10 Criminally Underrated Comic Book Video Games You Must Play

Yes, Transformers was originally a comic book. And yes, you absolutely MUST play Fall of Cybertron.

Transformers Fall of Cybertron
Activision

For the longest of times, comic book video games weren't exactly what you would call a hot commodity. Sure, they sold well, but video game developers always seemed to struggle nailing the transition from panel to pixel, a fact made worse, no doubt, by the industry's now extinct fascination with movie tie-ins.

Fortunately, this is no longer the case. Thanks to the likes of Rocksteady, Insomniac and even NetherRealm - the studios behind the Batman: Arkham series, Spider-Man PS4 and the Injustice franchise respectively - comic book video games are now at the forefront of the medium, pushing technological and storytelling boundaries in all kinds of different ways.

Of course, it's important to remember that there were still genuinely GREAT comic book video games before Arkham Asylum released in 2009. Some of the more notable examples include 2004's Spider-Man 2 movie tie-in, or even 2006's Marvel Ultimate Alliance. However, there are other, slightly more overlooked and indeed underrated comic book video games that released over the last two decades, all of which are well worth playing.

They might not be perfect, but the following titles are definitely in need of some new attention - especially from those who love comics.


10. Justice League Heroes

Justice League Heroes
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

It ain't no Marvel Ultimate Alliance, but Justice League Heroes is far from the terrible release critics opined it to be when it released in 2006.

Made in the vein of Raven Software's X-Men Legends series, Justice League Heroes put players in control of some of the League's most iconic members, including Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman, among many others. It didn't have four-player capability and certain levels locked players into the roles of two specific heroes, but it was still great fun, boasting a varied enough roster to keep things fresh over its eight-hour runtime.

DC fans are sure to get a kick out of the game's story too, with it featuring the likes of both Braniac and Darkseid as major antagonists, while lesser-known foes like Killer Frost and Queen Bee also feature.

Ultimately, the fact Justice League Heroes released the same year as Marvel Ultimate Alliance didn't do it any favours. It's nowhere near as good as Raven's epic RPG, but as a fun, linear co-op title that let's you play as some of DC's finest? It's pretty commendable.


9. Batman: Rise Of Sin Tzu

Batman Rise Of Sin Tzu
Ubisoft

One of the many video games based on Batman: The Animated Series, Batman: Rise of Sin Tzu released in 2003 and sort of... disappeared soon after. Not literally of course, but one could be forgiven for forgetting the game even exists, given the lack of attention it's received in the years since.

Developed by Ubisoft (back when their name was Ubi Soft - how retro), Rise of Sin Tzu put players in the shoes of Batman, Robin, Batgirl and Nightwing as they took on Sin Tzu, a brand new Batman villain created by superstar artist-turned-editor Jim Lee.

Sin Tzu himself may not have caught on as well as BTAS' other famous creations (Harley Quinn and Renee Montoya), but he was a formidable threat for the game and boasted a fun design.

The basic premise involves Sin Tzu organising mass breakouts at Arkham Asylum and Stonegate Penitentiary, which leads Batman to take on some of his more famous adversaries in Scarecrow, Clayface and Bane, among others. Gameplay itself was fairly rudimentary, not pushing any boundaries as far as the beat-em-up genre is concerned, but the addition of co-op made the whole thing worthwhile.

If you're a fan of BTAS and want a fun enough excuse to jump back in, you could do a lot worse than to play Rise of Sin Tzu.


8. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: Battle Nexus

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2 Battle Nexus
Konami

Yes, while the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles may have primarily made a name for themselves through cartoons and films, the brothers four actually started out life in the pages of a Mirage comic, written and drawn by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird.

Of course, if you were to recommend any one TMNT game for fans to play, it would be Turtles in Time. (The original - not the iffy remake.) That said, there are a few hidden, Turtle-y awesome gems out there for players to find if they go searching, and for those who loved the 2003 animated series (y'know, the one with the CRAZY good theme and dark tone), Battle Nexus should be their first port of call.

A follow-up to the show's first beat-em-up tie-in that released in 2003 (another fun title, by the way), Battle Nexus adapted the second season of the show and allowed up to four players to take control of Leonardo, Donatello, Michelangelo and Raphael, as well as other bonus characters like Splinter, Casey Jones and the edgiest edgelord space samurai to ever wield a giant scythe... thing, Slashuur.

It's definitely not the most intricate game going, but it's nowhere near deserving of the dismal review scores it got upon launch. Grab a friend, a slice of your favourite pizza, and enjoy bashing Foot ninjas while quipping terrible shell-based puns.


