10 Brutal Gaming Cutscenes That Still Haunt You
If watching them was bad, just think: somebody had to animate these.
As a general rule, death is something games teach you to avoid at all costs. No-one likes having hours of progress flushed down the toilet, and no-one likes watching characters they care about get murdered before their eyes. Some games, however, push this even further, by having special cutscenes dedicated to putting the protagonist through the most horrific situations imaginable.
Hours of animating, art and scripting work, all with a single purpose: To let you know that you just messed up really, really bad. While some of these deaths or otherwise traumatising moments are unavoidable, others are specially-tailored scenes based on whatever painful way your hero just kicked the bucket.
While a simple ‘Game Over’ screen might not leave much of a lasting impression, sometimes, games are intent on utterly traumatising you. Here’s 10 of the most brutal video game cutscenes that still haunt you to this day.
10. Lara Getting Skewered - Tomb Raider 2013
2013’s Tomb Raider reboot was a triumphant return to a series that had become increasingly risk-averse in previous years, and serves as an origin story for a more fleshed-out, human Lara Croft. Among other additions, it featured gripping, Uncharted-style set pieces, a semi-open world, and what was, at the time, one of the most satisfying bows in gaming.
The game also took a bloodthirsty glee in how many creative and cruel ways it could murder its heroine. Not content to ever let the player relax for more than a few brief moments, many action-heavy cutscenes also featured QTEs the player would need to succeed in if they wanted to avoid Lara getting mulched into so much hamburger meat.
Pickaxe through the chest? There’s a scene for that. Getting crushed by a giant boulder? There’s a scene for that. Lara getting her face chewed off by hungry wolves? You’d better believe there’s a scene for that. As brutal as these scenes all were, none quite matched the nonchalant callousness the game shows when it casually decides to skewer Lara through the throat with a sharpened stick because you didn’t slide down a hill quite the way it wanted you to. Oof.
9. A Bloater Borrowing Joel’s Face - The Last of Us
As every true fan of The Last of Us knows, Joel canonically survived the events of the horror masterpiece, and would then go on to live forever. This didn’t stop the 2013 game including a lot of hypothetical death scenes for the Nicest Man in Gaming, though, and perhaps none were quite as disturbing as watching Joel get his face torn off by a bloater in the basketball court of an abandoned school.
Up until this point in the game, you’ve only had to deal with a few different types of mushroom zombies, both of which go down fairly easily. It’s a big shock, then, when you finally face off against the chonky, gas hurling bloater, who’ll likely take every last shell in your inventory before it finally goes down.
Oh, and if this wasn’t enough, the thing will also kill Joel instantly if you let him get too close to it. Death may seem fairly mundane in The Last of Us’ post-apocalyptic world, but there’s nothing standard about the way the bloater tears Joel’s face apart like an unwanted piece of junk mail. Rough.
8. Emily’s Opticians' Appointment - Until Dawn
Supermassive’s 2015 interactive horror film Until Dawn is still an excellent spookfest in 2020, and one of its best features is how it knowingly utilises the sort of tropes that make lesser games fall flat.
Until Dawn knows a simple truth. Namely, that most horror protagonists are unlikeable idiots. You’ll have as much fun letting Until Dawn’s cast die as saving them, and perhaps none are more unlikeable than abrasive mean girl Emily.
There are several ways Emily can meet her end - you can even have one of the other characters shoot her, if you’re having a particularly bad day - but none are as brutal as watching the ghoulish wendigo perform impromptu eye surgery on her à la Blade Runner. The difference is that Rutger Hauer doesn’t have a set of three-inch claws. Ouch.
7. X Gon’ Give It To You - Resident Evil 2 Remake
By the time we find reporter Ben Bertolucci locked up in a cell next to Racoon PD’s parking garage, there’s a good chance we’ve got no real idea what the hulking, relentless Mr X is actually capable of. We’ve seen him casually move a crashed helicopter out of his path, sure, but if we’ve been playing well, there’s no chance we’ve actually let the buffest man to ever wear a fedora anywhere near us.
Then we meet poor Ben, who's locked himself up to stay safe from Racoon City’s terrors. It works, too, at least until Mr X breaks through the wall behind him, grabs his head, and pops it like a grape.
This alone would be terrifying enough, but the game’s camera doesn’t miss the opportunity to linger on the reporter formerly known as Ben’s freshly-popped eyeball dangling out of the remains of his skull. Tasty.
6. Mind Parasite, Make Yourself At Home - Baldur’s Gate 3
When most people picture Dungeons and Dragons, glorious tales of adventure spring to mind. Warm, welcoming taverns overflowing with delicious ale. Brave heroes facing off against noble, terrifying dragons. Solving fiendish riddles to gain entrance to ancient ruins.
