10 Failed Live Service Video Games With Shockingly Short Lifespans
Is the live service model dead yet?
It’s not a great mystery why so many video game publishers and developers are keen to get a solid live service game off the ground. Keeping players engaged means a product that brings in money for longer and that’s good for everybody.
Well, so long as the game is actually good and people in fact want to keep playing it. The financial side of producing live service titles might be a no-brainer but to expect to maintain an audience developers need to provide a steady stream of new content, interesting gameplay systems, and something to set itself apart from the pile of other live service games already saturating the market.
In the case of the games on this list, they failed to do some or all of the above, ultimately not managing to find or maintain a player base and consequently getting the server and support axe not long after they launched.
For various reasons, here are the live service games you won’t be playing today but not to worry, you probably wouldn’t have wanted to.
--
10. LawBreakers (2017-2018)
Starting off strong with a live service game that seemed like it had everything going for it, particularly given it was being created by Cliff Bleszinski of Gears of War fame.
LawBreakers was a first-person shooter that released onto PC and PlayStation 4 in August of 2017. If you’re sitting there thinking it’s odd that the game didn’t come out on Xbox One, you’d be right to wonder. Bleszinkski said it was strictly business but would later regret the move to leave out such an important platform, particularly while trying to get a live service game off the ground.
The game was originally intended to be free-to-play but was pivoted to a paid release.
Despite receiving some positive reviews for its dual-faction format that pitted the Law against the Breakers, and a number of varied and interesting modes, the game simply couldn’t build an engaged playerbase. In April of 2018 developer Boss Key revealed the game was not generating enough revenue to cover the costs of keeping it online and later that year the servers were shut down and the game was removed from Steam.
9. Apex Legends Mobile (2022-2023)
It feels just as weird putting Apex Legends on a list of failed video games as I’m sure you feel hearing it but Respawn did announce in January of 2023 that Apex Legends Mobile would be no more.
Despite the success of the main game on PC and console and the substantial critical and commercial success of Apex Legends Mobile, publisher EA weren’t so convinced. They released a statement saying that despite rocketing off at launch, the game had begun to fall short in the content quality, quantity, and cadence departments. Apex Legends Mobile has been given a 90-day window before it’s unplugged on May the 1st which will mean the game will have been live for just short of one year. Respawn said the high-quality experience that players expect from the game wasn’t sustainable due to factors beyond their control.
It’s all a little vague and confusing but suffice it to say, players are not particularly pleased.
The warning signs were there when it was revealed Season 4 was being delayed by over a month but fans who were invested in the title, especially those who have been told there are no refunds for any money spent on the game, are puzzled at best and furious at worst. Not every failed live service game actually deserved its curt lifespan and this is a great example.
8. Titanfall: Assault (2017-2018)
Continuing the trend here, it seems like it’s very hard to compete on mobile even for established franchises and AAA studios as Respawn had another stumble trying to get players invested in Titanfall: Assault.
The competitive RTS hit iOS and Android devices in 2017 and was developed by Particle City. You were primed to deploy and command a squadron of Pilots and Titans among other units in an attempt to quash your rivals. Despite the success of Titanfall and some relatively decent reviews, this game’s servers were also shut down just shy of its one year anniversary in July of 2018. It was announced that the concept and hopes for what the game could be just didn’t translate in the way that the publisher and developers envisioned.
Extensive post-launch plans were hinted at including new units and fan favourite cameos but ultimately the game was abandoned before most could be implemented.
7. Battleborn (2016-2021)
Battleborn, or not Overwatch if you prefer, was a fairly solid game that came out at the worst possible time. Developed by Gearbox Software, the MOBA had plenty of promising elements at launch. As a hero shooter it had a variety of interesting heroes, an engaging multiplayer format, and that Borderlands flavour thanks to its developer, that had already proven popular with gamers.
Unfortunately, the game just couldn’t compete with Blizzard’s Overwatch, another hero shooter that released in the same window and took the industry by storm.
With a little love and a lot of tweaking and updates it’s possible that Battleborn could have been refined into something great but with players migrating across to Overwatch in droves, there was very little to be done to keep the game alive. Within two months of its launch player numbers had fallen to below 1000 and frequent complaints over the game’s overly complex systems and poor matchmaking signalled the beginning of the end. The game transitioned to free-to-play in 2017, just over a year after its launch but it would spend the next couple of years dying a slow death regardless.
The game was removed from sale in 2019, in-game purchases were halted in 2020 and servers were shut down completely by 2021.
6. The Culling 2 (2018)
Sometimes a live service game just comes out at the wrong time and is overwhelmed by a very similar game. Sometimes the audience for a certain type of game is assumed to be there but just doesn’t materialise on launch.
Then there are the times where the game is just really crap, enter The Culling 2.
