10 Amazing Stories Trapped In Mediocre Video Games
Guardians of the Galaxy has the most overlooked story of the generation.
Story in video games, even today, is rarely the top priority.
Unless you're operating within very, VERY specific circumstances, gameplay should always come first and foremost, because it doesn't matter how well-written your game is - if the player is not enjoying the gameplay between each beat, they'll put that game down in a heartbeat.
But if the game you've made is, well, just kinda average at best on a gameplay level, then that presents an opportunity for your game's writing to shine. In some cases, anyway. In others, people will only see the unexciting gameplay and write off the rest.
But when it all pulls off, it's really something special, with people forgiving the so-so gameplay because they've grown so attached to the story and characters the gameplay revolves around.
These games might not be winning any awards due to their gameplay, but excel at getting you to care about what the gameplay is centring around.
10. Brutal Legend
The fact that more people don't know about Brutal Legend feels like an anomaly in the universe. Pitch this game's setup and story to a friend and I'll bet you dollars to donuts they'll say that that sounds completely awesome.
The reason it isn't better remembered is that, gameplay-wise, it just couldn't settle on what kind of game it wanted to be. Its controls scream action-adventure hack-n-slash, but its actual gameplay beats say strategy game. And while finding a balance between those two isn't impossible, Brutal Legend never threaded that needle, and so the gameplay comes off like a confused mess.
Which is why no one remembers the game where Jack Black gets transported to a heavy metal dimension and has to fight demons with a giant battleaxe that's also a guitar, alongside a badass goth warrior woman.
One would think that would be harder to forget, but that's what happens when you don't focus your core gameplay loop better.
9. Rule Of Rose
One of the most fascinating games released on the PS2, Rule Of Rose is a cult classic for a reason.
Its story, which centres around a young woman named Jennifer as she seeks to unravel the mystery of her forgotten childhood while also trying to survive against a cult of psychotic little girls known as the Red Crayon Aristocrats, is hailed by hardcore survival horror fans as one of the best in the genre.
A shame, then, that the gameplay doesn't measure up to its contemporaries in that regard. Survival horror games had made backtracking a staple by the time Rule of Rose came out, but the extent to which this game falls back on it is ludicrous.
Add onto that shoddy controls and worse combat that makes said backtracking even worse, and then top it all off with a story that - while amazing - takes two or three playthroughs to fully appreciate, and it being forgotten even by most horror game fans becomes less shocking.
8. Telltale's Batman
Telltale has always been known for one single king of gameplay, basically since their inception. It works well for them when the story being told is, you know, good. Otherwise, there just isn't much to these games, hence why I guarantee you that there are more of these games than you think.
But when a Telltale game's story works, it really works, hence Telltale's Batman series.
Telltale's Batman revolves around the titular hero solving a mystery surrounding the background of his parents. Background which, it turns out, is tangled up in some stuff he would rather not think about his venerated parents being involved in.
As Bruce descends deeper and deeper into this mystery, it'll be up to the player to decide how much of his life he burns to the ground in pursuit of the truth.
Telltale's Batman gives a welcome spin on the tried and true Batman formula. Just a shame the game itself doesn't give any new spins to the Telltale formula.
7. Sonic And The Black Knight
How hilariously fitting that the first genuinely fantastic Sonic The Hedgehog story comes in by far one of its most mediocre titles.
Despite the sword combat not being implemented nearly as well as it could have been, Sonic And The Black Knight still managed to tell a compelling story that makes one wish that Sega HAD gotten the gameplay right so the game could have been successful enough to continue the short-lived Storybook series this takes place in.
The story takes place in Camelot, where King Arthur has completely lost his mind. In retaliation to her king's madness, young mage Merlina summons a hero from another world to aid her in taking down the tyrant. No points for guessing who she summons.
You wouldn't think a story where Sonic The Hedgehog fights King Arthur would have not only one of the best twist villains in gaming history but also contain themes of nihilism and existential dread at the inevitability of death, but there you go.
If only the gameplay was a bit more polished, this game would have been remembered more fondly.
6. Persona 3
The past several years have seen the Persona series finally getting its due in the mainstream JRPG market here in the west, prompting many to return to previous titles to get their fix until Atlus finally releases the next game.
Persona 3 is considered by many hardcore fans to be the best in the series, due to its characters and story - both of which are magnificent. However, going back, there's little arguing just how much the franchise has left this entry behind in terms of gameplay.
For one, the most obvious example, having the player only able to control one character in a turn-based RPG was such a bad idea that they undid it in the PSP remake of the game. Also, other elements of the game that later entries would iron out and expand upon are presented bare bones in this. And while the idea of reverse arcana does help in giving your dialogue choices some actual weight, they simply don't go far enough with it.
