10 Exact Moments That Made Fans Hate Gaming Franchises

How to make a fanbase turn on you? Directly insult them.

Devil May Cry DMC Dante
Capcom

Gamers can be a fickle bunch at times, but often their famous ire is completely justified, especially when it comes to a hit franchise they've been passionately committed to for years or maybe even decades.

The fluid, ever-evolving nature of video games means that developers don't always get things right: sometimes they follow the wrong trend, the pressures of working to a tight deadline compromises the end product, or maybe they've got a greedy publisher calling all the shots.

But whatever the root cause, these 10 video game franchises all fell apart at one very specific moment in time, whether a cringe-worthy scene that defined everything wrong with a new entry, the botched reveal of a major tonal shift for the series, a completely unsatisfying ending or a business decision that sought to nickel-and-dime players.

Some of these franchises were at least lucky enough to claw their way back into players' good books, but it wasn't without a mighty effort.

Others, however, have been dead in a ditch ever since, either limping along quietly or flat-out dead, possibly never to return...


10. Chris Punches A Boulder - Resident Evil

Resident Evil 5 Chris
Capcom

There's a fair argument to be made that each of the first four Resident Evil games improved upon the one that preceded it, but the franchise well and truly hit a brick wall with the release of Resident Evil 5.

Though it retained the previous game's innovative new camera and combat mechanics, the survival horror aspect was largely jettisoned, given the game's excessive focus on action over scares.

The addition of a capable buddy character, Sheva, diluted most of the series' signature tension, especially if you decided to play the game co-op with an actual human rather than relying on the sub-par A.I.

But there's one single moment in Resident Evil 5 that really typefies the series' divergence away from horror towards bro-action shenanigans, and that's when Chris Redfield repeatedly punches a boulder blocking his way in the game's climax.

Now, Resident Evil has always been pretty daft, but this was the wrong kind of daft, and a jumping-the-shark moment if gaming has ever seen it.

But more than that, it perfectly exemplified how aggressively the series had pivoted away from suspenseful horror towards generic action schlock, as confirmed by the subsequent sixth game, which turned out to be both the most action-centric and worst of the lot.

Thankfully the series was eventually redeemed with Resident Evil 7, but there was a long time there where many fans had given up on Resident Evil ever being scary (or good) again.


9. Call Of Duty...In Spaaaaaace! - Call Of Duty

Call of Duty Infinite Warfare
Activision

Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare certainly wasn't the first entry into the franchise to dip its feet in the sci-fi genre, but while previous games featured increasingly outlandish technologies, speculative visions of the future and awesome exo-suits, 2016's entry into the annual franchise took a full-fledged sojourn to space.

The game's reveal trailer alone was met with overwhelming disdain from the fanbase, receiving 3.81 million dislikes on YouTube, making it the 6th most disliked video on the platform.

And though Infinity Warfare was as mechanically sound as any entry into the franchise, it was just too far a leap from the series' roots for many fans, and it being the third future-set CoD game in a row sure didn't help.

The game ended up selling only around half of what the previous game, Black Ops III, did, and signalled a general decline in the series' popularity (though 13.6 million units sold is still nothing to sniff at).

Above all else, it confirmed that Activision didn't really have anywhere interesting for CoD to go, and by venturing into space, they showed themselves both desperate and fresh out of ideas.

Despite the publisher trying to lure fans back with the Battle Royale-centric Black Ops IIII, the game only barely outsold Infinite Warfare, confirming that the sci-fi romp was the straw that finally broke the back of many fatigued fans.


8. The Release Of Fallout 76 - Fallout

Fallout 76 Glitch
Bethesda

Fans have cut Bethesda a hell of a lot of slack over the years, because despite how janky and mechanically rough their games tend to be, they also bring a ton of charm and depth to the table.

But with the release of last year's rancid Fallout 76, fans had finally had enough.

Though the developer promised a richly-realised online multiplayer Fallout experience, 76 launched in a blatantly unfinished, rushed-out state, touting horrendous performance issues, a bafflingly barren open-world (without any NPCs!), a misguided online-only approach and infuriatingly fiddly matchmaking.

Fans and critics registered their dissatisfaction vocally, resulting in Bethesda's worst-reviewed game in over a decade, and prompting it to be heavily discounted after just a week on sale.

If the game being a disaster wasn't bad enough, Bethesda initially buried their head in the sand amid the criticism, and further irked players by screwing up the collector’s edition bonuses.

Though Bethesda eventually apologised for the poor communication, promised to fix the collector's edition issues and is adding both NPCs and a Battle Royale mode to the game, it's all proved too little, too late for most fans.

