10 Comic Characters Still Waiting for Video Game Justice

If only every superhero game could be as good as Batman's Arkham series.

Superman-64-Cover Comic book characters have been making the jump to video games for decades, yet the majority of these games tend to - well, they tend to suck. More recently we have seen Batman and the Arkham series take the gaming world by storm, but even Batman has his Dark Tomorrow. Spider-Man has seen a number of games in his history, with a few hitting the mark, and many more falling short. There are a number of characters who have either starred in their own terrible games, or perhaps made an appearance in another more popular titles without getting much time for themselves. There are even a few characters who have had games fall into developmental hell and never get finished, published, or ever heard from again. We are going to take a look at 10 characters who have yet to see a game that really does them justice, starting with:

10. Aquaman

Offending Game - Aquaman: Battle For Atlantis (Lucky Chicken Studios) Largely considered one of the worst games ever made, Aquaman's only game title came out for the Xbox and Nintendo Gamecube, but we kind of wish it hadn't. Sloppy and disorienting controls made exploring the washed-out and abandoned city of Atlantis tedious and unfulfilling. You battled repetitive villains in two modes: swimming around the city and mashing a button to fight, or piloting a ship in the worst underwater Star Fox rip-off I've ever seen. The infuriatingly useless gameplay reminds us of another terrible comic game we will talk about later. Featuring the only-in-the-'90s version of Aquaman that saw the character grunge out with a hook for a hand, the game remains to this day a stain on the character, and video games in general. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rOQFZefkSNk How It Should Play: As with any good adaptation, first we need to look to the source material for inspiration. Geoff Johns has spent a few years building the character up to a new level of popularity, and any game developer would be a fool not to take that into account. With a number of villains peppered throughout the game, Aquaman can play a series of missions set both underwater and above ground that would actually utilise not only his unique abilities, but capitalise on some of the coolest moments of Aquaman's recent rise to respectability. Special Move: Mentally calling and controlling a huge sea monster to take out the last copy of Battle for Atlantis, save the city, and enjoy some Mera-time.

9. Fantastic Four

Offending Games - Fantastic Four (Probe Entertainment Limited), Fantastic Four (7 Studios) Our first look at a game featuring a playable Fantastic Four was ironically nearly unplayable. A terrible beat-em-up that was full of bugs, with controls that made it hard to walk, let alone use any of the team's powers. The second game was based off of the unsatisfying movie, and equally fails to deliver an entertaining game, plodding through the movies storyline and offering mundane missions like slowly moving flowers in space against a ticking clock. While the team was utilised far better in Marvel's Ultimate Alliance games, it still left us wanting more. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nwi6ys8cZAY How It Should Play: The Fantastic Four work best as a team, and the game should reflect that. While multiplayer-only games have their pros and cons, a third-person action game that featured four players locked in as the various members of the Fantastic Four would make for an interesting game, and offer the potential for some intense superhero/Halo style deathmatches. With a number of great locales, storylines, and villains to choose from, not to mention a ton of other playable characters using former members of the FF (She-Hulk, Wolverine, Medusa, etc.), the potential for a well done game featuring the Fantastic Four is intriguing, to say the least. Special Move: Flame On with the best of them as your team takes out the opposition with nothing but trash talk and terrible voice acting.

8. Iron Man

Offending Games - Iron Man , Iron Man 2, Iron Man 3 (Sega) Three games, each based off of their respective films, and all equally terrible, have taught us exactly how not to make an Iron Man game. The first game - developed by Secret Level/Artificial Mind and Movement - introduced us to a boring, disappointing mess of horrible visuals, floaty controls, and possible motion sickness. The second game - developed by Sega Studios - was a shorter version of the first, with two choices of armor - Iron Man and War Machine - to struggle with in a ridiculous shoot-em-up that is trying, chaotic, and not really worth the effort. Iron Man 3: The Official Game was developed by Gameloft, went straight to mobile users and played like Sonic the Hedgehog crossed with Space Invaders... but not cool at all. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_oLRmnzsmt8 How It Should Play: This seems like a no-brainer, especially when basing any game off of a movie like the Iron Man series - FIRST PERSON SHOOTER. We spend so much time in that helmet on screen we might as well get nice and comfy behind all the brilliant colours of the HUD while we take on the various villains from the comics. A few third person quick time segments mixed in with the Mechwarrior-like first person levels along with a healthy mix of armours to choose from would make this game a hit for any comic fan. Special Move: Assembling the Hulkbuster armor to completely destroy your opponent in online suit warfare.

