10 Biggest Video Game Bombs Of 2018

The irony of Fallout 76's sales being a wasteland.

Fallout 76
Bethesda

This year has been an absolutely great for gaming.

It's actually a lot easier to talk about all of the fantastic titles that came out this year, such as Red Dead Redemption 2, God of War, Marvel's Spider-Man and so many more. The amount of choice for any gamer this year is absolutely staggering.

That doesn't mean that there weren't some stinkers, though.

Several big games this year managed to shoot themselves in the foot by either not delivering on promises, being too similar to previous entries or, well, just not being very good.

Even worse are the cases where a game has failed for reasons other than its quality. There are several instances here where a game has bombed despite actually being great.

Unfortunately, with such strong competition, that means that there are a lot of games out there that were simply destined to fail.

The worst thing is that every single game on this list had potential. There's nothing worse than a game not living up to what it could really do, but the following selection is full of them.

10. Battlefield V

Battlefield V Attrition
EA

How did this one happen?!

Ever since the launch of Battlefield 2: Bad Company, the Battlefield series has been held in pretty high regard, delivering consistent and thrilling multiplayer experiences.

Yet for some reason this year, Battlefield V has completely failed to take off and has been received pretty neutrally. Considering how beloved Battlefield 1 was and how big of a name the series has, this one really is a complete surprise.

The controversy surrounding Battlefront II last year might be a contributing factor to how Battlefield V has been received, but it might just be because of how similar the game is to Battlefield 1. There aren't enough substantial changes to the average player to get really excited about this one.

There's also the fact that Black Ops 4 went all in on the Battle Royale trend and ended up taking the world by storm, so Battlefield V's lack of the mode definitely hurt it.

The sales numbers for Battlefield V ended up being down 63% from Battlefield 1 in the UK, and pre-order numbers were looking bad way before launch.

Considering the consistent quality of Battlefield, this one really is a shame.


9. Shadow Of The Tomb Raider

Shadow Of The Tomb Raider Lara Croft
Square Enix

The rebooted Tomb Raider games have never been given the attention they truly deserve, and that continues with the latest entry in the series.

In a year so packed full of amazing games, you really had to stand out in order to get some attention and unfortunately Shadow of the Tomb Raider didn't do much to differentiate itself from the previous games and actually made a lot of things worse in the long run.

It's a real shame because Shadow of the Tomb Raider does introduce a lot of things to try and make it more like the original games, but ends up including some of the worst aspects. Slow underwater sections are the worst inclusion, but the lack of an interesting plot is probably what kills the momentum most.

Although sales figures haven't been too bad, there was a massive lack of interest in the game at launch and it hasn't really picked up in the months after. Sales numbers were down by 70% from the original 2013 reboot, which shows the lack of interest.

Looks like we won't be seeing Lara Croft for a little while.


8. The Crew 2

The Crew 2
Ubisoft

The Crew 2 has suffered a similar fate to the first game by being completely forgettable.

Once again like the first game, this isn't for a lack of trying. Both games had some pretty awesome features such as the massive open-world map and the ability to switch vehicles on the fly to mix things up.

Even with these great ideas, The Crew 2 manages to fall short of expectations and ends up being really boring.

The Crew 2 really is the epitome of Ubisoft's design flaws- a huge open map with loads of uninteresting things to do in it. Unless you really love the driving mechanics, you're not going to have any reason to actually go and do what the game wants you to do.

Look at the Forza Horizon games. They don't need a big world because everything you do in them is good fun. Because of this, The Crew 2 sold about half of what the first game did in its first week, with the game only being more forgotten.

What this series really needs is an adrenaline shot in the arm. Why have all these great features if you can't make them any fun?


7. The World Ends With You: Final Remix

The World Ends With You Picture 3 E1347454103415
Square Enix

This one doesn't deserve to be here in the slightest.

Despite being an amazing game with fantastic music, great characters and an interesting gameplay style, The World Ends With You doesn't seem to have made much impact upon releasing.

The fact that The World Ends With You is such a niche game is one of the reasons why it didn't sell so well. If you don't like the very specific vibe the game is giving off, you aren't going to be interested in the slightest.

Final Remix also released in October, which was packed full of releases like Assassin's Creed, Red Dead Redemption 2 and Black Ops 4. It was a pretty stacked month to say the least. The World Ends With You barely cracked the charts in its first week, opening at number 21.

To be fair, the Switch port of The World Ends With You does come with a brand new set of problems that make it a little harder to recommend. The fact that the game can only be played comfortably using the handheld is a big annoyance as the motion controls take a lot of fun away.

Let's hope this doesn't stop a sequel.


6. Hitman 2

Hitman 2 Promo
IO Interactive

Why do the great games not get the attention they truly deserve?

That's right everyone, Hitman 2, one of the best games of the year, is also one of the most likely to bomb. Despite improving on an already amazing formula, the Hitman series has never quite been able to capture the huge audience that it deserves.

