10 Critically-Acclaimed Video Games That BOMBED
If they're so great, why didn't these video games sell?
Normally, in any other commercial sector, if your products sell well and receive critical acclaim... they're considered outright successes, and your company will subsequently flourish.
Does your sandwich shop make great sandwiches which Sandwich Monthly's Bob Ploughman refers to as "a lunchtime tuna mayo de force"? Then, your sandwich shop will do well.
Unfortunately, however, the video game industry has scaled to a point very few other sectors have even come close to matching, and as such, critical praise and even huge sales volumes don't equal profitability. Games are now so enormous that some publishers don't even expect to make any money until several years after a game's release (and when success is never guaranteed, two to five years without breaking even is a big gamble to take).
It's not an outrageous claim to say the gaming industry has grown too bloated to fit into its own jeans, and that judging games to be "failures" if they only make tens of millions is maybe indicative that the AAA space needs to be taken down a peg or two.
Even so, this is the system we're currently playing with, and as such we can only expect more excellently-reviewed games (some with millions of copies sold) to still be considered "bombs."
10. Sunset Overdrive (XBOX ONE)
There are very few development teams considered a "sure bet" in this industry, but one such team is Insomniac.
Masters of fine, fluid traversal and unorthodox movement mechanics mixed with wacky and inventive weaponry, Insomniac's action-platformer roots with Ratchet And Clank and Spyro can be felt in a lot of their newer games, and the most recent SpiderMan titles are widely considered to have some of the finest player locomotion in the biz.
So, then, it's bizarre that Sunset Overdrive, considered "proto-Spidey" in movement and "meta-Ratchet" in combat, fared so poorly in terms of overall sales.
Sunset Overdrive launches the player into a gaudy world of energy drink-fueled zombies and tells them the only way to survive is to bounce off parasols, grind along power lines, and fire records out of an LP submachine gun (relatable stuff). From saving a squad of LARPers to battling the literal developers of the game, there genuinely is nothing quite like it. So, what went wrong?
Unfortunately, the game was an Xbox One exclusive at launch, and really felt the shockwaves of the poorly-received console reveal event which drove fence-sitting gamers away from Microsoft's box over to the PS4. And, despite some serious petitioning, gamers never saw a Sunset Overdrive release on PlayStation consoles, dramatically reducing the game's reach and appeal.
Nowadays, it's often discounted on the Xbox store and Steam, so keep an eye out for Insomniac's overlooked gem.
9. Gravity Rush 2 (PS4)
There were several games that could be considered excellent proof of concept for the PS Vita: Tearaway for its unique utilisation of the hardware inputs, Uncharted Golden Abyss as a sheer graphical showcase, and Gravity Rush as a mixture of the two.
Using gyroscopic controls, players could tilt the centre of gravity to any point in the world and watch as its main character, Kat, hurtled dramatically towards it - like Buzz Lightyear emphatically asserts, "it's not flying - it's falling... with style!"
Mixed with some impressive stylised visuals and an enchanting soundtrack, the blancmange-haired Kat left a strong impression with critics, who regarded the game as a must-buy for the system.
It made sense, then, to release a sequel on the far more powerful PS4 console - in theory, at least.
Gravity Rush 2 was certainly far more refined in terms of gameplay, and graphically the upgrade was notable (particularly in the rich environment design), however due to heavy competition, being a more niche title, and the fact it was a sequel to a game many, many people hadn't even heard of, let alone played (as the PSVita sold around 12 units worldwide), sales were considered lacklustre overall, and as such, Kat's gravity-contorting adventures may well be shelved for now.
8. Split/Second (XBOX 360, PS3)
If you love driving really, really fast, you should play Split/Second, an absurdly upbeat game full of explosions, and hurtling dramatically through stacks of cardboard boxes.
What can only be described as "a bonkers reality TV show where people drive like they're on the M1 at 5.50pm on a Friday," Split/Second is a Disney-published racing game built around the idea of taking daring risks, feeling like a hero, and the line "I think we're juuuust gonna make it!".
It made a remarkably good impression on critics, who felt the game was "a racing game where every moment feels like the final stretch."
Whether you're outmanoeuvring rival racers whilst avoiding a plane crash, or driving through a crumbling building whilst your danger indicators have a fit, Split/Second definitely couldn't be accused of doing anything by halves.
However, ironically, whilst the game never moves out of top gear, sales started off strong and stopped dead very shortly after, leaving Split/Second burnt out all too quickly.
7. The Evil Within 2 (PS4, XBOX ONE)
This entry is a bit of a strange one, as the sales figures don't tell the whole story - so whether or not this truly belongs here is a mystery to all but the lovely folks at Bethesda.
