10 Awesome Ways Video Games Got Back At Critics
Dante trolls HARD.
"Everyone's a critic," or so the saying goes, and considering the many years and thousands of man-hours that go into developing even a mediocre game, it's easy to appreciate why so many developers end up frustrated with the feedback to their work.
While fans and professional reviewers alike often have many valid reasons for taking a game to task, they may also often forget that actual people worked on them, and that no matter how they turned out, all involved were simply trying to put a fun game out into the world.
And so, some developers decided to take matters into their own hands by holding a mirror up to all that criticism in their latest game, typically responding to the negativity associated with their prior title or even mocking the unfavourable pre-release press coverage of their new game.
These 10 games all dished up sassy in-jokes and Easter eggs to poke fun at the very nature of criticism itself, taking clear delight in turning the tables on those who passionately dragged their tireless work over the coals...
10. Video Game Violence Critics Are Called "F**king Idiots" - Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon
Video game developers have spent decades fighting the assumption that violent games are responsible for real-life violence, namely spree shootings and the such like.
And Ubisoft Montreal decided to voice their frustration in hilariously unsubtle fashion in their bonkers, ultra-violent, aggressively tongue-in-cheek Far Cry 3 spin-off, Blood Dragon.
In the early stages of the game, protagonist Rex has some chit-chat with Dr. Darling, and when the subject comes to video games, Darling drops this loaded monologue:
"Video games are a proven coping mechanism, like any hobby. They've been shown to improve hand-eye coordination, problem-solving, social interaction, and self-confidence. And no studies have managed to prove a correlation between video games and violence. Frankly, anyone who thinks games are bad for you is a f**king idiot."
And when Rex calls Darling out, she adds that the F-word is actually an acronym for "failing to understand our capacity for kindness." Boom.
9. In-Game "Market Analysis" Parodies Reviews Of The Previous Game - Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag
Assassin's Creed III is unquestionably one of the series' more divisive games, and one of the most common complaints is that protagonist Ratonhnhaké:ton (aka Connor) made for an incredibly dull and forgettable protagonist.
Ubisoft decided to poke gun at the complaints in the fourth main game, Black Flag, using one of Abstergo's in-game market analysis videos to throw fans' issues right back in their faces.
The video says of critics' and players' reactions to Connor, "our researchers came away unimpressed by his calm and stoic demeanour, with occasional flashes of extreme anger."
The voiceover adds that Connor ultimately wasn't "the sort of leading man [Abstergo] felt comfortable endorsing," while noting that researchers found his origin story "problematic," given how many fans complained that the game's prologue sequence was way too long.
Finally, the video drops all pretense of subtlety and implies that the broad, "normal" audience who complained about Connor were simply too closed-minded to the "foreign" story, which would only be of interest to "more educated" viewers. Ouch.
8. The "Ludonarrative Dissonance" Trophy Mocks Violence Concerns - Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
One common complaint about the Uncharted games is their frequent invocation of "ludonarrative dissonance," a phenomenon where a game's gameplay doesn't match the tone of its story.
Critics argue that despite the series being mounted as a breezy Indiana Jones-esque action-adventure story starring charming rogue Nathan Drake, Drake is actually depicted as a mass murderer through the gameplay, which in the earlier games in particular forces players to kill hundreds of anonymous goons.
Though Uncharted 4: A Thief's End significantly toned down the mandatory shootouts and general combat encounters, the game did nevertheless take aim at critics, with players who scored 1,000 in-game kills receiving a trophy named - you guessed it - "Ludonarrative Dissonance."
The game's co-director, Neil Druckmann, ultimately claimed the fourth game's reduced combat was an attempt to alter the series' pacing, because he "[doesn't] buy into" the ludonarrative dissonance argument.
Whether you agree with Druckmann or not, the trophy is an hilarious thumbing of the nose at those who took issue with the series' tone.
7. Literally Murdering Obnoxious Reviewers - Borderlands 2: Mr. Torgue's Campaign Of Carnage DLC
The Borderlands series can never be accused of taking itself too seriously, though that didn't stop developers Gearbox Software taking on snooty video game critics with the second game's DLC pack, "Mr. Torgue's Campaign Of Carnage."
In the optional mission "Matter of Taste," Mr. Torgue tasks players with hunting down a series of obnoxious game reviewers and straight-up murdering them for besmirching a number of his most beloved games.
First off there's "BuffGamer," who says that a game he scored 6/10 "sucked," seemingly satirising how so many video game critics don't use the full 1-10 point scale.
And while Gearbox was clearly having some fun at critics' expense, the mission does also poke fun at overzealous fans, who seem unable to accept any opinion contrary to their own, and also place way too much importance on review scores.
6. A Harsh Critic Of The Previous Game Is Cast As An Ugly Monster - Might & Magic III: Isles Of Terra
1988 RPG game Might and Magic II: Gates to Another World received mixed-to-positive reviews from most critics, though landed an especially scathing review from Computer Gaming World magazine, where legendarily harsh reviewer Scorpia criticised its "weak plot," while deeming it "not as good as the previous game on many counts," and "only for the devoted hack and slash crowd."
