10 Broken Yu-Gi-Oh Cards That Can NEVER Be Unbanned

Link and Xyz Monsters are nothing compared to these.

Pot of Greed
Konami

Konami recently revealed the brand-new Forbidden & Limited List, effective from the 15 June, to much controversy, with players expressing dissatisfaction at the Ban List's inability to contain the existing metagame in an adequate way.

Unlike Trading Card Games like Pokémon and Magic The Gathering, which operate a rotation of card legality as a preventative measure against power creep, Yu-Gi-Oh!'s Ban List is updated every few months to curb the professional game, handicapping the decks that dominated the previous format while encouraging players to experiment with new decks and cards.

While some cards take brief stints on the Ban List before being unleashed once again into the game after their effects have been dampened by newer cards or Yu-Gi-Oh!'s evolving pace, others have been banned since the very beginning. Often the most powerful cards are deceptively simple, with just a couple of lines of text rendering them too unbalanced for competitive play.

While some restricted cards effects' are weakened over time, there are some cards that just can never be un-banned without breaking the game, with a number of these being released in Yu-Gi-Oh!'s earliest sets.

10. Soul Charge

Soul Charge Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

A staggeringly powerful Spell Card, it's a surprise that Soul Charge was ever released. The fact that it was published as late as 2014, when Konami really should have had a bit more foresight when it comes to balancing power, is more shocking still.

For a measly 1000 Life Points per Monster and one lost Battle Phase, players can revive any number of creatures from their Graveyard, refuelling their entire Field. Essentially acting as five Monster Reborns in one (with very little added drawback), Soul Charge not only opens the door for players to Special Summon their most powerful Main Deck Monsters after thinning their Deck, but also allows duelists to easily access material for Synchro, Xyz and Link Summons.

A very versatile Spell, Soul Charge can create an insurmountable barrier of Monsters which even the most talented opponent would struggle to overcome. In a format full to the brink with archetypes that revolve around endless streams of Special Summons, Soul Charge is even more overpowered now than it was in 2014.


9. Dandylion

Dandylion Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

Unlike other Monsters that generate Tokens, which usually require being destroyed and sent from the Field to the Graveyard, Dandylion spawns two "Fluff Tokens" when it is sent to the Graveyard from absolutely anywhere, meaning players can thin their Deck or use Dandylion as Tribute, Synchro or Link fodder to Special Summon two incredibly versatile Level 1 Tokens on top of any other positive effects they may have already gained.

While the Tokens cannot be Tributed for a Tribute Summon during the turn they are Summond, there is absolutely no rule preventing them from being used as Synchro, Xyz or Link Summoning. As Level 1 monsters, they are perfect Synchro material; but two Fluff Tokens can also allow the player to bring out any number of powerful Link-2 monsters with ease.


8. Yata-Garasu

Yata-Garasu Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

Banned due to the infamous Yata-Lock that plagued the game way back in the early noughties, Yata-Garasu is an extremely dangerous card. There's little wonder it has been outlawed since the introduction of the first ever Ban List in 2004.

If the turn player is ever in a position to deal Battle Damage to their opponent with the 200 ATK Spirit Monster, it's safe to assume that their opponent won't have much in terms of defences in their hand anyway. Yata-Garasu's ability to prevent the opponent from drawing can result in an infinite loop (as the turn player can Summon Yata-Garasu again the very next turn, attacking and skipping the opponent's Draw Phase again), effectively locking out the opponent from playing the game.


7. Painful Choice

Painful Choice Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

Losing four cards just to add one to your hand might have been something of a drawback in the early days of Yu-Gi-Oh! when the game was little more than a battle of beatsticks. However, Painful Choice's ability to search out any card from the Deck, thin the Deck and beef up the Graveyard with Special Summon fodder (maybe even generating a couple of those pesky Fluff Tokens in the process), makes it an absolute beast of a Spell Card with three incredibly powerful positive effects and absolutely no drawbacks all rolled into one.

Indiscriminate card searchers, the ability to thin the Deck by five cards (an eighth of the Deck) and to add four cards to the Graveyard are all effects which in themselves can make a card worthy of the ban list, so a Spell which does all three is unimaginable in today's game.


6. Graceful Charity

Graceful Charity Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

Much like Painful Choice, Graceful Charity is a Spell Card which provides three advantages and absolutely no drawbacks.

Not stopping at simply allowing the player to draw three cards, the turn player can then discard two of them. Again, like Painful Choice, this second effect was probably initially intended as a drawback, getting rid of cards that the duelist may have needed.