It almost seems like kicking a man whilst he's down to have Hitman 2 not sell well, as the series was already dropped by Square Enix last year for not selling enough copies. The problem is that as long as the game is delivering what fans want (which is fairly niche) it's not being mainstream enough.

Despite only being available for less than a month, Hitman 2 is already receiving a ton of discounts and deals, which is a sure sign that it isn't selling as well as it needs to. In fact, Hitman 2 sales are reportedly down by 90% from the best-selling game in the series, Hitman Absolution. Yikes.

At this point it's looking doubtful that we'll see another adventure starring the bald menace.


5. Darksiders 3

Darksiders 3 Header
Stevivor

Another great franchise down the drains for trying to be something it's not.

The Darksiders games have never really been the most original titles in the world, with the first two being heavily influenced by Zelda, but at least they were actively improving on the formula with great action.

For the third game, the developers decided to try and mimic elements from the Dark Souls games, such as focusing on dodging and countering rather than straight up action. The difficulty ends up feeling pretty out-of-place and unfair

That's not to say that Darksiders 3 is a bad game by any means, just not one that does anything particularly interesting. If it had stuck to what made the first two games good, we might be singing a different tune.

Unfortunately the Darksiders games have never been the best selling games anyway, let alone launching against the competition of games like Red Dead Redemption 2 and Black Ops 4.

Apparently Darksiders 3 sold well enough to warrant another sequel, but that's certainly a surprise. Hopefully they learn their lesson next time.


4. Metal Gear Survive

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

Did Metal Gear Survive really come out in 2018? It's been a long year...

Releasing back in February, Metal Gear Survive is the game that no-one asked for based on the game that let a lot of people down.

After all the controversy surrounding Kojima's treatment, continuing the Metal Gear series was a big risk on Konami's part.

In all fairness, the Metal Gear games are fantastic enough that making a new one isn't really a bad idea. Making it about survival against weird crystal zombies, however, is.

Despite being based on The Phantom Pain's game mechanics, Metal Gear Survive just feels clunky and wrong, like something was lost in translation. Boring is really the best word for Survive.

Even if you can find some sort of enjoyment in the gameplay, the focus on online really hurt the whole experience and turned it into a grindy mess. The sales were bad enough that Konami omitted them from their earnings call this year, but that's telling enough.

The game ended up being one of the most mediocre titles of the year, and it seems like everyone was aware of how bad it was.


3. Overkill's The Walking Dead

Overkill S The Walking Dead
Overkill Software

The fact that Starbreeze might be going out of business because of this game is definitely indicative of a bomb.

Or in the words of Starbreeze, the sales of Overkill's The Walking Dead are "disappointing".

That's really a shame too because both the first and second Payday are really great games with a lot of love put into them.

Overkill's The Walking Dead is depressing because it actually holds a lot of this potential. A game that plays similarly to Left 4 Dead whilst also introducing new mechanics and objectives is definitely a good idea.

The problem comes from despite having some good ideas, Overkill's The Walking Dead is just pretty boring.

A lot of the time you find yourself repeating the same objectives over and over again, all the while facing dumb enemies and using some really clunky melee combat. Zombies are more annoying that anything else and there's nothing to set them apart from one another.

It might have been possible for this one to get better over time, but with a dwindling player count that's looking less and less likely.


2. Fallout 76

Fallout Game
Bethesda

Were you really expecting anything else?

Well actually, a lot of people were under the impression that Fallout: 76, whilst not being a traditional Fallout game, would still deliver an enjoyable experience.

They were sorely mistaken.

The biggest problem with Fallout: 76 is wasted potential. Although there are a lot of issues tying it down, it could very well be something good one day. To see the Fallout series fall so far is depressing.

Besides that, the world feels completely empty, there's barely a story to follow and having other players around doesn't really improve gameplay much at all.

Since launch, Bethesda has lost a lot of goodwill within the gaming community and it seems like Fallout: 76 might be the straw that broke the camels back.

The game has quickly been discounted and the player count is steadily dropping so it's safe to say that things are starting to look pretty dire. In fact, Fallout: 76 sales are down a whopping 82% from Fallout 4.

You can't be a bigger bomb than causing everyone to rethink your gaming strategy.


1. The Quiet Man

The Quiet Man
Square Enix

There's really no excuse for this one.

Not that anyone's really mourning how The Quiet Man turned out, but it really is a strange sort of thing.

Debuting at E3 this year, The Quiet Man was stealth launched late into November with nary any warning or marketing.

It's almost like Square Enix didn't want anything to do with it...

Even with a messy launch and lack of attention, The Quiet Man could still have ended up being a pretty good game. The idea behind it is actually pretty interesting, with deaf characters in game being a pretty rare thing.

The execution really messed everything up.

There aren't even any sales figures for the game because it was that bad.

The Quiet Man is woefully pretentious, confusing and a complete mess in terms of gameplay, and there's nothing about it remotely worth playing it for.

This comparison has been made a lot but The Quiet Man really is the gaming equivalent to The Room. It's that bad.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Fallout 76
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jumping through portals, swinging through cities, destroying beings made of darkness and occasionally shooting a gun or two. I also write about games.