10 Awesome Video Games That Succeeded Against The Odds
By 2021, when the next generation of consoles will likely release, we'll look back fondly on the past two decades, noting the video games that won our hearts and cramped our fingers. Personally, I've always relished in the charm of a surprise hit - a game that no one bet on but would still go on to make all of the money (and still be a great game). I've listed 10 such games that stand out in regards to their ratio of success and expectation. If you think I've missed anything important, be sure to write your pitch in the comments. Let's begin.
10. Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
Sure, the movie didn't succeed against the odds, but the game was a steal for 10 bucks. Based on the now-classic graphic novels of the same name, this game was a pixelated brawler, harkening back to the glory days of arcades and SNES. You could have four heroes onscreen at anytime, making this a chaotic (and gloriously) good time to have. How did it succeed against the odds? You have to remember that this was a licensed game, which means that no one had much hope for it. Licensed games are notorious for being too reliant on the movie or established media they're based on, so budgets and creative vision rarely sync up for the people who make and deliver these games. Add to that the fact that the movie completely bombed (sadly), and it's a wonder this game still managed to gain a huge fanbase.
9. Tomb Raider
If you told me I'd ever like a Tomb Raider game again, I would have...well I would have just disagreed because I'm not that dramatic, but it would have been a harsh disagreement. Granted, Tomb Raider: Underworld proved that Lara Croft still had a zealous fanbase, but it was hard to picture one of these games ever achieving mainstream success. Until they just decided to reboot the whole thing, which is actually a great method for tired video game franchises (sometimes). The team behind this game decided to take a page from the success of the Uncharted franchise by focusing on narrative and atmosphere over more classic staples of the franchise (of which there are still many). How did it succeed against the odds? Tomb Raider was gritty, bloody, and gorgeous. The environments were nicely rendered, and the combat was on par with the best third-person shooters out there. The game won a lot of critical praise and even managed to set franchise records, turning 13 year-olds all over the world into fans of Lara Croft-er-uh I mean Tomb Raider.
8. Call Of Duty: Black Ops
I lost interest in the Call of Duty franchise after the second Modern Warfare, so no one was less excited about Black Ops than me. In fact, I recall a lot of ill will being directed toward Treyarch. You may recall the turmoil going on at Infinity Ward when the men in charge were basically fired, and people were less optimistic about another "World at War" offering by Treyarch. Simply put, we were expecting the demise of the franchise that had begun to wear out its welcome. How did it succeed against the odds? While Modern Warfare and Modern Warfare 2 managed to bring in around $700 million each, Black Ops made over a billion, completely shattering expectations. And for good reason. Black Ops managed to present new multiplayer modes and a unique Cold War setting that helped keep the Call of Duty franchise from slipping into a repetitive bore (at least for a little while). Oh and it gave us zombies again.
7. Batman: Arkham Asylum
It's hard to believe that there was a time (only 4 years ago) when Batman had not yet translated well into video games. Previous Batman games had never really grasped the character, and by 2009, no one had even tried to make a fully-formed Batman game in this new generation. Rocksteady aimed to remedy this by coming out with their own take on Batman, focusing on the criminal wonderland of Arkham Asylum. How did it succeed against the odds? Rocksteady nailed it. They finally presented a comprehensive Batman game that let you feel like the dark knight, allowing you to fight hordes of bad guys, be a detective and even take criminals out from the shadows with memorable gadgets and set pieces. The game ended up being so good, critics hailed it as being the best Batman game of all time, just a year after The Dark Knight was hailed as one of the best superhero movies. And it wasn't just a critical success. Aslylum has since spawned two sequels, establishing itself as one of the major IP's for consoles. That is a lot of success for a mythology that had yet to spawn a great game.
