10 Amazing Video Games You Should Only Play Once
These games say all they need to in a single playthrough.
Though video game publishers are absolutely obsessed with stuffing as much "replay value" into their games as humanly possible - whatever that really means - some games just don't ever need to be played a second time.
Some video games say all they need to say on that initial, blissfully unaware playthrough, and whether due to their singular emotional impact, gruellingly bleak tone, or straight-forward gameplay that simply doesn't warrant further exploration, these 10 games are all best played just once.
Some experiences are better off remembered as just that - experiences you felt once in your life and continue to have fond memories of, because no repeat playthrough will ever be able to replicate the purity of playing it for the first time.
That's not to say that many haven't played these games more than once, but considering their grand impact on both the medium and players in general, there is very little extra to be gleaned from going back to them.
Needless to say, few who've played these 10 games will have ever forgotten the experience, even years or in some cases decades later...
10. Portal
Valve's Portal is one of the most iconic and influential puzzle games of the last 20 years - a mind-bogglingly creative physics-based puzzle-platformer that also touts a singularly eccentric, infectiously charming sense of humour.
As enormously satisfying as the moment-to-moment gameplay is, though, there's not a huge incentive to replay Portal because, this being a puzzle game and all, the fun is largely centered around solving problems with your portal gun.
Those euphoric lightbulb moments of figuring out a tricky test chamber simply can't be replicated upon repeat playthroughs when you're already equipped with the knowledge to progress, especially as the solutions themselves tend to be incredibly memorable and may not be forgotten by players for years and years.
Unless you're a speed-runner determined to bend the game over your knee and dismantle it as fast as possible, there's very little incentive to play it more than once, as masterful as it is.
9. Brothers: A Tale Of Two Sons
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is a game that leaves such a profound emotional impact on an initial playthrough that it's unlikely many will feel the need to ever play it again.
Without giving too much away, the indie adventure game focuses on two brothers setting off on a treacherous quest to find a cure for their father's illness, with each brother being controlled by a separate thumbstick.
It's not only an ingenious, fiercely original conceit but also one which has a stunning emotional payoff later in the story.
What follows forges such a potent, unforgettable memory that few will feel much of a desire to re-experience it.
It'll never hit the same way a second time, and considering some of the more tragic events that occur, you couldn't really be blamed for not wanting to go through it all again.
Just thinking about it is enough, honestly.
8. The Last Of Us Part II
The Last of Us Part II may be one of the most expertly crafted video games ever made, but it's also one of the most gruelling and emotionally draining.
Across its beefy 20-plus-hour story - more than double that of the original game - Part II tells an almost relentlessly bleak, sprawling tale of revenge that finds hope in only small, fading pockets.
For the most part this is a game concerned with the uglier side of humanity: murder, prejudice, fanaticism, and the soul-stripping inevitability of living through a global apocalypse.
The violence in the game isn't cool or fun despite how brilliantly engineered it is - Neil Druckmann and co. make you feel every kill you commit, enough to make you question not only Ellie as a character but your own complicity as a player.
By the time the game is over, there's profound relief that such an exhausting experience is finally done with. And so, nobody could be blamed for having no desire to put themselves through such a visceral emotional endurance trial ever again.
7. Life Is Strange
It's fair to say that most episodic video games don't offer massive amounts of replay value - even when there's a branching story to experience, the general limitations of the gameplay make replays a bit of a chore. You're better off just checking out the alternate pathways on YouTube, really.
This is certainly true of Life is Strange, a tremendously affecting fantasy-drama and easily one of the best episodic story-driven games ever made.
Though there are choices for the player to make, few of them have much of an impact on the overall trajectory of the story and merely alter character relationships.
Yet Life is Strange strikes a strong enough chord the first time that one playthrough is most certainly enough.
You'll likely be unable to shake its ending - whichever one you end up with - for a good while, and the gameplay offers very little reason to come back for more.
6. God Of War
A possibly controversial choice, but the original 2005 God of War is a shining example of an astoundingly well-made game that's incredibly enjoyable while you're playing it, and yet doesn't give players much of a reason to consider a second go-around.
The story is incredibly simple and lacks any sort of nuance which might tease players back, but the real reason God of War is a one-and-done? The combat.
God of War's combat is tremendously fun, but it's also incredibly shallow - franchise creator David Jaffe even admitted it himself - such that the game is best regarded as a bombastic popcorn action flick that you savour while playing and then simply cherish as a fond memory.
The same largely applies to most of the sequels, save for 2018's quasi-sequel/soft-reboot, which introduced a more substantial, character-driven story and massively refined the gameplay.
