10 Classic Video Games That DON'T Hold Up
They might be classics, but they're better remembered than played today.
Here at WhatCulture you’ll be able to find loads of lists where we lovingly celebrate the games of our past. Just because they’re old doesn’t mean they don’t totally still hold up! Well, except for the times that they don’t...
Nostalgia is a hell of a drug but sometimes even that potent stuff can’t conceal the fact that a game once great just ain’t what it used to be. We can totally appreciate them for what they were but we’d struggle to recommend getting a hands-on with any of these games this far into the 21st century.
We should clarify that we’re by no means saying any of these games are bad. Quite the opposite, they’re incredible, but whether graphics and mechanical upgrades have just come too far or the magic has faded, here are a bunch of games that absolutely earned their place in history, and should probably stay there.
10. GoldenEye 007
A game so good in its prime that it physically hurts us to put on this list, but unfortunately GoldenEye hasn’t aged all that well. Which is pretty fair enough given this one came out 25 years ago.
A large fault with how this one has aged is simply the graphical limitations of what was possible at the time. This is one of those games that if you grew up with it, it’s probably not going to bother you nearly as much but the combo of speeding through polygonal hallways, a low frame rate, and dated controls would make this one really tough to pick and play for the first time in 2022.
GoldenEye will always be iconic for the way it defined the FPS genre at the time and set the blueprint for what it could be, but you’d be forgiven for not wanting to re-adapt to the unusual mechanics and deal with the average AI which just doesn’t meet today’s standards.
In happy news, though, a clever group of people made GoldenEye: Source which is a total conversion mod for the game so just because the original hasn’t stood the test of time doesn’t mean the game’s magic isn’t still alive.
9. Might & Magic: World of Xeen
If you’re an enormous GoldenEye fan and I just hurt your feelings, here’s me coming for my own childhood game so we can all feel attacked together.
Might & Magic: World of Xeen is a combination game that includes Might & Magic 4 and 5. I still go back and play Might & Magic VIII pretty regularly and even that I would wildly struggle to recommend to even the most diehard CRPG fan in 2022, so sadly 4 and 5 are pretty much right out.
These New World Computing classics came out in a golden age of RPGs. Unfortunately that golden age being the early 90s, they haven’t quite kept up with the times. These were some of the earliest games to utilise animated cutscenes and pulse-code modulation, sound-based speech which is all very impressive. But not so impressive nowadays.
The interface is nigh-on impenetrable now and the graphics are what you’d expect from a game that came out in 1993.
It’s less of an issue with the later Might & Magic games as the interface evolved quite a bit and graphically they started using sprites for character models instead of ugly 3D models, but that change only happened after World of Xeen released. Might & Magic, we thank you very much for your service to party-based, turn-based combat RPGs but I begrudge no one for picking up Divinity Original Sin 2 instead.
8. Twisted Metal 2
Whether we give this entry to Twisted Metal 2 or the original is a bit of a moot toss up since they were both developed by SingleTrac and came out just one year apart, in 1995 and 1996 respectively.
If these games defined your childhood then you’re not alone and there’s a good reason for that, there really wasn’t anything quite like it when it came out.
Both games were financial and critical successes praised for their level design and colourful characters. Even so, the games were criticised for looking super average when they came out. That’s right, these games looked bad for 1995 standards so you can just imagine how they must look now.
While we don’t want to understate the joy of chaotic vehicular combat fun or the revolutionary impact this game had on the industry, the camera will frustrate the heck out of modern gamers, the mechanics are a lot to get your head around, and I mentioned the graphics right? Yeah, this thing looks like microwaved garbage.
It’s one of those things you’d never notice at the time but now it’s impossible to ignore. There’s also not all that much to do which was cool when you were a kid and just wanted to drive the car and make the guns go but might not be as satisfying now.
Yet again a happy ending for old school fans of the game though because the PS3 remake was massively well received so that’s one to check out if the classic isn’t to your liking.
7. Star Fox (1993)
I’m hoping you’ve got the message this far into the list that when we’re talking ‘classic’ video games we genuinely mean the cream of the crop, absolutely iconic games from their time because that’s Star Fox for the SNES. Star Fox is another one of those games you’ll be more able to forgive if you remember playing it when it came out in 1993 and you’ve got those nostalgia ties.
Trying to play it this year for the very first time would be a bold move indeed but feel free to see if it pays off.
As a sweeping statement it’s easy for us to just say that any early 3D game was the coolest thing on the planet when it came out and now they look understandably, incredibly rough. While we have no qualms about it earning its spot as one of the best video games of all time and being the first Nintendo game to use polygonal graphics, well, let’s just say you can tell it was the first one.
While we’ll always back ace pilot Fox McCloud, Star Fox’s visuals and mechanics make his first foray a little tricky to go back to. At least we’ve still got Star Fox 64.
6. Grand Theft Auto III
This one is another great example where you’ll think differently about it entirely based on how old you were when you played it. When I played this as a kid all I cared about was driving around and causing mayhem, I definitely didn’t think twice about the graphics. GTA 3 more than served what it could be and needed to be when it came out in 2001.
It just likely isn’t the GTA game you’d be reaching for now and a big part of that is Rockstar improving the formula with every entry.
This game was beloved for its sound, gameplay and world design when it first came out. The franchise embarked on 3D graphics for the first time and the models looked great. In short, this one was a slam dunk. It just happens to be that that slam dunk was 21 years ago so what was revolutionary at the time is now a little rough around the edges.
