10 Cancelled Video Games That Would Have Been GOTY
You could release this Indy game now and it would still be incredible.
The process of making a video game is a strenuous one, in all the ways you can imagine. Ensuring the engine is correct, getting artists to render environments, auditioning voice actors, hiring good developers - just thinking about it giving me a hernia, so I better stop.
As it is such a complex and mammoth task, many projects often don't see the light of day, or at least the interior lights of a storefront. Usually this isn't cause for concern; many developers cut their losses if a project can't get off the ground and nobody ever finds out.
However, there have been times when a game has been in development for months; it has a fanbase, all the potential for greatness, but suddenly it's stopped dead in its tracks and is cast away like a fart in the wind. So, with that odorous image firmly established, here are ten games that would not have stunk, and actually had a chance at Game of the Year had things not gone pear shaped.
10. This Is Vegas
Ah, Las Vegas. The site of greed-guzzling casinos, epilepsy-inducing light shows and very few video games, oddly enough.This Is Vegas could have changed that, and solidified itself as an example of a great action game, had it not met its end before release.
Set in the city of... yep, obviously, the game would have seen the City of Lights as the basis of its Saints Row style of glamour and guns. An open world action/gambling simulator doesn't sound like the most unique game premise out there, but Vegas's commitment to its setting could have differentiated it from its competition from Rockstar and Volition.
The trailers also did a decent job of exemplifying exactly what is so interesting about Vegas: the lights visible from the moon, scantily-clad dancers, the grim prospect of losing all of one's savings in one misjudged roll...
All of it was visible from the first glimpse, and it may have made its mark in how to properly convey a game's setting, but Midway's bankruptcy and an overinflated budget killed any chances Vegas had of relishing on PS3 and 360.
9. Dirty Harry
Movie tie-in games are rarely good at all, and there have been few virtual adaptations of classic films that released before many consoles even came out. Both indicate a surefire failure, but Dirty Harry developed by The Collective, with its open world San Francisco and indicated morality system, could have shaken that up entirely.
With assistance from Warner Bros. and Clint Eastwood himself, the game adaptation of the iconic franchise would be an LA Noire style sandbox in which you play the rogue detective hunting down baddies throughout the city. Hints at a good/bad way of playing similar to the Infamous series would apply based on how the game was played and how missions were conducted.
A different spin on the sandbox crime simulator that GTA inspired so much of, the game could have been the gruff and grizzled sibling of Bondi's Noire had it actually released, and with Eastwood's involvement it appeared as though it was going to be a definitive hit on PS3 and Xbox 360.
All seemed well enough; there was even a trailer released, albeit one with no actual gameplay. But, due to budget stresses, Dirty Harry was officially shelved before it ever got a chance to shake things up. Darn bureacrats.
8. Daredevil: The Man Without Fear
Superheroes are, if you haven't noticed, kind of a big deal right now, and thus superhero games are clambered after with vigorous fervor. 2018's Spider-Man saw the iconic web-slinging wisecracker get his shine on PS4, but long before him the Man Without Fear was receiving the virtual treatment.
Developer 5000ft Inc. was asked by Sony to develop a tie-in game for the 2003 Ben Affleck film. Now that sounds like a treacherous venture into generic movie-tie-in-game territory in which hardly anything stands out, but Daredevil: The Man Without Fear had the potential to be something different.
Sony wanted to implement grinding mechanics to allow Daredevil to slide along wires throughout New York to make up for his more limited traversal capabilities, and would also feature a vision mechanic similar to the Arkham series's Detective Mode.
These, along with the typical combat and upgrading of abilities commonplace in games of the time, would coalesce together to make a unique and interesting superhero video game the likes of which wouldn't be seen until Spider-Man 2 for the PS2.
Unfortunately, conflict between developer and publisher led to disputes over the game's direction and it would not see the light of day, not unlike its protagonist.
7. Prey 2
Science fiction holds a strong presence in gaming: Deus Ex and the Mass Effect series effectively pioneered the genre in the virtual plane, and even modern titles such as Dead Space and Alien Isolation hold a prominent position in the sphere. Even with these strong titles, Prey 2 could have matched them all had it not been relegated to the area I assume the unedited original Star Wars trilogy is held.
Playing as Killian Samuels, a US Marshall transported to an alien planet and having had his memories wiped, the game would have seen you take on jobs as a bounty hunter in a hostile city not unlike Blade Runner's LA inhabited by even scarier looking creatures than actual LA.
Obviously there would have been more going on, but one of its first trailers featuring the Johnny Cash song Rusty Cage was captivating beyond belief and it shot the number of eyes on the game to numerous digits. The gory but fluid shootouts, the grimy city, the towering behemoth at the end...
The trailer is still worth watching today, even if it leaves a bittersweet feeling as we hold the knowledge that Bethesda shelved Prey 2 out of fear for its quality. They also thought Fallout 76 was good enough to release. Hmm.
6. Whore Of The Orient
History is a gold mine for game settings, so much so it's bizarre that a franchise like Call of Duty is the only one to have pulled it off to mass success. Even more strange is the concept of faux-history and its lack of game adaptations.
With that in mind, Whore of the Orient's concept of a Western-occupied Shanghai attempting to cleanse itself of communism was a bold and extremely fresh idea from Team Bondi, of LA Noire fame, that plays up the real historical event of the Red Scare and plants it firmly in the skull of the player.
