10 Cruel Tricks Video Games Played On FPS Players

These classic FPS games knew how to push your buttons.

BioShock Andrew Ryan
2K Games

The first-person shooter may no longer be as popular as it once was, but it's still a meat-and-potatoes video game genre focused on the wish fulfilment of utilising insane weaponry against ridiculous foes.

It's a genre that's probably enjoyed less innovation than most, but that doesn't mean there aren't developers working hard to give players a unique or unexpected experience.

And that's certainly true of these 10 games, all of which played cruel, shocking tricks on players who were likely expecting more familiar, down-the-line thrills from these FPS titles.

But instead, the developers exploited our familiarity with the genre and its tropes to do something totally different, be it inverting our idea of what a "reward" is, using the first-person perspective to emphasise the horror of a certain situation, or just straight-up trolling us.

These 10 games, each of them terrific and iconic in their own right, refused to simply deliver a safe, competent time, but instead upended expectations with rug-pulls that just about nobody saw coming.

In some cases it was impossible not to respect the hustle, while in others it was undeniably infuriating...

10. The Sniper Rifle That Mocks You - Borderlands 2

Borderlands 2
Gearbox

There's nothing that Borderlands players love more than that sweet, sweet loot - the shiny new thing is always better than the shiny last thing, especially where weapons are concerned.

And by completing Borderlands 2's side mission "Hyperion Contract #873," where you're tasked with exterminating 100 bandits, you'll receive a new weapon by the name of the Morningstar.

The Morningstar is said to be an experimental weapon "custom designed for a murderer like yourself," and as awesome as that sounds, it becomes a lot less neat once you actually start using it.

Y'see, the Morningstar is a talking gun which will wax sarcastic to the user whenever they fire, reload, kill an enemy, swap weapons, or land a critical hit.

The gun's quips range from insulting your poor marksmanship ("if you were a better shot, you wouldn't need to reload") to guilting your murderous ways ("they had a family") and even getting weirdly personal ("you don't talk to your parents as often as you should").

It's a nagging price to pay for a sniper rifle that, infuriatingly, metes out a pretty beefy amount of damage.


9. Watch Your Own Slow, Agonising Death - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare

Call Of Duty 4 Modern Warfare Remastered
Activision

Back in 2007 when Call of Duty: Modern Warfare hit stores, players really didn't know what to expect.

Beyond delivering a slickly cinematic campaign, Infinity Ward also pushed the boundaries of FPS storytelling for the era, dishing up one majorly shocking moment which the series has repeatedly attempted to recapture ever since.

In the mid-game mission "Shock and Awe," the player takes control of Sgt. Paul Jackson as he chases down the terrorist Khaled Al-Asad, who is alleged to be in possession of a nuclear weapon.

The mission ends with the aforementioned nuke being detonated while Jackson and his team are evacuating the city, causing their helicopter to crash before it can clear the area.

The FPS genre being what it is, most players simply assumed that the game would continue with Jackson having inexplicably survived. And at first, that seems like it's case - an interactive cutscene shows Jackson pulling himself from the wreckage and surveying the irradiated surrounding area.

But it's also clear that Jackson's in a really bad way, and after a minute or two, he ends up dropping dead on the spot.

It remains perhaps the single most unexpectedly chilling moment in the entire Call of Duty franchise, eschewing the typical oorah military fetishism for a disarmingly sobering account of war's brutal cost.

After this the game of course switches perspectives yet again to another character, with players coming to understand that nobody they control is safe for the campaign's remainder.


8. GLaDOS Disintegrates The Companion Cube - Portal 2

Portal 2
Valve

The Portal games saw Valve relish screwing with the player through their interactions with the malevolent, deranged supercomputer GLaDOS. And in the second game, GLaDOS' cruelty perhaps reaches its agonising apex in Test Chamber 7.

In this chamber, players are reacquainted with their beloved Weighted Companion Cubes from the first game, but it's a short-lived honeymoon given that GLaDOS quickly makes pains to ruin your day.

Throughout the level GLaDOS continually disintegrates the cubes before your very eyes. She then warns you that the emancipation grill at the end of the level will obliterate any cubes you try to smuggle out, but also notes that the grill is broken.

And so, players will naturally grab a cube and attempt to transport it out of the chamber past the broken grill, only for the cube to suddenly disintegrate.

As ever, GLaDOS was lying to you about the grill being broken, and to rub salt in the wound, she says:

"I think that one was about to say 'I love you.' They ARE sentient, of course. We just have a LOT of them."

And like that, everybody playing just felt like total crap. Thanks, Valve.


7. Kill Hitler & Die Because Of It - Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus

Wolfenstein 2 Hitler
Bethesda

What could be more satisfying in a Wolfenstein game than getting the chance to kill Adolf Hitler himself? The wish fulfillment aspect speaks for itself, and so developers MachineGames knew they could spring a deliciously tricky trap for players in Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus.

During the game, B.J. Blazkowicz heads to the planet Venus to partake in a propaganda film audition - a film being produced by an elderly Adolf Hitler no less.

During the sequence, Hitler will get tired and take a nap on the floor, but as you're instructed to walk past him, it's possible to walk over to his slumbering body and activate a button prompt.

This will trigger an animation where B.J. stomps Hitler in the face, killing him instantly. But because we can't have good things, this will also instantly cause every Nazi in the room to turn their attention on you, and you'll quickly get shot dead or burned to a crisp.

