10 Classic Video Games (That Have Aged Horribly)

Your nostalgia is subject to change.

GTA III Staunton Island
Rockstar

Video games are many things: they're a form of entertainment, a way to make new friends and sometimes even works of art.

But they are also technology and - like most tech - they have an expiration date. As gaming advances, it's natural that some old games will succumb to the ravages of age. The process may be significantly slower for many, but even the very best games will eventually start to show some cracks.

In fact, sometimes it is the very best games that get hurt by age the most. You want to remember them for the classics that they were in their day, but then you actually try to play them again and find that they barely retain their former glory.

It doesn't mean that these aren't necessarily good games or that they don't deserve to be remembered as classics. It just means that time has been especially cruel to them.


10. Mortal Kombat

mortal kombat
Midway Games

Growing up, the question in school was always "Are you a Street Fighter kid or a Mortal Kombat kid?"

The key phrase there is "growing up". As time wears on it's hard to not look at the original Mortal Kombat as a one trick pony that cared more about making waves through its outlandish design, technological innovations, and violent content.

Mortal Kombat is not completely devoid of merit, but it does lack substance. The motion captured animation style severely limited the characters' movement capabilities and as such many matches are reduced to spamming cheap projectile attacks and spin kicks. The paltry amount of characters actually available to choose also makes it nearly impossible to actually develop a playstyle and feel particularly embarrassing in retrospect when compared to the amount of fighters available in similar titles of the era.

To really appreciate just how archaic this game is, try playing it on the Super Nintendo where the violence is all but gone. With that extreme element out of the equation, it's almost impossible to get any joy out of playing the original Mortal Kombat even from a nostalgia standpoint.


9. Crash Bandicoot

Uncharted 4 Crash Bandicoot
Naughty Dog

In an age where it was still considered to be necessary to have a system mascot; Crash Bandicoot served as Sony's representative for many.

It's amazing he ever achieved such a lofty standing considering that the initial Crash Bandicoot game was not very good. Many of its failures can be chalked up to the limitations of the Playstation system itself at that time. For as capable as Sony's inaugural system was from a technological standpoint, it always lagged behind the N64 and other rival systems when it came to creating true 3D worlds.

Crash, in retrospect, feels like an elongated tech demo for the possibilities of 3D gaming on the Playstation. Its pseudo-3D art style seemingly forced developer Naughty Dog to limit the gameplay to that of the most basic of 2D platformers. That higher level of skill that made some of the better 2D platformers as great as they are is removed entirely. What's left are a few design charms that help lend some lovability to Crash and his world and little else of note.

Developer Naughty Dog was of course just getting started in terms of what they would contribute to gaming, but their first major title has become an unfortunate representative of the limitations of its time.


8. Grand Theft Auto III

GTA III Claude
Rockstar

It would be difficult to justify a list of the most important games of all time if it didn't include Grand Theft Auto III. Rockstar's open world masterpiece wasn't the first of its kind - or obviously even the first of its franchise - but nonetheless completely blew open the world of game design.

It wouldn't be long, though, before developers everywhere would take the foundation the game laid and build much greater works upon it. Even the direct follow-up GTA: Vice City released just one year later would so substantially improve on the offerings of GTA: III that the previous game would essentially be rendered obsolete.

But Grand Theft Auto III's rapid aging isn't entirely a result of how much its successors would offer. Even at the time of its release many noted just how poorly GTA: III actually played, but wrote-off those shortcomings due to how notable the game itself was. Attempting to go back to this game's style of mission design, combat and general structure makes trying to appreciate its modern merits too tall of a task.

At the end of they day, Grand Theft Auto III is just not that much fun to actually play.


7. Banjo-Kazooie

Banjo Kazooie Freezeezy Park
Rare

A revolutionist is either typically viewed as a hero or villain with little grey area in-between. Usually, the difference is entirely based on the how their cause is viewed in retrospect.

In the same way that Mario 64 is treated as a heroic revolutionary experience for how it changed 3D gaming, there is a growing viewpoint that Banjo-Kazooie set the genre back in the long-term. This is mostly due to the game's emphasis on collecting. Whereas Mario 64 was more about the exploration of its world and the possibilities that environment afforded the player, Banjo-Kazooie placed more value on feeling its world with stuff. Stuff which then needed to be collected.

Sure Mario 64 had items to collect, but they were largely used to mark where players needed to go next and to create unique challenges. Banjo just gave you a to-do list of things to pick up if you wanted to experience the game in full. Its stylistic elements and moments of interesting gameplay make it impossible to fairly call Banjo-Kazooie a one trick pony, but unfortunately the game would set a design precedent where large world games would become a breeding ground for decreasingly compelling collectible items and objectives.

At its best Banjo-Kazooie is a slight step below Mario 64's brilliance. At its worst the game is a slightly archaic forebearer to a style of design that is quickly wearing out its welcome.


6. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater
Activision

Poor Tony Hawk's Pro Skater. Unlike some other games on this list, it is not hard to appreciate why Tony Hawk's Pro Skater was such a big deal when it was released in 1999. Skateboarding culture was reaching heights that few could have predicted and the game's buttery smooth control scheme placed it leagues ahead of any other similar title that had come before. It was the right game at the right time.

