10 Cruel Tricks Video Games Played On Open World Players
Invisible quest timers SUCK.
Video games are almost always primarily interested in you having a great time and ensuring you have all the tools to accomplish that, so perhaps in some cases developers like to let off steam by implementing cruel features designed to thwart you.
While certainly not every entry on this list is a personal attack on the player they certainly feel like they are. And in the time consuming and sprawling genre of open world games, there are as many avenues for developers to help you as there are ones to hurt you.
Whether intentional or not, all of these entries stung in one way or another so we've grouped them here so we can all grumble about it together.
--
10. Cool Parts Of The Environment... You Can't Reach - Cyberpunk 2077
This particular cruel trick may have become less prevalent in recent years with the advance of video game tech, creativity, and graphics enhancements, but it’s still a pain to encounter whenever you do.
Of course the boundaries of an open world have to be set somewhere but occasionally an environmental artist will get a little too excited and create something that looks really exciting just outside the game world limits.
So you’ll be moseying along down the street, spot an interesting looking mountain or cabin, try to make your way there before either being knocked back by a prompt or an invisible wall letting you know that particular bit is not part of the video game. That then leaves disappointed gamers wondering if said bit will be included as DLC, or if it’s just a particularly enticing but futile bit of scenery outside the game world perimeter.
Plenty of open world games do this but a good recent example is in Cyberpunk 2077 where you might have spotted a very enticing bit of scenery in the distance. Specifically, a rocketship that appears to be taking off.
If you’re anything like me you may have found yourself swimming to what appears to be a very cool rocket before realising said cool rocket is inaccessible and, no, I am not salty about that huge waste of time at all.
9. Failing Side Quests Due To Main Story Progression - Dying Light 2
Loads of sprawling open world RPGs are culprits of secretly gating you out of side quests if you head too far down the main path. The issue here is when there is so much side content, much of which isn’t signposted, and the player in question happens to be a completionist who hates the idea of missing anything at all.
So, me, and you if you relate to that last bit.
In open world games where the things you do in the main quest take you to new locations, permanently alter old ones, or might even lead to the deaths of important characters, many of us have trained ourselves to do all the side stuff before we make too much headway into the main missions. In Dying Light 2, for instance, there are multiple side missions you can miss out on or fail entirely if you opt to take on the main story mission first.
Don’t be fooled into thinking that just because this is an open world game with a whole mess of different things to take on, that there aren’t some consequences to doing things out of order.
Unless you’re following a guide it’s very easy to accidentally progress too far and lock yourself out of side content that could only trigger in certain, earlier world states. And checking your journal only to see some of your quests have mysteriously disappeared is a pretty crappy feeling. It’s probably fine if you're not a crazy completionist but if you are, we can absolutely classify this one as a cruel trick.
8. Psychic Guards - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
The Hero of Kvatch works hard but it’s arguable that Cyrodill’s guards work harder because boy does word spread like wildfire among the ‘ensuring you don’t violate the law’ community.
Someone needs to investigate the crime reporting systems between Oblivion guards because they are wildly effective. Kill off a dude in the middle of nowhere and the expert network of law enforcement in Cyrodiil ensures each and every soldier will know of your crimes, pursue you relentlessly, and run right up to you if you dare enter their vicinity letting you know you’ve been placed under arrest.
Psychic guards can also be found in Assassin’s Creed games and Grand Theft Auto has its own version of these dudes in their psychic police though I suppose at least they have radios.
Better pay the court a fine or serve your sentence because you’re not getting away from these guys.
7. This Specific Quest Is On A Timer - Mass Effect 2
Open world games are a buffet of quests, side activities, repeating gigs, NPCs to meet, you name it there’s a tonne to do. So it makes sense that almost always, unless otherwise specified, you can expect that you’re not on a timer to do any of these things. Unless there’s the urgency of a Majora’s Mask-style timer ticking you can safely assume that you tackle things as you like and when you like.
That’s why it’s especially cruel when all of a sudden a specific quest does require you to get something done quickly or to begin it in a timely fashion when the rest of the game hasn’t worked that way.
The most egregious example of this is probably Mass Effect 2’s suicide mission where you can actually get a lot of the crew killed by taking too long to kick off this last stand main mission. As soon as you finish off the Reaper IFF mission you’ll be on a hidden timer to get your ass in gear and go through the Omega-4 relay to save your crew.
Decide to do a few missions beforehand and you’ll find more and more of your crew die while you’re dawdling. Harsh.
6. Killing Off Your Ride-Or-Die - Cyberpunk 2077
One of the nastiest things an open world video game can do to you is help you bond with a charismatic, kind, or delightful companion only to unceremoniously kill them off. Final Fantasy and Cyberpunk 2077 and both culprits of this particular entry as they both use excellent writing to endear you to a character that you’d assume you’d never be saying goodbye to only to flip the switch on you in the cruellest of ways.
Spoilers for Cyberpunk in this next bit so if for some reason you don’t want those, come meet us over at the next entry.