By comparison, the earlier God of War games feel completely surface-level, which is fine, because sometimes a button-bashing, gory-as-hell action game is just what the appetite craves.
5. What Remains Of Edith Finch
What Remains of Edith Finch is a "walking simulator" by any definition, but also one of the most imaginative and visually stunning ever made.
While it'd be criminal to give away any of the narrative particulars, the title character's journey is so singular and unforgettable, juxtaposed against totally rudimentary traversal gameplay, that there's very little replay value here at all.
The payoffs to the various vignettes that comprise the short two-to-three hour playtime will stick with players for years after the fact, and considering some of the trickier, bolder subjects it confronts, it's tough to imagine many wishing to dive back in for another go.
Many complained that the game's $20 launch price was too steep for such a short experience that doesn't much benefit from repeat playthroughs, but the profundity of the short playtime more than compensates.
4. Death Stranding
Death Stranding may ultimately have been one of the most divisive AAA releases of the last few years, but for those who vibed with it, Hideo Kojima's unconventional action game offers a mesmerising experience like nothing else out there.
Jokingly referred to by many as the world's most elaborate walking simulator, Death Stranding pushes its action to the background for the most part, focusing instead on the deceptively simple act of traversing a post-apocalyptic United States and delivering packages.
The result is an intoxicating puzzle game where the challenge lies in navigating increasingly tricky terrain without damaging or outright losing your cargo.
Without a major focus on combat, it would've been reasonable to assume that the core campaign would be relatively short, but lo and behold, Death Stranding ended up being by far Kojima's longest game to date, with even a critical path playthrough lasting upwards of 30 hours.
Even the game's biggest fans likely won't disagree that it's a little long in the tooth overall, that it could've lost not a sliver of its emotional impact by cutting down on the repetitive transport missions and clocking in at, say, a more reasonable 20-25 hours.
As such, when there are so many new games out there waiting to be played, it's tough to prioritise replaying one that doesn't have a massive amount of respect for the player's time, even though it offers such a uniquely compelling gameplay loop.
3. Journey
Journey is an experiential video game like no other - a masterfully subtle, visually sumptuous adventure that's light on plot but heavy on atmosphere and beauty.
With a play-time of around two hours, Journey can be played alongside your morning coffee and doesn't beg to last a second longer. It's perhaps the example of a game that doesn't outstay its welcome while proving utterly transfixing for its entirety.
As eye-wateringly gorgeous as it is, Journey is also aggressively simple from a gameplay-perspective - it's basically a fancy walking sim - while the story, though begging deeper speculation, doesn't offer a ton for players to dig into in repeat playthroughs.
And yet, Journey is such a landmark title for the genre and indie games in general that, almost an entire decade later, it's still remembered vividly by those who played it only once on launch.
2. Silent Hill 2
Silent Hill 2 is the feel-bad game to end all feel-bad games - a cosmic-scale bummer you won't want to put yourself through more than once, nor should you.
And aptly, a single run through Konami's horror masterpiece is more than enough to leave a long-lasting, potentially even lifelong impression.
While many horror games lose their power on a second playthrough due to their reliance on previously-experienced jump-scares, Silent Hill 2 is no typical entry into the genre.
The game's thorny themes of guilt, depression, and so on have been relentlessly analysed by fans over the last 20 years, yet for the majority of people its oppressively heavy, downcast tone is so thick and invasive that it's difficult to ponder picking up the controller for another go.
It is a game that permanently marks anyone who plays it, and so there's really no need to dive back in. You'll be left thinking about James Sunderland's hellish odyssey and the game's wider message about humanity for years, even decades to come.
1. To The Moon
If you haven't played To the Moon yet, go do that now. Also, where have you been the last 10 years?
This adventure game's familiar retro aesthetic belies the fact that it's one of the most emotionally intelligent and heartbreaking video games of all time.
It's absolutely game a best played without much prior knowledge of its plot - which centers around themes of memory and mortality - and its narrative is so tremendously affecting as to become an emotional scab that players likely won't wish to pick at with a second playthrough.
More to the point, the writing is strong enough to compensate for the game's admittedly ropey gameplay - To the Moon was created by an incredibly small team using the RPG Maker XP engine, and to that end its central mechanics are both incredibly basic and bug-riddled.
Here the gameplay is a means to an end - a necessity to experience the story but not something you'll likely wish to do again.
And given that To the Moon's emotionally shattering story will sear itself in your memories forever more, there's really little to be gained from revisiting it.