For all its flaws, though, the game endures thanks to its story, by far the darkest tale in a VERY dark franchise, and one of the best RPG casts ever made.
5. Guardians Of The Galaxy
Guardians Of The Galaxy received rave reviews from fans upon its release. While a decent game on its own, a lot of the praise - admittedly - stemmed from it not being the conga line of terrible ideas and live service nonsense that was the ever disappointing Avengers game.
But even after the hype died down, the story presented in Guardians shined through its so-so gameplay.
The gameplay is fine, but it doesn't do anything to stand out from other single-player adventure games from the past half-decade. Meanwhile, the story, and how it presents the titular heroes, is what really draws people in.
Fans of the movies were satisfied by how well they translated James Gunn's style of dialogue and character interaction, while fans of the comics were treated to more comic accurate designs that were changed from page to movie screen.
4. Assassin's Creed Revelations
The Assassin's Creed games spent a lot of time on Ezio and the world surrounding Assassin's Creed 2. But they finally wrapped the whole thing up in order to move on with the franchise with the underappreciated Revelations.
Unlike the previous games, this is the first Assassin's Creed to center on more than one assassin at once, in this case protagonists Altair and Ezio, both of whom are at this point VERY old men. The game focuses on the twilight years of both of them as they unravel a conspiracy that stretches not only through their own respective time periods, but well into the present day.
While the gameplay is the same sort of thing Assassin's Creed had been doing up until that point, with a few added bits and bobs like a tower defense game that I'm sure SOMEONE was asking for, but for the life of me I couldn't tell you who. The story really is the biggest selling point the game has, tying up loose plot threads that the previous games had left hanging.
3. Ultima 6
Ultima - the grandfather of all CRPGs - is known among old-school gamers both for its engaging classic RPG gameplay, as well as its capacity for telling great stories when EA wasn't royally screwing them over.
Ironically, however, one of the series' best entries comes in its most disappointing game from a gameplay position, that being Ultima 6: The False Prophet.
While not bad by any means, the game's UI is frustratingly clunky, making even simple acts such as opening a box and taking out a single item far more complicated than it needed to be.
The story of Ultima 6 is its true selling point, being a story all about the unintended consequences of seemingly noble acts. The Avatar, your character, spent all of Ultima 4 and 5 trying to do the right thing and be a good person. But one act in 4, stealing a book known as the Tome Of Infinite Wisdom, ends up causing a holy war between the nation of Britannia and the book's rightful owners - the Gargoyles. A war that is, on no uncertain terms, YOUR fault.
Navigating this messy situation was some of the most fascinating writing the series had ever seen.
2. Bioshock 2
When Bioshock first hit shelves, it more or less changed the entire game. Its direct sequel, Bioshock 2, on the other hand, was either panned or just straight up overlooked by the very fanbase that demanded its existence in the first place.
This is a real shame because - while it doesn't really change anything fundamental about the gameplay, the story of Bioshock 2 is pretty close in quality to that of the original. It's sure as hell better than Infinite's story if nothing else.
Bioshock 2's story centers around a Big Daddy instead of some poor dumb squishy human, named Delta, as he navigates the still operational Rapture to rescue his charge from the enigmatic Sofia Lamb. While the original Bioshock focused on the flaws of a society built on Randian Objectivism, this one does the same with a Rapture that is now run on the philosophy of collectivism. An interesting twist to the thematic current of the original that gives Bioshock 2 a much-needed edge.
1. Spec-Ops: The Line
Whenever someone talks about Spec-Ops: The Line, the primary topic of the conversation will ALWAYS be the story, because there really isn't anything to the gameplay to make it worth talking about.
Whereas the gameplay is some of the most generic, bare minimum cover-based 3rd person team shooting of its time - competently built, but nothing new to it at all - the story is one of the greatest in the history of the medium.
The city of Dubai has been hit with a freak sandstorm, with the populace left struggling for survival, and a team of soldiers have been sent in to retrieve an American commander who got caught up in it. The leader is led by one Captain Martin Walker, who - as the mission becomes more and more perilous and he is forced to cross more and more moral lines as a result - slowly loses his grip on reality.
Spec-Ops: The Line is one of the darkest, bleakest looks at what was the dominant genre of the gaming industry. Which makes how rote the gameplay is just another thematic element to the story. This game does not want you to have fun at all.
Spec-Ops: The Line isn't just a great story trapped in a mediocre game. The mediocre game is the POINT of the story.