This one was especially puzzling as the character in question, Jackie Welles, featured in all of the marketing material for the game and seemed like your ride or die bestie... only to be killed off relatively early in the game.
This has ongoing implications for V who spends a lot of the game processing Jackie’s death as he continues to come up in her journey.
5. Don’t Fall In - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
As you’d expect there are plenty of open world games that feature a tonne of different biomes and some of these are huge bodies of water. Occasionally you won’t be able to get in at all but in games like The Witcher 3 your bigger problem is often getting out. A particularly cruel trick here is in designing a game with a superpowered mutant protagonist who has an enormous amount of trouble escaping water without a steady incline akin to the accessibility ramp of your local pool.
Any Witcher player can probably tell you stories about tumbling into water from a not-beach and being unable to find their way out for quite some time.
This is all the more infuriating when you’re hustling about trying to get smuggler’s caches or a bunch of sirens have just sunk your boat so you’re trying to get to the closest shore to dry off and nurse what’s left of your pride.
4. Patches - Dark Souls
This entry is just Patches. Patches is the cruel trick that is played on you in Dark Souls.
While it’s lovely to meet one of the few creatures in this horrorscape that aren’t trying to claw you to death immediately upon seeing you, Patches may as well be because this tricksy guy tries to kill you a tonne by convincing you to fall into or off dangerous terrain and then convince you he was just playing, begs your forgiveness and has the gall to ask if you’re still mates. Of course, friends are hard to come by in Lordran so you’ll probably give him a pass even though he is also very much trying to kill you, too, just in a less obvious way.
In case you took a shine to the trickster you’ll be stoked to hear he has iterations in every Souls game right up to Elden Ring where he is, you guessed it, up to shenanigans.
3. Your Failures Caught In Slow-Mo - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
I’m sure Bethesda only meant well when they let you see your kills in awesome slow motion animation, except that ‘slow motion’ isn’t ‘no motion’, so, say you’re attacking with a bow and arrow or a similarly small projectile and there’s a chance you’re in a sick zoomed-in cutscene just to watch yourself miss. Skyrim’s arrows so often have a mind of their own, even the game doesn’t seem to be aware of the fact that you can miss.
While this one is absolutely cruel, it’s probably a programming failure making it cruel and not the devs setting out to make you feel like a dummy.
This cruel trick gets even nastier and, let’s face it, more entertaining, because maxing out the archery tree in Skyrim will grant you the bullseye skill which can give you a chance to paralyse enemies with your shots. That sounds all well and good except upon getting paralysed they fall to the ground meaning they’ve moved position after the skill has been triggered meaning the arrow you just shot off right at their brain place has now sailed right over the top of them.
Not a waste of skill points at all.
2. Gear Up, Get Captured Anyway - Far Cry 5
Plenty of games commit this cardinal sin where they set up the imminent engagement with a pile of foreshadowing that has you understanding you’re really going to have to pull out all the stops to prepare for this one.
So, you pop your buffs, use your best consumables, buy that gear you’ve been eyeing off and steel yourself for what’s to come.
And that’s where you find out very quickly that this wasn’t going to be a real battle at all, and it was instead a scripted fail state you were never intended to be able to beat. This happens repeatedly in Far Cry 5 where you’d be forgiven for assuming you can win the encounter that tells you to avoid getting hit by the hallucinogenic bliss bullets so as not to be kidnapped. But try as you might, any damage you take during or even after this encounter will initiate the kidnapping cutscene.
Even if you take out every single enemy in the area and take no damage in the actual engagement, the scripted cutscene will zip you to the capture you totally didn’t deserve.
Whether these scripted failures kick you to a game over screen or progress the narrative, as is the case in Far Cry 5, it’s not really relevant to how burned you’ll feel by the amount of time and money you sunk into preparation for a battle that didn’t even get off the ground.
1. Tempting You With A Shortcut - Death Stranding
Everyone will have a different example of an open world game that tempted them with a shortcut that they decided to take and then deeply regretted 15 to 25 minutes later when they found themselves jammed on the side of an almost entirely vertical mountain knowing they would have been at their location by now if they just followed the GPS.
But we’ve all done it. You set your next location on your map and then you realise your GPS is directing you in the total opposite direction so you tell yourself the fastest way between two points is in a straight line and set off as such.
Even if there’s a mountain in the way. Or a barricade, or a town, or a body of water.
Perhaps the most brutal punisher of this mentality is Death Stranding where I vividly remember spending hours of my life trying to take what I had thought to be a shortcut only to find myself out of ropes and ladders halfway up a waterfall. In a game with arduous traversal mechanics you’d be forgiven for trying to get somewhere more directly, but in Death Stranding a shorter route almost always means a practically impassable one. Which you’ll realise for yourself when all your cargo is destroyed and you’re stuck in a nasty spot of timefall.
This one is admittedly kind of on us, but you’ll have wasted so much time that we can go ahead and just say this is the cruellest trick an open world video game has played on us.