10 Best Stories That ONLY Work As Video Games
If you can't play it, then why bother at all?
Ever since video games hit the world, there have been detractors who claim it's a form of niche entertainment rather than a vessel for storytelling. Well, those who think that way have certainly been on the losing side of the battle these last couple of decades.
Nowadays, video games have so much scope, beauty, and narrative potential, turning the medium into the perfect platform for stories that wouldn't work on a static screen.
Whether it's a triple-A experience that plays with something unattainable in real life or an indie project that uses the lens of interaction to paint something extraordinary, there's no denying that the gaming industry can generate some once in a lifetime stories.
These coming titles are the ones that go above and beyond to create something unique to the gaming sphere. They crafted expert experiences that would have had little to no effect were they in any other medium, proving that video games are undoubtedly worthy of being called art.
--
There is a big old spoiler alert on this one, as we will be discussing most of these narratives in detail. So, be warned!
10. Doki Doki Literature Club
Here's another spoiler warning in case you're years late to this party.
Doki Doki Literature Club is an experience unlike any other, so long as you go in blind. You take on the role of a nameless protagonist who joins his friend's literature club and begins to romance three of its members. However, things take a drastic turn when you discover that the fourth, non-romanceable girl (Monica) is fully aware she's a character in a video game.
She then manipulates the code to try and become the object of your affection and ends up creating some incredibly horrifying experiences, killing off the other girls and eventually deleting herself and resetting the game.
How can you make a story about a sentient video game character who breaks the fourth wall and messes with the player in a medium other than video gaming and expect it to work?
This story of a game character growing sentience is flawless here as the fourth wall breaking makes it feel uncomfortably real. This ties in with some incredibly cathartic scares, which centre on the mechanics you've experienced thus far, making this a true video game story.
9. Undertale
At its heart, this tiny game tells a straightforward story, but it's the context of its video game setting that makes it so special.
Undertale (in case you haven't been on the internet in the last five years) follows a young boy called Frisk who falls into The Underground, a realm full of monsters, and from there, he ventures to find his way out.
But that isn't the real story here. No, while that is the core experience, the beauty of Undertale comes from the changes that occur based on your actions. The game's notorious branching paths - neutral, pacifist and genocide - create entirely different sides to the story. Your decision to spare or kill monsters leads to massive ramifications, but where that becomes truly special is in the game's meta-narrative.
In Undertale, each of your saves and resets are canonical. If you decide to experience a pacifist run and receive a happy ending, your choice to start the game again is actively still a part of that same world. By resetting, you rip that happiness away from the characters you've grown to love, and this works in reverse too.
There's no way a concept as inherently tied to your decisions like that could work anywhere but in a video game.
8. Gone Home
Gone Home is a game that became the foundation of the "walking simulator" genre. But, of course, a description like that misses the point entirely. Yes, this is a game where you have very little to do regarding mechanics, but that leaves a perfect amount of space for narrative.
This future classic follows a young woman (Katie) who returns to her family home and explores the empty house. She picks up environmental clues and learns what happened in her absence, unveiling a long narrative about her sister coming out as gay and her parents responding poorly, leading to her sister running away from the household.
Naturally, the core plot of a girl coming out is hardly unique to video games. However, this specific story works entirely because of its video game holding device.
Looking through the eyes of Katie and learning everything in isolation through exploration highlights the loneliness of the house and the hole she left when she moved abroad. Through this lens, the central story of her sister's struggle becomes so much more intimate and effective, in a way that a conventional movie or book couldn't deliver.
Couple this with genre subversion - you're initially led to believe this will be a haunted house tale - and you've got a story that excels in video game form.
7. Portal 2
Applying narrative to a video game with a static puzzle per room set-up is no easy feat. The first Portal did a great job of it by introducing the world to the evil that was GLaDOS, but Portal 2 took that ball and rolled with it, crafting an excellent story that worked thanks to the lore of Aperture Science and the gameplay.
In Portal 2, you play as Chell after she awakens in the Aperture Science Facility. From there, you attempt to escape with the Stephen Merchant-voiced personality core Wheatley by your side, only to end up running into everyone's favourite cake enthusiast GLaDOS. You then reluctantly work together with her to take down Wheatley after he takes over and gets drunk with power.
There's so much in this narrative that works because of the video game parameters. The uneasy feeling of working alongside someone who you've actively opposed before, the puzzles making you feel like you're truly part of the world, and even discovering the history of Aperture and GLaDOS herself through those excellent Cave Johnson audio recordings.
The story is a perfect guiding hand that would not be satisfying were if not for the classic Portal puzzles and your involvement.
6. Oxenfree
Oxenfree puts you in control of Alex, a teenager set to arrive on Edwards Island for a party. However, she and her friends (or just acquaintances) end up being pulled into a mysterious battle for their lives against the ghosts of a submarine lost at sea.
So, teens getting lost on an island after uncovering a supernatural event that puts them in danger; so far, so typical narrative, right? But, where Oxenfree thrives is in subverting your expectations, letting you affect the narrative and giving you some of the most exciting dialogue gameplay in any video game. That's what makes this story so unique.