Had they developed it further, Bondi's fresh take on detectiving in Noire could have lent itself to Orient in unique ways, blending their attention to detail with 1940s America with engaging gameplay to bring something truly original, truly different to the gaming world.
This just makes it even worse to know that Whore of the Orient was scrapped for undisclosed reasons, throwing any hope of historical teachings out the window faster than any scent of socialism in West-owned Shanghai.
This stings more especially considering Bondi's seminal Noire hit. Orient could have been genuinely special had it not been for its abrupt cancellation.
5. Gotham By Gaslight
Once again we find a superhero adaptation like we do everywhere else in pop culture, but Gotham by Gaslight hits a little different than Daredevil.
Based on the highly regarded graphic novel, Gaslight is set in a 19th century Gotham centered on Batman's attempts to take down well-known Victorian delinquent Jack the Ripper.
Aesthetically, the game would have looked so much more impressively different than not just any other superhero games, but most other games in general. The setting of a 20th century city inhabited by historical versions of popular characters is a good sell on its own, and the early footage provides an eerie glimpse into foggy lamp lit streets and its great render of the Caped Crusader.
With the reason behind cancellation being THQ's failure to get the rights to adapt the novel, one can only read the source material to visualize what a full game would look and play like.
With the Arkham series retired by Rocksteady it feels like a natural next step to adapt one-off stories such as Gaslight, but that's only if such rights can be procured and it is based on a great story, as Gaslight was intended to be.
4. Legacy Of Kain: Dead Sun
If there's one early series that seriously deserves a new entry in glorious 4k HD, it's Legacy of Kain. The fate-altering vampire led bite-'em-up has had its fangs in PlayStation's neck since the first console sprang onto the market, and Dead Sun was Climax Studios's attempt to invite the series back home.
Old favourites Raziel and Kain were swapped out for a new protagonist in the form of Gein, a vampire who seeks revenge but becomes inevitably involved in a much grander story. Typical stuff for a game story, but the Kain series had proven it could deliver on such a story in a fantastic manner, so investment was high in Dead Sun from day one.
When news that the game's breathing was stopped, fans and writers were outraged and many different outlets covered it, criticizing heavily the move to cancellation well after so many people were invested in the franchise's revival.
Many years on, and Legacy of Kain is still in dire need of a PS4 transfusion. Dead Sun's wounds still linger, and many fans pine for the series to return to form.
3. Indiana Jones & The Staff Of Kings
This one comes as a bit of a stretch, but The Staff of Kings was originally planned for release on PS3 and Xbox 360 before it was reduced to only the earlier generations, so it deserves a spot. Also, it's my list.
For such a popular character, Indy has had no full length video game adaptations outside of the PS2 port of Kings and his LEGO interpretation. As a result, the downgrade for Kings hurts a lot more, especially after viewing the test footage.
Utilizing the Euphoria physics engine as seen in LucasArts' The Force Unleashed series, the game would follow Jones and his journey to find Moses' Staff before the baddies do, obviously. In which case, gun and fist fights would ensue in glorious ragdolly manner as with Starkiller's galactic antics.
Staff of Kings is still available for PS2, but it is a damn shame that the game never got a next-gen release. Indiana Jones is a series that would triumph on console under LucasArts, but it being played down to an earlier generation release means many mechanics that could have potentially been implemented simply couldn't be.
Maybe they thought the PS3 had snakes in it.
2. Star Wars 1313
A long time ago, at a games convention far, far away, LucasArts premiered a trailer for an upcoming game under the Star Wars banner. Everything was so hush-hush that the details were demanded by everyone. And LucasArts delivered that and beyond with 1313.
A ship swooping into view over a city we can only assume is Coruscant, the reveal of the protagonist (played by Wilson Bethel who would portray Dex in Daredevil's third season, ironically), the gunfight at the end, the promise of a gritty and mature story in the Star Wars underbelly... It all sounded too good to be true.
Unfortunately, it really was, as Disney's acquisition of LucasFilms meant all current projects in development under Lucas were axed, including Star Wars 1313. And thousands of fans voices cried out, but were then silenced, as Disney gave the game licensing rights to *sigh* Electronic Arts.
1313 had the potential for greatness, giving gamers a thorough glimpse into the grimier stories within the Star Wars universe and the fact that the protagonist was not a force user was a breath of fresh air. Sadly, it appears we can only look to Jedi Fallen Order to see what could have been, in any case.
1. Silent Hills
Oh, Konami. Once a very trusted developer, now the butt of numerous jokes and memes, mostly from disillusioned Metal Gear Solid fans. The widely acclaimed P.T. on the PS Store struck a particular chord with gaming horror fans due to its excellent depiction of a twisted repeating hallway that gradually became creepier and more disturbing with every recycle.
Thus, when the end of the demo was reached, and Norman Reedus sttod tall in all his goateed glory before the Silent Hills logo appeared, fans went, to put it mildly, into a frenzy over the newest addition to Konami's psychological scare-'em-up series.
Alas, it was not to be, as director Hideo Kojima and the company came to blows; this eventually resulted in Kojima's exit from association with Konami and the subsequent cancellation of Silent Hills. Co-director Guillermo del Toro blasted Konami and announced he would not direct any more games due to the project's closure.
The passion from the fanbase turned into rage, spawning a petition to convince Konami to continue the project reaching nearly 200,000 signatures, but sadly it seems the full, probably scarier version of P.T. will never see the light, and will remain shelved in the darkest corner of Konami's basement.