10 Exceptional Horror Video Games That Deserve A Comeback

Out of the shadows and back into our lives.

The Suffering
Midway Games

With the survival horror genre looking more bloated than ever thanks to the unending surge of fresh IP's and indie dev titles flooding the market, now might seem to be the worst time to start suggesting yet more horror titles for you to play. Yet hold on friend, before you slip back into the familiar jump scares and thin winding corridors that seem to make up ninety percent of these experiences, why not consider some of these titles that actually tried really hard to offer fresh and exciting mechanics yet for some reason never found their mark when it came to sales or public traction?

Plus from a publisher standpoint it's alway so strange to see great ideas just sitting in the shadows and constantly being passed over when they could just be polished up and repackaged into something that might make their owners a tonne of cash AND tickle that lovely nostalgia gland that they so love to milk.

So gather round the campfire kids as I tell you tales of haunted schools, or multiplayer zombie games, and of one experience so utterly off the wall it really has to be seen to be believed.

10. Blue Stinger

Blue Stinger
Activision

Blue Stinger is a survival horror game that doesn't play by any of your rules, it's a rude crude dude with an attitude and dropped on the Dreamcast way back in 1999. The standout feature of Blue Stinger was that instead of forcing the player to run from enemies at every given opportunity, here you were punching them in the face!

Take that evil! get back in my nightmares where you belong! It was kind of like if Nightmare Creatures went on a tropical holiday, featuring a blistering color pallette, cheesy dialogue, and MMM MM MM exceptional...ly terrible character designs.

Arguably there are two versions of this game in existence, the Japanese original, and the North American port, the latter of which removed the fixed camera angles that Resident Evil had popularised and gave things a traditional behind the character viewpoint. For many this completely changed the tone of the game, from a classic survival horror into something more resembling an action game. To be honest, the change is not something I like as the idea of running headlong into an enemy offscreen is always a nice little jumpscare, but considering the game's approach to combat, it arguably plays better in the port.

Either way for how unique it was to be able to batter mutated creatures, the ability to swap characters at any point, and for its over-the-top tone, this is a title that could make waves given the right care and attention.


9. Galerians

Galerians Video Game
ASCII Corporation

Galerians is such a twisted game that it still genuinely freaks me out when I think about it. From its grimy visuals to its horrendous narrative about human experimentation, the experience is one of pure unrelenting pressure and tension.

However, this is one teeny-tiny upside to all of this, that being you can use PSYCHIC POWERS TO OBLITERATE YOUR FOES! That's right in another inversion of survival horrors removing the power of their protagonist to create a foreboding atmosphere, here you're a walking nuclear reactor of power and fury! The only issue is, is that in order to control this raging set of otherworldly abilities, you need to use medications to stop from burning out.

Galerians is definitely looking ropey in this day and age, but the gameplay is still incredibly solid, and with a new coat of paint, those horrifying bosses and mutations you experience could offer the world over a new set of sleepless nights. It's Resident Evil meets Akira and there's nothing about that sentence I don't like.


8. Harvester

Harvester Screenshot
DigiFX Interactive, Harvester

Harvester is.

It is.

Jeez how does one even begin to describe the oddity that is Harvester? On paper it sounds simple, a 2D suvival horror puzzle game which looks like it was animated using the leftovers of the original Mortal Kombat games. However in practice this game is SO much more. And much of that "more" is that it's utterly bizarre, utlising the concept of the "uncanny" to an acute extent, presenting a town set in the 1950's that is filled with creepy, slightly off characters and events that are so bizarre that they almost warrent their own list.

From being able to try and seduce your own mother, to being shot at by a child if you choose to steal his candy, to how utterly insane it is to be able to get a game over involving a man with amputated legs accidently landing on a button that launches nuclear weapons which end up anihilating all human life.

Like I said it's a strange game. Yet it's so utterly unique that it's a franchise that needs a revist. Imagine if a studio like Devolver got their hands on it, and plied their knowing humor to the concept of a world where nothing is quite as it should be.


7. Cold Fear

Cold Fear
Ubisoft

There are an alarming amount of PS2 horror titles that never got the sequel rub, one-and-done affairs that came and went like the passing of the tides. However one that was unfairly jettisoned overboard to drown in the seas of obscurity was Cold Fear, a shockingly well-made horror title that never quite made the right splash.

Set aboard a monstrous ship, the player is tasked with uncovering why all has gone quiet below decks. Before you know it you're rushing through leaky corridors from unholy monstrosities, unsure if the next claustrophobic corridor will lead you to freedom or certain doom.

It was a concept so good that Resident Evil Revelations almost straight up copied the idea, but for some reason left out one of Cold Fear's best inclusions. At certain points in the game, the boat would be rocked by heavy waves, causing you to slip and slide across rooms, and completely mess up your aim on enemies. This constant threat of nature itself landing you in hot water made every moment drip with tension.

This game NEEDS a comeback, so please someone throw Cold Fear a life preserver or at least make room on that door your floating on.


6. The Suffering

The Suffering
Midway

Never have I felt more empowered and at the same time more vulnerable than when playing action-horror title The Suffering and it's sequel Ties That Bind. This is a glorious expression of body horror and an absolute gore-fest once the action kicks in, which is incredibly frequent.

In the original title, you play as a man called Torque whose death row due date is interrupted by literal Hell opening up on the prison's island. As you battle your way to freedom you learn of all the atrocities that took place on Carnate Island and each of the enemies you face come to represent these cruel methods of punishment and execution. It's a game that dripped with hatred and used this anger to fuel both your desperate attempt to escape but also as a constant reminder of the brutality that lies within each of us.

