10 EXACT Moments Video Game Fans Tapped Out
Another live-service shooter? Really?
Video game fans are, in general, a pretty loyal bunch. We voluntarily engage in what is often a fairly expensive hobby, keep franchises afloat for decades, and follow our favourite game creators as they venture between publishers and developers. Maybe that’s why we can be crankier than the average media consumer when we feel wronged.
There are a variety of ways game developers and publishers can lose favour with their fan base but a few sure fire examples include wild reimaginings of franchise narratives and gameplay mechanics, a willful ignorance of fan wishes, or that old chestnut, insidious microtransactions. The entries on this list contain a selection of the above and then some but what ties them all together is taking a group of fans who were very much on board and delivering them one defining moment where the majority of them noped out. Some never to return.
10. Not The Metal Gear Game We Were Looking For - Metal Gear Survive
For video game fans to really tap out we have to start with a franchise that is wildly beloved and they don’t get much bigger in that category than Metal Gear. At least, until Metal Gear Survive happened.
While 2015’s Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain had elements and story beats that weren’t everybody’s cup of tea, not to mention its lack of finish due to the relationship breakdown between creator Hideo Kojima and Konami, fans didn’t understand how good they had it until the arrival of Metal Gear Survive.
While loyal followers of the series tried to be optimistic, nothing was right about 2018’s game. The spin-off felt like a generic zombie survival actioner with some mild Metal Gear flavour that lost all of what made its parent franchise special. The game was critically panned as a repetitive, frustrating, and microtransaction-riddled cash grab.
Not to mention fans had already tapped out with the news Kojima was not involved in the creation of Survive, but the few who did stick around were out within the first few minutes of giving the newest Metal Gear game a go.
9. $75 For Skins - Marvel’s Avengers
It’s fair to say that fans of the Marvel Cinematic Universe put up with a lot and generally they’re a forgiving bunch. That goes doubly for fans of Square Enix’s Marvel’s Avengers video game which has already gone through the ringer for its broken matchmaking, uninspired endgame, and repetitive mechanics.
All that said, there were a dedicated bunch who stuck with it anyway, insisting the game really isn’t that bad. Then they went and tried to get those people to pay $75 for skins and that patience wore out.
Keep in mind these are the people who defended the game through all its early microtransactions including its XP boost that could only be purchased with real world money. A boost that was implemented after Crystal Dynamics altered the progression system to make it slower to level up which is pretty darn shady. Though this boost was dropped after only a month due to backlash the same consumer unfriendly tactics were pulled just a couple of months ago when the MCU Outfit Pack dropped and it was revealed the 10 outfits would run players $75. In some regions that’s even more than the game itself costs.
I feel like you don’t need me to explain why a bunch of people just shrugged their shoulders and walked away at that point.
8. No NPCs In This Post-Apocalypse - Fallout 76
Potentially controversial opinion here, but I’d argue that Fallout didn’t necessarily lose its player base when it was announced the game would focus on multiplayer. Was the focus on multiplayer what diehard single player fans of the classic Fallout games were keen for? Not necessarily.
But even for the most multiplayer-averse gamers like me there was a curiosity to what it would be like to share a big beautiful Bethesda open world with your friends.
Instead, the bigger fumble for dedicated Fallout buffs was probably the announcement that the game would have no NPCs. After all, there are plenty of MMOs and multiplayer games that manage to have engaging stories, and engaging stories are what the Fallout series is built on, but it’s tricky to do that when your only non-player characters are robots.
While some did enjoy the eerie empty post apocalypse, the soul of Fallout games is so often delivered through the NPCs, your relationships with them, and their troubling stories, that something very important was lost when they were omitted.
Of course, NPCs are back in Fallout 76 now and they’re unlikely to leave the franchise ever again but the decision to nix them certainly alienated a lot of fans.
7. Do You Guys Not Have Phones? - Diablo Immortal
There are a few things guaranteed to go down like a lead balloon when it comes to a highly anticipated announcement and those things can be summed up into three phrases, “free-to-play”, “mobile game”, and “microtransactions”.
And what do you know, while hopeful Blizzcon 2018 attendees bent their ear praying for news of Diablo IV, they got the trifecta with the announcement of Diablo Immortal.
You have to feel a little bad for game director Wyatt Cheng as by all accounts Diablo Immortal is a fully-fledged Diablo experience, it just happens to be on mobiles where nobody really wanted it to be. Especially when a PC and console-based Diablo game hadn’t been released for six years at this point.
What gamers in the room and around the world got was a mobile game ad when their expectations had been way up. While the game has now come to PC with some rampant microtransactions, at the time there were no plans to bring it to any platform other than mobile, at which point Cheng responded to booing with the infamous phrase, “Do you guys not have phones?”
It’s easy to point at the impending release of Diablo IV now and see that fans are clearly tapping back in, but there was a dark five years in the middle there.
6. Donte - DmC: Devil May Cry
Character redesigns aren’t always a bad thing but plenty of DMC fans were left with a bad taste in their mouth after spending time with the new and not-so-improved Dante of DmC: Devil May Cry. With a new look and a new attitude designed to appeal to a younger generation, this Dante got plenty of fans offside before the game even came out.
Even though the combat proved to be as satisfying as ever and this new Dante wasn’t without his fans, a lot of people decided this just wasn’t for them.
