10 Ambitious Video Game Gimmicks That BOMBED

Ambitious failures at their most disastrous.

Power Glove Nintendo
Nintendo

No entertainment medium moves as fast as video games, which are forever propelled forward by lightning-fast technical innovation and, yes, those gimmicks the industry attempts to force on us all for better or worse.

But to be clear, gimmicks aren't always a bad thing: the Wii's motion controls were a huge success and helped open up gaming to a far wider audience, while despite earlier failures VR has carved out a solid niche for itself in recent years.

And though the world at large is still wrapping their heads around what ray tracing is, it's so, so much more than a mere buzzword.

Hell, even some of the worst gimmicks are the furthest things from bombs - loot boxes continue to drain billions out of people's wallets every year, for example.

But what about those gaming gimmicks which, despite their oft-impressive technology and clear desire to innovate, flopped hard?

Whether a result of poorly designed hardware, bad timing, or a simple failure to shift units, these gaming gimmicks all died a most undignified death...

10. Tony Hawk: Ride Skateboard

Tony Hawk Ride
Activision

Tony Hawk: Ride was released in 2009 as a response to the hit skateboarding series' declining popularity, and in an attempt to capture the same market that gladly parted with heaps of cash for plastic Guitar Hero peripherals, bundled the game with a skateboard controller.

As far as daft gimmicks go it wasn't an inherently bad one, albeit executed with so little finesse as to suggest it was a desperate rush-job effort to revitalise the franchise.

Critics and players alike near-universally trashed Ride for its frustratingly fiddly and unresponsive peripheral, while the accompanying software simply didn't make for a fun or interesting game.

Executing even basic moves felt like a chore, and so there was nothing remotely intuitive about it. Activision's fatal misunderstanding, really, was thinking that the millions of people who played the Tony Hawk's series were all actually interested in doing it for real.

There's something to be said for foregoing the skinned knees and instead pulling off a 1080 spin from the comfort of your couch.

Instead, Tony Hawk: Ride wanted to charge players $120 for the "pleasure" of looking like an awkward goof in their living room - and not even delivering a basically fun time.

Despite the game bombing both with critics and at retail, Activision re-used Ride's peripheral one more time in their follow-up, Tony Hawk: Shred, which in an even greater feat of desperation introduced a snowboarding mode.

To add insult to injury, apathy was so high at this point that few critics even bothered to review it.


9. 3D Gaming

Killzone 3
Guerrilla Games

The 3D media boom period kicked off roughly a decade ago largely thanks to the stonking box office success of James Cameron's Avatar, convincing many hardware manufacturers that 3D was the next big thing and absolutely here to stay.

And so, 3D TVs became the new technological hotness for a brief time, despite the obvious issues - their price, the discomfort and expense of the 3D glasses, the lack of available content, and the fact that most movies that supported 3D exploited it for cheap gimmickry over sustained immersion.

In the gaming sphere uptake was even worse, with only around 100 major games officially supporting stereoscopic 3D, and many early adopters complaining that 3D actually made the games look less visually appealing, with more frantic games even inducing headaches in some players.

Though Nintendo did admittedly pull off an impressive coup with their glasses-free Nintendo 3DS, for every player who actually used the 3D mode, there was one who turned it off and never used it again.

As phenomenally as the 3DS family of handhelds have sold, the 3D was more a whatever accompaniment than a selling point, and tellingly, the tech was nowhere to be seen on the Nintendo Switch.

3D may well be dead, but at least its most obvious successor - virtual reality - is faring much better.


8. Scratch & Sniff Discs

Gran Turismo 2
Polyphony Digital

Smell is easily the most neglected sensory element in entertainment for obvious reasons, but for a brief glint at the turn of the millennium a cursory attempt was made to take advantage of players' olfactory faculties.

Believe it or not, Gran Turismo 2 was released with a "scratch and sniff" game disc - that is to say, players who rubbed the second game disc would be presented with the aroma marketed as "racing pit smell," approximating a combination of gasoline and burnt rubber, because why the hell not?