Larian Studios, however, have decided that Dungeons and Dragons is all about a bloated, purple worm with approximately 40 billion teeth burrowing its way through the gap between your eyeball and your brain, and making itself as snug as a bug in the deep recesses of your skull. What’s worse, you get a front-row, first-person seat to watch this thing saunter on down to the back of the bus. In this metaphor, the bus is your head.
Baldur’s Gate 3 isn’t going to let you forget you’ve got a disgusting, parasitical stowaway nesting in your cerebellum anytime soon, either. Barely a conversation goes by where the ticket-dodging worm doesn’t make itself known, whether by randomly granting you freaky psychic powers, or just causing you tremendously catastrophic migraines. We hope you bought some Ibuprofen.
5. Playing With Scissors - Outlast
Outlast’s Mount Massive Asylum is a chaotic place, so it’s a reassuring comfort to know that you can at least turn to its consummately professional medical staff in case of an emergency. One such professional is self-styled surgeon Rick Trager, who is courteous enough to give player character Miles a relaxing break in a wheelchair, before giving him a free checkup. What a gent.
After offering to take Rick outside to enjoy the fresh mountain air, Trager wheels the journalist into his surgery room, where he gives a delightful lecture on economics, then offers to remove Rick’s troublesome fingers with a pair of bone scissors. Again, a true gentleman.
A fantastically creepy voice performance from actor Alex Ivanovici, coupled with the protagonist's rapid breathing and screams of anguish, make this a nightmarishly memorable cutscene.
4. All My Friends Are Dead - Mass Effect 2
OK, so this one is far less gory than some of the others, but that doesn’t make it any less emotionally traumatizing. The Mass Effect series is well loved for having some of the best character writing of any RPG series. Mass Effect 2 uses that writing to get you completely invested in its cast then, should you make a few bad choices, ripping them away from you and leaving you alone in the cold emptiness of space.
The second Mass Effect game is often viewed as the series’ Empire Strikes Back for its grittier, ‘belly of the beast’ tone, and nothing is more emblematic of this than the infamous ‘suicide mission’ that acts as its finale.
To the game’s credit, it does go out of its way to repeatedly remind you that you should probably do some preparation for the practically impossible mission. Should you choose to ignore this advice, you can look forward to a heartbreaking hour of watching everyone you care about die horribly.
3. The Goggles Do Nothing - Clock Tower 3
Sometimes, it’s not enough for a brutal cutscene to shock you, gross you out, or otherwise make you want to boil your eyes. Sometimes, a cutscene has that special something that makes it genuinely disturbing. Cult horror classic Clock Tower 3 has one such scene.
The game follows protagonist Alyssa, and separates itself from other survival-horror titles by only really having one enemy to deal with at a time, albeit one that pursues you relentlessly throughout. Each chapter introduces a new foe, alongside a backstory for them. The second terror she meets is Corroder, a serial killer who murders his victims with acid.
Corroder alone isn’t all that terrifying, but the game introduces his backstory in a cutscene that’s equal parts heartbreaking and disturbing. Alyssa experiences a ghostly flashback where the Corroder invades the home of an elderly woman and her son, gleefully shrieking as he traps them both in a vat of acid. Words can’t really do it justice, which is probably for the best.
2. Stroggification - Quake 4
You can’t make a horrifically malformed cybernetic demon without buzz-sawing off a few limbs, as the old saying goes. No game knows this better than FPS Quake 4, which buys you a front row seat to the entire process of turning a human into one of these monstrosities. We hope you weren’t all that attached to your legs, although you won’t be needing them where you’re going.
Quake 4’s infamous ‘Stroggification’ scene straps you into the world’s worst theme park ride for one of gaming’s most uncomfortable first-person cutscenes. What makes the whole thing worse is that there’s someone right in front of you having the exact same thing happen to them, so you get to see every agonising detail play out before it's your turn in the spotlight.
But hey, at least you get some nice new robot legs. Painfully welded on to the bloody stumps where your own legs used to be. Yay.
1. Happily Families - Outlast: Whistleblower
Another entry from the Outlast series, sure, but no other game really does traumatising cutscenes quite like it. Plus, this one is in-keeping with the buzzsaw theme from Quake 4. Strap in, this one’s a doozy.
Outlast: Whistleblower is home to hopeless romantic Eddie Gluskin, a homicidal maniac intent on finding the perfect bride. Unfortunately, it’s slim pickings in Mount Massive, so Eddie is forced to rely on... less conventional methods. I won’t detail those methods here, but protagonist Waylon Park gets to experience them up close from inside a locker, before Gluskin ties Park down for his own romantic evening.
Two years before Kojima did it, Outlast: Whistleblower managed to leave players with enough phantom pain to last a lifetime.