6. Max Payne 3
It took about a decade and tons of studio mismanagement just to get a release date for this anticipated sequel, and many (like me) were very wary of Rockstar taking the reigns this time around. Sure, Rockstar has some of the best games of all time under its belt, but they had never really tried to adapt a franchise of this scale and format. No one was sure about this one. Plus, did you watch the movie? That was a piece of...well anyway. How did it succeed against the odds? Rockstar managed to take everything we love about the character of Max Payne and successfully bring him into the next generation. Max Payne 3 brought back everything we wanted (bullet time, noir character growth, frenetic action) with some new flair, including the fun and dynamic setting of Brazil and updated game mechanics. It may not be the best Rockstar game out there, but it is easily one of the best Max Payne games.
5. Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood
When the first Assassin's Creed was released, the reception was positive, but muddled. Ubisoft had a lot of problems to fix, which they actually managed to pull off with the superior Assassin's Creed 2. Then Ubisoft surprised everyone by announcing a sequel to be released just a year later without a numeral. When the news began to eke out, many analysts like myself were curious as to how good this game could actually be. The developers had spent about 3 years getting the second game ready, and Brotherhood was initially supposed to be an online/multiplayer-centric offering. How did it succeed against the odds? We thought we were getting a stripped down side story akin to a direct-to-DVD sequel, but we instead received one of the best entries in the series, introducing the assassin's guild and providing what is still considered to be the series' best surprise endings.
4. Spider-Man 2
The year was 2004. Previous attempts to capture the webhead experience had been met with meh amounts of success, with Spider-man and Spider-man 2: Enter Electro ranging from decent to good. The first Spider-Man movie had its own game (remember that?), which was your standard licensed game bought in order to satiate gamers who didn't know better. By the time a game based on the second movie was scheduled to come out, no one raised an eyebrow. How did it succeed against the odds? Shocker! Spider-Man 2 completely changed the way we play as Spider-Man and was a major step forward for superhero games. No more bottomless pits and linear narrative. Spider-Man 2 let you play as Spider-man in a huge sandbox version of New York City that has since been replicated constantly. This unexpectedly awesome sequel was a must-have for pretty much everyone with a Playstation 2, and to be honest, we've been waiting for a proper follow-up ever since.
3. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
Naughty Dog was having a tough time reinventing itself as the next generation began to take shape in 2007. Their big attempt to break into first-party titles for Playstation 3 started with the relative success of Uncharted: Drake's Fortune. The game sold well, and critics liked it enough, but some major technical issues kept most people from expecting much out of this new IP. Fortunately, Naughty Dog sold enough copies to warrant a sequel, which led to the release of Uncharted 2. How did it succeed against the odds? Few sequels leap a game from "good" to "perfect," but that's pretty much what happened with Uncharted 2. Critically acclaimed and awarded Game of the Year by almost everyone in 2009, this sequel managed to capture the attention of gamers everywhere, establishing Uncharted as one of Sony's most profitable first-party franchises.
2. X-Men Origins: Wolverine
This is one of the best examples of a game taking absolutely everyone surprise. No one expected that a licensed game based on a terrible movie would actually be good, especially when the last one (X-Men 3: The Last Stand) was considered to be one of the worst games of all time. How did it succeed against the odds? Gamers were delighted to find that this was a well-polished game with tons of fun to be had. The combat, though somewhat repetitive, was a blast, and the voice acting was uncharacteristically spot-on compared to other licensed titles. The game was a critical success, but that still didn't convince Sony to greenlight a game based on First Class, but I guess they knew something we didn't.
1. Borderlands
Before Borderlands, few people had even heard of Gearbox Software, though they were instrumental in bringing several Valve games to life (or Half-life). Nevertheless, Borderlands was released alongside several huge (and established) titles, including a new Call of Duty and Uncharted 2. No one was really keeping their eye on this new IP with cel-shaded graphics. How did it succeed against the odds? Borderlands was a sleeper hit that steadily gained widespread success based on its own merits. People fell in love with the online co-op mode, ability to replay the campaign seamlessly and seemingly infinite weapons that made the game ridiculously replayable. Before we knew it, Borderlands became one of the top games of the year and was even considered by Gameinformer to be one of the top 200 games of all time.