Survival horror games are typically considered to be tough sellers, comparatively. Horror is usually an adult genre, and not everyone enjoys the pant-ruining gameplay of hiding inside a cupboard until a haunting figure wearing a severed head as a hat leaves to growl at a different patch of darkness.
That said, The Evil Within boasted the notable presence of Shinji Mikami, the father of Resident Evil, and saw modest success alongside a fair critical reception.
When its sequel released and promised to address a lot of the issues players had with the original (including a bizarre aspect ratio and too much focus on trial-and-error chases/battles), sales appeared to see a deserved healthy spike shortly after launch, alongside some much-improved review scores from gaming outlets.
However, sales halted far sooner than analysts had predicted; The Evil Within 2 appeared to only reach a quarter of the sales of the original in the first week, and many assumed this was due to the game's last-minute announcement and subsequent release.
The Evil Within 2's figures may be significantly twisted, as this was around the time digital sales started truly exploding. Tango Gameworks concluded that, as previously-inconsequential digital sales hadn't been counted alongside the physical, digital sales may have made up a far higher percentage than they had initially anticipated.
Whilst they did not confirm if this was the case, seeing digital sales trends skew ever further into the majority, we can assume they were correct.
6. Conker's Bad Fur Day (NINTENDO 64)
It's difficult to overstate just how much of a statement Conker's Bad Fur Day made upon its original release - the boiled potato-tier boring Diddy Kong Racing character had received a trailer for his new suitable for all ages game, Twelve Tales, and expectations were tepid at best.
Another 3D animal mascot platformer? What was this,1993?!
So when the seemingly-AWOL Twelve Tales re-emerged as Conker's Bad Fur Day, a booze-fuelled, hangover-riddled romp through the rowdiest and raunchiest parts of gaming's netherbits, we were all completely blown away at the suckerpunch we'd just been delivered.
What Rare had done with Conker was the antithesis of a safe bet. They'd distinguished their mascot from the pack by making him NSFW, a lecherous drunken uncle - the intention being to draw an older clientele to the Nintendo 64, a console which had struggled with its "kiddy" image in the face of the clubland-cool PlayStation. Yet, they simultaneously alienated the vast majority of the console's player base, who were now unable to purchase or play the game, given its M for Mature rating.
This bet would do wonders in establishing Conker's Bad Fur Day as a cult classic, a genuinely unique title which risked a lot of reputation and faith in the interest of being fresh and unexpected, but targeting such a small part of the overall games market would ultimately be the reason the game failed to meet sales projections, and subsequently, fail commercially.
5. Immortals Of Aveum (PS5, XBOX SERIES, PC)
There was a time, believe it or not, when Electronic Arts was a developer and publisher renowned for taking risks; EA was known for Dizzy (a game with an Indiana Jones-style adventuring egg), Road Rash (race Ducatis whilst battering rivals with truncheons and flails) and The Sims (virtual sociopath sim) - all games with genuinely brilliant and psychotherapist-worrying concepts.
It was only during the early 00s (I refuse to write "noughties") where EA seemingly settled into a fairly banal rhythm of sure-bets and EA Sports ("...they're all the same!"), but this was simply because their output really ramped up - those niche, esoteric IPs like Garden Warfare and Mirror's Edge were still coming out, except now they were releasing against tougher competition (with EA inexplicably even releasing Titanfall 2 against their own Battlefield 1, causing the internet to go into conspiracy theory overdrive).
Immortals of Aveum is another such EA conspiracy-fodder title - with punchy magic-themed shooter combat and vibrant, saturated visuals, it seemed to embrace gaming audiences' new, more varied palate by mixing fantasy elements with familiar shooter gameplay, but it was seemingly released to very little marketing against the likes of Baldur's Gate 3, Armored Core 6, and Starfield - a seemingly unwinnable contest.
Critically, Immortals of Aveum is considered a good game with some genuinely novel concepts, so some more fervent fans believe it was a sacrificial lamb to prove single-player shooters "aren't worth making any longer."
Whilst EA believes it was simply due to the project being "overscoped," time will surely tell if single-player shooters become a rarity as a result.
4. Beyond Good And Evil (GAMECUBE, XBOX, PS2)
Given how prevalent photography modes have become in videogames, it's not a crazy assumption to suggest Beyond Good And Evil may well have fared far better in today's gaming landscape - which is probably why we're getting the sequel real, real soon, right?
Right?
