10 Amazing Video Game Characters That Were Killed Off Way Too Quickly

The best characters in video games are usually the first ones to die.

far cry 3 vaas
Ubisoft

Death happens to the best of us, and in the case of video games to the best of our favorite characters.

It's not uncommon for an important and/or beloved video game character to die. It can be a truly disheartening moment, but at least you can ease your pain by knowing their death serves a purpose in the overall story.

Unless they die too quickly.

Unfortunately, some truly amazing video game characters are taken from us before the full potential of their greatness is revealed. You only get enough time to fall in love with them and think of all the awesome things they might be up to in the future, before some unfortunate accident or other takes them out of the game forever.

These kinds of deaths feel like a waste of potential that could've made the story a lot more interesting, but it was cut too short.

Whether it's a charismatic villain who doesn't get their time to shine, a hidden talent that stays hidden forever, or a beloved companion you just wish you had more screen time with, the following characters have met their demise far too quickly.

MAJOR SPOILERS FOLLOW.

10. Carley - The Walking Dead

Walking Dead Doug Carley
Telltale

Carley from the Telltale's first Walking Dead season is remembered for two things: being one of two survivors that Lee can get killed early in the story, and being one of the two survivors that can get unexpectedly killed by Lilly two acts later.

The fact of the matter is that Carley is at best an episodic character that's bound to die for nothing but cheap shock value. And this is a great lost opportunity on Telltale's part, as Carley's potential exceeds far between being a bullet sponge.

As you get to learn from her brief interactions with Lee, Carley used to be a news reporter before the zombie outbreak, and because of this she knows Lee murdered his wife and her lover.

Her knowledge of Lee's past, combined with her assertive personality, would've worked great for the group dynamic in later episodes, as she could use Lee's secret to blackmail him or turn everyone against him. This would've been even more interesting if Telltale took her teased romance with Lee into consideration and developed it in later episodes.

Instead, Carley is used as nothing more than a prop to make people gasp at her disappointing death.


9. Moenbryda Wilfsunnwyn - Final Fantasy XIV

final fantasy xiv Moenbryda Wilfsunnwyn
Square-Enix

Moenbryda Wilfsunnwyn from Final Fantasy XIV is one of the Scions of the Seventh Dawn, the game's order of legendary heroes.

Her title along with her bulky physique of a Roegadyn are already enough to make her a certified badass, but on top of that, she has another interesting quality in that she shares a childhood bond with another fan favorite Scion—Urianger.

Unfortunately, that part of her character is never explored too deeply, as Moenbryda is one of the first Scions to die in A Realm Reborn.

Moenbryda goes out in an act of noble sacrifice, protecting your character, while you create the blade necessary for stopping the main bad guy, Nabriales. Her death is dignified and leaves a real impact on the game's narrative, but at the same time you can't help but think that when Moenbryda dies, the game squanders a whole rabbit hole of fascinating lore.

Her close relationship with Urianger that dates all the way back to when they were children could've shed some much-needed light on the backstory of one of the most enigmatic Scions, but instead, everyone is left wondering what his friendship with Moenbryda looked like.

Seriously, couldn't someone with a less interesting backstory take that fall for you?


8. Jackie - Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077 - Jackie Welles
CD Projekt

Jackie's death in Cyberpunk 2077 isn't anything surprising. The fact he wasn't going to make it was obvious even before Cyberpunk was released thanks to the game's trailer that basically spoiled his demise.

Still, a lot of people are upset about Jackie's death, not because they didn't expect it but because it feels rushed.

While Jackie's death makes sense story-wise, being the final nail in the coffin of V's past, the fans of the game think it happens too fast to properly establish his bond with their character.

Aside from two missions and a quick montage showcasing V and Jackie getting up to no good, you don't really get to learn more about his character or just how much he means to their partner-in-crime.

Because of this, his sudden death doesn't hit you as hard as it could, and it takes away from his overall role in the story.

From the little glimpse into who he is that you get, Jackie seems like a fascinating figure and a great friend, but there's no way for you to truly verify it before he is taken away from you, which is why most people simply forget about him and don't really care about his death after the fact.


7. Lenny - Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 Lenny Arthur
Rockstar Games

Pretty much every death in Red Dead Redemption 2 happens suddenly and hits you right in the feels with the strength of a thousand emotional trucks.

Sean, Kieran, and Hosea - all of these characters' deaths seem to happen too soon, but at the very least they manage to serve their purpose in the story and have their own character arcs.

This is what separates them from Lenny.

Though Lenny's death happens much later than that of any of the above, it still feels like his character has been severely underutilized, and it's taken away from you in the most undeserved fashion possible. The guy doesn't even get to die in a cutscene, for Pete's sake!

You only get to spend about ten minutes with him throughout the entire game, and he barely ever accompanies you on missions, which is a shame, as in the short time you share with him, he seems to be a fun character that could serve a larger role within the gang.

He's charismatic, quick-witted, and alongside Dutch, he is one of the best-educated men in the camp. It feels like he really should've had more opportunities to use his brain.

Instead of getting his brains blown out by a random gunman in Saint Denis!


6. Benny - Fallout: New Vegas

Benny Fallout
Bethesda Softworks

Benny is one of the most iconic characters from Fallout: New Vegas, even though you kill him relatively early in the story.

His fame within the game's community isn't just a matter of his legendary appearance in the game's intro (although it definitely helps), but also because he is an intriguing character with an equally intriguing master plan that you never get to see bear fruit.

Let's be honest, Benny is basically the whole reason behind the plot of Fallout: New Vegas. Not because he shoots you in the head, but because he's the one who crossed Mr. House and took the platinum chip.

