The Thing: A Lesson In Remake Failure

€œRemakes, sequels and prequels suck!€ That€™s the general consensus. Swiftly followed by accusations of laziness and lack of creativity. But it doesn€™t have to be that way. Aliens, The Fly, and Dawn of the Dead (2004) proved that. And how? By building on the originality of the first film and adding to the respective canons. Which brings me onto The Thing (2011) - a prequel in name only to John Carpenter€™s 1982 classic. This is a remake with a few plants and a tacked on ending to try and avoid the negativity of €œyet another remake€œ. But there€™s so much more that leads to the film€™s failure beyond obvious regurgitation so let€™s explore!

1. We€™ve Seen This Movie Already!

And it€™s the film that this one is trying to prequel! In 1982€™s The Thing, the Americans learn the Norwegians discovered something in the ice, the camp burned to the ground, and everyone died. But not what, why or how. We then we see the exact same events play out with the Americans and all the blanks are filled in. So nothing can be done in the prequel that we haven€™t already seen and we know how it ends because Kurt Russell and co saw the Norwegian camp and saved the dog. At least a sequel would mean we don€™t know how it ends until we€™ve actually seen it. More importantly, a sequel can take off in a new direction, like Aliens did. Unfortunately, this prequel was dead in the water because we know what happened at the Norwegian camp and we know that a solitary dog-Thing escapes.

2. No Shared DNA

Even though a sequel or prequel needs to forge its own path, it still needs to share DNA, otherwise it€™s not part of the same genus. Gone is the dim, dingy, claustrophobic set; full of snaking, winding and cluttered corridors. Gone is the ramshackle feel to the base. Instead we get wide open spaces, bright lighting, and a cosy environment. Everything looks safe. And safe equals trust.

3. Trust€™s A Tough Thing To Come By These Days

Carpenter€™s version is a paranoid horror about trust. At the dawn of the 80s, America was still feeling the chill of the Cold War, Reagan was almost assassinated, and AIDS emerged. Suspicion was everywhere - none of these threats carried a visible marker - and The Thing reflected these concerns right down to MacReady telling Blair €œtrust€™s a tough thing to come by these days€. Even Macready himself wasn€™t exempt of suspicion. Enough doubt is raised to make us wonder if he himself is a Thing. His clothes are found shredded, he leads his partner astray from the safety of the group, and manages to survive impossibly cold temperatures. As a result, the viewer is as in the dark as the characters on screen yet in the prequel there is never any doubt that Kate Lloyd (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) is human and we know who€™s alien because they€˜re forever exposing themselves - which nullifies the theme of €œwho can you trust?€ Instead it has nothing to say and is *just* a monster movie. And it doesn€™t even make sense which leads me on to:

4. That€™s Illogical, Captain

In John Carpenter€™s film, the Thing just wants to hide. As MacReady says: €œThis thing doesn't want to show itself, it wants to hide inside an imitation. It'll fight if it has to, but it's vulnerable out in the open€ yet in the prequel it attacks at will. It even escapes only to return and kill some more even though MacReady correctly remarks €œit wants to freeze. It wants to go to sleep in the cold until the rescue team finds it€. Likewise, logic is absent in an earlier scene where a Thing is being flown to safety yet spurns this gilt edged opportunity that it€™s waited 100,000 years for and decides to attack for no reason, and causes the helicopter to crash, killing it in the process. The prequel also invents a rule that€™s non-existent in the soon-to-be sequel - the Thing cannot replicate inorganic material - and in a stunning display of contradiction, has Sam Carter (Joel Edgerton) become a Thing despite being fully clothed and without a drop of blood. Which is kinda hard for as MacReady says: €œit rips through your clothes when it takes you over. Windows found Bennings' torn and bloody clothes in the storage room after he was taken over. Earlier, Nauls found a pair of shredded and dirty long johns in the kitchen€œ. The prequel also tells us that the alien crash landed, tried to crawl to safety, and ended up freezing in the ice. Yet in the final minutes it runs back to its spaceship that is - gasp - fully operational. In which case it didn€™t need to disembark. It could have simply flown off and spare us this godawful atrocity of cinema. And perhaps most crazy of all, when the US team found journals and VHS footage from the Norwegian camp they were unable to decipher them because everything was in Norwegian yet in this prequel, there€™s Americans and English characters and all but one of the Norwegians spoke fluent English! That means the 1982 film should have finished after 35 minutes when they realised they€™ve hauled back a frozen shape-shifting killer creature from outer space.

5. All One And The Same

John Carpenter€™s film featured array of characters. Tough, weak, quiet, loud, hot headed, calm, hippy, strict, scientific, spiritual. They were also physically varied: bearded, clean shaven, bald, dark, blonde, grey, curly, fat, slim. The prequel, however features, a host of blonde, bearded Scandinavians, none of which are distinct from another. The one character that hinted at individuality was never expanded on. Griggs shaved with a cut throat razor and this speaks volumes about character yet he had barely 5 lines in the entire film and the only time we saw the razor was when he packed it away. Character and plot development was ignored in favour of a cheao plant for the 1982 film - and that leads onto my final point:

6. Missed Opportunities

In the Carpenter film, the sight of this man, in frozen suicide, is chilling. Iced blood hangs from a razor blade gash along his forearm. What must he have suffered to be reduced to that outcome? Did we see his options dwindle as he raced through the base? Was the creature breaking down the door and he had nowhere to go? Sadly, we will never know because the prequel failed to show us. Everything that made the 1982 film great - bleak atmosphere, empty corridors, shadows and suspicion - is bereft in the prequel. As with Aliens, Terminator 2 and Dawn of the Dead, all the filmmakers had to do, was build on what made the originals so great yet it eschewed all of that for illogic and contradiction. The Thing (2011) didn€™t fail because the audience wasn€™t interested in a sci-fi horror. It failed because it ignored what made the original so great and spurned the opportunity to extend that film€™s stunning legacy into a great lineage.

Contributor

Chiselled, charismatic, intellectual.....these are just a few words in my vocabulary. Loves watching films and believes the best thing about Christmas is watching old people slip on ice.