On the flip-side, kicking Hitler while he's down will net you the "Kick It" trophy/achievement.


6. Take Your Time & The Hostages Die - Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Deus Ex Human Revolution
Eidos

The joy of video games often lies in the ability to explore their vast environments to your heart's content, yet in the case of Deus Ex: Human Revolution, that was anything but true.

In the opening level "Back in the Saddle," you have to exit Sarif Industries HQ and deal with a delicate hostage negotiation, though you're first allowed to take an amble through the office's lobby if you like.

It's a gorgeously rendered environment with a lot to take in, so you couldn't be blamed for stopping for a moment. But if you take too many moments here - that is, 15 minutes or more - in the next mission you'll be told that the hostages have died.

Now, the game does admittedly warn you to not hang around Sarif for too long, but it's also fair to say that many players simply assumed this was a canned remark rather than something actively tied to an in-game timer - especially as the Sarif interior looks so damn cool.

To make things even worse, you return to the lobby later in the game, meaning you could've just waited to take a look around until after the hostages were saved. But of course, hindsight is 20:20 and nobody knows this on a first playthrough.


5. Kill Boris & Natalya Won't Help You - GoldenEye 007

GoldenEye 007 Boris
Rare

Dealing with AI sidekicks in GoldenEye 007 is just a massive pain in the ass in general, and though we all know how frustrating it can be to keep Natalya Simonova alive during her escort missions, she's also got a deeply vengeful streak which can actually stop you from progressing.

In the late-game mission Control, players will encounter the malevolent hacker Boris Grishenko, who will run away from Bond while shouting, "I am invincible!"

At this point you may be unable to resist the urge to cap Boris, but if you do so before meeting up with Natalya, she'll later tell you that she saw what you did and refuse to help you open the doors needed to continue the mission.

This effectively triggers a Game Over, then, as you're now unable to progress any further through the level without Natalya's aid.


4. Giving You An Impossible Objective - Halo: Reach

Halo: Reach
Bungie

There's a basic expectation that you'll actually be able to complete any objective an FPS game throws up on your HUD, but at the end of Halo: Reach, that's sadly not the case.

The mission, "Lone Wolf," sees protagonist Noble Six taking a badass last stand against the Covenant. As the action kicks off, a single word appears as your objective: "Survive."

While on an initial playthrough you'll probably assume that Six is able to somehow withstand the relentless Covenant onslaught, that's not true at all. Story-wise you're simply distracting the Covenant long enough for the Pillar of Autumn to escape, setting up the events of the original Halo game.

And no matter how brilliant a Halo player you are, you'll eventually be overwhelmed by the might of the Covenant horde, ending the game on a deeply bittersweet note.

Yet by making the player think there might be a way to win this engagement, it ensures they don't just put the controller down and let fate take over. Clever, but cruel.


3. Get Rich & Die At The End - S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow Of Chernobyl

STALKER Shadow Of Chernobyl
GSC Game World

You could certainly argue that S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl is a brutal, prolonged exercise in cruelty from start to finish - a fiendishly difficult survival horror FPS that takes no prisoners.

As a result, you can't really be blamed for playing cautiously, being conservative with resources, and basically hoarding as much as humanly possible.

And yet, because developers GSC Game World apparently see money as the root of all evil - and, honestly, they're not wrong - anyone who reaches the end of the game with a decent wedge of cash will get the ultimate punishment for it.

If you've got more than 50,000 RU at game's end, you'll receive the so-called "greedy ending" - a video sequence where protagonist Strelok asks the Wish Granter for masses of wealth.

At this point, Strelok appears to be showered in more coins than he can carry, but it soon becomes clear that this is actually the nuts and bolts of the ceiling above him. The roof then collapses, crushing Strelok to death.

This is the ending most players receive on their first playthrough due to the game's intense difficulty and implicit encouragement to be frugal. What a crock.


2. "Would You Kindly?" - BioShock

Bioshock Andrew Ryan
2K Games

BioShock boasts one of the most ingeniously executed plot twists in the history of video games, where it's revealed that protagonist Jack has actually been manipulated by his apparent pal Atlas - who is actually villain Frank Fontaine in disguise - to do his bidding.

Throughout the game, Atlas uses the phrase "Would you kindly?" while asking the player to do various things, and it's ultimately revealed that this was a psychic trigger phrase used by Atlas to compel Jack to do anything he asked.

Rapture creator Andrew Ryan proves this to the player in devastatingly violent fashion late in the game by asking them to kill him while handing them a golf club.

At this moment, we're helpless to watch as Jack uses the golf club to beat Ryan to death, confirming we've been unwitting passengers to somebody else's commands for the entire game.

On one hand, it's a genius examination of the totally unquestioning means through which we play most video games, but on the other, it really stings.


1. One Player Must Die To Save The Others - Left 4 Dead

Left 4 Dead
Valve

In Left 4 Dead's "The Sacrifice" DLC, the game's emphasis on ensuring that as many players as possible make it to the end goes totally out the window.

Why? Because surviving the campaign requires one of the four-player squad to lay their life down in order to protect the others. Yup.

One member of the team must willingly stay behind and restart a generator which will help raise a bridge and cut the zombies off from the other players, in turn ending the game.

Canonically the character to sacrifice themselves is Bill, though any player is free to carry out the deed, as much as it flies in the face of the game's emphasis on individual survival at all costs. It's a selfless act for the greater good, but who among us really wants to do it?


Watch Next


In this post: 
Bioshock
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.