Following as the floating camera behind our heroine Jade, players can finally experience what it's like to fail to pay an electricity bill and be forced to take a second job (wow, what a fantasy!). When the orphanage she tends to with her disgruntled anthropomorphic pig pal (disgruntled, eh? Eh?) becomes vulnerable after they struggle to pay for power for their shielding bill, Jade takes on a job as a nature photographer before being pulled into a twisty plot full of subterfuge, spies, and propaganda (... just a bit).
Contributing heavily to Beyond Good And Evil's lack of commercial success was Ubisoft's utterly baffling choice to release it alongside their own Prince Of Persia: Sands Of Time, and up against big name IP releases such as Mario Kart Double Dash!!, Final Fantasy X-2, and Lord Of The Rings: Return Of The King.
It's no surprise, then, that the subsequent re-release on Xbox 360 and other platforms fared fairly well, but the damage of that poorly-timed initial release window had already been done.
3. Marvel Vs Capcom: Infinite (PS4, PC, XBOX ONE)
Marvel has an estimated value of $53 billion. Capcom has an estimated value of $10.6 billion. Combined, you'd think the marketing power the pair could harness could be an unstoppable brain-wrecker - just waves and waves of pure mind control targeted at the masses. We'd be helpless.
So imagine the surprise when Capcom announced Marvel Vs Capcom: Infinite - the latest in the highly-popular Marvel Vs Capcom series - and the most prominent response from its audience was "is that supposed to be Chun Li? Why does she look like Bob Geldof?"
Cynically referred to as a "transparent cash-grab," Infinite suffered from a litany of issues, not least of which being its presentation, which somehow managed to "make the ugly characters look unappealing." Add to this netcode issues, a spartan selection of characters and modes, and a $200 special edition which included a set of five cheap acrylic love eggs masquerading as "infinity stones," and suddenly the game's inability to really cash out seems a bit less perplexing.
Whilst Capcom would blame Marvel Vs Capcom: Infinite's lacklustre sales on a slow marketplace and "waning interest in superhero [properties]," it's widely accepted that the game simply failed to live up to expectations, and wasn't worth its price tag. And, given that Marvel-loving ebayers frequently buy literal Marvel-branded toilet paper for over 100 dollars USD, that really is saying something.
2. Elite Beat Agents (NINTENDO DS)
Elite Beat Agents should have been an easy sell for Nintendo's budding DS platform - take widely-known and loved licensed music tracks (albeit performed as naff cover versions), and have your players tap and swipe to the beat, engaging directly with the new hardware in a novel way, with a concept almost anyone can understand.
And yet, Elite Beat Agents (the westernised version of the comparatively more successful Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan!) simply couldn't garner the kind of attention that simple sales premise might imply - because the Nintendo DS was a breakthrough platform for non-gamers such as the very young or elderly, the visuals proved to be a bit too wacky and intimidating at a glance (and, to be fair to old Agnes, the game does have a level where you fight a lava golem at an amusement park by playing baseball to Good Charlotte's "Anthem.")
Whilst the younger audience opted for games such as Nintendogs, elderly customers found their comfort in experiences like 100 Incredibly Beige Wordsearches or Professor Mindsworth's Senility Delayer instead - Elite Beat Agents was simply too crazy for Grandma Ethel, but not cute enough for little Timothaniel.
Too few games these days allow you to stop a pirate mutiny by singing "Y.M.C.A," however finding an audience for that niche has, to date, proved difficult.
1. Shenmue (SEGA DREAMCAST)
Ah, Sega Dreamcast. Ol' Casty. Big Dreambo.
Nowadays, the console is widely accepted as one of gaming's finest, but in the early 00s it was considered by many to be too arcadey, too unconventional as a home console - the impending PS2 promised to be more cinematic, and less about the immediate, fleeting thrills and colourful visuals Sega's Dreamcast had become synonymous with (as well as midnight gaming-ruining screaming memory cards).
Enter Shenmue - the game which sought to change this impression by being the single-most cinematic, filmic epic ever played, a playable movie featuring revenge for a murdered father, magic mirrors, forklift truck races and loads of Kinder Egg toys.
It cost Sega as much as $70 million USD - by far the most ever spent on a videogame at the time - and whilst it's arguable this payoff was worthwhile from a creative standpoint, it was simply too much to recoup financially. Shenmue was intended to be a twelve-part saga spanning multiple console generations, but it ended up being one of Sega's very own coffin nails after the second part failed to match a tenth of the original's Dreamcast sales.
Still, with a hauntingly beautiful score, excellently-Segaish combat system and a deliberately slow pace which encouraged players to draw beauty and interest in the richness of the in-game world, Shenmue has influenced many games in its wake - arguably making its sacrifice more than worth the money and effort involved in its creation.