The story plays out linearly but changes depending on your decisions, giving you plenty of autonomy in the narrative. Not only that but the overly convoluted mystery of the island and the supernatural events haunting you unfold themselves naturally through exploration and dialogue, in a way that any other medium would struggle to pull off.
It masterfully juggles spookiness with mystery with typical teenage drama, making it one exceptional game. With the upcoming sequel scheduled for release this year, you'd better get on the boat and venture to the island yourself.
5. The Stanley Parable
Remember when you got sick of this game because every let's player on the internet was on it at the same time? Well, it must have done something right!
There's one aspect of storytelling that video games have a monopoly over, and that's choice. Sure, you've got some choose your own adventure books/films, but nothing can hold a candle to the gaming industry. The Stanley Parable is a title that encapsulates that.
This strange game puts you in the shoes of a man named Stanley, who awakens to find his office building empty. You explore and find a narrator attempting to dictate your actions and are given the option of defying him, leading to a slew of choices that change the game's narrative entirely.
Calling it a story might be a little bold, as the plot is essentially a diverging set of pathways leading to many different narratives. However, that's precisely why it's a perfect video game story. It addresses themes like the relationship between players and video game creators, choice in video games and even takes jabs at the concept of fate itself.
It's an ambitious and certainly creative deep dive into video game storytelling, so it had to be on this list.
4. Mass Effect 2
You know what, let's keep to the subject of choice by talking about one of the biggest triple-A games ever to have explored such an idea to its fullest.
Now, Mass Effect might feel like an unconventional choice for this list, as the story of a space commander battling against alien forces is hardly something cinema goers or avid readers are unfamiliar with. But Mass Effect 2 gives you something genuinely unique to the video game medium, and that's (again) choice.
Throughout the game, you (as Commander Shepard) venture around the universe, building up a team of allies to battle against the Collectors. You build your team and make choices that can strengthen or worsen your relationship with them. Ultimately, you descend upon the Collectors base, and your crew will live or die based on the decisions you've made and relationships you've built.
The choice-based gameplay here don't just give you options; it gives you responsibilities. You feel the weight of Commander Shepard's role as the lives of your comrades fall upon you. Of course, it's all well and good to watch a movie where someone else has that kind of pressure, but genuinely experiencing it is what makes this one best suited for gaming.
3. Paratopic
Paratopic is a weird game. It's about as far removed from your typical COD instalment or Fortnite battle as you can get, and that strange sense of avant-garde creativity is precisely what makes it such a captivating experience. It fits the bill regarding uniqueness, and when it comes to the story, it's not the kind of thing you'd be able to capture in a Netflix series.
Throughout Paratopic, you'll alternate between three characters in a narrative that's deliberately presented out of order. One of the stories follows someone walking around a forest attempting to photograph a rare bird, another sees you as a hitman ready to shoot someone in a diner, and the last one puts you in the shoes of someone who smuggles illegal VHS tapes.
This game relies on subverting your expectations of video games, and that's what makes it work so well. It deliberately traps you in mundane moments such as waiting for an elevator or driving for long periods and exists in this deliciously dated PS1 style to remind you that you're playing a game.
The flickering between narratives also leaves you genuinely unsure as to what's going on, even though you're the one in control of the characters, making it engrossing and fascinating.
2. The Void
From the biggest sci-fi movie to the most intimate romance book, the aim of any story is to help you escape what you know. When it comes to transporting you somewhere truly unfamiliar, few do it better than this one.
In this game, you play as a lost soul who has woken up in the mysterious Void, a purgatory-like existence where lifeforce is made up of colour. You collect colour to grow stronger and feed The Sisters, the oppressed and famished inhabitants of this space. However, soon you must venture forth and challenge their oppressors, The Brothers, and ascend from these depths.
As you can probably tell, this is a very encompassing experience where you'll feel like you're on a whole different plane of existence. The art design, the gameplay, and The Brothers' designs almost make you feel like you're in a lucid dream.
Plus, there's no big guiding hand in this game, as you are left to your own devices regarding what to do and who to follow. It's the kind of story that works because you, the player, are the life force behind it; without you, a story like this simply wouldn't exist.
1. What Remains Of Edith Finch
This is one of those games that you can whip out in any debate over video games being considered art. Because if someone can sit through this magnificent piece of work and still claim that gaming doesn't deserve its place on that pedestal, then they're either lying or more stubborn than a toddler who doesn't want to eat their broccoli.
The story follows as you read a letter from the titular Edith Finch and take control over her. You explore her childhood home and experience various gameplay moments relating to each of her family members, witnessing how they died and unlocking the mysteries of the "Finch family curse". It ends with the reveal that Edith has herself died, and the person reading the letter (you) is her son.
It's easy to chuck out words like emotional, beautiful and poignant with this one. The genius of it comes from how each segment fully reflects the character you're meeting, from Barbara's B-movie horror to Gregory's bright and imaginative bath. Through this you understand the characters, are constantly given fresh gameplay and piece together the narrative in a unique only achievable in a video game.