This left designer Jon Van Caneghem so incensed that, for the 1991 sequel Might and Magic III: Isles of Terra, he included an enemy in the game called Scorpia, which resembled a grey-skinned, overweight woman.
Scorpia was later said to be "flattered" by the inclusion, and not taking the revenge personally, gave Might and Magic III a warmly positive review, calling it a "big improvement in the series."
5. Letting You Kill Video Game Violence Protestors - Postal 2
Apocalyptic top-down shooter Postal stirred up considerable controversy upon its original 1997 release, with politician Joe Lieberman famously referring to the game as one of the "three worst things in American society," the other two being Marilyn Manson and Calvin Klein underwear commercials.
Furthermore, the U.S. Postal Service ended up suing developers Running with Scissors for their implied representation of the profession, despite the fact that the protagonist, known only as "the Postal Dude," is never depicted as a member of the USPS.
Anyway, for the 2003 sequel, the developers found a novel way to play with all the criticism that stemmed from the first game, while also stirring up an entirely new avalanche of controversy.
Postal 2 allowed players to visit and desecrate the offices of Running with Scissors itself, laying waste to anyone they find inside.
But the developers weren't ever going to simply stop there, and so also allowed players to slaughter a fleet of protestors picketing outside the company's offices.
4. Pretending The Bad Games Never Happened - Crash Bandicoot 4: It's About Time
Crash Bandicoot 4 received strong reviews from most critics, though there were nevertheless those disappointed that the game took the predictable "reboot-sequel" route of simply wiping all the undesirable sequels from the continuity via timey-wimey shenanigans.
But developers Toys for Bob included an hilarious gag to make light of the game's new chronology, when Quantum Mask Lani-Loli says to Crash and Coco, "How many times have you beaten this clown [referring to Dr. Neo Cortex], anyway?," to which Coco quickly replies, "three."
Lani-Loli then knowingly retorts, "Really? Only three? Funny. Seemed like more," poking fun at the many other jettisoned installments between Crash 3 and Crash 4 where Crash took on Cortex.
3. Ribbing Critics Who Found The First Game Too Difficult - Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge
1990's The Secret of Monkey Island is one of the most beloved and influential adventure games of all time, albeit one which also earned criticism from some quarters of the press who felt that the puzzles were too obtuse and challenging for their own good.
And so for the sequel Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge, developers LucasArts took shot at critics who became stumped by the previous title, with the back cover including among the game's listed features, "Optional easy mode for beginners and magazine reviewers."
This didn't stop the game receiving rave reviews, though - possibly because review copies didn't come with a retail box - and today it remains one of the most popular point-and-click titles ever produced.
Better still, critics generally praised the more accessible difficulty settings. Everyone's a winner, basically.
2. New Dante Trolls Haters By Teasing His Old Look - DmC: Devil May Cry
It cannot be understated how thoroughly upset fans and critics alike were when Capcom confirmed that not only was the fifth main Devil May Cry game a reboot, but that protagonist Dante had been redesigned, with an "edgier" style which was cynically intended to make the franchise more appealing to younger players.
An evidently frustrated Capcom decided to make fun of the relentless complainers within the game itself, by featuring an outrageously inflammatory - and some might say misguided - cutscene where the new, "emo"-style Dante ends up with a Classic Dante-esque silver wig flung on top of his head during a boss fight at a carnival.
After pausing for a moment, Dante literally stares at the camera and says, "Not in a million years," before ripping the wig off and getting back to business.
Given that DmC was actually a totally solid game on its own merits, this was certainly a justifiable - if ballsy - way to fire shots at all the pre-release complaints.
Granted, Dante did end up with the classic silver hair by game's end, and DmC's commercial failure eventually led to classic Dante's return anyway in Devil May Cry 5, so perhaps the critics ultimately got the last laugh.
1. A Snob Critic Is One Of The Game's Bosses - Psychonauts
Though cult classic platformer Psychonauts received wild raves from most reviewers, Double Fine founder Tim Schafer is no stranger to clapping back against his critics, having worked as one of the lead designers of the aforementioned Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge, and also the brilliant-but-divisive Grim Fandango.
Grim Fandango was lauded for its art style and atmosphere but also criticised by many for its off-kilter puzzles, which some deemed more frustrating than smart.
Seemingly as a retort to this, Psychonauts - which was Schafer's very next game - featured a boss by the name of Jasper Rolls, a snooty critic who lives within the mind of actress Gloria Von Gouton.
During the fight, Rolls throws out stereotypically hollow critical adjectives like "tedious," "monotonous," and "just plain bad."
In a genius added flourish, though, Jasper doesn't die when you defeat him, but simply shrink down to such a small size that his squeaky voice is imperceptible to Gloria and everyone else.