10 Best Moments In Bioshock Infinite

The Best of 2013 lists are out, and critics have almost universally decided that Bioshock Infinite belongs amongst the best of the best. While it has its issues (I for one am not a fan of the Lady Comstock sequences), the true sequel to one of the most beloved games of our time was also packed with wonderful, magical, passionate moments that made it the memorable experience that it is. When a game relies on story and storytelling as much as Bioshock Infinite does, it needs to bring the goods, or the whole thing was just an exercise in futility. Luckily for gamers everywhere, the adventure of Booker Dewitt and Elizabeth is jam-packed with moments that will live with us for years to come. In case this isn't clear already, this article is stuffed to the gills with spoilers, including bits about the ending of Bioshock Infinite and the crazy cool stuff leading up to that moment.

10. The Lottery

The Lottery (which happens anywhere between ten minutes and half an hour into the game depending on how many trashcans you root through) is the first moment where you really understand what Bioshock Infinite is all about. Up until the moment where Booker is asked to stone an interracial couple, Infinite just sort of feels like mimic of what has come before, main character loaded into a strange pod and all. But the Lottery is Bioshock Infinite's thesis statement: You are about to go through a sick, twisted city run by the very worst ideals of American exceptionalism, and I hope you're ready. It is also a good metric to test if you are a terrible person or not. Unsure about this new girl you're dating? Have her play the first chunk of Infinite and see if you want her to meet your parents after all.

9. "Come Dance With Me, Mr. Dewitt"

Booker don't dance. Elizabeth is a Disney princess with more depth. She's an intelligent, magical woman who will endear herself to you more than most real people and will end up breaking your heart into a thousand pieces. This is where we get to know the girl locked away inside the tower. We've seen the experiments conducted on her. We've seen her attacked by Columbia's giant mechanical Songbird. We've seen her long for Paris and open up a tear in reality to get herself there. But the moment she's free, so runs straight to music. And with some beautiful voice acting by Courtnee Draper, it's a moment that really sings. It's the perfect counterpoint to the Elizabeth we get in the second half of the story. This sweet, innocent version of Elizabeth won't be with us for long, but she's the one we'll remember fondest of all.

8. Elizabeth's Haircut

To save the life of a child, Elizabeth had to take a life. She killed Daisy Fitzroy, leader of the Vox Populi. The Elizabeth we refused to dance with at the docks can't stomach what she has done, no matter how noble the act. It's a fairly simple visual metaphor. The childish, innocent Elizabeth can no longer be, so she sheds her long ponytail and changes her clothes. It's a shocking, daring change in character, and it's where we start to see the tragic nature of Elizabeth's lot in life.

7. Fighting Slate

The battle itself, like all combat in Bioshock Infinite, is sort of only okay, but the tenor and drama surrounding it is absolutely perfect. Of all of America's faults that get addressed in Bioshock Infinite, the one that gets most thoroughly and qualitatively done is America's tendency to rewrite its history. Slate and Booker both fought at the Battle at Wounded Knee, and Slate simply cannot abide by Comstock writing himself the story. It's a showdown between two former allies, torn apart by a madman who can see nothing but himself. History is written by the winners, and up until the very final moments of Bioshock Infinite, Comstock is the winner.

6. The First Tear

This is where things just get... weird. Booker and Elizabeth find Chen Lin dead, who was their one chance to earn their airship back from Daisy Fitzroy and fly off of Columbia forever. It seems as if they're out of time and out of luck. Until the Luteces show up and offer up some tasty ideas on perspective. "On one side dead, the other alive. It's all about perspective." It's then that Elizabeth finds a tear and rips it open, taking the two of them to an alternate world where Chen Lin is still alive and they still have a chance to escape. This is the first of many universe jumps in Infinite, and it opens up the narrative to all of the wonderful possibilities we see before the credits roll.

5. Destroying The Tower

Songbird's last act. Elizabeth's only friend she has ever known was a giant mechanical bird. He brought her food and books. It was a complicated relationship, but the strongest that Elizabeth has. Throughout the story of Bioshock Infinite, Songbird has proved to be nothing but a nuisance for Booker and Elizabeth, but his final moments really redeem the big guy. After assisting you in an excruciatingly tough fight atop Comstock's blimp, Songbird is instructed to bring down the tower that held Elizabeth for her entire life. This unleashes her power, and allows us to move into the incredibly moving and gorgeous final sequence. After such an action, even if it was sort of against his will, Songbird's death hurts more than you thought it might. He did destroy the symbol of Elizabeth's oppression after all.

4. "How Long Have I Been Gone?"

Not since Spec Ops: The Line had us utterly destroy the lives of innocent civilians using white phosphorous has a game made me feel so much like utter crap. Elizabeth was counting on me, and what happened? I somehow disappeared for years, only appearing when she had been fully indoctrinated by Comstock and waging the war on New York that Booker saw in his dreams. The character that we spend the entire game growing closer to and engendering really deep affection for needed us, and we weren't there. It's absolutely devastating. Each audio log you find is just one more needle dug into your skin. Thank goodness it was all fixed in the end, but that older Elizabeth, brainwashed and alone, will continue to exist in her world as yet another Booker has let her down.

3. An Infinite Sea Of Lighthouses

I would be hard-pressed to recall a more hauntingly beautiful image in videogaming than any single moment of this scene as it unfolds. Elizabeth and Booker step out of the lighthouse that greeted gamers at the beginning of the first Bioshock and from there... It's really inexplicable. An infinite number of Elizabeths and an equally infinite number of Bookers hop from reality to reality, from one moment in time to the next, as we, the players, slowly unraveled exactly what was going on here. The sea of lighthouses is the moment where you put down the controller for a second and just say, "Wow."

2. The Luteces

How can anyone pick just one moment from these two? They're the first truly friendly faces Booker encounters in Columbia, even if absolutely everything about them is wrapped in mystery and theoretical physics. The Luteces appear over and over again, and each time they are an absolute delight. They also have far more to do with the overall mystery than anyone could have really anticipated. They've pulled so many of the strings that need to be pulled for this game to happen at all. Rosalind Lutece is the one who put Columbia in the sky in the first place. Robert Lutece first offered Booker the chance to give up his own daughter in exchange for the removal of his gambling debts. The sign of a truly great supporting character is the feeling of great joy and relief when they appear, and that is exactly what Rosalind and Robert Lutece inspired in the violent world of Bioshock Infinite. "Dies. Died. Will Die."

1. The Pinky

IT ALL MAKE SENSE NOW! I GET IT! ALSO, I'M CRYING! WHY VIDEOGAME?! WHY MUST YOU DO THIS TO ME?! I'm sure that I am not the only one who was totally wrecked by Bioshock Infinite's closing minutes. The moment that pinky came off, I was an inconsolable mess. There is no going back after that. The gloves are off. And so is that pinky. There is only one way for Booker to redeem himself after everything he (and Comstock) have done. And it surely broke your heart.

Contributor
Contributor

Kevin Lanigan is a fun-loving Sagittarius who enjoys long walks on the beach and sunsets. While running a popular blog called Chekhov's Gunman, Kevin hopes to one day write the best movies and television you can complain about on the Internet. One of those movies, entitled IT DIDN'T TAKE, just opened up on Indiegogo and would appreciate all donations. Rosebud is a sled.