However, the modern game is marked by the facility with which cards can be recycled from the Graveyard, with the majority of Monsters being more easily accessible from the Graveyard than from the Deck. Making Graceful Charity even more ridiculous, the turn player chooses which of the cards to discard, essentially giving them three chances to seek out a specific card they might need in a situation on top of their regular Draw Phase.


5. Makyura The Destructor

Makyura the Destroyer Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

Though Hand Traps (Monsters whose Quick Effects can be activated from the hand) are becoming more and more common, Yu-Gi-Oh! still maintains a basic balance introduced at the start of the game. Trap Cards, which are often more powerful than their counterpart Spells, must be Set before they can be activated, ensuring players cannot play these powerful cards straight away and giving their opponent a chance to clear them off the field.

Makyura The Destructor, however, turns this preventative measure on its head, completely overthrowing the balance of the game. Though Makyura's effect only lasts for one turn, often that turn - along with one well-timed Trap Card - can be enough to change the course of the Duel.

A Level 4 monster, Makyura is extremely easy to Summon, and can provide a permanent Field presence, with many players unwilling to destroy Makyura in order to not trigger its devestating effect.


4. Last Turn

Last Turn Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

Last Turn has one of the most unique concepts in the entirety of Yu-Gi-Oh!, effectively setting up a Mexican standoff situation between one Monster the turn player controls and absolutely anything the opponent chooses to Special Summon from their Deck.

However, Last Turn is just too easy to abuse, and its requirement (the player must have 1000 or fewer Life Points remaining) can encourage Duelists to play self-destructively, or otherwise completely undermine their opponent's strategy and potential near victory, with players only having to Summon one Monster with high ATK points in order to guarantee a win.

Unlike Self Destruct Button, a similar banned Trap Card which forces a Draw, Last Turn actually allows the player to snatch a win they had absolutely not earned, making Last Turn perhaps the most un-sportsmanlike card in the game.


3. Magical Scientist

Magical Scientist Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

A staple in consistent FTK decks, Magical Scientist's stats (300 ATK and DEF) are completely at odds with what is without a doubt the most overpowered Monster Effect in the entire game.

For 1000 Life Points, players can Special Summon one Level 6 or lower Fusion Monster from the Extra Deck - no once per duel, no once per turn, hardly any restrictions bar the Monster's inability to attack directly and having to be returned to the Extra Deck at the turn's close.

Even then, the sheer pool of powerful Level 6 Fusion Monsters that can be summoned is phenomenal, making players able to clear the opponent's Field with ease. Overpowered even when Fusion Monsters were the only cards in the Extra Deck, the introduction of Synchro, Xyz and Link Monsters - the most powerful of which Magical Scientist can easily provide fodder for - guarantees that Magical Scientist will never make it off the Ban List, no matter the Meta.


2. Fiber Jar

Fiber Jar Yu-Gi-Oh
Konami

On par with Last Turn, Fiber Jar is a game re-setter which requires minimal set-up from the player, able to dismantle any board with ease.

Shuffling all cards in the field and Graveyard into the Deck, Fiber Jar essentially starts the Duel over, with only players' Life Points remaining the same.

If Fiber Jar is Flipped on the opponent's turn, it's a nasty surprise that undermines all of the meticulous set-up and preparation that went into the construction of their Field. If Fiber Jar is played on your turn, it's a potential game ender.

Unlike the true first turn of the Duel, in which the turn player is prevented from attacking their opponent, Fiber Jar's effect has no such reservations. After flipping Fiber Jar, the player is free to construct a new board, ready to attack their opponent directly with no resistance whatsoever.


1. Pot Of Greed

Pot of Greed
Konami

The most infamous card in Yu-Gi-Oh! (and likely the history of Trading Card Games), Pot Of Greed only has three word in its text box: "Draw 2 cards".

In an age where Yu-Gi-Oh! cards are stuffed with so much text they're borderline illegible, it's easy to wonder why a simple three word card -- introduced in Legend Of Blue Eyes White Dragon, the game's very first booster set -- has been Forbidden for sixteen years.

Quite simply, Pot Of Greed is just too damn powerful. In a game which is arguably more about deck construction than strategy, the ability for any Deck to play a +2 card with absolutely no drawback is too staggering to comprehend. The majority of cards that revolve around drawing in Yu-Gi-Oh! provide a considerable drawback for relatively little benefit, are too slow for serious play, or provide some comparable benefit to the opponent.

Pot Of Greed is little more than an empty space in a Deck. And, in a game where every single card counts, the ability to cut a 40 card Deck to 38 is just too powerful to keep.


In this post: 
Yu-Gi-Oh
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

When Matteo isn't cashing in on a lifetime of devotion to his favourite pop culture franchises and indie bands, he's writing and publishing poems and short stories under the name Teo Eve. Talk about range.