10 Best Pokémon Appearances In Detective Pikachu

Which ones are the very best, like no one ever was?

Pikachu Psyduck Detective Pikachu
Warner Bros.

Pokémon: Detective Pikachu might not have fully broken the video game movie curse, but it’s certainly got more going for it than against. Yes, the human characters are mostly flat, the plot is convoluted and the tone spins off at random times, but overall it’s a solid movie - especially if you love Pokémon.

If you go to watch this without much knowledge of the franchise, the film won’t do you any favours except tell you the names of the creatures. Whether you’re a hardcore fan or just along for the ride though, make no mistake: the Pokémon are the stars of the show.

With that in mind, the movie tries to incorporate as many as they can. Around 60 of the 800+ ‘mons feature, with about half to a third getting any kind of role beyond a bit of a background gag.

They all shine in their own way, but these ten in particular really shine. The filmmakers clearly understand Pokémon and make use of their unique powers, which makes it all the better.

It’s certainly a movie that’ll mean more to dedicated fans, but after 20 years, the franchise has built up quite a few of those.

10. Aipom

Aipom Pokemon
Warner Bros

Aipom are one of the few non-Kanto Pokémon to be given a role of any significance, and it’s a good choice because Mankey might well have taken their place if they were going for the safer option. Aipom is definitely less well known, but the choice turned out to be inspired.

Aipom gives the audience their first encounter with the R gas, a serum derived from Mewtwo which makes Pokémon wild, ruthless and rabid. After opening a vial and nearly choking on it, Tim wafts it out the window, where the Aipom are sitting. Minutes later, he’s attacked by them.

He meets Pikachu as he’s running too, so the Aipoms play a key role in forming this dynamic. The manic craziness of the monkeys added to Reynolds’ over the top voicing means they set up some great one liners as well.

With a hand on the tip of their tails, Aipoms can create more carnage than most other Pokémon, especially when in swarms. The contrast between the rage driven creatures and their sweet and docile nature when the R gas wears off illustrates how powerful it is without asking you to understand any complex science too; wonderful storytelling for a children’s movie.


9. Torterra

Torterra Detective Pikachu
Warner Bros.

Torterra is perhaps the strangest inclusion here, as there are many cuter characters with more screen time than the Grass starter throughout the movie. It doesn’t really get a developed personality or even particularly a visual gag, but it’s part of probably the biggest set piece of the entire film, so deserves a special mention.

It’s one of many examples of the movie not just understanding Pokémon, but utilising what they bring to the table in unique and creative ways.

While visiting a Pokémon research centre, the main cast stumble across a Torterra sanctuary and note that the scientists are experimenting on the size of the creatures, but that they all look regular sized. The kids in the cinema might not spot the foreshadowing, but it’s highlighted pretty heavily nonetheless.

The whole sanctuary turns out to have been built on the backs of giant Torterras, and as they wake they begin a series of earthquakes. Though we don’t see much of the Torterras themselves aside from the occasional beady eye, we see the action revolve around them as the characters flee to safer ground.

Though there’s not much of Torterra itself, the movie would be missing a huge chunk of action without it.


8. Cubone

3532578 Detective Pikachu Cubone
Warner Bros.

Cubone has the first appearance of any real significance in the movie, and it sets the tone well. Desperately wailing in the middle of a field, Cubone perhaps doesn’t have the iconic feel of other creatures, but it does lay down an important ground rule.

The movie makes no serious attempt to explain Cubone’s backstory as an orphan who wears its mother’s skull as a helmet. Instead, it makes a joke about this where full context is required to get it. Aside from the personality Cubone has, it sets the movie’s stall out as being for the fans.

Early on, this subtle buy in lets everyone know that Pokémon are going to be utilised to their full extent. For Cubone personally, they dial his rage up to eleven and give us a good laugh early on.