For many it was a wake-up call that Bethesda has been massively over-indulged over the years, with some feeling so burned that they vowed to boycott the next Fallout game and any other Bethesda title such as Starfield or The Elder Scrolls VI.

Though Fallout 5 is certainly still a long way off, if gamers actually manage to hold a grudge over this, don't be surprised if the next game's sales are massively down on the blockbuster success the publisher saw with Fallout 4.

The spell is finally broken, and if Bethesda wants to win fan favour back, they'll need to fix their janky-ass engine and actually treat paying customers like they're not going to gladly lap up whatever scraps they're fed.


7. All The Quiet Fan Service - Metal Gear Solid

Metal Gear Solid V Quiet
Konami

Metal Gear Solid V might be the most frustratingly brilliant game ever made, because despite how note-perfect its moment-to-moment gameplay is, it's filled with missed opportunities and eyebrow-raising indulgences all at the same time.

Now, is it fair to blame Hideo Kojima for Konami forcing him to ship an unfinished game, with its much-discussed third chapter receiving the chop mid-production? No, but there is one massively embarrassing aspect of the game that Kojima certainly does have to answer for.

In the lead up to MGSV's release, discussions intensified surrounding the game's depiction of its heroine sidekick Quiet, who appeared to spend the entire game dressed in absurdly skimpy, totally impractical clothing.

Kojima addressed the criticism head-on before the game hit stores, claiming that "once you recognize the secret reason for her exposure, you will feel ashamed of your words & deeds."

Of course, as it turned out, the explanation for Quiet's lack of clothing was utterly laughable: she breathes and takes in nutrients through her skin, requiring her to bear as much skin as possible. Right.

It's painfully clear that Kojima just wanted to put a sexy fan service character in his game, complete with ridiculously suggestive poses and dance moves, and then made an hilariously half-assed attempt to justify it after-the-fact.

As mechanically amazing as MGSV may be, it's enough to make you question why you're giving Kojima so much rope, and how you'd explain Quiet to anyone - be it your mother, grandmother or girlfriend - who might walk in while you're playing.

Granted, the MGS series appears to be effectively dead with Kojima's departure, so you're basically hating a corpse at this point.


6. Dante Gets A Makeover - Devil May Cry

Capcom

Ninja Theory's 2013 DmC reboot was always going to be a tough proposition to fans, and Capcom sure didn't help things by insisting on a drastic re-design of beloved protagonist Dante in the hope of appealing to a younger player-base.

Though DmC was actually a relatively fun game, it required players to deal with a garishly re-imagined character who lacked the charm and badass look of the classic Dante.

Between his rubbish clothes, naff haircut (that isn't even white!), thinner frame and general emo-baiting appearance, DmC Dante feels like what you get when you ask a 60-year-old studio executive what they think an emo kid actually looks like.

Given that Capcom was clearly going all-in on the new Dante, fans were largely left apathetic, resulting in DmC under-performing commercially, and eventually leading to fans getting exactly what they wanted: another Devil May Cry game starring the traditional Dante.

Shame we had to wait six years for it, though.


5. Samus Freaks Out Over Ridley - Metroid

Metroid Other M Samus
Team Ninja

As Nintendo epically dragged their feet on delivering a still-gestating follow-up to 2007's Metroid Prime 3: Corruption, Metroid fans had to make do with the 2010 inter-quel Metroid: Other M, a game that single-handedly ruined the series' much-loved hero, Samus Aran.

In a misguided attempt to lend greater psychological depth to Samus, the alien-slaughtering icon was re-conceived as a fragile, scared young woman in a manner that was totally inconsistent with her prior, albeit mysterious, established character.

There's a shocking disconnect between the entertaining gameplay and the cut-scenes, the latter of which represents Samus as though she's a different character entirely compared to the earlier Metroid games.

This is most infamously realised during Samus' confrontation with antagonist Ridley, where she freezes up, panics and basically doesn't behave remotely how fans expect Samus to.

After all, she's kicked Ridley's ass countless times before, so all this did was demonstrate a patent lack of regard for who Samus is.

Developer Team Ninja reportedly aimed to make Samus an "appealing human character", but by transforming her into a bunny-stunned stereotype, they basically ruined her instead.

Thankfully 2017's Metroid: Samus Returns got the character back on terra firma, though it falls to the upcoming Metroid Prime 4 to fully restore the Samus' reputation.