The next year, EA also decided to take a crack with the release of FIFA 2001, which offered players a "football pitch" smell.

The short-lived gimmick hit a brick wall after that, though, and no subsequent video games were released with the oddball flourish.

Hilariously, though, players who dusted off their copies of the games recently have discovered the smell to impressively endure 20 years on.


7. Kinect 2.0

Xbox One Kinect
Microsoft

Microsoft launched the Kinect motion sensor camera in 2010 for the Xbox 360, hoping to compete with the Wii's enormously successful motion controls and capture a sizable slice of the market.

Kinect was a huge seller upon launch, shifting 10 million units within months of its release, and was moderately well-received by critics despite the frustrating lack of compelling software released for the platform.

For the 2013 release of the Xbox One, Microsoft came up with a next-generation Kinect, typically nicknamed Kinect 2.0, which would feature more complex and nuanced motion-sensing tech.

The Kinect 2.0's trouble began when Microsoft announced that it would need to be plugged into the Xbox One at all times, inviting concerns about privacy and the simple fact that not everyone wants a camera mounted in their living room while playing.

Microsoft eventually backtracked due to the huge public outcry during an already gaffe-filled Xbox One launch, and though Kinect 2.0 was still bundled with the console on release, it wasn't too long before they were quietly phased out, with later Xbox One models ditching the Kinect port entirely.

With little public interest in the new Kinect or its meager smattering of software, it was discontinued in late 2017. As impressive as the tech undeniably was, Microsoft simply failed to capture the public's imagination with it.


6. PSVR Aim Controller

PSVR Aim Controller
Sony

Though PlayStation VR has been a modest success for Sony, it's disappointing just how much of a bust the headset's accompanying Aim Controller has been.

The controller, designed for shooting games and giving players the tactile sensation of handling an actual gun, was launched with PSVR exclusive shooter Farpoint back in 2017, yet despite its impressively tactile quality, has been scarcely supported in the three-plus years since.

To date there are barely two-dozen games with Aim functionality, maybe half of which are actually worth playing, which for a peripheral that still retails for around £54.99 isn't really good enough.

Consistently limited stocks have kept the controller's price high ever since release, and though Sony likely didn't lose money on the Aim - after all, it's basically just a fancy plastic caddy for a Move controller with a trigger - it also didn't take off quite like they or consumers expected.

Given how much plastic tat most of us already have clogging up our wardrobes, it's tough to argue for the Aim's worth, despite how well it actually works in games like Farpoint, Dick Wilde, and Firewall Zero Hour.

With the recent announcement that the Aim is now supported by Dreams, however, many owners will doubtless by dusting them off for the first time in months if not years.


5. "Mixed Media" Video Games

quantum break
Remedy

With every new IP agonisingly desperate to become a Universe in its own right, it's little surprise that an increasing number of games are putting the cart before the horse and attempting to establish themselves as mixed media projects right out of the gate.

Surely the most infamous example of this is Remedy's sci-fi actioner Quantum Break, which rather than release a few comic books or maybe a couple of YouTube shorts, included a glossy, hours-long companion TV show right out of the box.

It was certainly a bold idea, especially as the live-action actors, such as Shawn Ashmore, Aidan Gillen, Lance Reddick, and Dominic Monaghan, were also the stars of the game itself, and players would be able to make decisions which altered the course of the both the live-action and game segments.

But despite the live-action component being surprisingly substantial and boasting strong production values, it ultimately failed to deliver anything more than generic sci-fi drama hokum, and so simply left players itching to get their hands back on the controller.

It didn't help that players who wanted to watch the videos from their system rather than stream them faced a hefty 75.61GB download, which back in 2016 was quite inconceivable.

In the end Quantum Break received mixed reviews and failed to sell enough to launch the media empire Microsoft was clearly banking on.

An ambitious effort, but it's usually best to just focus on putting out a great game rather than sinking funds into excruciatingly expensive live-action video production.


