10 Critically-Acclaimed Video Games NO ONE Played
Genius isn’t always rewarded.
Ordinarily a sterling critical reception translates to a lot players picking up your game. It’s a badge of quality, proving that the developers have put in the blood, sweat and tears to craft an experience that will justify your having parted with your hard-earned cash. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time; Red Dead Redemption; Bioshock: all rode that gold star of approval to gaming stardom.
Sadly, not all games meet with the same immediate success. Titanfall 2, Okami, Psychonauts and American McGee’s Alice are examples of games that got the good grades but were largely overlooked. But solid campaigning from dedicated fans and critics alike turned their fortunes around and won them the players they deserved.
Then there are the games that never got the player base, no matter how good the scores and how dedicated the fans. These are games that were the best in their genre, the most innovative titles ever made, or just plain once-in-a-lifetime masterpieces that did the hard work but never got the reward.
And some of these names might surprise you.
Time to redress the injustice and shine a light on those titles that were played by precious few, yet more than deserve a spot on everyone’s hard-drive.
10. Descent 3
The story of Descent 3 is a sad one.
The original Descent was something of a revolution. It popularized the six-degrees-of-freedom control scheme and was the first title to feature true-3D graphics. Add a maze of claustrophobic tunnels filled with mining robots gone rogue, and you had a game that was genuinely original.
Accordingly critical reception was glowing, citing not only its originality and graphics, but also its intelligent enemies and stellar sound design. Players also loved it: released in 1995, it, combined with Descent II, sold 1.1 million copies within three years.
Descent 3, released in 1999, expanded on everything that made its predecessors great, massively improving the graphics, enemy variety and AI, and sound design. The game also featured seamless transitions to brand new outdoor environments, an addition praised by critics for creating varied mission types that never got dull.
Yet despite being apex Descent, it sold only 53 000 copies within six months. One reason cited was its signature control scheme, which even critics found disorientating. Also, the rise of the first-person shooter, with its intuitive controls, meant that more demanding simulation-esque titles like Descent were no longer in vogue.
Descent 3 is still available to enjoy today, and spiritual successors like Overload keep the flag flying high.
9. Sacrifice
During their heyday developers Shiny Entertainment, of Earthworm Jim and MDK fame, had earned a reputation for the unconventional, so when it was revealed that its next project was an RTS, critics were intrigued.
And what critics got was both suitably brilliant and eccentric.
Played from a novel third-person perspective, Sacrifice casts players as a wizard in command of an army of truly weird and wonderful creatures. It was a menagerie that won universal praise, with one journalist admiringly describing it as an ale-fuelled collaboration between Salvador Dali and H. R. Giger.
Sacrifice was also praised for its visuals, including awe-inspiring spell effects enhanced by the third-person viewpoint and, again focusing on the creatures, for the fluid and believable animations that breathed life and immense character into those bizarre designs.
With all that unconventional brilliance it took an adventurous player to buy in, and indeed, though no sales figures were released, industry insiders confirmed that the game did poorly. One reason cited was marketing that failed to highlight the game’s strengths, and the other, perhaps more egregious misstep, was releasing the game a mere month after Red Alert 2.
Still, as winner of a number of Best Strategy Game of the Year awards, it remains well worth trying.
8. Rez HD
While other entries on this list are critically acclaimed games played by few, Rez is a critically acclaimed game few gamers have even heard of.
Combining the rail-shooter genre with the music game genre, Rez sees players shooting down viruses as they navigate levels best described as a Winamp visualizer meets the imaginings of M.C. Escher gone cyber psychadelic, all while an EDM backing track dynamically responds to the action.
It is a game that blurs the line between a video game and a piece of interactive art, and critics loved it, lauding the music, which appealed even to those not fans of the EDM genre, and stylized graphics that, as of the HD release, still hold up brilliantly.
Though it won numerous awards for innovation, and continued to be nominated for, and winning, awards as recently as 2016, the original, released in 2001, sold a mere 100 000 copies by 2003 in the US, with critics taking issue with the game’s lack of content (it’s about 2.5 hours) and concluding that it was perhaps too niche for its own good. With the HD upgrade Rez found its definitive version, scoring an 89 on Metacritic, but sadly the damage was done and it remains an under-appreciated title.