The sequel doubled down on all of this, upping the action and horror in equal measure, adding in yet more horrible creatures that begged to be dissected online in forums, and it's this enemy detail especially that's missing from a lot of modern horror titles. With Silent Hill constantly flatlining there's a gap in the market for some out-there designs and The Suffering was chock full of them.


5. Dino Crisis

Dino Crisis
Capcom

Oh Capcom you really are leaving money on the table with this one, aren't you? It's been long enough now that we've forgiven you for clearly doing so many lines in the bathroom that the idea of taking the Dino Crisis series to space seemed like a good one, and we just want this series back down on terra firma, please!

It's Resident Evil, with Dinosaurs. I can't imagine a single person who isn't at least tempted to see what a game with this description would be like, yet after the critical lambasting that Dino Crisis 3 received, at least when compared to the first two games, it seems like the franchise has been fossilized for good.

Rumours began swirling that a remake was on the cards from Capcom, but those died when it was revealed that the almighty Resident Evil 3 was to receive that prestigious treatment. However, the release of that title actually set a bit of a precedent. The team has an amazing new graphical engine, and was able to convert the third Resi game in short order, so would it be such a stretch to apply this to the original Dino Crisis?


4. I Am Alive

I Am Alive
Ubisoft

I Am Alive is probably one of the most ironic video game titles out there, as after playing through this utterly dour experience you might be left wishing you weren't, as this brutal survival title is utterly bleak. Imagine if The Road was made into a video game and you'd be on the right lines with this one.

Not that I'm chastising the game for having such negative tones, far from it in fact, as this oppressive atmosphere ended up creating a level of immersion that most other games only dream of achieving. Here you see the jagged fractures of what is left of humanity after an apocalyptic event and are tasked with just one goal. Survive.

This will push you to do unspeakable things as well as witness the death of hope in your fellow man. Yet as a standalone title I Am Alive came and went without much buzz, meaning it's perfect for a comeback. Days Gone and The Last of Us have shown how successful the "humanity on the brink" setting can be, and with a more focused approach, I Am Alive could scratch a much-needed itch.


3. Obscure

Obscure game
Hydravision Entertainment

There's the obvious joke that Obscure really has itself faded into obscurity, however when looking at the gameplay on offer and the brilliant concept of switching party members on the fly to utilize their own unique strengths, this school-based horror title really should have been on everyone's radar.

Using a similar tactic as Alan Wake in that light sources break down enemies in order for you to deliver the killing blow, Obscure's lighting direction is impeccable, creating a sense of dread when you move to poorly lit areas and realise you'll have to rely on what meagre supplies you have with you.

You can even play obscure with a friend, making the experience infinitely more fun as now both of you race around the school, avoiding monsters and solving puzzles. It's a dynamic that works so much better than the tosh AI you were lumbered with in Resi 5 and adds in a tonne of replayability.

The setting, atmosphere, campy dialogue and ability to play with a friend would all translate perfectly to a modern audience. Fingers crossed it gets the passing grade in the near future.


2. Resident Evil: Outbreak

Resident Evil Outbreak
Capcom

Woah Woah Woah. A Resident Evil game on a comeback list? Surely there must be some mistake? Everyone knows about Capcom's biggest tentpole franchise right?

Well my friend you're totally right, but it also appears that Capcom themselves have forgotten just how unique an idea Resident Evil: Outbreak was seeing as how they seem to have abandoned the concept entirely. This is a true shame because Outbreak 1 and 2 really were doing something special, pushing online co-op survival missions set within the iconic Racoon City. At the time, online play for the PlayStation 2 was in its infancy, and poor sales due to fans being put off by adverts suggesting it was ONLY online, meant that Capcom soon gave up on the spin-off.

Mechanically it's what you'd expect from the IP which is not a criticism at all. Tense moments, interesting and grotesque enemies, and characters with different load-outs and stats meaning that teamwork really was essential. Given the huge boom of online gaming since then and the rabid demand for online horror content, remaking or at least returning to this concept would be a dream come true for most Resi fans.


1. Mizzurna Falls

Mizzurna Falls
Human Entertainment

Imagine an open world, free-roam survival horror title set in an isolated town seemingly locked in a permanent winter and sprinkled with a liberal dose of Twin Peaks oddness. This is Mizzurna Falls, a video game that managed to cram all of this onto a PS1 disc and which is an utterly brilliant experience from start to finish.

Don't kick yourself for not knowing of Mizzurna Falls though as it never got a localization outside of Japan and it's only through the tireless work of fans and translators that English versions of this game exist. Yet this is precisely why this video game needs either a remaster or a full remake because it's an experience worth seeking out.

As protagonist Matthew, you need to explore a creepy and unfriendly town regarding the disappearance of your friends. As you delve further and further into the mystery, the dark secrets of the locals begin to surface and soon the title bleeds with a tense and uncomfortable atmosphere that breeds paranoia in every interaction you have.

Making things even more oppressive is a 7-day time limit in which you need to complete your investigation, and because each local has their own routines and the game includes a day/night cycle, you need to plan your actions in advance, making even a simple drive down a country road a frantic race against the clock.

It's a technical marvel considering the platform it released on and is assuredly one of the most deserving games when it comes to a refresh for the modern-day horror community.


Watch Next


In this post: 
The Suffering
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jules Gill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.