4. Unity's Glitch-Filled Release - Assassin's Creed

assassin's creed unity
Ubisoft

The Assassin's Creed franchise may have flirted with creative bankruptcy across its original run of annualised releases, but at least the games were genuinely slick, well-oiled products that launched in a healthy state.

That is, until the release of 2014's Assassin's Creed: Unity.

Pre-release, it seemed like Unity would be another smooth launch for the series...until players and the press got it in their hands and realised it was rife with bugs, ranging from the hilarious to the horrifying.

Unity has an especially disturbing tendency not to load facial textures correctly, resulting in grotesque abominations as pictured above. It's fun the first few times it happens, sure, but after a while you just want to play a game the way it's intended.

The state of the game was so bad that Ubisoft even discontinued its season pass, while offering ripped-off players the ability to download a recent Ubisoft game as compensation.

For many players, this killed the streak of well-crafted AAA tentpoles the series had delivered, and though subsequent games in the franchise certainly got back to a solid standard, as with Fallout 76, the spell was basically broken.

To their very mild credit, at least Ubisoft started to space out Assassin's Creed games a little in the wake of Unity's failure, occasionally taking a year off to prevent franchise fatigue.


3. Eli Dies...On A Cliffhanger - Half-Life

Half-Life 2 Episode 2 Eli Dead
Valve

Oh, Half-Life, how we loved you so.

Now, to be totally fair to Valve's legendary FPS franchise, this hatred has nothing to do with the quality of the Half-Life games whatsoever: they're all sharp, entertaining shooters that deliver what fans expect.

Except, 2007's Half-Life 2: Episode Two dared to conclude on an agonising cliffhanger - the death of Alyx Vance's father Eli - and 12 years later, fans are still waiting for either Episode Three or Half-Life 3 to tie things off.

Eli's death only exacerbates the frustration fans feel at the Half-Life series evaporating into the ether without a definitive ending, and Valve's infuriating lack of communication regarding the series' future has only further pissed fans off.

No matter the many great moments the Half-Life franchise has given us, Eli's elliptical death is the embodiment of all the unfulfilled promise and potential of the last decade-plus.


2. Pick A Colour, Any Colour - Mass Effect

Mass Effect 3.jpg
BioWare

Mass Effect 3 was unquestionably one of the most anticipated video games of the last decade, with fans excited that their decisions made over the course of the trilogy would finally pay off with a deep and meaningful ending.

But then the game came out, and after spending potentially hundreds of hours reaching the end, fans were told that none of their choices really mattered much, and they simply had to pick a colour in order to watch a multiple choice ending.

The result was one of the most vocally angry backlashes in video game history, with fans even exploring legal options against BioWare for "false advertising", which it was ultimately deemed the game was not guilty of.

Nevertheless, BioWare cowed to immense pressure and released an Extended Cut which added extra content to the game's ending, even if it was ultimately just a patch-job to fix a game whose structure and through-line were fundamentally counter to what fans expected.

Many were so soured on the game they never even bothered to play the follow-up, Andromeda, which amid mixed reviews ended up under-performing commercially and resulted in EA putting the franchise "on ice" for the foreseeable future.

A sad fate for a once-beloved series, but one which BioWare ultimately brought upon themselves.


1. Loot Boxes. Loot Boxes Everywhere. - Star Wars Battlefront

Battlefront 2
EA

Another hit sci-fi franchise that EA totally derailed, then, with Star Wars Battlefront. Fans were elated when the hit Star Wars-themed shooter was announced to make a return, but the 2015 reboot ultimately proved slick yet underwhelming, lacking in features and not fully living up to its promise.

EA did a fantastic job convincing fans that 2017's sequel, Battlefront II, would be everything the first game wasn't, and to fans and industry analysts alike, there was no reason to expect anything less than solid reviews.

But Battlefront II ended up skewered by press and players alike for its invasive loot box mechanics, which introduced pay-to-win incentives for those who threw down real money for the chance of scoring major gameplay advantages.

Amid mounting fan pressure, EA dug a hole for themselves with their deeply misjudged response - which became the most downvoted comment in Reddit history at the time - and quickly removed microtransactions in order to stem the tide of negativity.

But the damage had already been done: EA's share price tumbled an historic $3 billion, and though the game still sold incredibly well, it missed a sales target due to the wave of bad PR surrounding the loot box controversy.

It's safe to say that, having been burned twice in a row by a greedy EA, many fans will be giving the inevitable Battlefront III a miss and hoping that, one day, someone might actually do something both worthwhile and dignified with the Star Wars video game license.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mass Effect 3
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.