Rez Infinite, with VR support, is available on Steam.
7. ICO
ICO is a deceptively simple game. Adopting a ‘subtracting design’ philosophy, director Fumito Ueda crafted the game around a basic boy-meets-girls concept, reducing any element that interfered with that premise in order to create a fully immersive experience.
And it worked. ICO is a deeply emotionally involving game, one frequently cited as an example of video games as art.
But it took prodigious skill to craft that simplicity. The game was praised for the detail of its environments, the subtlety of the characters’ facial animations, clever puzzle design that guided you logically through without holding your hand, and a vulnerable companion who’s very vulnerability made you care about them. All this came together in what one reviewer described as a ‘game of perfect moments.’
Despite earning a Metacritic rating of 90, however, players weren’t sold, because ICO went on to shift a disappointing 700 000 copies from its 2001 released date to 2009. Ueda himself suggested that his minimalist approach may have hurt it, since most games were marketed via screen shots, and with ICO’s sparse interface there was little flash to market.
An HD remaster was released alongside Shadow of the Colossus for the PS3, so if you have an old unit handy and a disc gathering dust, ICO is well worth firing up.
6. FreeSpace 2
Along with System Shock 2, FreeSpace 2 is a game infamous for being brilliant but played by no one.
One of the most graphically advanced titles of its day, critics praised the extraordinary level of detail put into every aspect of the visuals, from the clarity of the backdrops, to the realism of its explosions, to ship designs that varied thematically from one faction to another.
As a space combat simulation dogfighting was key, and here too the game excelled, with Computer and Video Games citing its combat as the best of the classic space combat sims. A big factor in this was the scale and number of capital ships, which created an unmatched spectacle in which dogfights swirled among vast beam cannon blasts that could incinerate players in an instant.
But for all its bells and whistles it underperformed horribly. Released September 30th 1999, the game sold just 26 000 copies by the end of the year in the US. The reason came down to complexity: sims had a steep learning curve and were optimised for joysticks. Set against the newly popular first-person shooter’s easier controls and more accessible gameplay, the space combat simulation genre simply couldn’t compete.
Though now dated FreeSpace 2 remains on sale, so there’s no reason not to pick it up.
5. The Operative: No One Lives Forever
Though now better known for its Middle-Earth series, developers Monolith Productions were once an FPS powerhouse, producing acclaimed classics like Blood, Aliens Versus Predator 2 and the seminal F.E.A.R.. Appropriately their most highly-rated title is also an FPS, the criminally overlooked The Operative: No One Lives Forever.
A blend of first-person shooter and stealth game, The Operative is a delightfully inventive riff on the spy film genre. Praised for its graphics, clever AI, a fantastic sense of style perfectly on point with its Bond inspiration and truly witty humour, it was hailed as one of the best and most original shooters since Half-Life.
Unfortunately, while The Operative was not a flop, selling 350 000 copes in two years and doing well enough to merit an equally high scoring sequel, the numbers were disappointing for such a highly-rated game and critics found it difficult to explain why. Possibly the campy boxart and comedic tone invited inevitable comparisons to Austin Powers, or perhaps it was simply overshadowed by a little competitor called Perfect Dark, but either way few players picked it up.
To add insult to injury the game is no longer on sale, being mired in licensing issues, but untangle the mess and this game, and its sequel, are destined to become mega hits.
4. Planescape: Torment
Many an RPG fan would be stunned to see Planescape: Torment on this list. After all, it remains a regular entry in many a best of RPGs feature.
The game was universally praised for its writing (penned by industry maestro Chris Avellone), with critics giving it real literary weight, a big deal for a medium then still seen as something of a geek’s hobby.
The Planescape setting also earned much praise, eschewing as it did the Tolkien-esque fantasy of its competition for a world that is by turns demented, disturbing and grotesque, yet always utterly compelling. Add bright and colourful visuals, excellent sound design and a phenomenal soundtrack and you had a game that richly deserves its 91 Metacritic score.