Before you begin your hunt for him, Benny orchestrated a multi-layered plan to take New Vegas from House that was to culminate with him using the platinum chip to take over House's robot army.

You, of course, kill Benny before he can succeed, and then you get the option to finish what he started. However, you have to admit, the concept of working together with a guy who managed to outsmart all of your opponents or going toe-to-toe with him in a fight for New Vegas sounds way more interesting.

Well, at least you can settle for the second-best thing—eating his corpse.


5. Shinjiro Aragaki - Persona 3

persona 3 Shinjiro Aragaki
Atlus

Shinjiro Aragaki is a recurring character from the Persona series, best known for his brief and quite disappointing appearance in Persona 3.

Now, don't get it twisted. Shinjiro is a great character with a deep personality and a pretty fascinating backstory. It's just that you don't get to see a lot of him because the writers kill him off right after he joins your party, and they do it in the most forced and ungratifying way possible.

Shinjiro dies, sacrificing himself for Ken, who believes Shinjiro to be responsible for his mother's death. His death is certainly noble, but many players thought it felt flat and ruined a promising character arc because everything about it is completely illogical.

First off, the fact the attack that takes Shinjiro's life catches the SEES members by surprise feels forced, as they are always shown checking dates and preparing for when another strike occurs. Secondly, the game fails to acknowledge your party's healer during Shinjiro's death, at least by explaining why she can't mend his wounds.

Overall, it feels like the game forces this situation on you, which really takes away from the suspense of his sacrifice and makes you feel like the character died too quickly.


4. All Of Kiryu's Crew - Yakuza

Yakuza Kiwami Nishiki Kills Matsuhige
Sega

The first Yakuza game starts with Kiryu walking out of prison and reuniting with his old crew... Only to see them get killed one by one.

Yes, the series debut piles up so many corpses that it would probably struggle to fit all of them within the kill count of any two of its sequels!

It makes sense, given that Yakuza's creators didn't really know how well their first game would do, and they probably preferred to tell a more concise story rather than save up any characters for a sequel that could never come to pass.

Still, due to this decision, we lost a ton of seriously interesting characters with such deep ties to Kiryu's past that not even Goro can compare.

From his partners in the Yakuza to his childhood best friend and even Kiryu's adopted father, everyone important in Kiryu's life is gone by the end of the game, and because of this, none of the sequels got to expand on the unique relationships he had with all of them, other than in flashbacks and prequels.

Seriously, maybe only Yakuza 0 can compare in terms of how many deaths happened in the original!


3. Vaas - Far Cry 3

far cry 3 vaas
Ubisoft

Anyone who's played Far Cry 3 can agree that the best part of the game is Vaas, hand down.

The amount of promotional material about him that Ubisoft put out before Far Cry 3's release did not exaggerate about how great of a character he is, although they did fail to mention how small of a role he actually has in the game.

The crazed pirate appears in only the first part of the story, and while he dominates every scene he is in, he actually has less screen time than Far Cry 3's supposed main villain, Hoyt Volker.

For this reason, many of the game's fans consider Vaas' early death to be a missed opportunity. The story becomes far less engaging after he's gone, and none of the characters that appear afterward can hold a candle to the sheer showmanship the man displays.

Let's be real: there's a reason why Vaas is still being quoted to this day while people barely even remember Hoyt existed.

You don't see the latter telling you the definition of insanity while threatening to drop you off a cliff, do you?


2. Mirabelle Ervine - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

Mirabelle Ervine Skyrim
Bethesda

The College of Winterhold questline is considered one of the most boring and underwhelming faction side quests in Skyrim.

You don't actually spend any time at the college to study magic, and the jump between you being a fresh-off-the-presses apprentice and becoming the Archmage is so sudden that some people download mods specifically to make Tolfdir the new Archmage instead.

The rushed story of the college and its wasted potential is perhaps best illustrated by the death of its most underrated character—Mirabelle Ervine.

The right hand of Archmage, Mirabelle, is the one who actually runs the college instead of Savos. Mirabelle is the most competent person in the guild, and her matter-of-fact attitude makes the college feel like an actual institution instead of a ragtag collective of wacky mages.

Mirabelle dies halfway through the college questline (off-screen, to add insult in injury) and with her, the possibility of the college being more than a half-empty building.

If she were to remain the administrator, she would've been the perfect character to act as the college administrator and perhaps help you expand it like you can the Thieves Guild.

Instead, you get to be the archmage of a frozen ruin with three enrolled students.


1. Alfira - Baldur's Gate III

alfira baldurs gate 3
Larian Studios

Your team in Baldur's Gate 3 misses two very apparent members of every average DnD party: a short guy with a giant axe, and a bard.

Now, out of the two, the lack of a bard is the more frequently voiced complaint within the game's community, and that's because Larian has severely underused the perfect candidate for the role—Alfira.

Alfira is the tiefling bard that hides in the Druids' Grove with her fellow Avernus refugees in Act 1. The girl can teach you how to play instruments if you don't know how, and if you play as the Dark Urge... she will be one of the most gruesome victims of your murderous cravings.

Alfira's murder happens only a night after you agree to let her join your adventuring party. Her death is meant to be a shocking moment that reveals your character's unpredictable nature, but, in reality, it mostly makes people mad that they got cheated out of a genuinely promising companion.

The recent update actually made Alfira a playable party member after she joined you, but the girl is still killed off shortly after, so really, there's still a big Alfira-shaped hole in the roster of your in-game companions.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Games
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Video games enthusiast with a love for bizarre facts about his favorite titles. Really into old-school strategies and RPGs of all shapes and sizes.