That said, you can't overstate just how much Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 improved the franchise. The introduction of the "manual" trick allowed for players to string together combos that could not be dreamed of before. There were other minor tweaks and improvements from the first game, but that one gameplay overhaul so drastically opened up the gameplay possibilities that going back to what came before was not an option.

Your memories of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater being the greatest thing ever are not without justification, but be sure to leave them as just memories.


5. Tomb Raider

Tomb Raider Playstation
Square Enix

Playing the original Tomb Raider is a lot like listening to a drunken man spouting conspiracy theories. There's amusement to be found in their ideas, but ultimately there's not much substance to them.

The basic structure of Tomb Raider is a tremendous preview to the full potential of the 3D action-adventure genre. Many of the concepts it made functional would not be fully realized for years to come. It was the Indiana Jones game we always wanted at a time when such a thing felt like a pipe dream.

Sadly, it is also a game that would be classified as broken today in many respects. Its controls were appalling, the level design was confounding and the presentation was best in a class that frankly didn't have many students in the first place. The most joy you get out of playing Tomb Raider today are the moments when it feels technically functional.

They are moments few and far between.


4. Resident Evil

Resident Evil Jill Valentine
Capcom

The horror... the horror.

The most significant survival-horror game ever made remains scary today for reasons that were never quite intended. An archaic control scheme becomes the glue for obtuse puzzles and frustrating combat sequences all justified by poorly translated - and poorly delivered - lines of dialogue that form a basic story. Meanwhile, scenes of absolute frustration will destroy whatever good will you may have to look at Resident Evil as the notable video game release that history has properly deemed it to be.

The very good news about Resident Evil is that it has received a number of HD remakes that address many of the issues which plagued the original game and do a great job of preserving the qualities that made Resident Evil great at the time.

Just stay far away from the original Playstation release.


3. Shenmue

Shenmue Dreamcast
Sega

The one thing that nobody has ever denied about Shenmue is how far ahead of its time the game was. An open world cinematic masterpiece chronicling a kung-fu mystery/revenge story was the kind of game that many had dreamed of in their wildest fantasies, but never thought would be possible.

However, the implication that usually comes with a game being ahead of its time is that it didn't quite fit into the era it was released in. That's certainly the case with Shenmue as the game's ambitions would sadly outstrip the gameplay's reach. Like movies that suffer from too long of a runtime, Shenmue's faults largely lie in an inability to create enough compelling gameplay to last the length of the story. Too much time is spent aimlessly wandering and engaging in gameplay sequences that feel like they're trying to serve as bridges between actual, significant moments.

In a way, you can forgive Shenmue for its infamous translation issues and other quirks. They're actually kind of charming in a strange way. What is much harder to forgive is how underdeveloped the meatier aspects of Shenmue are.

Those shortcomings make for a game that is often more fun to reminisce about than actually play.


2. Goldeneye

goldeneye natalya
Rare

It feels wrong to speak ill of Goldeneye. To do so feels like betraying a longtime friend that you promised you would remain loyal to forever.

Goldeneye is not unique in the way that age has hindered its once innovative ways. Playing it recently, what struck me most about the game is how limited the player actually is. The free aim system that is in place is far too clunky to be your primary mode of play, meaning that most of the gameplay is limited to auto targeting shooting that asks little more from you than to point yourself in vaguely the right direction as your enemies and start pulling the trigger. There is little feeling of actual participation.

What separates Goldeneye from a pack of other games that suffer from such aging issues is how significant of a role the game had in many people's lives. It created friendships as well as lasting memories, and to this day the phrase "Goldeneye Parties" can summon the goofiest smile on the surliest face. The memories that people have of this game are as tangible as the game itself and that makes trying to go back to it a shocking experience.

Much like Tony Hawk's Pro Skater, the things that Goldeneye did well at the time deserve to be remembered. It is important, however, to realize that the game itself is a relic of another time and that continuing to compare modern experiences to your memories of the game - rather than the game itself - is a disservice to how much the medium has advanced.


1. Myst

Myst PC
Brøderbund

Have you ever stumbled upon an old photo of yourself sporting period specific fashion that is now drastically out of date and said "My god...what was I thinking?" If so then you'll know what its like to go back to Myst after all these years.

You can't understate the appeal of shiny and new when it comes to appealing to the mass market, and that's exactly what Myst was in 1993. It was a way to show off the raw graphical power of the CD-ROM format and it blew PC user's minds on the way to becoming the best-selling PC game of all time until the release of The Sims.

That's a statistic that would shock most modern gamers who can look past the game's dated visuals to find only a third rate puzzle adventure game. Myst's story and world are not nearly as grand as the game would have you believe from the outset, and the puzzles themselves are of that annoying design that aims to be as confusing as possible without ever once really approaching "clever" territory.

Many of the games on this list can ultimately be forgiven for being a product of a different time, but the success of Myst compared to the success of far superior similar titles at the time has gross implications on just how susceptible people can be to raw technological beauty else when using their buying power to determine the industry leaders.

In other words: Myst is basically the gaming equivalent of James Cameron's Avatar.

--

Which other games belong on this list? Share your favourites below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

An entertainment enthusiast living in Brooklyn, trying to make his way by slinging words at blank pages.