If only anyone played it. Despite being released in 1999 it had sold a mere 400 000 copies by 2017. To put that in context, the equally obscure and highly regarded adventure title, The Longest Journey (91 on Metacritic), sold 500 000...by 2004. Ultimately, Planescape was probably a bit too weird for mainstream tastes, and its focus on narrative rather than combat didn’t help much either.
According to Avellone the game was ultimately profitable, but that it did so poorly remains a travesty. Fortunately the Enhanced Edition has updated the classic title for new audiences.
3. Conker's Bad Fur Day
Conker’s Bad Fur Day, a phenomenal game hamstrung by one of the most bizarre marketing campaigns ever.
Ninteno was a family friendly icon, Mario being its most visible face. The developers of Conker’s Bad Fur Day, Rare, however, created a firmly adult game, with toilet humour aplenty, copious sexual innuendo, and lots of over-the-top violence.
Critics understood what Rare was doing: the humour was described as ‘cleverly lewd’ and its spoofs of popular movies ‘dead on.’ On top of the comedy it was also a mechanically superb game, praised for its ‘drop dead gorgeous’ graphics, creative level design and an advanced facial animation system able to accurately portray Conker’s mood.
But most buyers did not understand. The game was was marketed to adult males by advertising in bars and adult magazines, this with a cute anthropomorphic squirrel as protagonist. Parents, fooled by said squirrel and the Nintendo label both, were horrified at the sophomoric content.
Consequently the game was arguably too cute for adults and too adult for kids. Hence, it flopped, selling only about 55,000 copies within its first month of release, low numbers for a game that earned a 92 Metacritic rating.
Today the game is no longer on sale, a real pity as modern gamers would be far more likely to appreciate it.
2. System Shock 2
System Shock 2 is arguably the poster-child for critically acclaimed games that bombed. It won seven Game of the Year prizes, earning itself a Metacritic rating of 92, and is considered highly influential, with its DNA in everything from BioShock to 2017’s Prey.
And yet it sold barely 58 000 copies in ten months, and it’s difficult to understand why.
A blend of first-person shooter mechanics and deep RPG customization options, the game was consistently praised for immersive, open-ended gameplay that allowed players to play as they wanted to, a rarity at the time.
Critics were also universal in their praise of the game’s horror atmosphere, achieved through an unholy marriage of a nightmarish story, exceptionally creepy enemies and horrifying effective, spine-chillingly disturbing sound design, all of which had one journalist describing it as the most frightening game he’d ever played.
But with the first title’s deserved reputation for slow pace and a clunky interface, System Shock 2 was perhaps always up against it. It didn’t help that it faced strong competition in the form of Resident Evil 3, Age of Empires II, and Pokemon Gold/Silver.
Still, it remains an eminently playable classic to this day, and with an enhanced edition on the way will hopefully win the player base it has always deserved.
1. Grim Fandango
The highest-rated title on this list, with a 94 aggregate on Metacritic, and one of the highest-rated games of all time, Grim Fandango is an adventure game icon.
Winner of numerous Game of the Year awards its production was top-notch. The graphics were jaw-dropping, the art direction vibrant and brimming with personality, the voice-acting superlative and the music perfectly suited to its Mexican Land of the Dead setting. The story is expertly written, a cartoonish film-noir adventure populated with a cast of wacky, sometimes tragic, characters that many a critic felt would make an excellent film.
But for all its critical acclaim player uptake was distinctly underwhelming. According to Tim Schafer, development lead, the game, released in October 1998, sold approximately 500,000 units by 2012. To put that in context, Thief: The Dark Project, a niche stealth title released the same year, sold 500 000 by May 2000.
Why it flopped is tragically easy to answer. The adventure game genre was dying and Grim Fandango’s poor sales were seen as proof, and even though publishers LucasArts would release Escape from Monkey Island, sequels to hit adventure titles like Sam & Max and Full Throttle were ultimately cancelled.
Fortunately a remastered version was released in 2015, allowing new players to experience this landmark title.