Pretty much inconsequential to the overall story, Cubone is instead used not only to clarify that Pokémon backstories aren’t always going to be explained, but also to demonstrate protagonist Tim’s loneliness and talk us through the fact that that (in this narrative, at least), the Pokémon must choose the trainer too.

They don’t get the most out of Cubone, but it’s used well for its intended purpose.


7. Charizard

Detective Pikachu Charizard
Warner Bros.

The movie underplays the battling element of Pokémon, largely to good effect too. Plenty of other movies have this at their forefront - not to mention all the main series games - so all in all it was a good move.

That said, seeing Charizard in full battle mode (fuelled by the R gas) was still a treat, and it’s here representing Gengar and Blastoise too. Those two duke it out before Charizard and Pikachu take to the ring, with the ghostly prankster winning out. We don’t see much of that bout though, while Charizard gets a hefty chunk of screen time.

The scales on the fiery lizard are magnificently detailed, and were it not for the childish subject matter of the movie, might have been enough for a Visual Effects Oscar. He’s intimidating without being too scary for the youngster, and is well utilised in the movie’s first big action scene.

Unfortunately, with the battle simply a plot device to move the mystery forward, we don’t see Charizard in full swing. Chaos breaks out soon after they start and the snappy pacing moves along, leaving the pseudo dragon behind.


6. Greninja

Greninja Detective Pikachu
Warner Bros.

Despite its massive popularity, Greninja is limited to a fairly minor role, probably in part due to the fact it’s a Gen VI Pokémon. As such, it’s the most recent creature to feature in any sort of meaningful way, and it’s definitely a good pick.

They’re cast in the role of villains, causing the accident the entire movie is built around. This doesn’t really do Greninja justice though, but thankfully around about halfway through the movie they get a bit more of a spotlight shone upon them.

Inside the research facility, they’re released and start to creep around the laboratory, stalking the protagonists. It’s a little like the velociraptors in Jurassic Park, except far too rushed.

If they dwelled on the scene and let a sense of dread set in, it might have proved too much for the younger audience. Still though, it would have improved the scene and probably boosted Greninja up the list.

As it stands, the ninja frogs make the best with what they get and feature in probably the most exciting action scene apart from the climactic battle.

They’re not perfect and they’re defeated a little easily, but they’re entertaining nonetheless.


5. Mewtwo

Detective Pikachu Mewtwo
Warner Bros.

Mewtwo makes the top five purely by virtue of its status as a Legendary Pokémon and general cinematic appeal. It makes for some good moments, but ultimately is underused, atonal and a bit more of a deus ex machina even than it usually is.

After being involved in the opening exchanges of the movie, Mewtwo largely takes a backseat until the third act, which is clearly the worst. That’s not because of Mewtwo’s involvement, per sé, but the various twists of the plot hardly make the most of them either.

Mewtwo can certainly come off as hammy if played poorly, with the overly mystical vibes of the creature and the all knowing sense of omnipotence it brings. Pokémon: The First Movie leaned into this exactly the right amount, but Detective Pikachu sidesteps it entirely.

We see occasional moments of the real Mewtwo, but for the majority of the time it’s controlled by Bill Nighy’s Clifford, neutering its potential. No longer is Mewtwo an all knowing being with knowledge beyond our comprehension; it’s just a man with a few standard superpowers.

Still though, it’s Mewtwo, so it’ll be a crowd pleaser regardless.


4. Ditto

Ditto Detective Pikachu
Warner Bros

Ditto is the best thing about the movie’s third act, though that is admittedly a low bar. Its creepy, pebble black eyes first made waves when it debuted in the Pokémon anime, and they’ve been a cult part of Ditto’s existence since then.

In the games, Ditto can transform into a perfect copy of whatever creature it sees, but in most narrative driven adventure its beady eyes are a frequent feature. They’re used to great effect here, seeing it hop between Pokémon and people alike.

The groundwork is laid early on, as it transforms into a roadie to wheel Bill Nighy’s character’s wheelchair away, but the movie does a good job of keeping the twist under wraps.