Plenty of players felt the redesign instructed by Capcom left Dante seem like he was trying way too hard to be cool and serious, and ultimately it all fell flat. Given that DmC is an origin story there is some amount of leeway in what they could get away with as far as the redesign but it left most fans feeling like they lost their favourite gothic and sarcastic protagonist in place of a wannabe facsimile.
If DmC wasn’t a Devil May Cry game it might not have gathered as much ire but it was so, Donte was born.
5. It Was All A Dream - Twelve Minutes
Spoiler warning here as we will need to talk about the full plot of 2021’s Twelve Minutes in order to dig into just how bad this one screwed over fans who stuck with it to the end. If you don’t want to know what happens come meet us at number 4 but this game probably isn’t worth playing for what it’s worth.
There are two major moments where fans who were truly dedicated to the time loop puzzle game would have tapped out and it’s really tough to pick a favourite.
Well, a least favourite. It’s either the incest story beat or the plot all being a total dream so they’re both really bad.
While Twelve Minutes’ heavy narrative focus and time loop mechanic weren’t for everyone, it was exactly what certain players were looking for. And so a collection of fans were enraptured, trying to sort out the puzzle elements of the singular apartment location, discover more pieces of the mystery, and ultimately unravel the narrative. What a disappointment then when it turns out that, among other reveals, you and your wife are half-siblings about to have a baby. Ew.
While one ending lets you just go on knowingly with your weird incest life, another heavily implies your experiencing the whole thing through hypnosis and it’s not really happening at all. I’ll let those tapped out fans decide which is worse.
4. No Autosaving - Returnal
This one divided those who did and did not tap out based on their non-gaming life commitments. Those who were able to dedicate chunks of time to gaming didn’t see it as a problem at all and those who scrape out precious morsels of video game breaks in their day were so broken down by it that they had to give up on Returnal whether or not they wanted to.
The drama was that at launch runs in the 2021 roguelike Returnal had to be completed all in one go without abandoning the console.
Okay, you could technically pause it, but if you turned off the game or suffered a power outage you would lose your progress. This being a pretty brutal punishment in a game that’s already very far from easy. In some cases your runs could take up to an hour of precision shooting and platforming so losing any ground to something that wasn’t your fault felt like a loss you couldn’t or didn’t want to recover from.
Though the game now lets you suspend your progress and safely turn off the console should you like to, plenty of fans tapped out before this implementation.
3. Built On Microtransactions - Star Wars Battlefront 2
With every consumer-unfriendly business practice and ludicrously priced or positioned microtransaction scheme, publishers run the risk of burning a bridge between them and their players. While a lot of these real-world money mechanics and practices slide on by as just a little insidious, EA kicked off the mother of all video game controversies when they tried to wring fans dry with Star Wars Battlefront II’s microtransactions.
In essence, EA was all set to charge you for everything from skins to weapon upgrades and everything in between thereby breaking the game down into who wanted to pay-to-win and who didn’t.
EA were forced to pull way back on their microtransaction plans in order to salvage a tiny amount of goodwill from their previously keen fanbase but by this point they’d stirred up enough ire that plenty of fans decided to move on from the game entirely before it even properly launched.
2. Princess Beach - Death Stranding
There’s a certain amount of twisty-turny, yet inarguably compelling melodrama that you’re signing up for when you agree to let Hideo Kojima take you down the rabbit hole of one of his video game narratives.
Death Stranding is certainly up there with his most bizarre and divisive games to date and while I am absolutely a Death Stranding apologist, there is a point in the story even the most diehard and accepting fans had to say, “Well this is all getting a bit silly.”
Toward the pointy end of the already wildly convoluted narrative peppered with characters that have names like Fragile and Die-Hardman, you find yourself on the foreshadowed beach that links the living and the dead.
All of this is fine, except when you are speaking to your sister Amelie about linking herself to the chiral network and Sam is for some reason compelled to say, “So I’m Mario and you’re Princess Peach?”. As if that wasn’t cringey enough, she suggests you run home across the beach together, and I quote, “like Mario and Princess Beach.”
Because they’re on a beach. Get it? Yeah. They also run in slow motion. It’s a moment that’s very hard to get on board with even for fans who’ve swallowed the entire story so far.
1. A Live-Service Looter Shooter. Again. - Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League
A Rocksteady superhero game is more than enough to get ears perked up and keen to find out what lies in store, especially after the awesome legacy of the Batman: Arkham games.
Imagine the disappointing blow to fans of the not-even-out-yet Suicide Squad game helmed by the famous studio after we got gameplay and realised it looks like a generic looter shooter.
Dreams of nuanced relationships between the Suicide Squad members and complex combat, traversal, and abilities that cover the breadth of all that the Arkham franchise accomplished and then some are all but dashed at this point. Despite starring a Suicide Squad made up of Harley Quinn, King Shark, Captain Boomerang, and Deadshot taking aim at a corrupt Justice League, the gameplay so far appears Fortnite-esque with alien things, gear scores, and guns for every character at the forefront.
Yes, even Captain Boomerang, which even if you know nothing about him, you’d expect probably preferences chucking a boomerang. Well, not in this game.
It’s too early to be sure this one is a bust but players en masse are worried and some formerly excited fans have already tapped out expecting the worst.