7. Spider-Man: Edge Of Time

Spider-Man Edge of Time
Activision

Activision will never know what a good thing they had going with studios like Beenox and High Moon. The two companies now handle support for Call of Duty these days and little else, but at the beginning of the 2010s, both were busy working on different comic book franchises.

For Beenox, that franchise was Spider-Man. Treyarch had long abandoned their web-slinging days by alternating with Infinity Ward on Call of Duty, but there were promising signs that Beenox could deliver.

For starters, 2011's Spider-Man: Shattered Dimensions was fantastic. The studio made a brave call in divesting from the open-world formula that had governed Spidey's game since the 2004 movie tie-in, and it paid off, with the studio getting the chance to bring four different Spider-Men to life, all of which featured different voice actors from Spidey's past.

But with success came many pitfalls, and it's still the case that Shattered Dimensions remains Beenox's best offering. The Amazing Spider-Man was... fine, while its sequel was the victim of a rushed development cycle (another reason to be thankful Activision now no longer have the Marvel license).

Still, there is one other Beenox Spidey game that I feel as though gets a bit of an unfair rap, and that's Edge of Time. It downgraded Shattered Dimension's four Spider-Men to just two, but it has a superb story written by veteran comic book writer Peter David, and fun enough gameplay to boot. It might not be up there with the best, but it's far from the disaster its review scores would imply.


6. Guardians Of The Galaxy: The Telltale Series

Guardians of the Galaxy Telltale
Telltale Games

Until its demise the other year, Telltale Games had built up a solid rep for delivering compelling comic book video games, channelling the spirit of old-school, LucasArts-esque point-and-click adventures into solid works like The Walking Dead, The Wolf Among Us and Batman.

There is one offering from the studio that's gone a little under-appreciated through, and that is Guardians of the Galaxy.

Released just after Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 premiered in 2017, Telltale's interpretation of the team borrowed heavily from the films but adopted an aesthetic more in line with Marvel's comics. It shares continuity with neither, which gave the studio's writers the freedom to craft their own story without any potential restrictions.

The end is result is really enjoyable, and if you're familiar with Telltale, you'll know what to expect.


5. Batman Vengeance

Batman Vengeance Boxart
Ubisoft

I've already spoken about how great Batman Vengeance is in an article a while back, but it deserves mentioning again because - hoo-boy - it's still really overlooked.

Vengeance is another Ubisoft Bat-title and one that also follows on from Batman: The Animated Series. It's effectively a 'lost' episode, with the game's style and presentation mirroring BTAS' near enough perfectly. All the usual suspects are there as far as the cast's concerned, with Kevin Conroy and Tara Strong reprising their roles as Batman and Batgirl respectively. Mark Hamill, Arleen Sorkin and Bob Hastings also return to voice Joker, Harley Quinn and Commissioner Gordon.

The gameplay is pretty decent, but it's the story and presentation where Vengeance really shines through. It features a bombshell opening and an eerie tone throughout, but the cherry on top is that each level comes with its own title card, just like the animated series itself.

That isn't to say the gameplay is forgettable or anything either. Combat and navigation is fun and intuitive, and Ubisoft went to great lengths to grant players access to the Dark Knight's entire arsenal, featuring an assortment of gadgets to play with. Even the Batmobile and Batwing make appearances!

It's nowhere near as definitive as Arkham, but players won't find a better game based on BTAS than Ubisoft's criminally overlooked title.


4. X-Men Legends II: Rise Of Apocalypse

X-Men Legends 2 Magneto Wolverine
Raven Software

Another studio sadly lost to Activision's focus on Call of Duty, Raven Software was one of the most prominent groups of developers in the early-to-mid-noughties.

Raven were responsible for Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast, as well as its follow-up Jedi Academy - two of the most critically acclaimed Star Wars games ever made. However, they're perhaps most fondly known for their Marvel games - particularly Marvel Ultimate Alliance and 2009's X-Men Origins: Wolverine.

While those two titles are stellar, and encapsulate the best bits about Raven, it's meant that their other two Marvel games - X-Men Legends and X-Men Legends II: Rise Of Apocalypse - have gone overlooked. This really makes no sense, as apart from the change in roster, there is nothing about either title that makes them inferior to MUA.

They're probably the most authentic X-Men games fans have ever gotten, and those who've read the comics are bound to get a double kick out of them. The gameplay is just as good as MUA's, and while the cel-shaded graphics aren't too incredible, they get the job done. Plus, there's the added bonus of cinematics from Blur Studio, which more than hold up today.


