its own.
With critics and audiences alike largely praising the film so far, it's got everything it needs to become a modest box office hit and endure as one of the year's cult faves.
If you're one of the many who decries the lack of original movies in cinemas, you owe it to yourself to support something that's so damn fun and well-made.
But before we get to the effusive praise, first here's what doesn't quite work...
Downs...
3. It Totally Peaks In The First Act
The double-edged sword of The Menu's robust, riveting first act is that it sets such a high standard that the rest of the movie can't quite live up to.
The first 40-or-so minutes do such a fantastically fun, tight job of introducing audiences to the central characters, establishing the tone, and building a mystery, that once we know what's going on a little of the lustre is lost.
Your mind will surely be whirring throughout that first act trying to figure out the precise motivations of celebrity chef Julian Slowik (Ralph Fiennes) and his very weird dining experience, but once the cards are on the table, it settles into a more familiar - if still very fun - mode.
Such is the penalty for giving the audience such an enticing in, that it's a huge struggle to follow it up with something equally compelling, and it ultimately ends up a hair shy.
2. Ralph Fiennes' Unconvincing American Accent
Ralph Fiennes is a terrific actor and, on paper, seems perfectly cast as the quietly unhinged celebrity chef about to put his customers through a night of hell.
Yet for reasons that remain unclear, the decision was made to have Fiennes speak with an American accent for the role, and as much as we all love him, a stateside twang isn't his strongest suit as a performer. As a result, it's a regular distraction.
From the first moment we see him, Fiennes' American accent sounds totally phoney, and even if you accept that Julian could've picked up a strange hybrid of American and British accents from his time working as a chef in the U.S., that excuse doesn't totally wash.
Most of the time when Fiennes speaks, it's easy to hear him wrestling with and trying to suppress his own native English accent, at which point you have to wonder why he didn't just play the part that way instead.
1. It's Too Obvious At Times
Nobody is going to come away from The Menu calling it a subtle satire, and while that's hardly a problem for the majority of its runtime, there are certainly some moments where it gets a little too heavy-handed for its own good.
There are times where characters verbalise the movie's themes in overt ways that come off as unnatural, no matter that most audience members will be able to interpret the thematic intent from what's happening on screen.
Again, for the most part Seth Reiss and Will Tracy's script nails a solid balance, but there are occasions when it puts a little too fine a point on specific concepts for the cheap seats.
These issues aside, though, The Menu has a lot to offer audiences looking for a thrilling, hilarious night out at the movies...
Ups...
7. It's A Hilarious Satire Of Foodie Culture & Class
Despite some of the horrifying things that happen in the film, The Menu doesn't take itself all that seriously, given that it functions primarily as a flavourful satire of both foodie culture and class.
From literally its very first scene, the movie relentlessly mocks effete, pretentious foodies like protagonist Margot's (Anya Taylor-Joy) boyfriend Tyler (Nicholas Hoult) - a glorified fanboy of chef Julian who is obsessed with minimalist "refined" cuisine and every insufferable thing that entails.
On another level there's also a burning disdain for the cult of celebrity chefs, for while Julian certainly isn't an obvious caricature of any real-life chef, the deity-like regard with which he's held by his fans and even his own staff is horrifying in its own way.
The script further relishes prodding class war, namely the disparity between wealthy elite customers and the "lowly" kitchen staff who create their meals.
It all adds up to a rich, blackly comedic stew that keenly generates a consistent barrage of laughs, even though none of it could ever be called sly or cunning.
6. Anya Taylor-Joy's Superb Lead Performance
Anya Taylor-Joy wraps up what's been quite the incredibly year for her with a killer lead performance as Margot - effectively the audience surrogate character given how little interest she has in gastronomy compared to her fawning partner.
We share her incredulity at the highfalutin nonsense unfolding around her, and then the shock as the scenario becomes increasingly horrifying.
She's immediately sympathetic from the moment we see her enduring the pompous fancies of her windbag boyfriend, and remains an easy-to-root-for character throughout.
There's also a little more to her than there first appears to be, and Taylor-Joy pulls that aspect of the character off gracefully. All in all, she's the anchor that carries the movie, and impressively manages to stick out in a mighty ensemble doing a lot of good work.