7. Spawn

Offending Games - Spawn (Ukiyotei), Spawn: Armageddon (Point of View) The first Spawn game was a typical side-scroller that we had seen countless times before, and while not the worst of its kind it certainly didn't offer anything new to the gaming community. The gameplay was laborious and involved the use of hard combos that were unnecessary to master. Spawn: Armageddon arrived on the PS2 and offered up better graphics as it brought Spawn to the streets to battle all sorts of monsters as basically a third-person shooter. Unfortunately, the difficulty was low, the game physics were frustrating and Armageddon ended up being dull and boring, as were most of the other Spawn games that were released to similar lacklustre responses. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_5kgR0Vfd0s How It Should Play: Spawn would benefit the most using the Arkham formula of games, but keeping it even darker and full of the great qualities that made Spawn such a hit; moving away from boring combos and repetitive missions in favour of a heavily story-based game that sees Spawn moving across his city using chains, cape and hell-powers among the various missions that carry him through the game. Keep some of the same great cast of characters from the early comics while featuring a number of his craziest villains, all in a tightly scripted story that could make for the fun, time-consuming game that Spawn deserves. The current game mechanics inspired by the Arkham games, along with some serious power/artillery upgrades, and ridiculously huge boss battles would give the character new life in the video game world. Special Move: Spawn teleports to hell to make Malebolgia answer for the previous Spawn games in an arena deathmatch for the win.

6. Green Lantern

Offending Game - Green Lantern: Rise of the Manhunters (Double Helix Games) Another movie-based game, Rise of the Manhunters is unique in that it is a fairly simple and unoriginal game, but still managed to entertain at times, despite the ridiculous dialogue and button-mashing sensibilities. The game does cause frustration due to the sheer potential awesomeness that comes with a Green lantern video game, which we watch slip away every time GL constructs another hammer or baseball bat, although some of the later unlockable constructs offer a bit more imagination. Other appearances by GL in video games are usually incredibly linear and don't tap into the best qualities of the character at all. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Osko13AiBIQ How It Should Play: Any Green Lantern game needs to fully embrace the Corps. Hundreds of characters have worn the GL ring over the years, leaving a huge cast to feature in a game that shouldn't be confined to one city, planet, or even solar system. Green Lantern should be a game that sees the Corps policing the galaxy, moving from system to system with a recruited team of GL's, much like the widely successful Mass Effect series. The constructs in the game would be a key factor to making it work, and would allow for a number of customisable options, the least of which would be the design of the GL uniform. Whether entering the Corps as a new recruit or leading it as your favorite GL character, the game could reach new and old fans of the character alike, especially if they offered a construct customising option for game coders to truly make the game your own. Special Move: Reach 100% completion to watch a special cinematic of Guy Gardner getting one-punched by Batman, because it is still that good.

5. Hellboy

Offending Games - Hellboy: Asylum Seeker, Hellboy: The Science of Evil Asylum Seeker - developed by Cryo Studios - is considered one of the worst games to show up on the Sega Dreamcast, which is quite an illustrious award for a long line of terrible games that followed the system into nothingness. The game had spent a few years in development, which left it out-dated and under-performing on newer consoles (the PS version had greatly inferior graphics). The Science of Evil - developed by Krome Studios - came close to making a good Hellboy game, but also suffered from diminished graphics and gameplay on the next-gen consoles it released on. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tghmDDN0orw How It Should Play: The core of anything involving Hellboy is the art and creativity of Mike Mignola, which is crucial to making a new video game work. The rich cast of the BPRD would add to the horror-themed game as Hellboy embarks on one of his many supernatural adventures. The setting is key, as is a unique story that would flesh out Mignola's beautiful world in a way we have never seen. I would be happy controlling Hellboy as he uneventfully walked through some of the fine pages of artwork we've seen over the years, but we can probably do better than that. Special Move: After using his Right Hand of Doom to destroy his previous games, Hellboy loads the crumpled remains of Asylum Seeker into the Samaritan, lights a stogie, and blows the audience away.

4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Offending Games - All of them... except Turtles in Time, of course. I know, Turtles in Time - developed by Konami - is and forever will be one of the best games we ever played in our childhood. Unfortunately, we haven't seen too many TMNT games come close to that level of entertainment, which most developers seem hellbent on re-capturing the side-scrolling awesomeness of, with little to show for it. A number of handheld and plug-n-play games were released, and a few more recently that each pulled from the various animated series' on at the time, which were usually made as fighting games. Recently, Out of the Shadows - developed by Red Fly Studios -, which was partially based off of the new Nickolodeon series, was released to dismal reviews, which were fitting considering the game was bogged down by technical difficulties and sloppy gameplay. How It Should Play: Open world seems to be the answer to a lot of games, and TMNT is no different. Moving around, above, and beneath the city as your favourite turtle, with a dedicated multiplayer mode that allowed for the other members of the team to be controlled and play the game along with you. The game would need to find it's own direction, not relying on or being hindered by any of the animated versions that came before. Instead, developers would need to move forward with a new vision, using the original Eastman and Laird run as a guideline. Special Move: A ninja spin kick that allows us to avoid the inevitable Michael Bay movie tie-in game.