4. UDraw GameTablet

Udraw Thq
THQ

Pour a cold one out for the uDraw GameTablet, a doomed but actually rather competent piece of hardware developed by the late THQ, the commercial failure of which led to the company going bankrupt the very next year, and former president Jason Rubin later calling it a "massive mistake." Oof.

The uDraw was a graphics tablet initially launched for the Wii and later the PS3 and Xbox 360, allowing players to draw creations on-screen and even use the stylus as a "controller" in certain bespoke video games.

Reviews for the hardware were rock solid, but the prohibitive $70 launch price turned many potential customers off, not to ignore the lack of compelling software available for it.

The Wii version sold acceptably, but the PS3 and Xbox 360 launches were disastrous, leaving THQ with 1.4 million unsold units, leading to an estimated $100 million in losses and setting the company's collapse in motion.


3. Biofeedback Video Games

Wii Vitality Sensor
Nintendo

In 2009, Nintendo infamously announced the Wii Vitality Sensor, a peripheral which would track the player's pulse within games, yet without showing off any accompanying software, players weren't quite sure what its utility would be.

Despite planning to show the device off with games at E3 2010, the Vitality Sensor skipped the show and was quietly cancelled, with the late Satoru Iwata confirming in 2013 that they couldn't get to the product to function with more than 90% of players.

In 2012, light-gun game Cabela's Dangerous Hunts 2013 introduced a new "Top Shot Fearmaster" gun peripheral which would measure the player's heartrate and adjust gameplay accordingly.

If your pulse ran too high, the screen would blur until you calmed down, and camera sensors on the gun could even detect if you were shaking and lessen your accuracy as a result.

The game ultimately received mixed reviews, coming and going without much fanfare at all.

Similarly in 2015, indie horror game Nevermind offered up its own take by allowing players to strap on a heartrate monitor, and in the event their pulse ran too high, the game would begin to make its puzzles more challenging.

Though the game itself received broadly positive reviews, the supported heart monitor hardware was expensive, and even though players could alternately use a webcam to measure registered anxiety in their face, it ultimately felt like a bit of a half-measure.

As fascinating as it is to see forward-thinking game creators pushing the boundaries of the medium, biofeedback gaming isn't ever going to catch on with the mainstream.

Though we all have half-decent heartrate sensors on our phones these days, it's a market unlikely to ever grow substantially beyond the mobile sphere.


2. Toys-To-Life

Starlink game
Ubisoft

The toys-to-life genre is an undeniably fascinating one, typically requiring players to purchase real, tangible toys which are then able to interface with the software by attaching to existing hardware.

But toys-to-life is also an unapologetic fad which enjoyed a surge of popularity in the early-to-mid 2010s thanks to series like Skylanders, Disney Infinity, and Lego Dimensions.

And while there's no denying the incredible commercial success these games have had - Skylanders made $3 billion in a mere four-year period - it's also fair to say that toys-to-life has largely gone the way of Guitar Hero and thoroughly cratered.

As hardware sales dwindled, the aforementioned franchises all packed up operations, while Nintendo's Amiibo is currently clinging to life support, and 2018's Starlink: Battle for Atlas was effectively dead within six months of its release.

As a fusion of toy and video game, it's certainly an inspired idea evidently dreamt up by a galaxy-brained executive somewhere, but not one which offered up enough substance to be anything more than a craze which proved phenomenally successful for a brief time.


1. The Nintendo Power Glove

Power Glove
Nintendo

At the top of the pile of defunct gaming gimmicks, though, is the Nintendo Power Glove, an infamous virtual reality peripheral released for the NES in 1989.

In theory, it allowed players to control NES games using only the glove, while its array of programmable functions would let players register their hand and finger inputs in real-time.

In reality, the Power Glove was a fiddly, unresponsive hunk of junk, and only two games were ever actually released for it specifically.

Despite being largely panned by the press, it sold close to 1 million units, possibly thanks to it featuring prominently in the Nintendo-backed 1989 film The Wizard, where it was infamously referred to as "so bad."

The Power Glove was ultimately discontinued the year after it hit stores, and today remains the textbook example of botched gimmick hardware which failed to meet expectations.


In this post: 
quantum break
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.