5. The INCREDIBLE First Act
It can't quite be overstated just how brilliant the first reel of this movie is: it's a masterclass in building suspense, introducing the roster of characters, and letting the audience know what they're in for albeit without showing every single card.
Director Mark Mylod does a superb job of slow-building unease, because though anyone who's seen the trailer knows that something bad's soon enough going to happen, we're never quite sure when the punctuating, game-changing moment is going to come, or what exactly it's going to be.
And though the final hour doesn't land with the same verve, it's nevertheless one of the tightest and most delicately, nimbly crafted first acts of any "genre film" in recent memory.
If it's said that a film needs to hook the viewer in the first 10 minutes or risk losing them entirely, then The Menu locks them in a damn vice grip within that time.
4. The Strong Ensemble Cast
The film's cast is low-key stacked, and per its bevy of well-drawn characters ensures this is one of the most purely entertaining ensembles of the entire year.
Beyond Taylor-Joy and Fiennes in the lead roles, Nicholas Hoult is an absolute riot as Margot's unbearably up-his-own-ass food-lover partner Tyler. It's a performance that verges on caricature yet never quite goes over the top, ensuring Tyler remains a recognisably grandiose douchebag throughout.
Elsewhere Hong Chau is very good as Julian's second-in-command Elsa, bringing a cool severity to the fore throughout most of her screen time albeit with occasional spicings of unexpected humour.
Janet McTeer is meanwhile perfectly cast as a snooty food critic dining at the restaurant, as is John Leguizamo as a washed-up movie star desperately clinging to the fading embers of his career (though Leguizamo's own is thankfully doing just fine).
All in all this unconventional collection of esteemed performers helps keep The Menu consistently entertaining even when it begins flirting with more familiar ideas.
3. Mark Mylod's Sharp, Stylish Direction
All the props in the world to director Mark Mylod, whose work on this film marks a major step up from his prior directing efforts, such as Brit comedy Ali G Indahouse and rom-com What's Your Number?
Mylod hasn't been sitting on his hands during the 11 years since the latter film, though, having sharpened his teeth on episodes of Shameless, Game of Thrones, Succession, and many more.
As a result, this is a supremely confident piece of filmmaking from top to bottom.
The visuals, so loving captured by veteran DP Peter Deming (Mulholland Drive), perfectly imitate the glossy style of contemporary food shows, and the production designers deserve a tip of the hat for finding such a lush-yet-eerie location for Julian's remote island restaurant.
And then there's the fact that the various courses consumed throughout the film are noted with on-screen text in a fashion that becomes increasingly, hilariously tongue-in-cheek the longer the night rages on.
But perhaps the biggest challenge for any director making this movie would be reconciling its tone, and ensuring that the comedy and horror elements don't clash in an offputting way.
But Mylod makes the balance seem easy and effortless, so nimbly are the potentially conflicting tones massaged into a totally coherent whole. One suspects Mylod will be getting some seriously heavyweight scripts coming his way after this.
2. It's Full Of Fun Twists & Turns
The best thing you can do to ensure maximum enjoyment of this movie is to basically avoid watching the trailer altogether, because it is absolutely a film that rewards those who go in knowing as little as possible.
Though the trailer certainly doesn't ruin the movie's big conceit, it will allow you to glean things that probably shouldn't be known by a first-time viewer.
After all, it's a film jam-packed with giddy twists and turns, and if you haven't obsessively followed the marketing you surely won't figure them all out.
The playfulness of the script, performances, and direction make it easy to lose yourself in the wild, absurd ride and simply have fun with it rather than questioning the precise logic of every single reveal.
It's a film that continually introduces new wrinkles to keep things interesting, and whether you guess where it's going or not, you're likely to be entertained by the outcome.
1. The Excellent Pacing
As much as so many of us love to complain that modern films are too damn long and just don't know when to end, you won't hear many bemoaning that The Menu is a slog.
At a pacy 106 minutes, this is a film that knows exactly what it wants to pull off and does it without excess fat or bloat. It certainly isn't rushed - especially not during its deliberate first act - but every single scene feels like it does something important or worthwhile.
And as mentioned, the consistent slew of revelations regarding the characters and their situation ensures there's really no dull downtime whatsoever.
It is an extremely propulsive and energetic piece of filmmaking that many other directors could clearly learn a thing or two from.
And before you know it it's over, and you'll probably wonder how the time breezed by so fast.