The reveal of Suki Waterhouse’s Ms. Norman with the black eyes made great use of Ditto’s mechanics, as did its switch to Machamp. Kathyrn Newton’s Lucy worked well for the final fight with Tim, but the logic kind of dissolves with Roger Clifford.

Norman and Lucy both act in quite simplistic ways which suit Ditto’s Pokémon brain, but as Clifford he seems to be far more intelligent than he should be. All the same, Ditto makes for some great set pieces in its cameo.


3. Mr. Mime

Detective Pikachu Mr Mime
Warner Bros.

Mr. Mime is one of the least popular Pokémon out there. The humanoid ‘mons never get that much love to begin with, and Mime’s design is one of the goofiest.

The anime, where Ash’s mom kept one as a butler/pet didn’t endear it to anyone either, and despite being the powerful Psychic type, he’s got the weakest line of all Psychics in Kanto. Simply put, unless you’re a contrarian, you probably don’t like Mr. Mime.

That’s why it’s strange that they’re even in this movie, much less given a scene to star in. However, it turns out that Mr. Mime is a brilliant example of the filmmakers understanding Pokémon.

Garchomp, Milotic and Zoroark are all massively beloved ‘mons, but there’s no room for them in the movie as they don’t bring anything to the table. Mr. Mime, despite a lack of fans, demonstrably does.

Though it’s nobody’s favourite, that might change after some brilliant body acting and funny slapstick in Detective Pikachu. It’s silly, no doubt, and the burning alive joke might be too much for some, but they wrung every inch of potential out of Mime.

After stealing the show in the trailer, there was still enough material for the movie itself.


2. Psyduck

Detective Pikachu Psyduck
Warner Bros.

In some ways, picking Psyduck as the film’s supporting Pokémon assisting Kathryn Newton’s Lucy was a risky choice. A heavy fan favourite from the anime thanks to Misty’s Psyduck, it was one of the few Pokémon to have an established and well known personality, as opposed to one just buried in lore or direct to DVD movies.

However, the choice proved to be a stroke of genius, as Psyduck manages to provide comic relief yet again. They downplay the clumsiness and goofiness of Misty’s Psyduck and instead give Lucy’s a warmer sense of humour.

This Psyduck feels like he’s in on the joke, rather than the butt of it, building off a good dynamic with Pikachu and Lucy.

It helps that he’s clearly the star of his partnership too, keeping up a solid and consistent performance while Lucy’s wobbles throughout. She begins as an overly serious noir detective trope, and you’re never sure if she’s ironic about this or playing in straight.

Later, she sheds any personality whatsoever, only existing to be good looking and occasionally push the plot along. Psyduck is left carrying the weight the script leaves behind, but shoulders it all with charm.


1. Pikachu

detective pikachu
Warner Bros.

It was probably to be expected, with the movie being about Pikachu and the hugely talented Ryan Reynolds voicing him, but with that came a lot of pressure. Thankfully, Pikachu delivers in spades and is undoubtedly the star of the show here.

Obviously there’s the trademark Reynolds wit, and you really get the sense the filmmakers gave him license to let loose. He’s no Robin Williams’ Genie, but he carries the movie in a similar manner and it wouldn’t be at all surprising to find out that he’d improvised just as much.

Away from Reynolds’ stellar contribution though, Pikachu itself is brings a lot to the party. The flashes of the cute ‘pika pika’ cries pull your heartstrings, arguably more than the slightly convoluted emotional plot strands.

The body language is brilliant too, combining the adorable scurrying typical of the short, fluffy Pokémon with the more anthropomorphic expectations that come with Reynolds’ voice. Not since Stitch has a movie character used their body movements so well.

It’s disappointing that we don’t get to see much of the electric powers the little mouse is known for, but that’s a minor issue. The anime is jam packed with that if you need your fill.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)