3. Batman: Arkham Origins

Batman Arkham Origins
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Okay, so, Batman: Arkham Origins. It's my favourite Arkham game! And it's also one that was an unfortunate victim of circumstance.

When Origins was announced in 2013, it was facing something of an uphill climb. Fans were still digesting the bombshell ending to Batman: Arkham City, and when it was announced the next entry in the series wasn't going to be a sequel - and that Rocksteady wouldn't be developing it either, no less - there was a bit of a backlash. Arkham was seen as Rocksteady's baby, and without the studio at the helm - and with no Kevin Conroy or Mark Hamill - Origins was almost seen like an imposter; a distraction before normal programming resumed with Arkham Knight.

I'm not saying that Origins didn't have its problems, because it did. It wasn't as polished as the Rocksteady entries and it's understandable why the recycling of certain content would've frustrated players, but its pros still far outweigh its cons.

For starters, Arkham Origins has the best story in the entire series. Joker and Batman's first meeting has been played out so many times in the comics and on film, but Origins found a way to make it fresh and exciting. Fans also tend to overlook the many gameplay advancements the prequel made, with Montréal bringing the Batcave, CSI-style detective work and new enemy types to the fore. PLUS, it kinda... sorta... has the best boss battles in the entire series. (But don't tell Rocksteady I said that.)

If you found yourself writing Origins off back in 2013, or did play it and didn't find it to your liking - give it another shot. You won't be disappointed.


2. Ultimate Spider-Man

Activision

Ultimate Spider-Man is one of those games I look back on and just... wonder how it even exists?

Games based on specific Spider-Man comics had been a thing before, sure - but the years running up to 2005 had seen Activision and studio Treyarch pivot to movie tie-ins, with 2002 and 2004's Spider-Man games both being adapted from the Sam Raimi Spidey films. There was no indication the studio would look to the comics for inspiration, let alone one as specific as Ultimate Spider-Man.

The Ultimate Universe may be consigned to the back-issue bin nowadays, but it was everything at the turn of the century, with Brian Bendis and Mark Bagley leading the charge on a new take on everyone's favourite wall-crawler.

Next to the original Stan Lee, Steve Ditko and John Romita comics, Ultimate Spider-Man is the web-slinger's best run. It was one of Marvel's biggest sellers, reaching the zenith of its popularity arguably around the same time Treyarch decided to adapt the series to the gaming medium, and is something every Spidey fan should read, given the chance.

But is Ultimate Spider-Man (the game) underrated? Yes. Not by a long shot, but it is. The game has long been overshadowed by its hugely influential predecessor - Spider-Man 2 - but just because a game was influential doesn't mean it's superior. Ultimate Spidey is an improvement over the 2004 game and for plenty of reasons, not least because it adapts the art of the comic perfectly, but also because it gave players access to Manhattan AND Queens.

2018's Spider-Man game is still the wall-crawler's best, but Ultimate Spider-Man deserves the silver medal.


1. Transformers: War For / Fall Of Cybertron

Transformers War for Cybertron
Activision

Like the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, it may surprise some people to learn that the Transformers started out life as a comic book too. Granted, they were developed in conjunction with Hasbro and Takara, but the entire lore behind the series was invented by Marvel's Bob Budiansky, with industry legend Dennis O'Neil even coming up with the name for Optimus Prime.

Transformers is of course one of the most successful toylines of all time, but success doesn't always mean quality. The Robots in Disguise have suffered more than a couple of duff adaptations over the years, including the Bay films, but also in video games.

Which is why it was such an amazing surprise when High Moon came along, gathered up all the Autobots and Decepticons, and delivered one of the all time great comic book video games in 2010's Transformers: War for Cybertron. Oh, and then they followed that up with another stellar title in Fall of Cybertron, which added the Dinobots, which also automatically makes it the best thing ever.

High Moon don't get nearly enough praise for what they did on the Cybertron titles. They're both games you can tell were made with a great deal of love and care, by fans of the original cartoon and the toys that accompanied it. The fact they never got the chance to finish the series by taking it to Earth is one of Activision's biggest crimes, and the fact the studio is stuck on Call of Duty only adds further insult to injury.

--

Let us know which comic book video games you think are underrated down in the comments below!


Watch Next


You'll Never Get 100% On This Batman: Arkham Quiz!

batman arkham origins
Warner Bros.

1. In Which Game Did Joker Threaten To Raze Gotham City With A Series Of Hidden Bombs?

In this post: 
Transformers
 
First Posted On: 
Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.