3. Silver Surfer

Offending Game - Silver Surfer (Software Creations) While the Surfer has appeared in a number of games featuring Marvel characters, his only headlining game for the NES was forgetful, frustrating, and frankly, pretty difficult. Players, using a crude simulacrum of the Surfer, navigate the side scroller in fear of everything from rubber ducks to the walls and floors of the game, as a single hit killed. The boss battles featured lame villains, and out of the huge selection of powers the Surfer has in his possession, the game relies solely on a repeating stream of silver pellets that can be upgraded to shoot more of the same. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVI9yUPOc2A How It Should Play: Norrin Radd AKA the Silver Surfer has such a rich origin story, and a third person action game that follows his creation at the hands of the planet-eater Galactus would do the character justice. The game would follow his time as the herald, preparing planets for Galactus to devour, until finally the Surfer arrives on Earth, where he rebels against his master using all the Power Cosmic as his disposal. The potential for a really good Silver Surfer game is staggering, considering the scope and scale presented with the characters. Like a galactic Shadow of the Colossus, playing as the Surfer rebelling against Galactus would be a video game moment to be remembered. Special Move: The ridiculously awesome soundtrack, coupled with the death screen from the game. 'Nuff said.

2. Daredevil

Offending Games - Daredevil (Cancelled), Ultimate Alliance 1 & 2 (Raven Software) Daredevil has appeared in a few games over the years in a supportive role, but only once has he ever come close to headlining his own game. The game itself looked terrible, in a weird cross between Activision's Spider-Man and Tony Hawk's Pro Skater. Gamers and comic fans alike should be glad this game never came out, and even Matt Murdock can see that his inclusion in the Ultimate Alliance series was just a tease. While using the character as a part of your team was always fun, it did little to tap into what makes him so great. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qSNgXKCwLwo How It Should Play: Making a game that could properly develop and visualise Daredevil's unique powers, including the fact that the main character is blind would not be an easy task, and it wouldn't work in just any ordinary game. Luckily, the gaming world is continually evolving, and we've come to enjoy the level of storytelling and gameplay we find in adventure games like Telltale Games The Walking Dead or The Wolf Among Us. An adventure story game that mixed elements of third person battle scenes while playing along with the story in a unique gameplay experience sounds like the best way to bring Daredevil to the gamers properly. Special Move: A special radar sense that lets us avoid any other terrible games featuring Daredevil.

1. Superman

Offending Game - All of them, but especially the travesty known as Superman 64 (Titus Software). With the exception of Death and Return of Superman (which only gets a pass because it was an okay side-scroller that adapted the storyline... well enough), there has never been a good Superman game released. They have either featured the character in ridiculous situations that fail to utilise his powers, offered a red version of him for the second player with no explanation why, or the worst offence... making a Superman game into an impossible-to-control flight simulator that results in one of the worst games ever made in the history of games. Even the movie game for Superman Returns, which provided the best attempt to date at an open world Superman game, fell flat and missed the mark of what makes Superman a fun character to play as. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNpBwU3PTX8 How It Should Play: The key to a great Superman game is power. If I'm donning the tights of THE superhero, I want to feel super. What all of these games have lacked is the feeling that Superman could deflect an asteroid if needed, and his prime responsibility should not be escort missions or time spent flying around uselessly. This needs to be an open-world game in more than just classification. We want to be able to fly high above the city of Metropolis to float in the atmosphere, where Superman can best pinpoint where his particular set of skills is needed, and then drop in to go to work on the latest villain, giant monster, natural disaster, or any other job that only Superman can handle. Obviously making a Superman game isn't easy, as we've seen 10+ terrible games, but the secret just may be to go bigger than any game has gone before.
Special Move: Getting the biggest open world game ever conceived into the hands of gamers faster than a speeding bullet.

Honorable Mentions

Thor - God of Thunder was the movie tie-in game and came off as pretty lackluster. Almost terrible enough to make the top 10, however despite many glitches and frustrating repetition, it was still somewhat cool to bring the hammer down. An actually good game of Thor would further explore the various realms of the universe while not wimping out when it comes to giant god battles. Blade - Blade has appeared in Ultimate Alliance, as well as the fairly mediocre Ghost Rider game, but his only offering so far was the movie tie-in Blade II that was beyond terrible. What it did do, was open up the need for a really good Blade game that taps into the horror crowd while keeping the comic fans interested. Green Arrow - Green Arrow has shown up in a few Justice League/DC universe games, but the Emerald Archer could take his quiver to the streets of Star City much like Bats did in Gotham. Trick arrows, staunch politics and a game any sniper enthusiast would fall in love with makes a GA game a sure thing. The Flash - Also featured in a number of DC ensemble games, the Flash has never received his own game, much to the chagrin of his adoring public. While the super speed mechanics might be hard to develop in game, if done properly it could be less like Sonic the Hedgehog and more like the quick, chaotic movements of games like the underrated Vanquish. Captain America - Cap has starred in a few games, with his latest (Captain America: Super Soldier) coming so close that it hurt. The fight mechanics and use of the shield were inspired, but the game itself was boring, void of any life, and lacked any sort of punch. However, since using the shield to reflect a bullet back at the attacker, then tossing it to take out two or three more attackers, then catching in time to once again to reflect another shot felt so good, of course it would leave us wanting more! Which comic characters do you think still deserve some video game justice? Let us know in the comments section!

Contributor
Contributor

Sent to Earth from a dying planet, young Scott Fraser grew to adulthood in Alberta, Canada with a love for comics, film, games, and all things deep fried. He has dedicated his life to pedantic ramblings about continuity, superhero superiority, and Han shooting first. He also writes for Geek Magazine.