All of the older GTA games naturally suffer under the technical limitations of their time as you’d expect. The character models and animations haven’t held up, the indecipherable faces and low-poly graphics are forgettable, and there’s just very little reason to drop back to this one when Rockstar took every facet of it and improved it for each subsequent entry in the franchise. The controls are classically clunky for this period of games that were just getting to grips with 3D, and modern players will struggle with the lack of a cover system, frustrating vehicle handling, and cars that’ll seemingly blow up by just looking at them sideways.
While everything GTA 3 did was super important for setting the groundwork for what would come next, you’re better off spending your time with a more recent GTA and appreciating what GTA 3 built than actually trying your hand at it.
5. Metroid (1986)
Metroid as a franchise is so vital to gaming history, it literally kickstarted a genre. While the series would go to some really special places, and you shouldn’t overlook entries just because they’re old, you could get away with overlooking the very first entry which was released on the Nintendo Entertainment System in North America in 1987.
The wild amount of grinding to restore your health when you die and uninspiring level design will likely grate on gamers who try to pick it up now. As will the lack of direction which, while exciting at the time, is generally not what gamers prefer nowadays.
Like GTA, Metroid just got better as it went so unless you really want to see where it all started, there’s very little reason to go back to the original.
There’s no map and a tonne of corridors that look exactly the same. Though these elements make the platformer more frustrating than anything else and limitations like having to stand still in order to aim are unlikely to win any new fans, Metroid’s legacy is undeniable, so we can still appreciate this one for that.
4. Sonic Adventure
On the whole, old school 3D platformers have had trouble ageing well and Sonic Adventure is absolutely no exception.
The 1998 Sega Dreamcast adventure was massively praised on release for its visuals, so much so it was just about the best any video game had ever looked at the time. Critics were less kind to the game’s FMV cutscenes and voice acting but the gameplay was generally quite impressive.
Having said that even back in the 90s this one caught some flack for having an incredibly frustrating camera and boy that hasn’t changed. The voice-acting might be worth it for the comedic value but otherwise it’s cringe-inducing and the controls have aged like milk. I know this one has its fans but unfortunately it’s hard to pinpoint many things in this game that haven't aged badly. From the movement to the level design and story progression, it’s tedious at best and frustrating at worst. You might be able to forgive it if it’s a childhood favourite but otherwise you’re likely to struggle to get joy out of this one.
I’d like to say that chilling with the blue blur is never a bad thing but if you’re considering going back to Sonic Adventure I’d suggest spending your time with literally any other game.
3. Final Fantasy VIl (1997)
Here is the part of the list where I get really scared about upsetting you, so let’s just say Final Fantasy VII is absolutely one of the best games in the series. It’s also really old and hasn’t stood up super well which is probably why they’re halfway through remaking it (and the remake is absolutely fantastic).
I feel like that about covered it but let’s dig a little deeper anyway.
A wonderful story with a phenomenal soundtrack and gorgeous visuals, Final Fantasy VII suffers only from being a product of its time. Is it still one of the greatest games ever made? Absolutely. But it’s hard to deny that 25 years on the visuals of course don’t hit like they used to. The blockheads would be pretty funny to a newcomer and the once gorgeous pre-rendered backgrounds just look pixelated now. 3D PS1 games all largely suffer from the same issues as time has gone on, and it's only due to FF6 being 2D that that entry has aged better visually. Similarly, the once innovative combat system grates a little more now, the frame rate drops a tonne in battles, and the English localisation is pretty terrible.
Much like GTA 3, while it’s incredibly cool that FF7 was the first 3D entry, time has certainly taken a toll.
But like we said, the Remake is a slam dunk so if you can’t vibe with the original we’ve got this one. And the second half will hopefully come out sometime before the heat death of the universe.
2. The Sims
The Sims 1, like many games on this list, changed everything when it came out, and it was an absolute joy. This one is a victim of just how far the series has come and how much it has evolved. Now the series offers more ways to play than ever, it looks gorgeous, you can play the whole thing as an RPG if you want to, there’s complex trait systems and a suite of ways to individualise your characters.
Whether this came to a head in The Sims 3 or The Sims 4 is debatable but going back to the 2000 original makes absolutely no sense.
Though it set the groundwork for almost every system and feature in the game, including a bunch of the townie NPCs who would go on to be mainstays for the net 20 years, the visuals just don’t look good any more, the UI is ugly, the animations are super stiff, and your options to engage, build, and play around are just a lot more limited. All that said, the soundtrack for The Sims 1 is simply stunning so I have to give it that.
1. Tomb Raider (1996)
People like to joke about games being literally unplayable but a lot of elements in the original Tomb Raider do make that an almost accurate descriptor.
Lots of the games on this list can be celebrated for what they established in their respective series and franchises even if they themselves didn’t stand the test of time. Tomb Raider is pretty much the poster child for that concept. Though it was celebrated in 1996 for its unique mix of puzzle solving, platforming, and exploration, it really hasn’t aged well.
The polygons are straight up out of control (yes the ones you’re thinking about), the tank controls which were common at the time are pull-your-hair-out level agonising, and the textures make almost every non-Lara thing look like an indecipherable block. The save system that only lets you save at certain points and the camera with a mind of its own don’t help matters either.
We love Lara, we love how far the Tomb Raider series has come, and we love that because there are plenty more great games in it we don’t have to play the original ever again.