If you were disappointed that I included a game that had three decent years on the market before falling apart at the seams in the last entry, then this one which barely scraped through a single week is for you. For the uninitiated, The Culling 2 is the sequel to Xaviant’s 2017 first-person battle royal game The Culling. This 16-player arena where you’d try to gear up and survive was actually one of the first cabs off the rank when the battle royale genre was just getting going but in a similar move to Battleborn, it made the fatal mistake of not being PUBG. Nevertheless, The Culling 2 which upped the player count to 50 was made anyway but sadly made a similar fatal mistake of not being Fortnite. Come 2018, The Culling 2 was released, lambasted by critics and players alike for being unfinished, dropped to single digit player numbers within two days of launch, and was pulled from sale just over a week later.
It certainly didn’t help that the game launched on the same day a new Fornite season landed but safe money says this one was sinking anyway.
5. Anthem (2019-2021)
Anthem is a little bit like Beetlejuice, we said the phrase “failed live service game” too many times and now it’s here right on schedule so let’s walk you through this trainwreck.
Anthem might not have the shortest lifespan of all the games on this list but given it was developed by BioWare and published by EA, who both have a track record of creating some of the greatest games ever made, there’s an argument here that it’s still the most embarrassing. Perhaps most obvious to players who dipped into this admittedly pretty world was the realisation that everything felt soulless. Characters were bland, gameplay was boring and grindy, and the story was uninspiring. While the game was technically passable it fell well short of critical and consumer expectations and the joy of buzzing about the game world couldn’t make up for its relentless repetition and brutal load times. Though BioWare did their best to patch some of the game’s issues quite quickly, it wasn’t enough to drag in new players or keep old ones engaged.
As a result, it was announced development was being abandoned in early 2021.
4. Hyper Scape (2020-2022)
If there’s a trend on this list it’s that there’s no such thing as a game developer or publisher so big that it can’t fail to pull off a successful live service video game. The next three entries on our list including this one are perfect examples of that but we’re starting it off with Ubisoft Montreal’s Hyper Scape.
Hyper Scape was a free-to-play first person shooter battle royale that was unique in that Twitch viewers would be able to affect the outcome of matches.
As intriguing as that twist and the old familiar setup of 100 players on a shrinking map are, the game was criticised for its unbalanced gunplay and frustrating mechanics. The graphics and map design were up to snuff, and there were some interesting iterations on the formula like the win condition that involved you hanging onto a crown for a full minute to win the match, but it simply couldn’t maintain its momentum after its beta release.
In April of 2022, almost two years after its official launch, the game was shut down, with Ubisoft announcing it failed to meet player expectations.
3. Paragon (2016-2018)
Another game that learned the hard way you shouldn’t try to compete with Fortnite is Epic Games’ own older child Paragon.
Released a year earlier than Fortnite: Battle Royale, Paragon was a free-to-play MOBA that had you attempt to destroy your enemy’s base on a symmetrical map partitioned with three lanes. Ten players were divided into two teams, all of which would take on the role of a hero with their own set of skills and weapons.
This is a sketchy one as the game never actually made it to full release, but it was in open beta for two years until Epic Games decided Fornite was the favourite child and shut down Paragon’s servers.
The team was reduced and ultimately dissolved in order to shift attention and resources to Fortnite, but players of Paragon who did buy it received full refunds. On top of that, the 17 million dollars worth of game assets were put on the Unreal Engine Marketplace for free, so that’s pretty cool.
2. Babylon’s Fall (2022-2023)
One of the newer live service flubs on this list, you’d expect the superstar devs behind Bayonetta and Nier wouldn’t have any trouble creating a live service world that people want to stay engaged with, but Babylon’s Fall was just riddled with problems from the get go.
Panned across the board, PlatinumGames’ action RPG was all set to give you an exciting game world to play in, cooperative questing, and vibrant hub locations.
Instead, the challenges in the game were largely boring and repetitive with a predictable and uninspiring difficulty gradient and very few reasons for players to re-engage. Players took issue with the subpar visuals and lack of content, and really all Babylon’s Fall achieved was a crash course in what not to do when trying to make a live service game in 2022. Despite its impressive pedigree, just six months after its release publisher Square Enix announced the game would no longer be supported.
It’ll be done and dusted by February of 2023 but given exactly one person was playing it in May of last year, that kind of makes sense.
1. Radical Heights (2018)
We kicked off our list with LawBreakers so it stands to reason we’d wrap it up with the only other game Boss Key Productions made before they were dissolved and that’s Radical Heights. The battle royale game quickly fell under the wheel of PUBG and Fortnite, along with most of the other aspiring battle royale games at the time.
After only five months of development it rocked up in what the developer called “X-Treme Early Access”, which should have been our first sign to worry.
The idea was to let the community help shape the game while in its early access state but instead players found the game to be unpolished, underwhelming, and uninspiring. Just over a month after its release in April of 2018 the studio folded and the game was subsequently abandoned.